[
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c5",
    "representativeText": "A multi-pronged approach is needed to make the necessary changes to spur and sustain open scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c5",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c8",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1062",
      "osft-doc-1373/c594",
      "open-science-source-03/c271",
      "osft-doc-1459/c517",
      "osft-doc-1327/c493",
      "open-science-source-21/c91",
      "open-science-source-38/c127",
      "open-science-source-06/c64",
      "osft-doc-1449/c68",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c55",
      "osft-doc-1646/c24",
      "osft-doc-1737/c22",
      "osft-doc-1771/c27",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c5",
      "osft-doc-0992/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-0992",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 17,
      "documents": 16
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 17
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c194",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c194",
    "representativeText": "Research assessment must include greater recognition for open science practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c194",
      "open-science-source-03/c244",
      "osft-doc-0268/c9",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c242",
      "open-science-source-42/c122",
      "osft-doc-1327/c652",
      "osft-doc-1449/c423",
      "osft-doc-1449/c347",
      "osft-doc-1283/c47",
      "osft-doc-1283/c57",
      "open-science-source-38/c82",
      "open-science-source-10/c175",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c246",
      "osft-doc-1673/c49",
      "open-science-source-03/c257",
      "osft-doc-1449/c344",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0268",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 17,
      "documents": 12
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 8,
      "may": 2,
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0268/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0268/c22",
    "representativeText": "Open science requires wholesale cultural change.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0268/c22",
      "osft-doc-1449/c131",
      "open-science-source-21/c96",
      "osft-doc-1449/c35",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c240",
      "osft-doc-1449/c94",
      "osft-doc-1449/c5",
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c62",
      "osft-doc-1283/c25",
      "open-science-source-05/c14",
      "osft-doc-0730/c13",
      "open-science-source-02/c33",
      "osft-doc-1449/c336",
      "osft-doc-0411/c47",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c4",
      "osft-doc-1327/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-05",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-54-c1",
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-0268",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0730",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 16,
      "documents": 12
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 15,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c10",
    "representativeText": "Article processing charges (APCs) create significant barriers for less-well-resourced researchers and institutions to make their research available.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c10",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c16",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c51",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c10",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c10",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c14",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c41",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c69",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c26",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c41",
      "open-science-source-36/c163",
      "open-science-source-03/c246",
      "open-science-source-02/c150",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 14,
      "documents": 11
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 13,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c56",
    "representativeText": "Evaluations of individual researchers or of research groups should not use journal brand or Impact Factor as a proxy for research quality.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c56",
      "osft-doc-1869/c119",
      "osft-doc-1869/c9",
      "osft-doc-0108/c26",
      "osft-doc-0296/c21",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1371",
      "osft-doc-0142/c118",
      "osft-doc-0108/c21",
      "open-science-source-02/c134",
      "osft-doc-0296/c15",
      "open-science-source-03/c256",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c17",
      "osft-doc-1327/c266",
      "osft-doc-1869/c4",
      "open-science-source-02/c317",
      "open-science-source-10/c171"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 16,
      "documents": 10
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 10,
      "must": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c8",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly publications should carry full reuse rights, such as those provided by a CC BY 4.0 International License or its functional equivalent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c20",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c13",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c3",
      "open-science-source-19/c30",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c77",
      "osft-doc-1373/c317",
      "osft-doc-1459/c345",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c33",
      "osft-doc-1673/c208",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c28",
      "osft-doc-0211/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 12,
      "documents": 10
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 8,
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c90",
    "representativeText": "Assessment bodies and institutions should move beyond exclusive reliance on journal impact factors and quantitative output metrics, adopting qualitative, context-sensitive, and narrative-based approaches that recognise the full research package.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c90",
      "osft-doc-1373/c423",
      "osft-doc-1459/c455",
      "osft-doc-0108/c34",
      "osft-doc-1673/c111",
      "open-science-source-18/c765",
      "osft-doc-0296/c30",
      "osft-doc-1047/c22",
      "osft-doc-1327/c148",
      "open-science-source-18/c660",
      "osft-doc-0142/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 11,
      "documents": 10
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 9,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c2",
    "representativeText": "Everyone should be able to access the knowledge that shapes our world.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c2",
      "osft-doc-1869/c306",
      "osft-doc-0114/c23",
      "osft-doc-0211/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 10
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 9,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c47",
    "representativeText": "Day-to-day operations of infrastructure organisations should be supported by day-to-day sustainable revenue sources.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c47",
      "osft-doc-0020/c38",
      "osft-doc-0151/c65",
      "osft-doc-0756/c20",
      "osft-doc-0846/c40",
      "osft-doc-1781/c67",
      "osft-doc-0836/c47",
      "open-science-source-09/c19",
      "osft-doc-0860/c19",
      "open-science-source-38/c203"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 10
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 9,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c589",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c589",
    "representativeText": "The current reward system in research is still highly focused on publication of novel results in high impact journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c589",
      "osft-doc-1373/c565",
      "osft-doc-1673/c319",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c106",
      "open-science-source-04/c50",
      "open-science-source-45/c217",
      "osft-doc-0441/c154",
      "osft-doc-1327/c684",
      "open-science-source-10/c166",
      "osft-doc-1878/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 10
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 10
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0846/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0846/c87",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure organisation must not use patents to prevent the community from replicating the infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0846/c87",
      "osft-doc-0151/c121",
      "osft-doc-1287/c81",
      "osft-doc-0836/c79",
      "open-science-source-09/c49",
      "osft-doc-0020/c79",
      "osft-doc-0756/c43",
      "osft-doc-1781/c134",
      "osft-doc-0860/c48",
      "osft-doc-0860/c47",
      "osft-doc-0836/c77",
      "osft-doc-0020/c77",
      "osft-doc-0756/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 13,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 8,
      "may": 1,
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c347",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c347",
    "representativeText": "Publicly (or taxpayer) funded research should be accessible to the public.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c347",
      "osft-doc-1673/c209",
      "osft-doc-1373/c318",
      "osft-doc-0411/c46",
      "osft-doc-1869/c88",
      "osft-doc-1398/c38",
      "osft-doc-1673/c109",
      "osft-doc-1373/c304",
      "open-science-source-19/c23",
      "osft-doc-1373/c214",
      "osft-doc-0900/c13",
      "open-science-source-23/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-23",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0900",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 12,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 9,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-29/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-29/c1",
    "representativeText": "Research outputs should be shared rapidly and openly.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-29/c1",
      "open-science-source-21/c41",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c129",
      "open-science-source-07/c9",
      "osft-doc-1646/c19",
      "osft-doc-1737/c17",
      "osft-doc-1771/c19",
      "osft-doc-1373/c645",
      "open-science-source-21/c40",
      "osft-doc-1373/c303",
      "osft-doc-1327/c276"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-07",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-29",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 11,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 8,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c30",
    "representativeText": "Revenue sources should be evaluated against the infrastructure's mission and not run counter to the aims of the organisation or service.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c30",
      "osft-doc-0860/c30",
      "osft-doc-0860/c31",
      "osft-doc-0836/c55",
      "osft-doc-0151/c91",
      "osft-doc-0846/c59",
      "osft-doc-1287/c56",
      "osft-doc-0020/c52",
      "osft-doc-0756/c29",
      "osft-doc-1781/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 10
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c1",
    "representativeText": "Sharing knowledge is a human right.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c1",
      "open-science-source-11/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-11",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 6,
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c30",
    "representativeText": "Open Science increases trust in scientific claims.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c30",
      "osft-doc-1878/c33",
      "open-science-source-03/c17",
      "open-science-source-03/c133",
      "osft-doc-0411/c50",
      "osft-doc-1646/c7",
      "osft-doc-1771/c7",
      "osft-doc-1373/c12",
      "open-science-source-25/c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c60",
    "representativeText": "Indicators for research assessment should reflect the complexity and varied context of the research environment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c60",
      "osft-doc-0142/c31",
      "osft-doc-1459/c451",
      "osft-doc-0050/c66",
      "osft-doc-0150/c65",
      "osft-doc-1449/c400",
      "open-science-source-04/c120",
      "open-science-source-18/c766",
      "osft-doc-1047/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c74",
    "representativeText": "Open data must be accompanied by a practical way to actually obtain it.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c74",
      "osft-doc-1781/c126",
      "osft-doc-0756/c39",
      "osft-doc-0836/c75",
      "osft-doc-0846/c82",
      "osft-doc-1287/c77",
      "osft-doc-1869/c247",
      "osft-doc-0151/c115",
      "osft-doc-1449/c227"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1781",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c1",
    "representativeText": "Research transcends disciplines, geography, institutions, and stakeholders.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c1",
      "osft-doc-0860/c1",
      "osft-doc-0020/c3",
      "osft-doc-0151/c25",
      "osft-doc-0756/c1",
      "osft-doc-0836/c23",
      "osft-doc-0846/c1",
      "osft-doc-1287/c24",
      "osft-doc-1327/c283"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c32",
    "representativeText": "Appropriate revenue sources may include value-added services.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c32",
      "osft-doc-0020/c57",
      "osft-doc-0756/c31",
      "osft-doc-0860/c33",
      "osft-doc-0151/c96",
      "osft-doc-0836/c57",
      "osft-doc-0846/c65",
      "osft-doc-1287/c58",
      "osft-doc-1781/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c33",
    "representativeText": "Appropriate revenue sources may include consulting.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c33",
      "osft-doc-0020/c58",
      "osft-doc-0756/c32",
      "osft-doc-0860/c34",
      "osft-doc-0151/c97",
      "osft-doc-0836/c58",
      "osft-doc-0846/c66",
      "osft-doc-1287/c59",
      "osft-doc-1781/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c34",
    "representativeText": "Appropriate revenue sources may include API Service Level Agreements.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c34",
      "osft-doc-0020/c59",
      "osft-doc-0756/c33",
      "osft-doc-0860/c35",
      "osft-doc-0151/c98",
      "osft-doc-0836/c59",
      "osft-doc-0846/c67",
      "osft-doc-1287/c60",
      "osft-doc-1781/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c73",
    "representativeText": "Organisations which define sustainability based merely on recovering costs are brittle.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c73",
      "osft-doc-0756/c23",
      "osft-doc-0846/c45",
      "osft-doc-1287/c50",
      "osft-doc-1781/c73",
      "osft-doc-0020/c42",
      "osft-doc-0836/c50",
      "open-science-source-09/c23",
      "osft-doc-0860/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0756/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0756/c8",
    "representativeText": "Governance must reflect the demographics of the membership.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0756/c8",
      "osft-doc-0151/c37",
      "osft-doc-0846/c17",
      "osft-doc-0020/c15",
      "osft-doc-1287/c31",
      "osft-doc-0836/c28",
      "open-science-source-09/c7",
      "osft-doc-0860/c7",
      "open-science-source-38/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 8,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c60",
    "representativeText": "Appropriate revenue sources for infrastructure organisations may include membership fees.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c60",
      "osft-doc-0151/c99",
      "osft-doc-0846/c68",
      "osft-doc-1287/c61",
      "osft-doc-1781/c92",
      "open-science-source-09/c35",
      "osft-doc-0020/c60",
      "osft-doc-0756/c34",
      "osft-doc-0860/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c190",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c190",
    "representativeText": "Any research-supporting infrastructure or service should ensure inclusivity.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c190",
      "osft-doc-0756/c2",
      "osft-doc-0836/c24",
      "osft-doc-1287/c25",
      "osft-doc-0151/c26",
      "osft-doc-0846/c2",
      "osft-doc-0020/c4",
      "osft-doc-1327/c284",
      "open-science-source-09/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c3",
    "representativeText": "A board-governed organisation drawn from the stakeholder community builds confidence that the organisation will make decisions driven by community consensus and a balance of interests.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c3",
      "osft-doc-0860/c3",
      "osft-doc-1820/c2",
      "osft-doc-0020/c10",
      "osft-doc-0151/c30",
      "osft-doc-0836/c25",
      "osft-doc-0846/c6",
      "osft-doc-1781/c57",
      "osft-doc-1287/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c55",
    "representativeText": "Openness has an advantage in accelerating research broadly.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c55",
      "open-science-source-21/c1",
      "osft-doc-1702/c11",
      "osft-doc-1283/c8",
      "osft-doc-0298/c124",
      "osft-doc-1646/c10",
      "osft-doc-1737/c8",
      "osft-doc-1771/c10",
      "osft-doc-1612/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 9
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1193/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1193/c57",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure to support making data and results open and discoverable is needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1193/c57",
      "osft-doc-1702/c57",
      "open-science-source-51/c45",
      "open-science-source-14-c1/c317",
      "open-science-source-12/c94",
      "osft-doc-1327/c329",
      "open-science-source-12/c51",
      "osft-doc-1327/c996",
      "open-science-source-38/c136",
      "osft-doc-1449/c274",
      "osft-doc-1327/c723"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-14-c1",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-51",
      "osft-doc-1193",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 11,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7,
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1049",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1049",
    "representativeText": "Progress toward a more open research world has been growing steadily.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1049",
      "open-science-source-12/c75",
      "osft-doc-1171/c17",
      "osft-doc-1673/c114",
      "open-science-source-50/c101",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c1",
      "osft-doc-1373/c552",
      "osft-doc-1459/c576",
      "osft-doc-1673/c314"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-50",
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1171",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0777/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0777/c21",
    "representativeText": "Openness contributes to the transparency of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0777/c21",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c169",
      "open-science-source-42/c288",
      "osft-doc-1702/c9",
      "osft-doc-1449/c414",
      "open-science-source-42/c879",
      "open-science-source-50/c27",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c147",
      "osft-doc-1612/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c75",
    "representativeText": "Underlying data should be made easily available via periodic data dumps.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c75",
      "open-science-source-09/c65",
      "osft-doc-0151/c116",
      "osft-doc-0756/c40",
      "osft-doc-0836/c76",
      "osft-doc-0846/c83",
      "osft-doc-1287/c78",
      "osft-doc-1781/c127"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c45",
    "representativeText": "The public should be able to access final peer-reviewed accepted manuscripts freely, without embargo or delay, and under terms that make them fully reusable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c45",
      "osft-doc-1646/c32",
      "open-science-source-28/c6",
      "open-science-source-19/c22",
      "open-science-source-23/c38",
      "osft-doc-0534/c23",
      "open-science-source-36/c85",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-28",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0534",
      "osft-doc-1646"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c48",
    "representativeText": "The organisation may obtain patents to protect its own operations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c48",
      "osft-doc-0020/c78",
      "osft-doc-0756/c42",
      "osft-doc-1781/c133",
      "osft-doc-0151/c120",
      "osft-doc-0846/c86",
      "osft-doc-1287/c80",
      "osft-doc-0836/c78"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c61",
    "representativeText": "The contingency fund should be separate from those allocated to covering operating risk and investment in development.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c61",
      "osft-doc-0846/c54",
      "osft-doc-0020/c49",
      "osft-doc-0151/c87",
      "osft-doc-0836/c54",
      "osft-doc-1781/c79",
      "osft-doc-0756/c28",
      "osft-doc-1287/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c10/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c10/c9",
    "representativeText": "The data underlying publications should be made open by default with appropriate safeguards to protect privacy.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c10/c9",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c32",
      "osft-doc-0860/c42",
      "osft-doc-1449/c38",
      "osft-doc-1373/c171",
      "osft-doc-1459/c181",
      "osft-doc-1673/c90",
      "osft-doc-0963/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c10",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5,
      "must": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c17",
    "representativeText": "Institutional repositories run by libraries or research institutions can play an important role in public access compliance because they generally do not charge authors to deposit articles or manuscripts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c17",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c13",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c19",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c60",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c53",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c18",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c33",
      "open-science-source-36/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c109",
    "representativeText": "Successful adoption and implementation of open science practices requires interoperable and sustained infrastructures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c109",
      "osft-doc-0138/c16",
      "osft-doc-1327/c741",
      "osft-doc-1373/c362",
      "osft-doc-1459/c394",
      "osft-doc-0785/c3",
      "osft-doc-1869/c13",
      "osft-doc-1673/c236"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-0785",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 6,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c27",
    "representativeText": "Member States should set out diverse paths to achieving open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c27",
      "osft-doc-1646/c22",
      "osft-doc-1737/c20",
      "osft-doc-1771/c25",
      "open-science-source-03/c144",
      "osft-doc-1327/c169",
      "osft-doc-1373/c143",
      "osft-doc-1459/c152"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c15",
    "representativeText": "Open Science enables researchers to drive Open Innovation within Europe and beyond.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c15",
      "open-science-source-03/c32",
      "osft-doc-0975/c35",
      "osft-doc-1646/c11",
      "osft-doc-1737/c9",
      "osft-doc-1771/c11",
      "osft-doc-0825/c3",
      "osft-doc-1398/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c172",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c172",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters collaboration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c172",
      "osft-doc-0002/c7",
      "open-science-source-04/c57",
      "osft-doc-1646/c23",
      "osft-doc-1737/c21",
      "osft-doc-1771/c26",
      "open-science-source-25/c6",
      "open-science-source-27/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "open-science-source-27",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c30",
    "representativeText": "Any stakeholder group should be welcome to join an infrastructure organisation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c30",
      "osft-doc-0756/c6",
      "osft-doc-0020/c13",
      "osft-doc-0836/c27",
      "osft-doc-0151/c36",
      "osft-doc-0860/c6",
      "osft-doc-0846/c14",
      "open-science-source-09/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c2",
    "representativeText": "Open science is a set of principles and practices that aim to make scientific research from all fields accessible to everyone for the benefits of scientists and society as a whole.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c2",
      "osft-doc-1449/c17",
      "open-science-source-03/c53",
      "osft-doc-0068/c27",
      "osft-doc-1771/c50",
      "osft-doc-1702/c1",
      "osft-doc-1646/c44",
      "osft-doc-1737/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 8
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c56",
    "representativeText": "Data related to the running of the research enterprise should be a community property.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c56",
      "osft-doc-0151/c95",
      "osft-doc-0756/c30",
      "osft-doc-0836/c56",
      "osft-doc-0846/c64",
      "osft-doc-1287/c57",
      "osft-doc-1781/c88",
      "osft-doc-0836/c13",
      "osft-doc-1287/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 9
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0296/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0296/c1",
    "representativeText": "The ways in which the output of scientific research is evaluated by funding agencies, academic institutions, and other parties must be improved.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0296/c1",
      "osft-doc-0108/c1",
      "open-science-source-02/c110",
      "open-science-source-18/c94",
      "open-science-source-03/c254",
      "osft-doc-1373/c426",
      "osft-doc-0108/c10",
      "osft-doc-1047/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c231",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c231",
    "representativeText": "Incentives at both institutional and wider community levels are needed to initiate change toward open and reproducible research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c231",
      "osft-doc-1327/c259",
      "osft-doc-0138/c29",
      "osft-doc-1327/c256",
      "osft-doc-1373/c618",
      "osft-doc-1459/c641",
      "open-science-source-06/c65",
      "open-science-source-12/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 8
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c165",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c165",
    "representativeText": "Strategies for Open Scholarship must be joined-up so that the actions of those with similar aims do not work at cross-purposes.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c165",
      "osft-doc-1373/c260",
      "osft-doc-1459/c289",
      "osft-doc-1373/c481",
      "osft-doc-1399/c17",
      "osft-doc-1869/c379",
      "open-science-source-03/c159",
      "osft-doc-0068/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 5,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c270",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c270",
    "representativeText": "Research evaluation should consider alternative metrics, including those explicitly designed to measure openness.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c270",
      "osft-doc-1373/c427",
      "osft-doc-1459/c458",
      "osft-doc-0138/c30",
      "osft-doc-1612/c80",
      "osft-doc-1327/c824",
      "open-science-source-06/c289"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "may": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c648",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c648",
    "representativeText": "Those who design and use metrics must take a fuller account of the existing diversity of research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c648",
      "osft-doc-1373/c421",
      "osft-doc-0296/c44",
      "osft-doc-0068/c48",
      "osft-doc-0108/c48",
      "osft-doc-1459/c450",
      "open-science-source-06/c280"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c98",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c98",
    "representativeText": "Diverse research outputs should be valued in research assessments.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c98",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1318",
      "osft-doc-0108/c19",
      "open-science-source-03/c166",
      "osft-doc-1373/c216",
      "osft-doc-1283/c59",
      "osft-doc-1327/c267"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c4",
    "representativeText": "Everyone should be able to benefit from the knowledge that shapes our world.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c56",
    "representativeText": "A successor organisation must honour this same set of principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c56",
      "osft-doc-0756/c14",
      "osft-doc-1287/c37",
      "osft-doc-0836/c36",
      "osft-doc-0020/c30",
      "osft-doc-0846/c28",
      "osft-doc-0151/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c57",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructures exist for a specific purpose.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c57",
      "osft-doc-0020/c32",
      "osft-doc-0151/c58",
      "osft-doc-0756/c15",
      "osft-doc-0836/c37",
      "osft-doc-0846/c31",
      "osft-doc-1287/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c63",
    "representativeText": "The CC0 waiver is best practice in making data legally available.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c63",
      "osft-doc-0020/c70",
      "osft-doc-0151/c111",
      "osft-doc-1781/c150",
      "osft-doc-0836/c73",
      "osft-doc-0846/c77",
      "osft-doc-1287/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c15",
    "representativeText": "Institutional repositories can play an important role in providing long-term preservation support.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c15",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c21",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c62",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c55",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c20",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c35",
      "osft-doc-1327/c205"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c9",
    "representativeText": "Authors must not conflate compliance with article processing charges (APCs).",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c9",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c9",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c15",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c9",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c13",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c29",
      "osft-doc-0534/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-0534"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 6,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c3",
    "representativeText": "Everyone should be able to contribute to the knowledge that shapes the world.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c39",
    "representativeText": "Grant dependency for funding operations makes organisations fragile.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c39",
      "osft-doc-0756/c21",
      "osft-doc-0846/c41",
      "osft-doc-1781/c68",
      "osft-doc-0836/c48",
      "open-science-source-09/c20",
      "osft-doc-0860/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c40",
    "representativeText": "Grant dependency for funding operations makes organisations more easily distracted from building core infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c40",
      "osft-doc-0756/c22",
      "osft-doc-0846/c42",
      "osft-doc-1781/c69",
      "osft-doc-0836/c49",
      "open-science-source-09/c21",
      "osft-doc-0860/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c68",
    "representativeText": "All software required to run the infrastructure should be available under an open source license, excluding other software that may be involved in running the organisation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c68",
      "osft-doc-0151/c102",
      "osft-doc-1287/c73",
      "osft-doc-0836/c71",
      "osft-doc-0846/c71",
      "osft-doc-0756/c35",
      "osft-doc-1781/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c43",
    "representativeText": "Organizations that supply metrics should be open and transparent by providing data and methods used to calculate all metrics.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c43",
      "osft-doc-0296/c39",
      "osft-doc-1373/c420",
      "osft-doc-1459/c449",
      "osft-doc-1449/c376",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1345",
      "osft-doc-1283/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c46",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure organisation should depend on its community to support the creation of a legislative environment that affects it.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c46",
      "open-science-source-09/c54",
      "osft-doc-0020/c27",
      "osft-doc-0756/c12",
      "osft-doc-0836/c32",
      "osft-doc-0846/c25",
      "osft-doc-1287/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c6",
    "representativeText": "Open Science is about increased reproducibility for research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c6",
      "osft-doc-0777/c22",
      "open-science-source-21/c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c94",
      "open-science-source-42/c880",
      "osft-doc-0975/c15",
      "osft-doc-1449/c404"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0756/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0756/c36",
    "representativeText": "For an infrastructure to be forked, it is necessary to replicate all relevant data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0756/c36",
      "osft-doc-0020/c69",
      "osft-doc-0151/c110",
      "osft-doc-0836/c72",
      "osft-doc-1781/c149",
      "osft-doc-1287/c74",
      "osft-doc-0846/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c53",
    "representativeText": "Generating a contingency fund that can support a complete, orderly wind-down should be a high priority for infrastructure organisations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c53",
      "osft-doc-0756/c27",
      "open-science-source-09/c60",
      "osft-doc-0020/c48",
      "osft-doc-0151/c86",
      "osft-doc-1781/c78",
      "osft-doc-1301/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1301",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 6,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c6",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is a holistic term that encompasses many disciplines.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c6",
      "osft-doc-1373/c6",
      "osft-doc-1569/c4",
      "open-science-source-25/c2",
      "osft-doc-1612/c19",
      "osft-doc-0441/c346",
      "osft-doc-1878/c337"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c13",
    "representativeText": "Open scientific practices improve the quality of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c13",
      "osft-doc-0975/c14",
      "osft-doc-1327/c613",
      "osft-doc-0441/c82",
      "osft-doc-1878/c78",
      "osft-doc-1459/c280",
      "osft-doc-1373/c251"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c24",
    "representativeText": "Organisations and services must have financial resources beyond immediate operating costs to weather economic, social and technological volatility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c24",
      "osft-doc-0860/c24",
      "osft-doc-1820/c4",
      "osft-doc-0151/c76",
      "osft-doc-0756/c26",
      "osft-doc-0846/c48",
      "osft-doc-0836/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c35",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR factors of findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reuse should be strengthened for any shared research output.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c35",
      "osft-doc-1646/c20",
      "osft-doc-1737/c18",
      "open-science-source-28/c14",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c142",
      "osft-doc-1449/c231",
      "osft-doc-0932/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-28",
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-0932",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c44",
    "representativeText": "The community, not infrastructure organisations, should collectively drive regulatory change.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c44",
      "open-science-source-09/c52",
      "osft-doc-0020/c25",
      "osft-doc-0756/c10",
      "osft-doc-0846/c23",
      "osft-doc-1287/c33",
      "osft-doc-0836/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c168",
    "representativeText": "The current incentive structures of academia work against implementing open scholarship practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c168",
      "osft-doc-1878/c164",
      "osft-doc-1283/c53",
      "open-science-source-12/c67",
      "osft-doc-1869/c98",
      "osft-doc-0050/c63",
      "osft-doc-0411/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 7
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c142",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c142",
    "representativeText": "There is no one-size-fits-all way of practicing open science, due to the diversity of science systems, actors and capacities across the world and the evolving nature of supporting information and communication technologies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c142",
      "osft-doc-1031/c1",
      "open-science-source-27/c5",
      "open-science-source-27/c6",
      "osft-doc-1031/c3",
      "open-science-source-42/c115",
      "osft-doc-1327/c764",
      "osft-doc-1327/c191",
      "osft-doc-1327/c389",
      "osft-doc-1449/c134"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-27",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1031",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 10,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 9,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-53/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-53/c20",
    "representativeText": "Open infrastructure needs support to keep running.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-53/c20",
      "open-science-source-38/c19",
      "osft-doc-0050/c7",
      "osft-doc-0150/c7",
      "osft-doc-0050/c36",
      "osft-doc-1673/c243",
      "osft-doc-0150/c35",
      "osft-doc-1459/c404",
      "open-science-source-38/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-53",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 9,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 6,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c384",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c384",
    "representativeText": "The best way to regard infrastructure is as existing interactive technologies that go unnoticed until they cease to work as they should.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c384",
      "osft-doc-1459/c411",
      "osft-doc-0836/c15",
      "osft-doc-1287/c15",
      "osft-doc-0836/c14",
      "osft-doc-1287/c14",
      "open-science-source-05/c94",
      "osft-doc-0730/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 8,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c12",
    "representativeText": "Articles should be openly licensed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c12",
      "open-science-source-29/c22",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c33",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c27",
      "osft-doc-0211/c21",
      "osft-doc-1459/c618",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-20",
      "open-science-source-29",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1124/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1124/c24",
    "representativeText": "The peer-reviewed journal literature should be accessible online without cost to readers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1124/c24",
      "osft-doc-0504/c21",
      "osft-doc-0504/c15",
      "osft-doc-1702/c60",
      "open-science-source-03/c73",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c42",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c176",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c176",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should develop and teach courses on the various practices of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c176",
      "osft-doc-1459/c189",
      "osft-doc-1673/c93",
      "osft-doc-0441/c180",
      "osft-doc-1449/c277",
      "osft-doc-1878/c176",
      "osft-doc-0441/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-27/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-27/c32",
    "representativeText": "The potential of Open and Collaborative Science lies in the processes of participation it encourages.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-27/c32",
      "osft-doc-1031/c21",
      "open-science-source-03/c38",
      "osft-doc-0975/c44",
      "open-science-source-03/c104",
      "osft-doc-1283/c17",
      "open-science-source-21/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1031",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c36",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure organisation should publicly describe a plan (a living will) addressing the conditions under which it would be wound down, how this would happen, and how any ongoing assets would be archived and preserved when passed to a successor organisation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c36",
      "osft-doc-0756/c13",
      "open-science-source-09/c55",
      "osft-doc-0836/c33",
      "osft-doc-0836/c34",
      "osft-doc-1820/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c324",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c324",
    "representativeText": "Flexibility must be allowed for in Open Scholarship strategies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c324",
      "osft-doc-1459/c604",
      "osft-doc-1373/c578",
      "osft-doc-1459/c603",
      "osft-doc-0951/c30",
      "osft-doc-1399/c28",
      "osft-doc-1327/c307"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-11/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-11/c3",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly knowledge must be accessible to all communities, including readers and authors, without barriers and paywalls.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-11/c3",
      "open-science-source-04/c53",
      "open-science-source-03/c124",
      "osft-doc-0825/c58",
      "osft-doc-1398/c59",
      "open-science-source-04/c59",
      "osft-doc-1869/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-11",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c174",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c174",
    "representativeText": "The burden of paying APCs falls inequitably on authors who have the fewest funding options and who can least afford to pay them.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c174",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c39",
      "osft-doc-1373/c602",
      "osft-doc-1459/c627",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c41",
      "osft-doc-1327/c807"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c649",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c649",
    "representativeText": "Those who design and use metrics must design sensitive and meaningful metrics to reflect and support the existing diversity of research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c649",
      "osft-doc-0050/c61",
      "osft-doc-1283/c61",
      "osft-doc-1373/c402",
      "osft-doc-1459/c430",
      "osft-doc-1673/c261"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 5,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c46",
    "representativeText": "Open sharing accelerates the progression of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c46",
      "osft-doc-1195/c7",
      "osft-doc-1869/c84",
      "open-science-source-04/c75",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c40",
      "osft-doc-1283/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1195",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c227",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c227",
    "representativeText": "Member States should develop recognized skills and training programmes in support of the attainment of open science competencies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c227",
      "osft-doc-0002/c31",
      "osft-doc-0785/c4",
      "osft-doc-1373/c294",
      "osft-doc-1459/c324",
      "osft-doc-1327/c766"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0785",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c201",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c201",
    "representativeText": "Incorporating open scholarship can bring about more opportunities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c201",
      "osft-doc-1459/c256",
      "osft-doc-1673/c135",
      "osft-doc-1373/c235",
      "osft-doc-1253/c62",
      "osft-doc-0441/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c58",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure's purpose can be radically simplified or even rendered unnecessary by technological or social change.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c58",
      "osft-doc-0020/c33",
      "osft-doc-0846/c32",
      "osft-doc-0151/c59",
      "osft-doc-1287/c39",
      "osft-doc-0836/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c64",
    "representativeText": "Privacy and data protection laws limit the extent to which data can be made legally available.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c64",
      "osft-doc-0151/c112",
      "osft-doc-0836/c74",
      "osft-doc-1287/c76",
      "osft-doc-0846/c78",
      "osft-doc-1781/c151"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c40",
    "representativeText": "\"Green\" OA status is defined as a publication freely available in an OA repository.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c40",
      "open-science-source-36/c56",
      "osft-doc-1459/c505",
      "osft-doc-1702/c105",
      "osft-doc-1673/c285",
      "osft-doc-1373/c467"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c17",
    "representativeText": "Requiring grantees to provide AHRQ a sufficient license as a term and condition of funding is the most straightforward approach that minimizes complexity and burden in compliance for grantee institutions and authors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c17",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c23",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c51",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c40",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c21",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c21",
    "representativeText": "Even if an author from a grantee's institution signs a publication agreement that conflicts with the agency's license, the agency's license remains intact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c21",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c26",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c28",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c27",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c55",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c14",
    "representativeText": "Institutional repositories can play an important role in improving discoverability of research outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c14",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c20",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c61",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c54",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c34",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c53",
    "representativeText": "Many valuable open science infrastructure initiatives depend on precarious funding, volunteer efforts, or short-term projects, making them vulnerable.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c53",
      "open-science-source-38/c16",
      "open-science-source-53/c17",
      "osft-doc-1373/c368",
      "osft-doc-1673/c240",
      "osft-doc-1459/c401"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-53",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open science makes multilingual scientific knowledge accessible for everyone.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c10",
      "osft-doc-1646/c2",
      "osft-doc-1737/c2",
      "osft-doc-1771/c2",
      "osft-doc-1283/c16",
      "osft-doc-0777/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c37",
    "representativeText": "Open Science encompasses open data as an aspect impacting the entire research lifecycle.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c37",
      "open-science-source-42/c281",
      "osft-doc-1399/c2",
      "osft-doc-0951/c7",
      "osft-doc-0825/c29",
      "osft-doc-1398/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c98",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c98",
    "representativeText": "(Meta)data should meet domain-relevant community standards.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c98",
      "osft-doc-1197/c21",
      "osft-doc-0050/c45",
      "osft-doc-0150/c45",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c67",
      "open-science-source-38/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c309",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c309",
    "representativeText": "Alternative business models, such as the Open Library of Humanities, should be developed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c309",
      "osft-doc-0836/c81",
      "osft-doc-1287/c83",
      "osft-doc-1327/c84",
      "osft-doc-1449/c157",
      "open-science-source-19/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c152",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c152",
    "representativeText": "Institutions can support open scholarship by providing explicit training in principles and practices of open research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c152",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c20",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c11",
      "osft-doc-1373/c586",
      "osft-doc-1673/c332",
      "osft-doc-1878/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c122",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c122",
    "representativeText": "Reliance on JIFs for assessment mistakes a metric about journals for a metric about articles or authors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c122",
      "osft-doc-1373/c409",
      "osft-doc-1459/c439",
      "open-science-source-55/c5",
      "osft-doc-1327/c977",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1342"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c32",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles mean making data interoperable.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c32",
      "osft-doc-0963/c13",
      "open-science-source-25/c27",
      "osft-doc-1771/c22",
      "osft-doc-1027/c32",
      "open-science-source-26/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1027",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c407",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c407",
    "representativeText": "Open Science practices may discourage and reduce the incidences of fabrication, falsification, plagiarism and other unacceptable practices by making them easier to detect.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c407",
      "osft-doc-0411/c44",
      "osft-doc-0825/c27",
      "osft-doc-1398/c27",
      "open-science-source-21/c11",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1348"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open Science enables more efficient and effective use of research investments.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c9",
      "osft-doc-1737/c7",
      "osft-doc-1771/c9",
      "osft-doc-0825/c16",
      "osft-doc-1398/c16",
      "osft-doc-1327/c598"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c209",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c209",
    "representativeText": "Open research practices are widely supported.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c209",
      "osft-doc-0050/c62",
      "osft-doc-0150/c61",
      "osft-doc-1459/c253",
      "osft-doc-1373/c232",
      "osft-doc-1673/c295"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c10",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure provides the tools, platforms and workflows that make practising open science technically possible.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c10",
      "osft-doc-1702/c7",
      "open-science-source-53/c18",
      "osft-doc-1869/c30",
      "osft-doc-1327/c286",
      "osft-doc-1287/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "open-science-source-53",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c632",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c632",
    "representativeText": "Openness is not equally embraced by or available to all researchers everywhere.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c632",
      "osft-doc-1373/c220",
      "osft-doc-1459/c234",
      "osft-doc-1673/c116",
      "osft-doc-1878/c73",
      "osft-doc-1449/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c60",
    "representativeText": "Open Science has a dynamic and evolving nature.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c60",
      "osft-doc-1646/c43",
      "open-science-source-03/c273",
      "osft-doc-1612/c1",
      "osft-doc-1449/c92",
      "osft-doc-1373/c639"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c266",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c266",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly practices, the way science is undertaken, and the possibilities and associated activities of scholarly communication are changing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c266",
      "osft-doc-1373/c236",
      "osft-doc-1459/c257",
      "osft-doc-1673/c136",
      "open-science-source-45/c15",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1044"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c234",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c234",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship makes research outputs and scholarly practices more accessible and inclusive.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c234",
      "osft-doc-1459/c255",
      "osft-doc-1673/c134",
      "osft-doc-0777/c17",
      "osft-doc-1593/c9",
      "osft-doc-0825/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1593",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c29",
    "representativeText": "Peer-reviewed scholarly publications may include peer-reviewed book chapters, editorials, and peer-reviewed conference proceedings published in other scholarly outlets that result from federally funded research.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c29",
      "open-science-source-36/c93",
      "osft-doc-1646/c63",
      "osft-doc-1702/c98",
      "osft-doc-1737/c76",
      "osft-doc-1771/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 6
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c66",
    "representativeText": "Research funders should diversify the portfolio of what is considered a research output for assessment purposes.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c66",
      "osft-doc-1459/c165",
      "osft-doc-1373/c157",
      "osft-doc-1459/c330",
      "osft-doc-0108/c29",
      "osft-doc-0296/c25",
      "osft-doc-1373/c300"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1771/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1771/c28",
    "representativeText": "Canada should adopt an Open Science approach to federally funded scientific and research outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1771/c28",
      "osft-doc-1646/c25",
      "osft-doc-1737/c23",
      "osft-doc-0951/c15",
      "osft-doc-1399/c12",
      "osft-doc-0951/c9",
      "osft-doc-1399/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c190",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c190",
    "representativeText": "Researchers' perspectives must be included to ensure that open science policies, infrastructure, and tools are relevant, practical and effective.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c190",
      "osft-doc-1327/c487",
      "osft-doc-1737/c16",
      "osft-doc-1771/c18",
      "osft-doc-1646/c18",
      "osft-doc-1327/c443",
      "osft-doc-1327/c992"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 7,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 7
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c333",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c333",
    "representativeText": "Quantitative approaches to research assessment should support, not replace, qualitative approaches.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c333",
      "osft-doc-1373/c419",
      "osft-doc-1459/c448",
      "osft-doc-1047/c32",
      "osft-doc-0142/c167",
      "osft-doc-0142/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c80",
    "representativeText": "Universities, research institutions, funders, libraries, and publishers should collaborate on a transition to open practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c80",
      "osft-doc-1869/c328",
      "osft-doc-1327/c332",
      "osft-doc-1327/c554",
      "open-science-source-06/c70",
      "osft-doc-1213/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c329",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c329",
    "representativeText": "Next-generation metrics can be \"gamed\".",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c329",
      "osft-doc-0142/c598",
      "osft-doc-1373/c433",
      "osft-doc-1459/c465",
      "osft-doc-1673/c266",
      "osft-doc-0142/c565"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c76",
    "representativeText": "Open and FAIR research information requires the use of infrastructures that provide standard and open interfaces.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c76",
      "open-science-source-05/c74",
      "open-science-source-03/c189",
      "open-science-source-05/c12",
      "open-science-source-09/c50",
      "osft-doc-0860/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-05",
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0730",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1213/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1213/c4",
    "representativeText": "Open Access means unrestricted, online access to peer-reviewed, scholarly research papers for reading and productive re-use, not impeded by any financial, organisational, legal or technical barriers.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1213/c4",
      "osft-doc-1124/c21",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c14",
      "osft-doc-0504/c18",
      "open-science-source-25/c3",
      "osft-doc-0504/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c28",
    "representativeText": "Member States should develop an enabling policy environment for open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c28",
      "osft-doc-0785/c2",
      "osft-doc-0068/c36",
      "osft-doc-0068/c37",
      "open-science-source-03/c157",
      "osft-doc-0633/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-0785"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c312",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c312",
    "representativeText": "Stakeholder groups' goals in the Open Scholarship agenda are often in conflict or tension depending on their intrinsic motivations, understanding, and goals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c312",
      "osft-doc-1673/c182",
      "osft-doc-1869/c191",
      "osft-doc-1673/c213",
      "osft-doc-1327/c2",
      "osft-doc-1373/c312"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c72",
    "representativeText": "Decision makers at scholarly journals, publishers, funders, and higher education and research institutions should recognize and reward a variety of Open Scholarship activities, particularly regarding research evaluation and open education policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c72",
      "osft-doc-1673/c21",
      "osft-doc-1449/c319",
      "open-science-source-10/c174",
      "osft-doc-1327/c110"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c74",
    "representativeText": "Organisations which define sustainability based merely on recovering costs are stagnant.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c74",
      "osft-doc-0756/c24",
      "osft-doc-0846/c46",
      "osft-doc-1287/c51",
      "osft-doc-1781/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c22",
    "representativeText": "Open Science must become embedded at every level and in every aspect of the scientific endeavour.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c22",
      "osft-doc-0441/c176",
      "osft-doc-1878/c172",
      "open-science-source-03/c132",
      "osft-doc-1449/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c431",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c431",
    "representativeText": "New metrics must reflect more diverse forms of scientific impact.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c431",
      "open-science-source-06/c285",
      "osft-doc-1449/c356",
      "osft-doc-1283/c62",
      "open-science-source-10/c225"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c11",
    "representativeText": "Published articles should have immediate access without embargoes.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c11",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c68",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c34",
      "osft-doc-0951/c20",
      "osft-doc-1399/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-20",
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c11",
    "representativeText": "Open Science aims at introducing more people to academic research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c11",
      "osft-doc-0411/c12",
      "osft-doc-0777/c18",
      "osft-doc-0002/c12",
      "osft-doc-1702/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c2/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c2/c90",
    "representativeText": "Academic evaluation and reward systems must be changed to attract and retain diverse personnel in appropriate career paths.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c90",
      "osft-doc-1459/c429",
      "osft-doc-1673/c260",
      "osft-doc-1373/c401",
      "osft-doc-1327/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0211/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0211/c26",
    "representativeText": "Researchers and grant recipients should publish their work according to the principles of the open access paradigm.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0211/c26",
      "osft-doc-1039/c13",
      "osft-doc-1459/c38",
      "osft-doc-1213/c28",
      "osft-doc-1373/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1039",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c9",
    "representativeText": "Financial means and privileged access must never be the prerequisites to realizing the benefits of federally funded research that the American public deserves.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c9",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c46",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c4",
      "osft-doc-1373/c394",
      "osft-doc-1459/c422"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-34",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c3",
    "representativeText": "The production of scientific knowledge must be inclusive.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c3",
      "open-science-source-27/c34",
      "osft-doc-0441/c178",
      "osft-doc-1878/c174",
      "osft-doc-1373/c646"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c478",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c478",
    "representativeText": "There are great benefits to be derived from embracing Open Science approaches.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c478",
      "osft-doc-1612/c3",
      "osft-doc-1673/c133",
      "open-science-source-03/c292",
      "osft-doc-1327/c634"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c256",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c256",
    "representativeText": "Training in skills for open and reproducible workflows needs to be emphasized.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c256",
      "osft-doc-0050/c96",
      "osft-doc-0150/c93",
      "osft-doc-1449/c295",
      "osft-doc-0680/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0680",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c225",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c225",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility depends on transparently documenting and sharing all data products used in research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c225",
      "open-science-source-50/c104",
      "open-science-source-12/c5",
      "osft-doc-1673/c221",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c143",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c143",
    "representativeText": "Open science should build on long-term practices, services, infrastructures and funding models that ensure the equal participation of scientific producers from less privileged institutions and countries.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c143",
      "osft-doc-0975/c50",
      "osft-doc-1327/c24",
      "open-science-source-41/c355",
      "open-science-source-31/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-31",
      "open-science-source-41",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c23",
    "representativeText": "The practice of open science is anchored in the values of collaboration and sharing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c23",
      "osft-doc-1646/c16",
      "osft-doc-1737/c14",
      "osft-doc-1771/c16",
      "osft-doc-1869/c162"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c48",
    "representativeText": "Member States should collaborate in bilateral, regional, multilateral and global initiatives for the advancement of open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c48",
      "osft-doc-0975/c54",
      "osft-doc-0002/c38",
      "osft-doc-0785/c8",
      "open-science-source-10/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0785",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c8",
    "representativeText": "The processes and policies for governing the organisation and selecting representatives to governance groups should be transparent, within the constraints of privacy laws.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c8",
      "osft-doc-0860/c8",
      "osft-doc-1287/c32",
      "osft-doc-0836/c29",
      "osft-doc-0756/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c31",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles mean making data accessible.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c31",
      "osft-doc-0963/c12",
      "open-science-source-25/c26",
      "osft-doc-1771/c21",
      "osft-doc-1027/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1027",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c76",
    "representativeText": "Publication venues should make full text of all publications, including supplementary text and data, available for download in a machine-readable community standard format such as JATS XML.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c76",
      "osft-doc-1213/c56",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c14",
      "open-science-source-20/c13",
      "open-science-source-19/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-20",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c521",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c521",
    "representativeText": "Contributing to major societal challenges requires collaborations with a broad range of societal stakeholders.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c521",
      "osft-doc-1373/c387",
      "osft-doc-1459/c414",
      "osft-doc-1673/c255",
      "open-science-source-03/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c52",
    "representativeText": "Openly available research is cited more regularly than closed research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c52",
      "osft-doc-1327/c649",
      "osft-doc-0298/c176",
      "open-science-source-36/c172",
      "osft-doc-1449/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-22/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-22/c3",
    "representativeText": "Access to research should be equitable for diverse stakeholders.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-22/c3",
      "open-science-source-04/c60",
      "open-science-source-03/c127",
      "osft-doc-1373/c393"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-22",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c34",
    "representativeText": "Article Processing Charges are rising rapidly in price.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c34",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1135",
      "open-science-source-19/c63",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c35",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c12",
    "representativeText": "Institutional repositories run by libraries and other research institutions generally do not charge authors to deposit articles or manuscripts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c12",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c18",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c17",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c32",
      "open-science-source-36/c369"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c26",
    "representativeText": "Requiring that the additional license be granted as a term and condition of funding ensures that the agency receives its additional license at the moment the scholarly publication is created, which is how the longstanding federal purpose license operates.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c26",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c60",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c20",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c24",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c40",
    "representativeText": "APC costs disproportionately affect female researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c40",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c40",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c68",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c25",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c28",
    "representativeText": "FAIR Principles comprise the principle that data and research objects should be reusable.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c28",
      "open-science-source-12/c33",
      "osft-doc-0963/c14",
      "osft-doc-1771/c23",
      "osft-doc-1027/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1027",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-29/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-29/c12",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should deposit research outputs in venues that ensure the outputs are FAIR.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-29/c12",
      "osft-doc-1283/c76",
      "osft-doc-1459/c22",
      "osft-doc-0963/c25",
      "open-science-source-21/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-29",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c327",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c327",
    "representativeText": "A journal's impact factor refers to the average number of citations the journal's publications received.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c327",
      "osft-doc-1373/c408",
      "osft-doc-1459/c438",
      "osft-doc-1449/c360",
      "osft-doc-0142/c445"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-51/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-51/c2",
    "representativeText": "Most open infrastructure projects have little funding.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-51/c2",
      "osft-doc-1373/c365",
      "osft-doc-1459/c397",
      "osft-doc-1673/c238",
      "open-science-source-38/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-51",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c2",
    "representativeText": "Outputs from scientific research include research articles reporting new knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c2",
      "osft-doc-1646/c45",
      "osft-doc-1702/c2",
      "osft-doc-1737/c63",
      "osft-doc-1771/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c3",
    "representativeText": "Outputs from scientific research include data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c3",
      "osft-doc-1646/c46",
      "osft-doc-1702/c3",
      "osft-doc-1737/c64",
      "osft-doc-1771/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c31",
    "representativeText": "Institutions should be explicit about the criteria used to reach hiring, tenure, and promotion decisions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c31",
      "osft-doc-0296/c27",
      "osft-doc-0142/c112",
      "osft-doc-1327/c147",
      "osft-doc-1767/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c113",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c113",
    "representativeText": "Science is a community endeavor.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c113",
      "osft-doc-1878/c107",
      "osft-doc-1353/c118",
      "open-science-source-04/c69",
      "open-science-source-45/c152"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c21",
    "representativeText": "Liberating knowledge locked behind paywalls will accelerate innovation across all sectors globally.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c21",
      "osft-doc-1398/c22",
      "open-science-source-20/c24",
      "osft-doc-1213/c15",
      "osft-doc-1702/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-20",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c32",
    "representativeText": "Open Science helps make the human right to share in scientific advancement and its benefits a reality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c32",
      "osft-doc-1398/c33",
      "open-science-source-42/c291",
      "osft-doc-0002/c16",
      "open-science-source-03/c324"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c18",
    "representativeText": "Federal departments' and agencies' open science action plans should address the sharing of legacy data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c18",
      "osft-doc-1399/c16",
      "osft-doc-1646/c29",
      "osft-doc-1737/c31",
      "osft-doc-1771/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c31",
    "representativeText": "The evolving international context of open science should be monitored by the Chief Science Advisor.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c31",
      "osft-doc-1399/c29",
      "osft-doc-1737/c58",
      "osft-doc-1646/c42",
      "osft-doc-1771/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c299",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c299",
    "representativeText": "There is a lot of diversity in the open knowledge stakeholder group.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c299",
      "osft-doc-1673/c128",
      "osft-doc-1869/c380",
      "osft-doc-1459/c248",
      "osft-doc-1373/c227"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c345",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c345",
    "representativeText": "The open science community's work should be understandable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c345",
      "osft-doc-1373/c388",
      "osft-doc-1459/c415",
      "osft-doc-1673/c256",
      "open-science-source-04/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c457",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c457",
    "representativeText": "Working together enables the scholarly communication community to find common ground and build a sustainable foundation for open reforms.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c457",
      "open-science-source-38/c135",
      "osft-doc-0777/c10",
      "osft-doc-1373/c568",
      "osft-doc-1459/c592"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c553",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c553",
    "representativeText": "The potential that an open future holds for research and society is vast.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c553",
      "osft-doc-1459/c494",
      "osft-doc-1373/c455",
      "osft-doc-0825/c63",
      "osft-doc-1398/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c413",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c413",
    "representativeText": "Open Science practices such as open access publishing, open data, open peer review and open research have the potential to bring about new and exciting pathways for supporting a culture of research integrity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c413",
      "open-science-source-42/c63",
      "osft-doc-1593/c13",
      "osft-doc-0441/c83",
      "open-science-source-21/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1593"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c119",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should encourage and adopt the principles for fairer research assessment outlined in DORA.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c119",
      "osft-doc-1373/c115",
      "osft-doc-1327/c137",
      "osft-doc-0142/c102",
      "osft-doc-1673/c269"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open Science creates opportunities to benefit from the diversity of knowledge systems and perspectives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c10",
      "osft-doc-1646/c12",
      "osft-doc-1771/c12",
      "osft-doc-1459/c251",
      "osft-doc-1673/c130"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c246",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c246",
    "representativeText": "Data should be Findable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c246",
      "osft-doc-1449/c226",
      "open-science-source-12/c145",
      "osft-doc-1940/c6",
      "osft-doc-1197/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1197",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c15",
    "representativeText": "Open scientific practices improve the impact of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c15",
      "osft-doc-0975/c16",
      "osft-doc-0411/c49",
      "osft-doc-0633/c1",
      "osft-doc-1283/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c39",
    "representativeText": "To enable linking of information from different sources, open research information should make use of persistent identifiers such as DOIs, ORCIDs, and ROR IDs to reference research outputs, researchers, research organizations, and other entities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c39",
      "osft-doc-0730/c42",
      "osft-doc-0050/c48",
      "osft-doc-0150/c48",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c37",
    "representativeText": "Barriers to publication created by APCs negatively impact authors, especially in instances where publishing in particular APC-based journals is viewed as important for career advancement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c37",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c37",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c37",
      "open-science-source-38/c128",
      "open-science-source-02/c154"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c55",
    "representativeText": "The Federal purpose license authorizes the agency to authorize others to make broad use of the copyrighted work for federal purposes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c55",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c48",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c24",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c79",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c13",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship offers a paradigm shift toward transparency.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c13",
      "osft-doc-1673/c232",
      "osft-doc-1459/c376",
      "osft-doc-1373/c343",
      "osft-doc-1327/c638"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c121",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c121",
    "representativeText": "Data in contemporary e-Science must be Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable in the long-term.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c121",
      "osft-doc-0971/c44",
      "open-science-source-05/c67",
      "open-science-source-20/c15",
      "osft-doc-0932/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "open-science-source-20",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0932",
      "osft-doc-0971"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c691",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c691",
    "representativeText": "The promise of open will unfold differently for different audiences, such as different fields of study, institutions, and researchers at different career stages.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c691",
      "osft-doc-1459/c10",
      "osft-doc-1171/c16",
      "osft-doc-1373/c9",
      "osft-doc-1569/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1171",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c585",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c585",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly communication is a rapidly evolving landscape.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c585",
      "osft-doc-1459/c611",
      "osft-doc-1673/c331",
      "osft-doc-1327/c46",
      "open-science-source-04/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c354",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c354",
    "representativeText": "Software and code should be made readily available as a research output.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c354",
      "osft-doc-1373/c326",
      "open-science-source-03/c80",
      "osft-doc-1412/c100",
      "osft-doc-0211/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1412",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c168",
    "representativeText": "High costs associated with Open Access publishing actively discriminate against researchers from Low and Middle Income Countries.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c168",
      "osft-doc-1373/c264",
      "osft-doc-1459/c292",
      "osft-doc-1327/c714",
      "open-science-source-02/c151"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c302",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c302",
    "representativeText": "Many researchers adopt Open Scholarship practices, such as data sharing and Open Access publishing, without equating them with the term 'Open Scholarship'.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c302",
      "osft-doc-1373/c523",
      "osft-doc-1459/c548",
      "osft-doc-0411/c53",
      "osft-doc-1327/c465"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c230",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c230",
    "representativeText": "Cultures of openness among scholarly communities are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c230",
      "osft-doc-1373/c219",
      "osft-doc-1459/c233",
      "osft-doc-1673/c115",
      "osft-doc-1353/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c31",
    "representativeText": "Even where researchers are sympathetic to the aims of Open Science, they might not yet see the worth in taking up Open Science practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c31",
      "open-science-source-12/c57",
      "osft-doc-1373/c564",
      "osft-doc-1459/c588",
      "osft-doc-1673/c318"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0633/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0633/c39",
    "representativeText": "Broadening the scope of public access cultivates a scientific ecosystem that is more equitable, collaborative, and impactful.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0633/c39",
      "open-science-source-36/c104",
      "osft-doc-0975/c42",
      "open-science-source-03/c36",
      "open-science-source-02/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c598",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c598",
    "representativeText": "Limitations of openness may relate to privacy issues.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c598",
      "osft-doc-1373/c573",
      "osft-doc-0020/c71",
      "osft-doc-0756/c38",
      "open-science-source-21/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 5
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c107",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Guiding Principles do not suggest any specific technology, standard, or implementation-solution.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c107",
      "osft-doc-0971/c46",
      "osft-doc-1507/c13",
      "osft-doc-1686/c13",
      "osft-doc-1507/c45",
      "osft-doc-1686/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0971",
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c122",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c122",
    "representativeText": "There are numerous competing, parallel, or overlapping definitions of what Open Scholarship comprises in terms of both research principles and practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c122",
      "osft-doc-1459/c241",
      "osft-doc-1373/c501",
      "osft-doc-1459/c535",
      "osft-doc-1373/c223",
      "osft-doc-1327/c404"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c28",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles are designed to be complementary to the FAIR Principles and other mainstream data frameworks.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c28",
      "open-science-source-26/c23",
      "open-science-source-30/c154",
      "open-science-source-30/c7",
      "open-science-source-42/c866",
      "open-science-source-26/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c259",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c259",
    "representativeText": "Evaluation and assessment systems should take into account that diversity of disciplines requires different approaches in open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c259",
      "osft-doc-0142/c86",
      "osft-doc-1047/c38",
      "osft-doc-0142/c702",
      "osft-doc-1673/c173"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c324",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c324",
    "representativeText": "Open source and open scholarship accelerate innovation and research discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c324",
      "osft-doc-1673/c219",
      "osft-doc-1327/c599",
      "osft-doc-1193/c80",
      "osft-doc-1327/c667"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1193",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c30",
    "representativeText": "All peer-reviewed scholarly publications resulting from federally funded research should be made freely available and publicly accessible by default in agency-designated repositories without any embargo or delay after publication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c30",
      "open-science-source-19/c27",
      "open-science-source-36/c20",
      "open-science-source-36/c86",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c405",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c405",
    "representativeText": "A proportion of research funder budgets should be allocated to support sustainable scholarly infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c405",
      "osft-doc-1373/c371",
      "osft-doc-1673/c244",
      "osft-doc-1373/c370",
      "open-science-source-03/c193"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c12",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should form better relationships with other stakeholders involved in Open Scholarship developments.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c12",
      "osft-doc-1459/c48",
      "osft-doc-1373/c50",
      "osft-doc-1373/c74",
      "osft-doc-1327/c162"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c40",
    "representativeText": "Peer review is often untransparent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c40",
      "osft-doc-0142/c763",
      "open-science-source-18/c72",
      "open-science-source-18/c31",
      "osft-doc-1353/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c51",
    "representativeText": "Openly available research is viewed more frequently than closed research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c51",
      "osft-doc-1327/c648",
      "osft-doc-1449/c45",
      "open-science-source-36/c10",
      "osft-doc-1449/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c36",
    "representativeText": "The increase in the cost of research communication presents a growing risk of diverting funds away from the research process itself.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c36",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c36",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c36",
      "open-science-source-36/c162",
      "open-science-source-36/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c1",
    "representativeText": "Scientists' use of AI is growing exponentially.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c1",
      "open-science-source-45/c79",
      "open-science-source-42/c884",
      "open-science-source-45/c26",
      "open-science-source-12/c218"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c206",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c206",
    "representativeText": "Improving reproducibility requires shared norms.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c206",
      "osft-doc-0050/c191",
      "osft-doc-0050/c22",
      "osft-doc-1373/c446",
      "osft-doc-1459/c483"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c20",
    "representativeText": "Optimal conditions for reasoned dissent occur when researchers, or any interested party, have unrestricted access to study protocols, data and analyses.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c20",
      "osft-doc-1878/c23",
      "osft-doc-1878/c30",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c42",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1253/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1253/c14",
    "representativeText": "Open science comprises open access publishing, which applies broadly to all disciplines of study, including basic and applied sciences, natural and social sciences, and the humanities.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1253/c14",
      "osft-doc-0411/c16",
      "osft-doc-0411/c36",
      "osft-doc-0825/c28",
      "osft-doc-1398/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c770",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c770",
    "representativeText": "Common assessment mechanisms should be created to track open science progress.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c770",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c187",
      "osft-doc-1737/c34",
      "open-science-source-03/c310",
      "open-science-source-03/c316"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c570",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c570",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should be aware of the functions of the wider scholarly communication system and the diverse range of processes and norms involved in it.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c570",
      "osft-doc-1673/c322",
      "osft-doc-1459/c595",
      "osft-doc-1459/c594",
      "osft-doc-1327/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c34",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should adopt personal open scholarly practices such as sharing research data and materials in free, openly-licensed formats so methods and results can be freely examined and built upon.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c34",
      "osft-doc-1373/c36",
      "osft-doc-1878/c307",
      "osft-doc-1373/c25",
      "osft-doc-0268/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0268",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c249",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c249",
    "representativeText": "Data should be Reusable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c249",
      "osft-doc-1449/c229",
      "osft-doc-1449/c225",
      "osft-doc-1197/c18",
      "osft-doc-0963/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1197",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c68",
    "representativeText": "Metadata should be provided and recorded in a standard, interoperable, nonproprietary format.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c68",
      "osft-doc-1213/c57",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c92",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c63",
      "osft-doc-1213/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c128",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c128",
    "representativeText": "Preprint servers should be used.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c128",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c16",
      "osft-doc-1373/c66",
      "open-science-source-28/c4",
      "osft-doc-1373/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-28",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c474",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c474",
    "representativeText": "Open Science represents a fundamental change in the way universities and their scholars work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c474",
      "open-science-source-25/c17",
      "osft-doc-0411/c11",
      "osft-doc-0411/c29",
      "osft-doc-1869/c383"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c47",
    "representativeText": "Under longstanding policy, agencies already receive a license to any copyrighted work created with federal funds that authorizes the agency to make broad use of the work for federal purposes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c47",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c53",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c54",
      "open-science-source-36/c397",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c59",
    "representativeText": "National-level actors should support collaborations that help build richer connectivity between systems and communities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c59",
      "osft-doc-1459/c150",
      "osft-doc-1373/c141",
      "osft-doc-1373/c191",
      "open-science-source-10/c144"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c7",
    "representativeText": "Research is pluralist.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c7",
      "osft-doc-0142/c732",
      "osft-doc-0142/c646",
      "open-science-source-18/c110",
      "osft-doc-1327/c786"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c58",
    "representativeText": "Universities should align their assessment, reward and evaluation systems with Open Science developments.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c58",
      "open-science-source-25/c19",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c241",
      "open-science-source-21/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c119",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure organisation should commit to a patent non-assertion covenant.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c119",
      "osft-doc-0846/c85",
      "osft-doc-1287/c79",
      "osft-doc-1781/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c13",
    "representativeText": "Governments and universities must ensure the immediate and unrestricted sharing of research findings funded by taxpayers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c13",
      "open-science-source-22/c2",
      "open-science-source-21/c32",
      "open-science-source-34/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-22",
      "open-science-source-34",
      "osft-doc-0114"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c49",
    "representativeText": "When involved in committees making decisions about funding, hiring, tenure, or promotion, researchers should make assessments based on scientific content rather than publication metrics.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c49",
      "osft-doc-0296/c45",
      "open-science-source-18/c773",
      "open-science-source-43/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c48",
    "representativeText": "The SSA's public access policy should ensure the final publication carries full reuse rights, such as those provided by a CC BY 4.0 International License or its functional equivalent, not just the right for the publication to be made available in the repository.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c48",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c12",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c29",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c355",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c355",
    "representativeText": "The journal title in which research outputs are published should not be used as a proxy for the assessment of the quality of research outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c355",
      "osft-doc-0296/c20",
      "osft-doc-1373/c56",
      "osft-doc-1459/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c52",
    "representativeText": "Universities should encourage open and reproducible research initiatives by creating incentives such as promotion and tenure categories and service recognition.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c52",
      "osft-doc-1373/c112",
      "osft-doc-1449/c340",
      "open-science-source-21/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c10",
    "representativeText": "A federal public access policy must allow for broad and expeditious sharing of federally funded research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c10",
      "open-science-source-20/c10",
      "open-science-source-19/c24",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-20",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-34"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c255",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c255",
    "representativeText": "Evaluation and assessment systems should increasingly focus on the quality of research outputs rather than quantity.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c255",
      "open-science-source-43/c87",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c127",
      "osft-doc-0068/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c18",
    "representativeText": "Research data and code must be Accessible to be shared and reused effectively.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c18",
      "osft-doc-1459/c36",
      "open-science-source-07/c10",
      "osft-doc-1373/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-07",
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c258",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c258",
    "representativeText": "Evaluation and assessment systems should take into account evidence of research impact and knowledge exchange, such as widening participation in the research process, influence on policy and practice, and engaging in open innovation with partners beyond academia.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c258",
      "osft-doc-0108/c30",
      "osft-doc-0296/c26",
      "osft-doc-0142/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0860/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0860/c4",
    "representativeText": "Participation or membership should follow an opt-in approach with principles of non-discrimination and inclusivity.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0860/c4",
      "open-science-source-09/c4",
      "osft-doc-0020/c14",
      "osft-doc-1287/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c36",
    "representativeText": "Member States should align incentives to support open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c36",
      "osft-doc-0785/c6",
      "osft-doc-0068/c38",
      "osft-doc-1869/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-0785",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1213/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1213/c5",
    "representativeText": "The only restriction on use of Open Access material should be an obligation to attribute the work to the author.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1213/c5",
      "osft-doc-0504/c20",
      "osft-doc-1124/c23",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1702/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1702/c73",
    "representativeText": "Open access supports scientific discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1702/c73",
      "open-science-source-21/c28",
      "osft-doc-0504/c4",
      "osft-doc-1124/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c364",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c364",
    "representativeText": "The JIF cannot be used as a surrogate for the quality of individual articles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c364",
      "osft-doc-0268/c12",
      "osft-doc-0142/c460",
      "open-science-source-02/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0268",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c100",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should teach students and early career researchers about open lab notebooks, version control, continuous analysis, and other aspects of Open Scholarship in introductory research courses.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c100",
      "osft-doc-1459/c214",
      "osft-doc-1373/c201",
      "osft-doc-1767/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c489",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c489",
    "representativeText": "Open science solutions must be collaborative, requiring broad collaboration to ensure all perspectives are considered and there is broad ownership of ideas.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c489",
      "osft-doc-0633/c10",
      "open-science-source-03/c178",
      "osft-doc-1373/c148"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1399/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1399/c15",
    "representativeText": "All research outputs should be Open by Design and by Default.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1399/c15",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c6",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c24",
      "osft-doc-1459/c224"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c25",
    "representativeText": "Open sharing of resources, data, and the products of research enhances accessibility for the scholarly community and the wider public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c25",
      "osft-doc-1878/c28",
      "open-science-source-27/c31",
      "open-science-source-21/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open Science has the potential to change the workings of the scholarly communication system for the better.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c9",
      "osft-doc-1449/c480",
      "osft-doc-0975/c38",
      "open-science-source-06/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c111",
    "representativeText": "A scholarly communication system in which open science is the norm should be created, to accelerate discoveries and maximise the impact of research, for the benefit of science and society.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c111",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1055",
      "osft-doc-1459/c320",
      "osft-doc-1373/c290"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c38",
    "representativeText": "Shared outputs should be accompanied with detailed metadata that allows other researchers to understand and reuse the materials.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c38",
      "osft-doc-1940/c24",
      "osft-doc-1197/c3",
      "osft-doc-0645/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-43/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-43/c25",
    "representativeText": "In a reputation economy, quantitative metrics such as publication number, impact factors and h-index often count more than the quality of the research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-43/c25",
      "osft-doc-0441/c153",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1118",
      "open-science-source-13/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-13",
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0441"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c12",
    "representativeText": "Any stakeholder group may express an interest in membership.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c12",
      "osft-doc-0756/c5",
      "osft-doc-0836/c26",
      "osft-doc-1287/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c44",
    "representativeText": "All research objects should be Findable, both for machines and for people.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c44",
      "open-science-source-22/c5",
      "osft-doc-1373/c23",
      "osft-doc-1327/c275"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c19",
    "representativeText": "Centralized and common elements of federal departments' and agencies' open science action plans should be developed collaboratively, such as in relation to timelines, accessibility, official languages, and IT considerations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c19",
      "osft-doc-1771/c34",
      "osft-doc-1737/c32",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c60",
    "representativeText": "There are too many stakeholders with different interests and perspectives who influence different decision points in scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c60",
      "osft-doc-1459/c316",
      "osft-doc-1673/c186",
      "osft-doc-1373/c286"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c7",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship encompasses many practices.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c7",
      "osft-doc-1569/c5",
      "osft-doc-1459/c7",
      "osft-doc-1673/c146"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c62",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include book chapters.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c62",
      "osft-doc-1702/c97",
      "osft-doc-1737/c75",
      "osft-doc-1771/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c64",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include conference papers.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c64",
      "osft-doc-1702/c99",
      "osft-doc-1737/c77",
      "osft-doc-1771/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c66",
    "representativeText": "Notions such as journal impact factor are poor surrogates for measuring the true impact of scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c66",
      "osft-doc-1459/c437",
      "osft-doc-1869/c117",
      "osft-doc-1327/c974"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c277",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c277",
    "representativeText": "Publishing models should be favored that are controlled by academic-led and nonprofit organizations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c277",
      "open-science-source-43/c11",
      "open-science-source-23/c44",
      "open-science-source-03/c265"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c36",
    "representativeText": "Sustainable funding mechanisms and transparent governance structures are crucial to guarantee continuity of services, enable community participation, and ensure that these infrastructures can evolve alongside research needs, ultimately strengthening the global capacity to verify, reproduce, and re-use scientific work.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c36",
      "osft-doc-0050/c39",
      "open-science-source-05/c18",
      "osft-doc-0730/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c198",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c198",
    "representativeText": "Shifting resources from APC-based OA to green and diamond OA will enhance community control over scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c198",
      "open-science-source-43/c68",
      "open-science-source-10/c157",
      "open-science-source-38/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c6",
    "representativeText": "The use and acceptance of OA preprints has grown.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c6",
      "osft-doc-1459/c508",
      "osft-doc-1673/c288",
      "osft-doc-0068/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c134",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c134",
    "representativeText": "Increased openness reinforces the fundamental feature of science as a distinct form of knowledge based on evidence and tested against reality, logic and the scrutiny of scientific peers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c134",
      "osft-doc-0441/c29",
      "osft-doc-1878/c32",
      "osft-doc-0411/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c97",
    "representativeText": "Repositories should adopt interoperable standards and best practices to ensure the content in repositories is appropriately vetted, discoverable and reusable by humans and machines.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c97",
      "osft-doc-1213/c27",
      "open-science-source-06/c213",
      "osft-doc-1327/c853"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c59",
    "representativeText": "If it is possible, the organisation and staff should have direct incentives to deliver on the mission and wind down.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c59",
      "osft-doc-0846/c33",
      "osft-doc-0151/c60",
      "osft-doc-1287/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c14",
    "representativeText": "Diamond Open Access is a scholarly publishing model without costs for authors or readers.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c14",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c84",
      "open-science-source-28/c29",
      "open-science-source-36/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-28",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c159",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c159",
    "representativeText": "Lead Stakeholders should progressively redirect a defined and predictable share of existing subscription, Article Processing Charges and Transformative Agreements expenditure toward coordinated, community governed, non-commercial funding mechanisms at national and international levels.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c159",
      "open-science-source-23/c64",
      "open-science-source-02/c267",
      "osft-doc-1459/c206"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-23",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c140",
    "representativeText": "Research should deliver societal benefit.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c140",
      "osft-doc-1459/c418",
      "osft-doc-1373/c391",
      "open-science-source-27/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c38",
    "representativeText": "\"Gold\" OA status is defined as a publication published in a fully open access journal.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c38",
      "osft-doc-1459/c506",
      "osft-doc-1673/c286",
      "osft-doc-1373/c468"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c511",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c511",
    "representativeText": "Research funders, scholarly publishers and other stakeholders have experimented with a wide range of innovations to address current challenges in peer review, many of which are now being implemented more widely.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c511",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1113",
      "osft-doc-0142/c779",
      "open-science-source-02/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c531",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c531",
    "representativeText": "The research system in its current form is underpinned by an ethos of extreme competitiveness and scarce resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c531",
      "osft-doc-1373/c549",
      "osft-doc-1459/c573",
      "osft-doc-1673/c312"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c96",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c96",
    "representativeText": "Peer review is a process by which experts in a field or discipline assess research proposals, research outputs, researchers, or research units, typically within the same field or discipline.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c96",
      "open-science-source-36/c206",
      "osft-doc-1047/c90",
      "osft-doc-0142/c219"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c17",
    "representativeText": "Long-term preservation of research outputs should be provided via either a digital repository maintained by the funding agency or an appropriate institutional or disciplinary repository.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c17",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c70",
      "open-science-source-38/c205",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-20",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c16",
    "representativeText": "Paywalls at subscription-based journals prevent citizens, patients, clinicians, policymakers, and scholars at institutions with limited resources from engaging with research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c16",
      "open-science-source-36/c17",
      "open-science-source-02/c27",
      "osft-doc-1353/c130"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c12",
    "representativeText": "Enhancing access to research outputs improves the Department's transparency and accountability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c12",
      "osft-doc-1646/c3",
      "osft-doc-1737/c3",
      "osft-doc-1771/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c6",
    "representativeText": "Depositing final peer-reviewed accepted manuscripts into PMC is the most affordable compliance mechanism for grantees because it is free for the author.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c27",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c23",
      "osft-doc-0534/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "osft-doc-0534"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c4/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c4/c39",
    "representativeText": "APC costs disproportionately affect younger researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c39",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c39",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c67",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c29",
    "representativeText": "Making data public can catalyze collaboration for future research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c29",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c45",
      "open-science-source-12/c36",
      "osft-doc-1193/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1193"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c6/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c6/c18",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should have a digital persistent identifier such as an ORCID.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c18",
      "osft-doc-1373/c118",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c47",
      "open-science-source-21/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c50",
    "representativeText": "Full public reuse of a publication allows others to interrogate the results.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c50",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c15",
      "osft-doc-0441/c22",
      "osft-doc-1878/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c78",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c78",
    "representativeText": "RDA is a global organization that stands for data sharing without barriers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c78",
      "osft-doc-1027/c87",
      "osft-doc-1507/c18",
      "osft-doc-1686/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027",
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c61",
    "representativeText": "Metadata associated with scholarly publications and data resulting from federally funded research should include, at minimum, a unique digital persistent identifier for the research output.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c61",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c17",
      "open-science-source-21/c36",
      "osft-doc-1197/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-34",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c115",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c115",
    "representativeText": "The European Open Science Cloud (EOSC) has an ambition of integration and federation of services based on an agreed interoperability framework.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c115",
      "osft-doc-1373/c166",
      "osft-doc-1459/c176",
      "osft-doc-1673/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c119",
    "representativeText": "Replicable research means that the same results are obtained when new data is collected and analysed again with the same methods and protocols.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c119",
      "osft-doc-1459/c382",
      "osft-doc-1673/c235",
      "osft-doc-1373/c352"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c147",
    "representativeText": "Research funders, research institutions, industry actors, and relevant scientific communities should implement practices that blend open science with safeguards against potential risks.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c147",
      "osft-doc-1646/c49",
      "osft-doc-1771/c55",
      "osft-doc-0633/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c112",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c112",
    "representativeText": "Teaching loads, funding acquisition, and administrative tasks are eating into researchers' research hours.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c112",
      "osft-doc-1373/c563",
      "osft-doc-1459/c587",
      "osft-doc-1673/c317"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c165",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c165",
    "representativeText": "Global challenges require a collaborative interdisciplinary solution.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c165",
      "open-science-source-18/c520",
      "osft-doc-1327/c724",
      "open-science-source-03/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c83",
    "representativeText": "Replication strengthens confidence in research findings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c83",
      "osft-doc-0150/c73",
      "osft-doc-1353/c225",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c124"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0105/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0105/c149",
    "representativeText": "Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural world through application of one or more elements of the scientific method.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0105/c149",
      "osft-doc-1771/c56",
      "osft-doc-1646/c50",
      "osft-doc-1737/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1225",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1225",
    "representativeText": "Metrics proposed for assessing research impact are in an early stage of development.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1225",
      "osft-doc-1373/c403",
      "osft-doc-1459/c432",
      "open-science-source-06/c242"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1344",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1344",
    "representativeText": "Existing or emergent indicators can be gamed.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1344",
      "osft-doc-1373/c432",
      "osft-doc-1459/c464",
      "osft-doc-1673/c265"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0152/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0152/c4",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly research can be idealised as an inspirational process for advancing collective knowledge to the benefit of all humankind.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0152/c4",
      "osft-doc-1373/c1",
      "osft-doc-1459/c1",
      "osft-doc-1569/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0152",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0152/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0152/c5",
    "representativeText": "Current research practices often struggle with a range of tensions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0152/c5",
      "osft-doc-1373/c2",
      "osft-doc-1459/c2",
      "osft-doc-1569/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0152",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c18",
    "representativeText": "Scholars have understood the benefits of open, transparent, reproducible and cumulative research practices for hundreds of years.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c18",
      "osft-doc-1878/c21",
      "osft-doc-1373/c637",
      "osft-doc-1459/c660"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c22",
    "representativeText": "Producing the peer-reviewed journal literature is not costless.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c22",
      "osft-doc-1124/c25",
      "osft-doc-1398/c47",
      "osft-doc-0825/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c30",
    "representativeText": "Open Science includes sharing the methodology and programming code used to conduct the research.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c30",
      "osft-doc-1398/c30",
      "open-science-source-42/c283",
      "osft-doc-1612/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c56",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should adopt transparent financial models that directly correlate the price of publication with the quality of services offered.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c56",
      "osft-doc-1398/c57",
      "osft-doc-1327/c324",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c22",
    "representativeText": "Strategies for implementing FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) principles for research data and metadata should be in place by January 2023.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c22",
      "osft-doc-1399/c20",
      "osft-doc-1737/c41",
      "osft-doc-1771/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c24",
    "representativeText": "Implementing FAIR principles for research data and metadata requires robust data management practices for research data and metadata.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c24",
      "osft-doc-1399/c22",
      "osft-doc-1771/c41",
      "osft-doc-1737/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0963/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0963/c11",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Data Principles include making data Findable.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0963/c11",
      "open-science-source-12/c30",
      "open-science-source-25/c25",
      "osft-doc-1027/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c5",
    "representativeText": "The private enterprises holding this scholarly metadata do not answer to any community board.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c5",
      "osft-doc-0836/c5",
      "osft-doc-0730/c6",
      "open-science-source-05/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c416",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c416",
    "representativeText": "Open science has different philosophical underpinnings for different audiences.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c416",
      "osft-doc-1673/c181",
      "osft-doc-1373/c281",
      "osft-doc-1459/c311"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c108",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c108",
    "representativeText": "Research libraries should collect information about how much is being spent on Article Processing Charges and Book Processing Charges for Open Access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c108",
      "osft-doc-1459/c110",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c47",
      "osft-doc-1327/c218"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c119",
    "representativeText": "Faculty and funder support for Open Access and related quality assurance initiatives that are decoupled from journals should be built on.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c119",
      "osft-doc-1673/c56",
      "osft-doc-1459/c125",
      "osft-doc-1327/c669"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c149",
    "representativeText": "Showcases, highlights, and good practices of Open Scholarship practices should be created on national websites or portals, together with relevant information and resources.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c149",
      "osft-doc-1459/c158",
      "osft-doc-1673/c81",
      "osft-doc-1283/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c229",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c229",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship has a range of different social, economic and cultural contexts, which its various communities and stakeholders are united under.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c229",
      "osft-doc-1459/c250",
      "osft-doc-1869/c22",
      "osft-doc-1327/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c26",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should adopt open source and/or free software for the conduct of research and analysis.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c26",
      "osft-doc-1673/c9",
      "osft-doc-1459/c25",
      "osft-doc-1869/c267"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c407",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c407",
    "representativeText": "Traditional metrics for measuring scientific impact have proven problematic, for example by being too heavily focused on journal publications or inappropriately applied at the journal level.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c407",
      "osft-doc-1673/c263",
      "osft-doc-1449/c324",
      "open-science-source-02/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c412",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c412",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship seeks alternative metrics (altmetrics) that can make use of new possibilities of digitally networked tools to track and measure the impact of scholarship through formerly invisible activities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c412",
      "osft-doc-1459/c441",
      "osft-doc-1673/c264",
      "osft-doc-0142/c596"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c502",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c502",
    "representativeText": "Governments, public and private funding agencies, research institutes, and educational entities continually develop diverse policies to govern Open Scholarship initiatives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c502",
      "osft-doc-1459/c536",
      "osft-doc-1673/c367",
      "osft-doc-0026/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0026",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c540",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c540",
    "representativeText": "To lower engagement thresholds, the use of jargon should be avoided where possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c540",
      "osft-doc-1459/c565",
      "osft-doc-1327/c868"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c583",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c583",
    "representativeText": "Universities and research funders are in a position to adopt new practices in hiring, promotion, and tenure, and in particular to control how Open Scholarship feeds into these practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c583",
      "osft-doc-1459/c609",
      "osft-doc-1673/c329",
      "osft-doc-0138/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c99",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c99",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should adopt the Initiative for Open Citations (I4OC) in conjunction with the wider uptake of open standards.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c99",
      "osft-doc-1459/c99",
      "osft-doc-1673/c43",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c469",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c469",
    "representativeText": "Open Science brings many challenges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c469",
      "osft-doc-1171/c18",
      "open-science-source-12/c42",
      "osft-doc-1327/c561"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1171",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c187",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c187",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should convert saved resources currently spent on closed-journal subscriptions into funds supporting scholarly infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c187",
      "osft-doc-1373/c175",
      "osft-doc-1673/c92",
      "open-science-source-18/c769"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c270",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c270",
    "representativeText": "The core aspects of Open Scholarship include the category of principles and values.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c270",
      "osft-doc-1673/c147",
      "osft-doc-1373/c8",
      "osft-doc-1569/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c273",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c273",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship include transparency.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c273",
      "osft-doc-1673/c150",
      "osft-doc-1373/c249",
      "osft-doc-0680/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0680",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c17",
    "representativeText": "The scientific community is integral to Open Science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c17",
      "osft-doc-1737/c15",
      "osft-doc-1771/c17",
      "osft-doc-1869/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c31",
    "representativeText": "Federal departments and agencies should make federal science publications openly accessible by January 2023, while respecting privacy, security, ethical considerations and appropriate intellectual property protection.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c31",
      "osft-doc-1737/c36",
      "osft-doc-1771/c37",
      "osft-doc-1399/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c47",
    "representativeText": "Scientific research outputs include public contribution to and dialogue about science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c47",
      "osft-doc-1702/c4",
      "osft-doc-1737/c65",
      "osft-doc-1771/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c57",
    "representativeText": "Federal science articles are defined as scholarly articles authored or co-authored by federal scientists or researchers in peer-reviewed academic journals.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c57",
      "osft-doc-1702/c92",
      "osft-doc-1771/c63",
      "osft-doc-1737/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c58",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications are defined as scientific communications that scientists and researchers use to share their work.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c58",
      "osft-doc-1702/c93",
      "osft-doc-1737/c71",
      "osft-doc-1771/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c59",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include research or scientific reports.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c59",
      "osft-doc-1702/c94",
      "osft-doc-1737/c72",
      "osft-doc-1771/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c60",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include monographs.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c60",
      "osft-doc-1702/c95",
      "osft-doc-1737/c73",
      "osft-doc-1771/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c61",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include edited books.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c61",
      "osft-doc-1702/c96",
      "osft-doc-1737/c74",
      "osft-doc-1771/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c65",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c65",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include conference contributions.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c65",
      "osft-doc-1702/c100",
      "osft-doc-1737/c78",
      "osft-doc-1771/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c66",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include posters.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c66",
      "osft-doc-1702/c101",
      "osft-doc-1737/c79",
      "osft-doc-1771/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c67",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c67",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include plain language summaries.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c67",
      "osft-doc-1702/c102",
      "osft-doc-1737/c80",
      "osft-doc-1771/c73"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c68",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications include technical scientific products.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c68",
      "osft-doc-1702/c103",
      "osft-doc-1737/c81",
      "osft-doc-1771/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c352",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c352",
    "representativeText": "Continued reliance on non-transparent, non-reproducible metrics information from commercial providers will be detrimental to scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c352",
      "osft-doc-1373/c619",
      "osft-doc-1459/c642",
      "open-science-source-02/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c42",
    "representativeText": "Open access is a means to the usability of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c42",
      "osft-doc-0777/c25",
      "open-science-source-04/c58",
      "osft-doc-0504/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-0777"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c135",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly communication should embrace the possibilities of new technology.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c135",
      "osft-doc-1673/c140",
      "open-science-source-06/c32",
      "osft-doc-0211/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c7",
    "representativeText": "Depositing final peer-reviewed accepted manuscripts into PMC is the most equitable compliance mechanism for grantees because it is free for the author.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c24",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c26",
      "open-science-source-23/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c6/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c6/c14",
    "representativeText": "Federally funded publications, data, and other research outputs and their metadata should be reusable to the American public and the scientific community in an equitable and secure manner.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c14",
      "open-science-source-34/c76",
      "osft-doc-1771/c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c10/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c10",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-34",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c8",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship is a key tool for creating a more equitable, inclusive, and just research environment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c8",
      "osft-doc-0441/c96",
      "osft-doc-1878/c91",
      "osft-doc-0975/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c123",
    "representativeText": "CARE should be operationalized for Indigenous Peoples' data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c123",
      "osft-doc-1612/c79",
      "open-science-source-30/c55",
      "osft-doc-1027/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c146",
    "representativeText": "Making research outputs as open and FAIR as possible could stimulate their impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c146",
      "osft-doc-0900/c31",
      "open-science-source-12/c123",
      "osft-doc-1612/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-0900",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c68",
    "representativeText": "AI is driving change across the shifts occurring in research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c68",
      "open-science-source-12/c204",
      "open-science-source-42/c202",
      "open-science-source-41/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c43",
    "representativeText": "An organisation must be able to adapt and change, not merely survive.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c43",
      "osft-doc-0151/c75",
      "osft-doc-0846/c47",
      "osft-doc-0756/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0846"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c132",
    "representativeText": "A primary barrier to widely sharing and reusing data is the lack of incentives for researchers to share information in a timely and transparent manner.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c132",
      "osft-doc-1195/c4",
      "open-science-source-22/c8",
      "open-science-source-19/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-22",
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1195"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0785/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0785/c1",
    "representativeText": "Member States should prioritize promoting a common understanding of open science, its associated benefits and challenges, and the diverse paths to open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0785/c1",
      "osft-doc-0002/c26",
      "open-science-source-03/c146",
      "osft-doc-1449/c276"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0785",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c398",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c398",
    "representativeText": "All research outputs created during the research lifecycle, from lab notebooks to methods, materials, algorithms, data, code and the paper, should be constantly and continuously documented and shared.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c398",
      "osft-doc-0645/c18",
      "osft-doc-1327/c274",
      "open-science-source-29/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-29",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c359",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c359",
    "representativeText": "The Journal Impact Factor (JIF) is one of the most common bibliometric measures used by researchers, journals and universities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c359",
      "osft-doc-0108/c11",
      "osft-doc-0296/c6",
      "osft-doc-1327/c973"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c13",
    "representativeText": "Open Science reduces delays in the sharing and re-use of scientific information.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c13",
      "osft-doc-1737/c11",
      "osft-doc-1771/c13",
      "open-science-source-25/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c221",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c221",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship reduces redundancy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c221",
      "osft-doc-1646/c8",
      "osft-doc-1771/c8",
      "osft-doc-0975/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c64",
    "representativeText": "As AI tool adoption grows, ensuring responsible use is critical.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c64",
      "open-science-source-45/c284",
      "open-science-source-03/c217",
      "open-science-source-18/c488"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1193/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1193/c105",
    "representativeText": "Science outputs—papers, data, materials, registrations, and the infrastructure hosting them—should be open to the maximum extent possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1193/c105",
      "open-science-source-03/c86",
      "osft-doc-0002/c17",
      "open-science-source-21/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1193"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c416",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c416",
    "representativeText": "Reproducible research is imperative.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c416",
      "osft-doc-0441/c179",
      "osft-doc-1878/c175",
      "osft-doc-0084/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0084",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c248",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c248",
    "representativeText": "Data should be Interoperable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c248",
      "osft-doc-1449/c228",
      "osft-doc-1940/c19",
      "osft-doc-0645/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 4
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c63",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous communities feel tension between protecting their interests in scientific data generated from their lands, waters, and people, and supporting or being subject to open data and data sharing initiatives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c63",
      "open-science-source-26/c54",
      "open-science-source-30/c1",
      "open-science-source-26/c25",
      "open-science-source-30/c144",
      "open-science-source-30/c142"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 6,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 6
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c49",
    "representativeText": "Guidelines for research assessment must take into account career stage and discipline.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c49",
      "osft-doc-0142/c719",
      "osft-doc-0142/c787",
      "osft-doc-0142/c367",
      "open-science-source-43/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c93",
    "representativeText": "Funders and Research Performing Organisations should give credit for FAIR data resulting from research work, similar to publications, methods, code and other outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c93",
      "open-science-source-12/c24",
      "open-science-source-12/c114",
      "open-science-source-12/c147",
      "osft-doc-1869/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c50",
    "representativeText": "Compiling existing and creating new tools and criteria for implementing the CARE Principles are needed to achieve data that are FAIR with CARE.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c50",
      "osft-doc-1027/c57",
      "osft-doc-1027/c127",
      "osft-doc-1027/c56",
      "open-science-source-30/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c3",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles are people- and purpose-oriented.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c3",
      "open-science-source-26/c57",
      "osft-doc-1027/c66",
      "open-science-source-26/c7",
      "osft-doc-1027/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c11",
    "representativeText": "Funders should actively support and incentivise replication studies across all funding streams.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c11",
      "osft-doc-0150/c12",
      "osft-doc-0150/c86",
      "osft-doc-0150/c84",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c128"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "may": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c773",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c773",
    "representativeText": "Peer review cannot process the complete research output of a nation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c773",
      "open-science-source-18/c681",
      "open-science-source-17/c59",
      "open-science-source-18/c62",
      "open-science-source-18/c684"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-17",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c67",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c67",
    "representativeText": "Forking carries a high cost and remains challenging in practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c67",
      "osft-doc-1781/c104",
      "osft-doc-1287/c69",
      "osft-doc-1287/c68",
      "osft-doc-1781/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c18",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should highlight best practice showcases to demonstrate what is possible with Open Scholarship and its wider advantages.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c18",
      "osft-doc-1373/c61",
      "osft-doc-1459/c62",
      "osft-doc-1459/c178",
      "osft-doc-1373/c168"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c276",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c276",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship seeks to ensure diversity and inclusion are key principles in scholarly conversations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c276",
      "osft-doc-1373/c438",
      "osft-doc-1459/c470",
      "osft-doc-1373/c634",
      "osft-doc-1459/c657"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c65",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c65",
    "representativeText": "Channeling more money into the existing scholarly system, with its perverse incentives and skewed power dynamics, is no longer sustainable for research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c65",
      "osft-doc-1459/c164",
      "osft-doc-1373/c156",
      "osft-doc-1459/c666",
      "osft-doc-1373/c643"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c87",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should develop Open Scholarship workflows for all group members to take advantage of open scholarly infrastructure and tools.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c87",
      "osft-doc-1459/c175",
      "osft-doc-1373/c165",
      "osft-doc-1373/c207",
      "osft-doc-1459/c220"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1781/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1781/c100",
    "representativeText": "Long-term trust requires that the community believe it retains control.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1781/c100",
      "osft-doc-1287/c64",
      "osft-doc-0836/c63",
      "osft-doc-1287/c21",
      "osft-doc-0836/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c278",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c278",
    "representativeText": "The concept of open is under debate.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c278",
      "osft-doc-1327/c359",
      "open-science-source-04/c13",
      "osft-doc-1327/c413",
      "osft-doc-1327/c917"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c130",
    "representativeText": "There are concerns about the peer review process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c130",
      "osft-doc-0142/c22",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1200",
      "open-science-source-18/c2",
      "osft-doc-0142/c753"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c5",
    "representativeText": "Peer review remains the method of choice for assessment of research quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c5",
      "osft-doc-0142/c189",
      "osft-doc-0142/c758",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1199",
      "open-science-source-18/c675"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c27",
    "representativeText": "Implementation of the CARE Principles as a required dimension of open and FAIR data must ensure that the use of data aligns with Indigenous rights.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c27",
      "osft-doc-1027/c35",
      "open-science-source-30/c74",
      "open-science-source-30/c117",
      "osft-doc-1027/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c479",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c479",
    "representativeText": "Cultural change at the university level is needed to support Open Science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c479",
      "open-science-source-25/c34",
      "osft-doc-1327/c54",
      "osft-doc-1327/c292"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c20",
    "representativeText": "Journal-based metrics, such as Journal Impact Factors, must be eliminated from use in funding, appointment, and promotion considerations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c20",
      "osft-doc-0296/c14",
      "osft-doc-0296/c22",
      "osft-doc-1673/c268"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c50",
    "representativeText": "Guidelines for research assessment must be appropriately tailored to their target, such as individual or institution.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c50",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1300",
      "open-science-source-06/c282",
      "osft-doc-0142/c619"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c68",
    "representativeText": "Mandates alone are not enough to drive implementation of open science principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c68",
      "osft-doc-1449/c85",
      "osft-doc-1327/c12",
      "osft-doc-1327/c656"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c4",
    "representativeText": "Operationalizing the FAIR Principles for scientific data with the CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance brings people and purpose to the fore in order to resolve Indigenous Peoples' rights to and interests in their data across the data lifecycle.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c4",
      "osft-doc-1027/c3",
      "open-science-source-30/c62",
      "open-science-source-30/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c12",
    "representativeText": "Openness of research information must be the new norm.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c12",
      "open-science-source-05/c13",
      "open-science-source-05/c17",
      "osft-doc-1327/c502"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c56",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should make software and code available under open licenses that allow for free access, modification, and reuse.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c56",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c75",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c72",
      "open-science-source-03/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c121",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c121",
    "representativeText": "Engaging CARE in data stewardship necessitates making data FAIR.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c121",
      "open-science-source-26/c114",
      "open-science-source-30/c70",
      "open-science-source-26/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c35",
    "representativeText": "The peer review system is overloaded.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c35",
      "open-science-source-18/c356",
      "open-science-source-18/c104",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1112"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c111",
    "representativeText": "A system of scholarly communication should incentivize, reward, and recognize reviewing, no less than doing research, in order to create a balance between the production of knowledge and its consolidation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c111",
      "open-science-source-18/c285",
      "open-science-source-18/c18",
      "osft-doc-1327/c776"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c41",
    "representativeText": "Peer review is potentially biased.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c41",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1201",
      "open-science-source-18/c434",
      "osft-doc-0142/c768"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c16",
    "representativeText": "Research information generated in publication processes should be made openly available through open scholarly infrastructures, using standard protocols and identifiers where available.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c16",
      "osft-doc-0730/c15",
      "osft-doc-1373/c95",
      "osft-doc-0730/c73"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c1",
    "representativeText": "Peer review is often seen as one of the cornerstones of the research system.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c1",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1110",
      "osft-doc-0142/c190",
      "osft-doc-0142/c751"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c16",
    "representativeText": "UNDRIP asserts Indigenous Peoples' rights and interests in data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c16",
      "osft-doc-1027/c21",
      "open-science-source-30/c79",
      "osft-doc-1027/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c18",
    "representativeText": "Access to data for governance is essential to support self-determination.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c18",
      "osft-doc-1027/c23",
      "open-science-source-30/c81",
      "open-science-source-30/c186"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c30",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility is important to scientific inquiry.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c30",
      "osft-doc-1353/c230",
      "open-science-source-04/c80",
      "osft-doc-1353/c229"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c188",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c188",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility is inherently contextual.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c188",
      "osft-doc-0150/c203",
      "osft-doc-0150/c132",
      "open-science-source-42/c496"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c36",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should make available a range of article-level metrics to encourage a shift toward assessment based on the scientific content of an article rather than publication metrics of the journal.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c36",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1374",
      "osft-doc-0142/c136",
      "osft-doc-0296/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c37",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should encourage responsible authorship practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c37",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1372",
      "osft-doc-0296/c33",
      "osft-doc-0142/c134"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c21",
    "representativeText": "Simplified processes are vital in encouraging researcher adoption of open practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c21",
      "open-science-source-12/c211",
      "osft-doc-1327/c189",
      "osft-doc-1327/c938"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c222",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c222",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship refers to the inclusion and role of research within wider society.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c222",
      "osft-doc-1459/c239",
      "osft-doc-1459/c238",
      "osft-doc-1673/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c237",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c237",
    "representativeText": "The pervasive spread of the Web has left much of the pre-existing scholarly publication model and industry fundamentally unchanged.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c237",
      "osft-doc-1459/c258",
      "osft-doc-1673/c138",
      "osft-doc-1673/c310"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c246",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c246",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship allows us to balance different categories and meanings across many diverse communities of practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c246",
      "osft-doc-1459/c267",
      "osft-doc-1673/c145",
      "osft-doc-1673/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c253",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c253",
    "representativeText": "The barrier to understanding Open Scholarship's principles and practices must be overcome in order to maximise participation and engagement with both the principles and the practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c253",
      "osft-doc-1459/c283",
      "osft-doc-1327/c312",
      "osft-doc-1327/c755"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c274",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c274",
    "representativeText": "Open Access books are a major problem in the Humanities, but less so in STEM.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c274",
      "osft-doc-1459/c302",
      "osft-doc-1673/c175",
      "osft-doc-1459/c303"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c465",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c465",
    "representativeText": "Research into various aspects of Open Scholarship and its impacts has found them to be almost overwhelmingly positive.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c465",
      "osft-doc-1459/c503",
      "osft-doc-1673/c282",
      "osft-doc-1459/c501"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c539",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c539",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship comes with its own set of technical terms.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c539",
      "osft-doc-1459/c564",
      "osft-doc-1459/c282",
      "osft-doc-1673/c158"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c622",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c622",
    "representativeText": "Big commercial publishers pose a threat because they will try to bundle their services for institutions via 'big deals', locking institutions into non-transferable services in order to access other services they consider vital, the same strategy used in bundling journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c622",
      "osft-doc-1459/c645",
      "osft-doc-1459/c647",
      "osft-doc-1673/c355"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c499",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c499",
    "representativeText": "Passionate, persevering champions demonstrate a great capacity to achieve substantial changes and create strong influences, almost single-handedly.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c499",
      "osft-doc-1673/c278",
      "osft-doc-1373/c460",
      "osft-doc-1673/c279"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c142",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c142",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles have been embraced in many quarters.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c142",
      "osft-doc-1686/c134",
      "open-science-source-12/c34",
      "osft-doc-1686/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c26",
    "representativeText": "Implementation of an Open Science approach should take a phased approach.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c26",
      "osft-doc-1737/c24",
      "osft-doc-1771/c29",
      "osft-doc-1737/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c2/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c2/c1",
    "representativeText": "The wwPDB maintains a single PDB archive of macromolecular structural data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c2/c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c20",
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c2",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c68",
    "representativeText": "The wellbeing of Indigenous people must be central in data ecosystems to minimize harm, maximize benefits, promote justice, and allow for future use.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c68",
      "open-science-source-30/c89",
      "open-science-source-30/c198",
      "open-science-source-26/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c214",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c214",
    "representativeText": "Impact measurement is an ongoing challenge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c214",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1220",
      "osft-doc-0142/c239",
      "open-science-source-06/c271"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c285",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c285",
    "representativeText": "AI can be a powerful enabler when used responsibly and in tandem with human expertise.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c285",
      "open-science-source-10/c110",
      "open-science-source-42/c321",
      "open-science-source-42/c584"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c367",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c367",
    "representativeText": "Existing open scholarly infrastructure services offer crucial services to a range of stakeholders.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c367",
      "osft-doc-1459/c400",
      "open-science-source-38/c4",
      "open-science-source-38/c225"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c19",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous nations should be actively involved in governance of data to ensure ethical reuse of data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c19",
      "osft-doc-1027/c24",
      "open-science-source-30/c83",
      "open-science-source-30/c189"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c644",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c644",
    "representativeText": "Researchers need to give credit where credit is due.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c644",
      "osft-doc-0105/c73",
      "osft-doc-0105/c12",
      "open-science-source-04/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c12",
    "representativeText": "Open access gives authors and their works vast and measurable new visibility, readership, and impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c12",
      "osft-doc-1124/c13",
      "osft-doc-1213/c10",
      "osft-doc-1213/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c331",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c331",
    "representativeText": "The transition to Open Science should be aligned with a transition to assessing researchers' performance on a broader, multi-dimensional basis that includes research and Open Science activities as well as other professional achievements.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c331",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c245",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c69",
    "representativeText": "All published research outputs from public funding in Europe must be made public in a way that ensures immediate Open Access, while being sensitive to disciplinary differences.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c69",
      "open-science-source-20/c16",
      "osft-doc-1213/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-20",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open science engenders public trust.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c10",
      "osft-doc-0975/c18",
      "osft-doc-1737/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c9",
    "representativeText": "The research environment is characterized by individual publication rewards.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c9",
      "osft-doc-0441/c156",
      "osft-doc-1878/c149"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c30",
    "representativeText": "Newly generated scientific research outputs produced by federal scientists and researchers, and scientific research outputs contracted by federal departments and agencies, need to be made Open by Design and by Default.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c30",
      "osft-doc-1771/c32",
      "osft-doc-1646/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c14",
    "representativeText": "Open scientific practices improve the reproducibility of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c14",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c170",
      "osft-doc-1449/c417"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c4",
    "representativeText": "Open sharing of research benefits society by promoting reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c24",
      "open-science-source-50/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-50"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c190",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c190",
    "representativeText": "Improving reproducibility requires cultural change.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c190",
      "osft-doc-0150/c205",
      "osft-doc-0963/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0963"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c44",
    "representativeText": "Large strides have been made in some open scholarship practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c44",
      "osft-doc-1459/c232",
      "osft-doc-1327/c433"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c188",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c188",
    "representativeText": "Access to the products of research builds trust in the products and processes of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c188",
      "osft-doc-1569/c13",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1569",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c222",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c222",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship enables higher quality and more efficient research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c222",
      "osft-doc-1673/c156",
      "osft-doc-1459/c373"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c162",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c162",
    "representativeText": "Lead Stakeholders and community-led infrastructure providers should invest in and sustain shared, community governed infrastructures and services, such as publishing platforms, repositories, long-term preservation networks, metadata systems, and editorial support.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c162",
      "osft-doc-1253/c28",
      "open-science-source-03/c174"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c109",
    "representativeText": "There is a growing recognition of the importance of open science practices beyond Open Access to publications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c109",
      "osft-doc-1373/c13",
      "osft-doc-1569/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c18",
    "representativeText": "Open access practices must become universal and apply to all research funded anywhere in the world.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c18",
      "osft-doc-0900/c15",
      "osft-doc-1673/c106"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0777/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0777/c11",
    "representativeText": "Everyone should have an equal opportunity to participate in co-development.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0777/c11",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1073"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0777",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c35",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure organisations should publicly describe how ongoing assets could be archived and preserved when passed to a successor organisation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c35",
      "open-science-source-09/c12",
      "osft-doc-0860/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c51",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly publication and communication ecosystem should enable credit for open and reproducible research efforts.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c51",
      "osft-doc-1327/c769",
      "open-science-source-38/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c225",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c225",
    "representativeText": "Member States should provide systematic and continuous capacity building on open science concepts and practices, including comprehension of guiding principles and core values as well as technical skills in digital literacy, data science and stewardship, curation, preservation, information literacy, web safety, content ownership and sharing, software engineering and computer science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c225",
      "osft-doc-0002/c34",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0002"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c262",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c262",
    "representativeText": "Member States should ensure that the practice of open science is taken into account as a scientific and academic recruitment and promotion criterion.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c262",
      "osft-doc-1373/c196",
      "osft-doc-1459/c210"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c40",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure should aim to make all relevant data openly available, following best practices such as applying a CC0 waiver where appropriate, to support potential forking or replication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c40",
      "osft-doc-0860/c41",
      "osft-doc-1301/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1301"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c52",
    "representativeText": "Universities, funders, and information and analytic providers must enable fair evaluation of research outputs, valuing quality and integrity.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c52",
      "open-science-source-04/c116",
      "osft-doc-1283/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c29",
    "representativeText": "Member States should invest in infrastructure that contributes to open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c29",
      "open-science-source-03/c194",
      "osft-doc-1449/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c8",
    "representativeText": "Open science increases the sharing of information, for the benefit of science and society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c8",
      "osft-doc-1327/c555",
      "open-science-source-04/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c16",
    "representativeText": "The global science community and scholarly communication community should embrace the diversity in the open science space.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c16",
      "osft-doc-0975/c49",
      "open-science-source-03/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c643",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c643",
    "representativeText": "New metrics must be designed to create incentives that influence researcher behaviour, preferably based around openness.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c643",
      "osft-doc-1373/c620",
      "osft-doc-1673/c353"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c41",
    "representativeText": "Awareness and engagement with open science principles is growing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c41",
      "open-science-source-27/c2",
      "osft-doc-1459/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c14",
    "representativeText": "Increasing transparency in science and scholarship leads to an increase in public trust of science and scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c14",
      "open-science-source-06/c74",
      "open-science-source-45/c144"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c41",
    "representativeText": "Recognizing regional differences in researchers' experiences should occur in order to tailor support and solutions that account for local contexts.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c41",
      "osft-doc-0050/c176",
      "osft-doc-1673/c323"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c64",
    "representativeText": "Effective policy must align incentives with reproducible and trustworthy research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c64",
      "osft-doc-0150/c63",
      "open-science-source-04/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c702",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c702",
    "representativeText": "Researchers' incentive is to publish in high-status journals, many of which carry higher costs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c702",
      "open-science-source-36/c273",
      "open-science-source-55/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c4",
    "representativeText": "Open Science enables the scientific community to evaluate the reproducibility of scientific results.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c4",
      "osft-doc-1737/c4",
      "osft-doc-1771/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c157",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c157",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is not a simple construct to understand.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c157",
      "osft-doc-1459/c281",
      "osft-doc-1373/c252"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c8",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should adopt a broad-scale approach to the variety of open scholarly research and education practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c8",
      "osft-doc-1459/c24",
      "osft-doc-1449/c437"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c21",
    "representativeText": "When federally funded research is available to the public, it can accelerate the rate of discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c21",
      "osft-doc-0748/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "osft-doc-0748"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c218",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c218",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship is a dynamic field.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c218",
      "osft-doc-1878/c215",
      "osft-doc-1459/c662"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c45",
    "representativeText": "All research objects should be Accessible, both for machines and for people.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c45",
      "open-science-source-06/c177",
      "osft-doc-0211/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c362",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c362",
    "representativeText": "Research material sharing is critical for reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c362",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c121",
      "osft-doc-1449/c196"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c158",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c158",
    "representativeText": "New researchers should continue to be instructed in best practices regarding Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c158",
      "osft-doc-1459/c166",
      "osft-doc-1673/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c5",
    "representativeText": "Any relevant group may express an interest in participation or membership.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c5",
      "osft-doc-0860/c5",
      "osft-doc-0846/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c4/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c4/c33",
    "representativeText": "Author-side fees, particularly article processing charges (APCs), present financial barriers to authors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c33",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c33",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c7"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c29",
    "representativeText": "Open sharing of resources, data, and the products of research enhances inclusivity for the scholarly community and the wider public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c29",
      "osft-doc-0441/c26",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c148"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship engages both peers and the public at large in science and other scholarly activity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c10",
      "osft-doc-1373/c389",
      "osft-doc-1459/c416"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c2",
    "representativeText": "In Open Science, research data, lab notes and other research processes are freely available.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c2",
      "osft-doc-0951/c5",
      "osft-doc-1612/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c77",
    "representativeText": "Federal agencies should commit funding to the development and maintenance of open infrastructure, including but not limited to research sharing repositories.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c77",
      "osft-doc-1673/c248",
      "open-science-source-03/c192"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c123",
    "representativeText": "Open science should benefit humanity as a whole.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c123",
      "osft-doc-1327/c347",
      "osft-doc-0002/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c186",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c186",
    "representativeText": "Public-interest infrastructure should be protected from commercial enclosure, ensuring that scholarly communication remains accessible, inclusive, and governed by the research community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c186",
      "osft-doc-0836/c21",
      "osft-doc-1287/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c71",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c71",
    "representativeText": "Publication venues must provide high-quality article level metadata in a standard interoperable non-proprietary format, under a CC0 public domain dedication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c71",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c69",
      "osft-doc-1459/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c26",
    "representativeText": "Sharing research outputs in a timely manner and with licenses that encourage reuse facilitates collaboration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c26",
      "osft-doc-1459/c364",
      "osft-doc-1673/c223"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c22",
    "representativeText": "NIST should require grantees, as a term and condition of funding agreements, to ensure that the agency receives a license to agency publications sufficient for NIST to grant the public re-use rights.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c22",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c81",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c47",
    "representativeText": "Other researchers can build on findings to generate new knowledge within and across disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c47",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c32",
      "open-science-source-06/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c17",
    "representativeText": "UNDRIP asserts Indigenous Peoples' authority to control their data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c17",
      "osft-doc-1027/c22",
      "open-science-source-30/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-28/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-28/c30",
    "representativeText": "Posting a preprint or depositing an Author Accepted Manuscript allows authors to comply with the foundation's policy without paying a fee.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-28/c30",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c17",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-28"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0068/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0068/c28",
    "representativeText": "Open science is an inclusive construct that combines various movements and practices aiming to increase scientific collaborations and sharing of information for the benefit of science and society.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0068/c28",
      "open-science-source-03/c54",
      "osft-doc-1253/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0105/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0105/c29",
    "representativeText": "Openness and transparency about all elements of the research and scientific process are important.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0105/c29",
      "osft-doc-0777/c1",
      "osft-doc-0633/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-0777"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c12",
    "representativeText": "The Journal Impact Factor was originally created as a tool to help librarians identify journals to purchase, not as a measure of the scientific quality of research in an article.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c12",
      "osft-doc-0296/c7",
      "open-science-source-55/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c44",
    "representativeText": "Experimentation with further ways to make the transition from present methods of dissemination to open access should be encouraged.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c44",
      "osft-doc-1124/c45",
      "osft-doc-1327/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c94",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructures are built to be shared by a community of users.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c94",
      "open-science-source-05/c93",
      "open-science-source-38/c452"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0971/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0971/c26",
    "representativeText": "Research data should be as open as possible and as closed as necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0971/c26",
      "osft-doc-1449/c425",
      "open-science-source-09/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0971",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0971/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0971/c54",
    "representativeText": "Research data should be made available as soon as possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0971/c54",
      "open-science-source-14-c1/c315",
      "osft-doc-0105/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-14-c1",
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-0971"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1213/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1213/c50",
    "representativeText": "Publications should preferably be published under the Creative Commons Attribution CC BY license.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1213/c50",
      "osft-doc-1449/c37",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c71",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c71",
    "representativeText": "Venues used for the publication of research outputs must ensure long-term archiving.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c71",
      "open-science-source-43/c82",
      "osft-doc-1213/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1301/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1301/c16",
    "representativeText": "Open data licensing under POSI should enable other organizations to re-use their data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1301/c16",
      "osft-doc-0108/c44",
      "osft-doc-0296/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1301"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c120",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c120",
    "representativeText": "A governance structure for a world-wide scholarly infrastructure should be agreed on and developed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c120",
      "osft-doc-1673/c57",
      "osft-doc-1459/c126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c228",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c228",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship community members come from countries around the globe and a range of socio-economic situations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c228",
      "osft-doc-1459/c249",
      "osft-doc-1673/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c259",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c259",
    "representativeText": "Diverse cultures, backgrounds, and interests among Open Scholarship stakeholders mean that one-size-fits-all solutions could potentially harm local interests, or vice versa.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c259",
      "osft-doc-1459/c288",
      "osft-doc-1327/c309"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c293",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c293",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship should be mainstreamed so that it competes with traditional processes in terms of reach, uptake, and incentivisation and reward.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c293",
      "osft-doc-1459/c323",
      "osft-doc-1673/c191"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c553",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c553",
    "representativeText": "Diffusion of Open Scholarship practices is often slow and granular, and beset by frictions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c553",
      "osft-doc-1459/c577",
      "osft-doc-1673/c315"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c566",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c566",
    "representativeText": "The reward system's focus on novel results in high impact journals can stifle the rate of growth of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c566",
      "osft-doc-1459/c590",
      "osft-doc-1673/c320"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c633",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c633",
    "representativeText": "People must still be able to do what they are already doing, even if they participate in Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c633",
      "osft-doc-1459/c656",
      "osft-doc-1673/c366"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c77",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should explore substituting proprietary software with open source alternatives.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c77",
      "osft-doc-1459/c76",
      "osft-doc-1869/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c8",
    "representativeText": "A transition to Open Science is a process, not a single event.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c8",
      "osft-doc-1869/c155",
      "osft-doc-1327/c850"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c141",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c141",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should create new or support existing international library consortia and collaborations to co-operate on infrastructure developments.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c141",
      "osft-doc-1673/c51",
      "osft-doc-1373/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c315",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c315",
    "representativeText": "Conflicts between different stakeholder groups can often be distinguished based on competing interests, which filter through at multiple levels in communication, policy, and practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c315",
      "osft-doc-1373/c285",
      "osft-doc-1673/c185"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c468",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c468",
    "representativeText": "Scholarship requires all voices to be heard.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c468",
      "osft-doc-1373/c436",
      "osft-doc-1673/c274"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c549",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c549",
    "representativeText": "High awareness of Open Scholarship does not necessarily translate into adoption, often due to a lack of information, sufficient incentives and motivation, or interest.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c549",
      "osft-doc-1673/c303",
      "osft-doc-1373/c524"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c578",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c578",
    "representativeText": "Further experimentation should be encouraged to demonstrate the applicability of larger-scale adoption of Open Scholarship practices and to increase the rate of growth and ultimate impact of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c578",
      "osft-doc-1673/c316",
      "osft-doc-1373/c554"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1612/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1612/c59",
    "representativeText": "The use of open source software and hardware is preferred over closed and commercial options.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1612/c59",
      "osft-doc-1373/c296",
      "osft-doc-1459/c326"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c103",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should develop open educational resources for further Open Scholarship development.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c103",
      "osft-doc-1459/c218",
      "osft-doc-1373/c205"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c131",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c131",
    "representativeText": "Diversity presents challenges for setting strategic direction and building shared plans in the Open Scholarship movement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c131",
      "osft-doc-1459/c252",
      "osft-doc-1373/c261"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c189",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c189",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship's success could include shifting public funding models to pay for the dissemination of services and outputs, rather than individual copies/subscriptions of content.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c189",
      "osft-doc-1373/c291",
      "osft-doc-1459/c321"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c68",
    "representativeText": "Institutions should provide and support foundational open scholarship infrastructure, technological and human, for all members of campus.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c68",
      "osft-doc-1459/c113",
      "osft-doc-1449/c221"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c137",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c137",
    "representativeText": "The evolution of scholarly communication has opened up new opportunities for researchers to work and collaborate.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c137",
      "osft-doc-1327/c47",
      "open-science-source-45/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c39",
    "representativeText": "Peer review has a mighty filtering function.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c39",
      "open-science-source-18/c307",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c21",
    "representativeText": "Likeminded stakeholders must work together to uphold values and commitment to a fairer, more equitable, inclusive and open scholarly landscape.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c21",
      "osft-doc-1449/c67",
      "osft-doc-1327/c994"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c81",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c81",
    "representativeText": "A publication fee or article processing charge should not be required for compliance.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c81",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c6",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c70",
    "representativeText": "Under open access models, publishers allow the public to access publications in a journal for free.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c70",
      "osft-doc-1449/c142",
      "osft-doc-1702/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0211/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0211/c25",
    "representativeText": "A complete version of the work and all supplemental materials, including a copy of the permission, must be deposited in at least one online repository, supported and maintained by an academic institution, scholarly society, government agency, or other well-established organization, that seeks to enable open access, unrestricted distribution, interoperability, and long-term archiving.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0211/c25",
      "open-science-source-03/c71",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-0211"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c102",
    "representativeText": "Current academic structures around science communication, prestige-based funding, and teaching and mentoring practices perpetuate power imbalances and exploitation of privilege.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c102",
      "osft-doc-1878/c96",
      "osft-doc-1459/c665"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c13",
    "representativeText": "Interested institutions and individuals should help open up access to the rest of the literature and remove the barriers, especially the price barriers, that stand in the way.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c13",
      "osft-doc-1124/c15",
      "osft-doc-1327/c950"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0680/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0680/c21",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship must be integrated fully into teaching and mentoring.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0680/c21",
      "osft-doc-1869/c207",
      "osft-doc-1878/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0680",
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c51",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure organisations must be able to adapt and change, not merely survive.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c51",
      "osft-doc-1287/c52",
      "osft-doc-1781/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1031/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1031/c23",
    "representativeText": "Open and Collaborative Science cultivates co-creation in society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1031/c23",
      "open-science-source-27/c23",
      "osft-doc-1612/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-1031",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c4",
    "representativeText": "Open Science is scholarly research whose outputs are publicly available.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c4",
      "osft-doc-1612/c2",
      "osft-doc-0951/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c668",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c668",
    "representativeText": "Academia needs to centre its scholarly practices on the possibility to freely participate in research output.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c668",
      "osft-doc-1373/c649",
      "osft-doc-1869/c261"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c55",
    "representativeText": "Open science is defined as an inclusive construct that combines various movements and practices aiming to open the processes of scientific knowledge creation, evaluation and communication to societal actors beyond the traditional scientific community.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c55",
      "osft-doc-0068/c29",
      "osft-doc-0411/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-0411"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c355",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c355",
    "representativeText": "Software and code should be re-usable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c355",
      "osft-doc-0932/c45",
      "osft-doc-1869/c252"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0932",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c105",
    "representativeText": "Open science provides the basis for an enhanced dialogue between scientists, policymakers and practitioners, entrepreneurs and community members, giving all stakeholders a voice in developing research that is compatible with their concerns, needs and aspirations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c105",
      "osft-doc-1646/c5",
      "osft-doc-1771/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c132",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship communities aim to open up the process of scholarly exploration to the widest possible audience.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c132",
      "osft-doc-1673/c258",
      "osft-doc-0411/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c81",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c81",
    "representativeText": "It is helpful for trainees to receive instruction in how open scholarship practices are conducted in order to use these practices in their own work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c81",
      "osft-doc-0441/c86",
      "osft-doc-1449/c294"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c320",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c320",
    "representativeText": "Journals that charge subscriptions and make only some articles OA are hybrid journals.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c320",
      "open-science-source-36/c74",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c1",
    "representativeText": "Addressing complex and interconnected environmental, social and economic challenges for the people and the planet is urgent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c1",
      "osft-doc-0975/c1",
      "osft-doc-1327/c890"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c171",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c171",
    "representativeText": "The costs associated with operationalization of open science relate to the development and adoption of open science infrastructures and services.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c171",
      "osft-doc-0068/c54",
      "osft-doc-1449/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c56",
    "representativeText": "Open science comprises all scientific disciplines and aspects of scholarly practices, including basic and applied sciences, natural and social sciences and the humanities.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c56",
      "osft-doc-0068/c30",
      "osft-doc-0411/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-0411"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c60",
    "representativeText": "Open science builds on the pillar of open engagement of societal actors.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c60",
      "osft-doc-0068/c34",
      "osft-doc-1612/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c109",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly communication should provide transparent and competent review.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c109",
      "osft-doc-1327/c774",
      "osft-doc-0105/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c36",
    "representativeText": "Decision making in science is increasingly guided by indicators and analytics.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c36",
      "osft-doc-0730/c39",
      "osft-doc-0142/c877"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c81",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c81",
    "representativeText": "Publishing includes the sharing of research data and research software through appropriate repositories.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c81",
      "osft-doc-0730/c83",
      "open-science-source-06/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c172",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c172",
    "representativeText": "Experimental protocols need to be preserved as part of the research object and shared publicly.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c172",
      "osft-doc-1373/c29",
      "osft-doc-1459/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c173",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c173",
    "representativeText": "Workflows need to be preserved as part of the research object and shared publicly.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c173",
      "osft-doc-0645/c100",
      "osft-doc-1327/c127"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c267",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c267",
    "representativeText": "Measures of assessment and impact have not caught up with these changes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c267",
      "osft-doc-1327/c237",
      "open-science-source-13/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-13",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c3",
    "representativeText": "The internet, as in so many other areas of human activity, is changing the way things work in scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c3",
      "osft-doc-1327/c49",
      "osft-doc-0211/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c25",
    "representativeText": "Organisations and services should have a clear policy on maintaining financial reserves, including the purpose, minimum and maximum level, and governance of these funds.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c25",
      "osft-doc-0860/c25",
      "osft-doc-1820/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c36",
    "representativeText": "Organisations that rely on volunteers and their labour should recognise this as a valuable resource for the organisation's long-term viability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c36",
      "osft-doc-0860/c37",
      "osft-doc-1820/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c37",
    "representativeText": "Organisations that rely on volunteers and their labour should factor it into sustainability planning and risk management.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c37",
      "osft-doc-0860/c38",
      "osft-doc-1820/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c38",
    "representativeText": "Organisations that are heavily dependent on a limited number of individuals should take steps to reduce their dependence on these individuals, including via transition and succession planning.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c38",
      "osft-doc-1820/c8",
      "osft-doc-0860/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860",
      "osft-doc-1820"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c53",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure organisation's role is to provide a base for others to work on.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c53",
      "osft-doc-0836/c31",
      "osft-doc-0846/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-0846"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c78",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c78",
    "representativeText": "Trust must be embedded within platform governance.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c78",
      "osft-doc-0836/c18",
      "osft-doc-1287/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c51",
    "representativeText": "Waiver policies for publishing services should be equitable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c51",
      "osft-doc-1253/c31",
      "osft-doc-1459/c139"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c60",
    "representativeText": "Journals/platforms must have a solid system in place for review according to the standards within the relevant discipline and guided by the core practices and policies of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c60",
      "osft-doc-1398/c56",
      "osft-doc-0825/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c57",
    "representativeText": "cOAlition S organisations may advance open peer review through supportive policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c57",
      "open-science-source-18/c755",
      "osft-doc-1327/c773"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-17/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-17/c76",
    "representativeText": "AI-assisted grant proposals converge on the rhetorical surface of fundability without necessarily matching in intellectual depth.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-17/c76",
      "open-science-source-18/c301",
      "open-science-source-46/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-17",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-46"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c20",
    "representativeText": "Where possible, peer review processes should be transparent, involving greater openness, in order to improve accountability and learning and to widen participation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c20",
      "open-science-source-03/c277",
      "osft-doc-1327/c130"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c208",
    "representativeText": "Technology applications, particularly those using AI, are coming to be seen as actors in peer review processes, performing different kinds of checks and quality assessments.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c208",
      "open-science-source-41/c308"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-41"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c302",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c302",
    "representativeText": "AI may drive a sharp rise in the overall volume of research proposals and outputs, with varying degrees of quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c302",
      "open-science-source-17/c60",
      "open-science-source-46/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-17",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-46"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c407",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c407",
    "representativeText": "Open peer review reports tend to be of better quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c407",
      "osft-doc-1353/c168",
      "open-science-source-04/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c576",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c576",
    "representativeText": "Alternatives to traditional project funding mechanisms are needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c576",
      "open-science-source-44/c4",
      "osft-doc-1327/c193"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-44",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-23/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-23/c35",
    "representativeText": "Funded researchers should deposit copies of their Author Accepted Manuscripts into PubMed Central or another agency-approved open repository immediately upon acceptance.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-23/c35",
      "open-science-source-19/c32",
      "osft-doc-0534/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-23",
      "osft-doc-0534"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-23/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-23/c5",
    "representativeText": "Models relying on Article Processing Charges undermine scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-23/c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c34",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c55",
    "representativeText": "The use of trusted, public repositories ensures long-term preservation of data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c55",
      "osft-doc-1353/c170",
      "osft-doc-1869/c366"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c55",
    "representativeText": "Software, code, and other outputs align with the FAIR Principles by ensuring data is findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c55",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c74",
      "osft-doc-0932/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-0932"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c4/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c4/c38",
    "representativeText": "Barriers to publication created by APCs result in fewer opportunities for individual researchers to share their results with the scientific community and the public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c38",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c38",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "open-science-source-24-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c33",
    "representativeText": "Libraries play an important role in facilitating research data sharing, storage, and management.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c33",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c49",
      "osft-doc-1869/c300"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c6/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c6/c19",
    "representativeText": "Digital persistent identifiers improve discoverability of research outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c19",
      "open-science-source-21/c117",
      "osft-doc-0050/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "osft-doc-0050"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c9",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly publications should be assigned globally unique and persistent identifiers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c9",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c69",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c7"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c16",
    "representativeText": "The SSA should include institutional repositories as viable compliance options for the deposit of publications.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c16",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c78",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c46",
    "representativeText": "Other researchers can ensure the integrity of the findings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c46",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c31",
      "open-science-source-04/c110"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c14",
    "representativeText": "Collective benefit is more likely to be realized when data ecosystems are designed to support Indigenous nations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c14",
      "osft-doc-1027/c19",
      "open-science-source-30/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c20",
    "representativeText": "The majority of Indigenous data is controlled by non-Indigenous institutions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c20",
      "osft-doc-1027/c25",
      "open-science-source-30/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c21",
    "representativeText": "Non-Indigenous institutions that control Indigenous data have a responsibility to engage respectfully with Indigenous communities to ensure the use of Indigenous data supports capacity development, increases community data capabilities, and strengthens Indigenous languages and cultures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c21",
      "osft-doc-1027/c26",
      "open-science-source-30/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c52",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Principles' data-centric criteria ignore relationships, power differentials, and the historical conditions associated with the collection of data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c52",
      "osft-doc-1027/c60",
      "open-science-source-30/c141"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c58",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles are likely to find expression across the data lifecycle from collection to curation and from access to application, with implications and responsibilities for a broad range of entities from funders to data users.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c58",
      "osft-doc-1027/c67",
      "open-science-source-30/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-27/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-27/c1",
    "representativeText": "Networked technologies are enabling collaboration in scientific knowledge production.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-27/c1",
      "osft-doc-0411/c48",
      "open-science-source-45/c166"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-27",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0411"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-33/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-33/c11",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly publishing system presents overt challenges to disruption and innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-33/c11",
      "open-science-source-29/c6",
      "osft-doc-1327/c849"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-29",
      "open-science-source-33",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c207",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c207",
    "representativeText": "Peer review work is typically provided by researchers on a volunteer basis, coordinated by volunteer or professional editorial staff.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c207",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1111",
      "open-science-source-18/c191"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c334",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c334",
    "representativeText": "Commercial and nonprofit publishers can have different operating philosophies and motivations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c334",
      "osft-doc-0050/c1",
      "osft-doc-0150/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c107",
    "representativeText": "Open science infrastructure fosters reproducibility within and outside of the scientific community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c107",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c30",
      "osft-doc-0050/c196"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-0050"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c127",
    "representativeText": "Funding calls usually focus on novel research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c127",
      "osft-doc-0050/c81",
      "osft-doc-0150/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c130",
    "representativeText": "To facilitate reproducibility of research results, the software needed to produce, process and analyse research results must be sustained.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c130",
      "osft-doc-1869/c244",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c195",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c195",
    "representativeText": "Communities play a key role in the transition to open science as catalysts for collaboration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c195",
      "osft-doc-1869/c21",
      "osft-doc-0963/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c82",
    "representativeText": "There has been a renewed interest in the diamond open access business model.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c82",
      "open-science-source-23/c45",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c108",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c108",
    "representativeText": "Empowering communities is necessary to make open science practices normative.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c108",
      "osft-doc-0050/c65",
      "osft-doc-0150/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c156",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c156",
    "representativeText": "The financial burden of open access publishing extends beyond covering the article processing charge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c156",
      "open-science-source-36/c370",
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-54-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c70",
    "representativeText": "The success of public access hinges on well-supported research infrastructure, including repositories, persistent identifiers, publishing platforms, training programs, and expert labor.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c70",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c28",
      "open-science-source-53/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-53"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c329",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c329",
    "representativeText": "AI will improve scientific understanding by opening up new research directions that would otherwise be prohibitive, even without explainability techniques.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c329",
      "open-science-source-45/c273",
      "open-science-source-42/c185"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c379",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c379",
    "representativeText": "Scientific progress is important to almost every major economic, environmental and security goal.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c379",
      "osft-doc-0114/c19",
      "osft-doc-0900/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c203",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c203",
    "representativeText": "AI-driven changes to the methods of scientific research centre on making existing tasks more efficient.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c203",
      "osft-doc-1459/c391",
      "osft-doc-1373/c360"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c545",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c545",
    "representativeText": "Secretive practices, such as closed data and models, in the AI conference publication model conflict with open science principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c545",
      "open-science-source-10/c115",
      "osft-doc-1031/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1031"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c55",
    "representativeText": "Training AI models on biased inputs can likely lead to biased outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c55",
      "open-science-source-41/c347"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c141",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c141",
    "representativeText": "Accessibility of data used in a study is important for confidence in research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c141",
      "open-science-source-12/c6",
      "osft-doc-0142/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c218",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c218",
    "representativeText": "Public engagement with research is important.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c218",
      "osft-doc-0441/c114",
      "osft-doc-1878/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c46",
    "representativeText": "Universities, funders, and information and analytic providers must provide training and guidance on AI to ensure researchers have the skills and confidence to use new tools effectively and ethically.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c46",
      "open-science-source-42/c813",
      "open-science-source-18/c487"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c31",
    "representativeText": "The results of a study should be at least computationally reproducible using the same data and analyses.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c31",
      "osft-doc-1373/c350",
      "osft-doc-1459/c380"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-53/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-53/c14",
    "representativeText": "The future of Open Science depends on sustained investment in the Open Infrastructure that powers it.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-53/c14",
      "osft-doc-1373/c557",
      "osft-doc-1459/c581"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-53",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c1/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c1/c51",
    "representativeText": "Research teams need to value and promote data sharing from the project's beginning.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c51",
      "osft-doc-1373/c58",
      "osft-doc-1459/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c1",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-55/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-55/c31",
    "representativeText": "Aspects of methodological rigor, such as sample size, experimental design, and reproducibility, could be considered indicative of research quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-55/c31",
      "osft-doc-0441/c128",
      "osft-doc-1878/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c33",
    "representativeText": "Member States should invest in digital literacy to support open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c33",
      "osft-doc-1283/c44",
      "osft-doc-0748/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0748",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c21",
    "representativeText": "Trust in the selection of representatives to governance groups is best achieved through transparent processes and operations in general, within the constraints of privacy laws.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c21",
      "osft-doc-0151/c41",
      "osft-doc-0846/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0846"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c29",
    "representativeText": "Publicly describing a plan addressing the conditions for winding down an organisation, how it would happen, and how ongoing assets could be archived and preserved when passed to a successor organisation is a powerful way to create trust.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c29",
      "osft-doc-0151/c52",
      "osft-doc-0846/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0846"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c122",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c122",
    "representativeText": "The volume and complexity of datasets, code, protocols, and other digital objects is growing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c122",
      "osft-doc-0150/c117",
      "osft-doc-0645/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c15",
    "representativeText": "Journal Impact Factors can be manipulated, or gamed, by editorial policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c15",
      "osft-doc-0296/c10",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1011"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c23",
    "representativeText": "Many funding agencies, institutions, publishers, and researchers are already encouraging improved practices in research assessment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c23",
      "osft-doc-0296/c17",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1157"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c35",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should greatly reduce emphasis on the journal impact factor as a promotional tool.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c35",
      "osft-doc-0296/c31",
      "osft-doc-0142/c128"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c38",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should encourage the provision of information about the specific contributions of each author.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c38",
      "osft-doc-0296/c34",
      "osft-doc-0142/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c8",
    "representativeText": "Funding agencies, institutions that employ scientists, and scientists themselves all have a desire and need to assess the quality and impact of scientific outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c8",
      "osft-doc-0296/c3",
      "osft-doc-1327/c144"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c14",
    "representativeText": "Open access mandates will significantly accelerate science-based solutions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c14",
      "osft-doc-0900/c14",
      "osft-doc-0825/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c2",
    "representativeText": "The existing reward system in academic research potentially compromises the credibility of research outcomes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c2",
      "osft-doc-0441/c87",
      "osft-doc-1878/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1083",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1083",
    "representativeText": "Reliance on just a few metrics or indicators fails to adequately capture the full breadth of routes to impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1083",
      "osft-doc-1047/c59",
      "open-science-source-06/c157"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c28",
    "representativeText": "Carefully selected and applied quantitative indicators can be a useful complement to other forms of evaluation and decision-making.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c28",
      "osft-doc-1449/c399",
      "osft-doc-1047/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c459",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c459",
    "representativeText": "The distribution of citations over the publications in a journal is highly skewed.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c459",
      "osft-doc-0108/c13",
      "osft-doc-0296/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c89",
    "representativeText": "The systemic and potential effects of indicators should be recognised and anticipated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c89",
      "osft-doc-1459/c452",
      "osft-doc-1373/c422"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c53",
    "representativeText": "Any metrics used to monitor and raise awareness of reproducibility must be carefully designed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c53",
      "osft-doc-0050/c10",
      "osft-doc-1449/c328"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0152/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0152/c6",
    "representativeText": "The collective (\"commons\") ideal of scholarly research conflicts with the competitive system in which most scholars work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0152/c6",
      "osft-doc-1459/c3",
      "osft-doc-1373/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0152",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0152/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0152/c7",
    "representativeText": "Much of the infrastructure of the scholarly world is becoming largely digital.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0152/c7",
      "osft-doc-1373/c4",
      "osft-doc-1459/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0152",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0211/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0211/c28",
    "representativeText": "Open access publication should be recognized in promotion and tenure evaluation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0211/c28",
      "osft-doc-1327/c81",
      "osft-doc-1459/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0211",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c51",
    "representativeText": "Open research outputs are typically openly licensed in order to maximize re-use while allowing the creator to retain ownership and receive credit for their work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c51",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c40",
      "open-science-source-36/c241"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0411"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c233",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c233",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's glossary aims to help clarify terminologies, including where terms are used interchangeably or with different associated meanings across fields.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c233",
      "osft-doc-1878/c231",
      "osft-doc-1373/c542"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c245",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c245",
    "representativeText": "The literature on open and reproducible scholarship grows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c245",
      "osft-doc-1878/c243",
      "osft-doc-1673/c283"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c345",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c345",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship includes Open Science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c345",
      "osft-doc-1878/c336",
      "osft-doc-1869/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c40",
    "representativeText": "Other fields have discovered similarly worryingly low rates of reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c40",
      "osft-doc-1878/c41",
      "osft-doc-1353/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c43",
    "representativeText": "Introductions, manifestos, and guidelines for conducting open and reproducible research have been published in many fields and disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c43",
      "osft-doc-1878/c44",
      "osft-doc-0680/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-0680",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c73",
    "representativeText": "A common thread that unites the different fields of the scientific enterprise is transparent, accessible and cumulative research practices, including reproducible and replicable science for empirical fields.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c73",
      "osft-doc-1878/c71",
      "open-science-source-21/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c23",
    "representativeText": "The overall costs of providing open access to the peer-reviewed journal literature are far lower than the costs of traditional forms of dissemination.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c23",
      "osft-doc-1124/c26",
      "osft-doc-1213/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c47",
    "representativeText": "All research objects should be Reusable, both for machines and for people.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c47",
      "osft-doc-1327/c277",
      "osft-doc-1373/c647"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c84",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c84",
    "representativeText": "(Meta)data should be assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c84",
      "osft-doc-1197/c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c10/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c10",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c90",
    "representativeText": "The protocol should allow for an authentication and authorization procedure, where necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c90",
      "osft-doc-0932/c39",
      "osft-doc-1197/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0932",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c38",
    "representativeText": "Universities should serve citizens at large, not just a small fraction of scientists fortunate enough to access scientific knowledge.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c38",
      "osft-doc-1398/c39",
      "osft-doc-1449/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c54",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should preserve and champion conservation of scientific findings as a core value of scientific publishing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c54",
      "osft-doc-1398/c55",
      "osft-doc-1327/c836"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c62",
    "representativeText": "The challenges of achieving open science are immense, but the collective will and potential to overcome them are equally great.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c62",
      "osft-doc-1398/c63",
      "osft-doc-1449/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c41",
    "representativeText": "Financial sustainability is a key element of creating trust.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c41",
      "osft-doc-1287/c41",
      "osft-doc-1781/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c45",
    "representativeText": "An organisation that is well-meaning and has the right expertise will still not be trusted if it does not have sustainable resources to execute its mission.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c45",
      "osft-doc-1287/c45",
      "osft-doc-1781/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c61",
    "representativeText": "Critical infrastructure can still be co-opted by a subset of stakeholders even with the best possible governance structures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c61",
      "osft-doc-1287/c62",
      "osft-doc-1781/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c64",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure must be forkable so that the community can take control if necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c64",
      "osft-doc-1287/c65",
      "osft-doc-1781/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c65",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c65",
    "representativeText": "The community could replicate the entire infrastructure system if the organisation loses the support of stakeholders, despite all established checks and balances.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c65",
      "osft-doc-1287/c66",
      "osft-doc-1781/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c66",
    "representativeText": "Each crucial part of the infrastructure, including software systems and data, must be legally and technically capable of replication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c66",
      "osft-doc-1287/c67",
      "osft-doc-1781/c103"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c68",
    "representativeText": "The ability of the community to recreate the infrastructure creates confidence in the system.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c68",
      "osft-doc-1287/c70",
      "osft-doc-1781/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c69",
    "representativeText": "The possibility of forking prompts all players to work well together, spurring a virtuous cycle.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c69",
      "osft-doc-1287/c71",
      "osft-doc-1781/c106"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c25",
    "representativeText": "Implementing FAIR principles for research data and metadata should be accomplished using a common approach across the federal science community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c25",
      "osft-doc-1399/c23",
      "osft-doc-1737/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c36",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science defines science as including fundamental and applied natural science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c36",
      "osft-doc-1646/c51",
      "osft-doc-1771/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c37",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science defines science as including fundamental and applied physical science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c37",
      "osft-doc-1646/c52",
      "osft-doc-1771/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c38",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science defines science as including fundamental and applied biomedical science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c38",
      "osft-doc-1646/c53",
      "osft-doc-1771/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c39",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science defines science as including fundamental and applied social science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c39",
      "osft-doc-1646/c54",
      "osft-doc-1771/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0963/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0963/c17",
    "representativeText": "Data should be cited in the manuscript with an appropriate data availability statement.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0963/c17",
      "open-science-source-12/c143",
      "osft-doc-1412/c189"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0975/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0975/c13",
    "representativeText": "Open, transparent, collaborative and inclusive scientific practices coupled with more accessible and verifiable scientific knowledge subject to scrutiny and critique constitute a more efficient scientific enterprise.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0975/c13",
      "open-science-source-03/c12",
      "osft-doc-1373/c340"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c135",
    "representativeText": "Using Indigenous innovation as a best practice to develop similar principles or criteria benefits other communities with collective rights, such as minoritized groups, geographically located communities, special professions, or consumers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c135",
      "open-science-source-26/c132",
      "open-science-source-30/c125"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1031/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1031/c26",
    "representativeText": "Open and Collaborative Science strives to use knowledge as a pathway to sustainable development, equipping every individual to improve the well-being of our society and planet.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1031/c26",
      "osft-doc-1398/c67",
      "osft-doc-1612/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1031",
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1124/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1124/c28",
    "representativeText": "Achieving open access requires new cost recovery models and financing mechanisms.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1124/c28",
      "osft-doc-0504/c25",
      "osft-doc-1327/c158"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1193/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1193/c86",
    "representativeText": "Making data publicly accessible creates new pathways for engaging in science and using data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1193/c86",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c28",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "osft-doc-1193"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1195/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1195/c1",
    "representativeText": "Data sharing practices are needed to maximize knowledge gain by researchers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1195/c1",
      "osft-doc-1412/c2",
      "open-science-source-12/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1195",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1197/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1197/c20",
    "representativeText": "To be reusable, (meta)data must be associated with their provenance.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1197/c20",
      "osft-doc-0645/c97",
      "open-science-source-30/c206"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c1",
    "representativeText": "Open Science is scholarly research that is collaborative.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c1",
      "osft-doc-0411/c1",
      "osft-doc-0975/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0975",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c136",
    "representativeText": "FAIR is a set of agreed principles applicable to Research Data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c136",
      "osft-doc-1686/c47",
      "open-science-source-21/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c2",
    "representativeText": "Open Science is scholarly research that is transparent.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c2",
      "osft-doc-1253/c16",
      "osft-doc-0411/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1083",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1083",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly communication community has many stakeholder groups with a stake in the outcome of reform measures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1083",
      "open-science-source-04/c6",
      "osft-doc-1449/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c170",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c170",
    "representativeText": "A modern scientific record requires preservation and access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c170",
      "open-science-source-04/c61",
      "open-science-source-25/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c220",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c220",
    "representativeText": "Better open access technology is needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c220",
      "open-science-source-06/c227",
      "open-science-source-02/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c436",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c436",
    "representativeText": "There isn't necessarily policy alignment or coordination between areas of open science practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c436",
      "osft-doc-1373/c640",
      "osft-doc-1459/c663"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c618",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c618",
    "representativeText": "Not all researchers everywhere have equal awareness of or access to open science resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c618",
      "osft-doc-1373/c521",
      "osft-doc-1459/c547"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c777",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c777",
    "representativeText": "Support for preprint services should be increased.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c777",
      "osft-doc-0633/c40",
      "open-science-source-18/c778"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c976",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c976",
    "representativeText": "High-impact-factor work translates into promotions and grants.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c976",
      "open-science-source-45/c220",
      "open-science-source-02/c316"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c10",
    "representativeText": "Novel research practices accelerate the pace of innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c10",
      "osft-doc-1569/c10",
      "osft-doc-1459/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c101",
    "representativeText": "Open Access repositories and policies should be made easily discoverable and accessible on the institutional website and relevant indexing services.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c101",
      "osft-doc-1673/c47",
      "osft-doc-1459/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c102",
    "representativeText": "Information about how the sector interacts with the research literature could be used to help with publisher negotiations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c102",
      "osft-doc-1459/c104",
      "osft-doc-1673/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c103",
    "representativeText": "Information about how the sector interacts with the research literature could be used to break up big deal contracts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c103",
      "osft-doc-1459/c105",
      "osft-doc-1673/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c104",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c104",
    "representativeText": "Information about how the sector interacts with the research literature could be used to cancel subscriptions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c104",
      "osft-doc-1673/c28",
      "osft-doc-1459/c106"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c105",
    "representativeText": "Research libraries should collect information about which venues researchers are publishing in.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c105",
      "osft-doc-1459/c107",
      "osft-doc-1673/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c106",
    "representativeText": "Research libraries should collect information about who is doing the editorial and peer review work.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c106",
      "osft-doc-1459/c108",
      "osft-doc-1673/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c107",
    "representativeText": "Research libraries should collect information about how much is being spent on serial subscriptions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c107",
      "osft-doc-1459/c109",
      "osft-doc-1673/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c109",
    "representativeText": "Research libraries should collect information about which articles are being downloaded and cited.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c109",
      "osft-doc-1459/c111",
      "osft-doc-1673/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c11",
    "representativeText": "Novel research practices stimulate critical industries around the world.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c11",
      "osft-doc-1569/c11",
      "osft-doc-1459/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c110",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c110",
    "representativeText": "Time and effort spent on training and advocacy for the various aspects of Open Scholarship, including Open Source, Open Access, and Open Education, should be promoted and compensated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c110",
      "osft-doc-1459/c112",
      "osft-doc-1673/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c113",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c113",
    "representativeText": "New ways of describing wider contributions to scientific communities should be defined.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c113",
      "osft-doc-1459/c118",
      "osft-doc-1673/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c116",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c116",
    "representativeText": "Currently available sort, filter, and search/discovery technology should be implemented across scholarship outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c116",
      "osft-doc-1673/c62",
      "osft-doc-1459/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c122",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c122",
    "representativeText": "Article-processing charges in hybrid titles should be reduced to match the market average for OA-only journals.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c122",
      "osft-doc-1459/c129",
      "osft-doc-1673/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c125",
    "representativeText": "Where subscriptions have not yet expired, offsetting agreements for hybrid journal titles should be mandated in order to reduce double-dipping.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c125",
      "osft-doc-1673/c71",
      "osft-doc-1459/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c126",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c126",
    "representativeText": "Where offsetting deals are in place, they should be streamlined and standardised across sectors to reduce administrative burden.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c126",
      "osft-doc-1459/c133",
      "osft-doc-1673/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c127",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly publishers should engage with the UK Scholarly Communications License.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c127",
      "osft-doc-1673/c73",
      "osft-doc-1459/c134"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c129",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c129",
    "representativeText": "Engaging with the UK Scholarly Communications License would reduce the time spent on embargo processing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c129",
      "osft-doc-1673/c74",
      "osft-doc-1459/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c132",
    "representativeText": "Those outside of the UK may extend the UK Scholarly Communications License, or relevant variations of it, towards other regional funding and licensing strategies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c132",
      "osft-doc-1673/c77",
      "osft-doc-1459/c138"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c138",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c138",
    "representativeText": "OpenAIRE could provide interoperability resolutions to institutional repositories, particularly for the European area and with a focus on the long tail of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c138",
      "osft-doc-1459/c146",
      "osft-doc-1673/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c139",
    "representativeText": "OpenAIRE could enhance the outputs visibility of institutional repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c139",
      "osft-doc-1673/c55",
      "osft-doc-1459/c147"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c142",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c142",
    "representativeText": "Action should be taken against the privatisation of scholarly works and processes in order to achieve transformation of the publishing industry into one comprised of fair licensing, fair market competition, and ownership by the scholarly community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c142",
      "osft-doc-1459/c151",
      "osft-doc-1673/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c144",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c144",
    "representativeText": "Wider adoption of preprint and Open Access policies should be encouraged.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c144",
      "osft-doc-1673/c67",
      "osft-doc-1459/c153"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c150",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c150",
    "representativeText": "OpenAIRE National Open Access Desks could provide input and facilitate communication between all stakeholders towards establishing national guides.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c150",
      "osft-doc-1459/c159",
      "osft-doc-1673/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c152",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c152",
    "representativeText": "A cost-effectiveness analysis of Open Scholarship should be created to be used as the basis for an argument about how much taxpayer money it costs every year to delay decisions in the above areas.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c152",
      "osft-doc-1673/c61",
      "osft-doc-1459/c161"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c154",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c154",
    "representativeText": "Further engagement in defining the relative roles of research funders and libraries in developing or funding scholarly infrastructure is essential.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c154",
      "osft-doc-1459/c163",
      "osft-doc-1673/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c161",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c161",
    "representativeText": "Workflows that take advantage of Open Scholarship practices should be developed to demonstrate their increased effectiveness in comparison to traditional, more closed workflows.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c161",
      "osft-doc-1459/c169",
      "osft-doc-1673/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c164",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c164",
    "representativeText": "A comprehensive set of mechanisms that allow fully open research processes to public participation should be created.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c164",
      "osft-doc-1459/c174",
      "osft-doc-1673/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c170",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c170",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should implement opt-out automatization of manuscript handling and single-click submission to a local or remote open repository under default open licenses.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c170",
      "osft-doc-1459/c180",
      "osft-doc-1673/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c172",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c172",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should implement opt-out automatization of code accessibility and version control under default open licenses.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c172",
      "osft-doc-1459/c182",
      "osft-doc-1673/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c173",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c173",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should backfill open repositories with full text for all works which are in the public domain, permissively licensed, or otherwise permitted by copyright exceptions and other policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c173",
      "osft-doc-1459/c184",
      "open-science-source-03/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c184",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c184",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should encourage hybrid journals attaining a higher proportion of Open Access over subscription articles to flip to pure Open Access with an APC reflecting the running costs of the journal.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c184",
      "osft-doc-1459/c197",
      "osft-doc-1673/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c185",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c185",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should refuse to support publication of Open Access articles in hybrid journals that have not attained a higher proportion of Open Access over subscription articles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c185",
      "osft-doc-1459/c198",
      "osft-doc-1673/c97"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c187",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c187",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should increase funding for outreach, especially to under-represented demographics.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c187",
      "osft-doc-1459/c200",
      "osft-doc-1673/c98"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c200",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c200",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should support the formal training of junior researchers in the usage and best practices of newly developed scholarly infrastructure tools and services.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c200",
      "osft-doc-1459/c213",
      "osft-doc-1673/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c203",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c203",
    "representativeText": "The Carpentries could support training of early career researchers on foundational coding and data science skills.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c203",
      "osft-doc-1459/c216",
      "osft-doc-1673/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c204",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c204",
    "representativeText": "The RDA Early Career and Engagement Interest Group could accommodate students and junior researchers needs on Open Science matters through its Mentorship Programme and other activities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c204",
      "osft-doc-1459/c217",
      "osft-doc-1673/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c208",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should communicate the advantages or impact of adopting Open Scholarship workflows to other groups.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c208",
      "osft-doc-1459/c221",
      "osft-doc-1673/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c210",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c210",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should establish a permanent fund to be used towards more sustainable ventures, including Open Source software development, APCs and BPCs, preprint servers, and other Open Scholarship costs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c210",
      "osft-doc-1459/c223",
      "osft-doc-1673/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c213",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c213",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should develop innovative solutions and functionalities that do not exist today.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c213",
      "osft-doc-1459/c226",
      "osft-doc-1673/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c215",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c215",
    "representativeText": "Penalties must be applied to those who do not conform to the Open Access publication mandate.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c215",
      "osft-doc-1673/c110",
      "osft-doc-1459/c228"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c217",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c217",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should help researchers take control of the research and evaluation processes based on what they believe will contribute most to scientific progress.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c217",
      "osft-doc-1459/c230",
      "osft-doc-1673/c112"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c218",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c218",
    "representativeText": "The movement for Open Scholarship has evolved from a collection of small, localized efforts into a broad international network of institutions, organizations, governments, practitioners, advocates, and funders.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c218",
      "osft-doc-1673/c113",
      "osft-doc-1459/c231"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c226",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c226",
    "representativeText": "A movement is a group of people working together to advance their shared political, social, or artistic ideas.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c226",
      "osft-doc-1673/c127",
      "osft-doc-1459/c247"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c238",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c238",
    "representativeText": "The slow rate of change in scholarly communication can possibly be attributed to the wide range of diverse stakeholders engaged in this domain and the deep entrenchment of interests and positions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c238",
      "osft-doc-1459/c259",
      "osft-doc-1673/c139"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c242",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c242",
    "representativeText": "All educational resources and research outputs, as a global societal common good, should be accessible free of charge to all members of the public who wish to benefit from them.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c242",
      "osft-doc-1459/c263",
      "osft-doc-1673/c143"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c257",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c257",
    "representativeText": "Motivations to engage with the practices (Incentives) are a major precondition to Open Scholarship adoption.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c257",
      "osft-doc-1673/c163",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c139"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c262",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c262",
    "representativeText": "Hundreds of individual initiatives and organisations already exist to help provide and promote Open Access at different levels around the world.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c262",
      "osft-doc-1459/c290",
      "osft-doc-1673/c166"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c270",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c270",
    "representativeText": "Other terms such as e-Research and Digital Humanities describe similar practices across different communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c270",
      "osft-doc-1459/c298",
      "osft-doc-1673/c171"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c273",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c273",
    "representativeText": "Accounting for variation in biological supplies from different laboratory companies is a significant issue in reproducibility for biological research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c273",
      "osft-doc-1459/c301",
      "osft-doc-1673/c174"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c283",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c283",
    "representativeText": "There is little consensus on the best way forward for Open Access at a multitude of scales, geographic, institutional, and individual.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c283",
      "osft-doc-1673/c183",
      "osft-doc-1459/c313"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c288",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c288",
    "representativeText": "There are varied opinions, and a lack of consensus, around what extent of Open Scholarship adoption is necessary to constitute success.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c288",
      "osft-doc-1459/c318",
      "osft-doc-1673/c187"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c292",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c292",
    "representativeText": "Sufficiently high quality and diversity of services should be provided to permit adequate choice for researchers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c292",
      "osft-doc-1459/c322",
      "osft-doc-1673/c190"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c297",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c297",
    "representativeText": "Quality of research and achievement should be measurably increased, leading to greater career prospects and to social, academic, and economic growth and innovation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c297",
      "osft-doc-1459/c327",
      "osft-doc-1673/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c299",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c299",
    "representativeText": "Policies should explicitly allow use of preprints and other pre-publications in funding applications.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c299",
      "osft-doc-1459/c329",
      "osft-doc-1673/c196"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c302",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c302",
    "representativeText": "There is an unequal distribution of access to knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c302",
      "osft-doc-1459/c331",
      "osft-doc-1673/c199"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c305",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c305",
    "representativeText": "Democracy in Open Scholarship means equal access to knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c305",
      "osft-doc-1459/c333",
      "osft-doc-1673/c201"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c306",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c306",
    "representativeText": "Democracy in Open Scholarship means equal possibilities to contribute to knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c306",
      "osft-doc-1459/c334",
      "osft-doc-1673/c202"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c307",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c307",
    "representativeText": "Democracy in Open Scholarship means equal rights to participate in the world-wide community's decisions that affect knowledge creation and distribution.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c307",
      "osft-doc-1459/c335",
      "osft-doc-1673/c203"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c308",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c308",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is antithetical to closed power clubs limited to a small number of participants deciding for the whole international community, whether such clubs are supported by institutional or governmental funders or are bottom-up organisations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c308",
      "osft-doc-1673/c204",
      "osft-doc-1459/c336"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c310",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c310",
    "representativeText": "The new rules governing Open Scholarship are more likely to appear through open debate and many collective projects.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c310",
      "osft-doc-1459/c338",
      "osft-doc-1673/c206"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c311",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c311",
    "representativeText": "Several specific mechanisms, including peer-to-peer and blockchain-based mechanisms, have been recently proposed to realise democratic values in Open Scholarship in a decentralised way.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c311",
      "osft-doc-1459/c339",
      "osft-doc-1673/c207"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c313",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c313",
    "representativeText": "Awareness of the broader research, industry and education landscape helps to position Open Scholarship to have the greatest possible impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c313",
      "osft-doc-1459/c341",
      "osft-doc-1673/c214"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c314",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c314",
    "representativeText": "Awareness of the broader research, industry and education landscape helps to mitigate the potential of other policies and priorities to limit Open Scholarship's potential.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c314",
      "osft-doc-1459/c342",
      "osft-doc-1673/c215"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c315",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c315",
    "representativeText": "Copyright proposals that limit who is permitted to undertake text and data mining, or policies promoting intellectual property and commercialisation, should be balanced with policies that permit a wide range of uses of data, research, and knowledge.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c315",
      "osft-doc-1673/c216",
      "osft-doc-1459/c343"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c319",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c319",
    "representativeText": "The increasing private sector funding of research is a difficult aspect to reconcile with the view that publicly funded research should be accessible to the public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c319",
      "osft-doc-1459/c348",
      "osft-doc-1673/c210"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c32",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should make their contributions to openness visible in public.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c32",
      "osft-doc-1673/c7",
      "osft-doc-1459/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c323",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c323",
    "representativeText": "The 'weak licensing - strong certification' approach to patent management is especially easy to apply in medicine, where therapeutic devices or compounds are weakly licensed in terms of patents but the requirements for entering the market are set high by the regulator.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c323",
      "osft-doc-1673/c218",
      "osft-doc-1459/c350"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c337",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c337",
    "representativeText": "The creation of knowledge is strengthened through critique.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c337",
      "osft-doc-1459/c370",
      "osft-doc-1673/c230"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c338",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c338",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship seeks to harness network effects by connecting scholars and making scholarly processes at all levels transparent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c338",
      "osft-doc-1459/c371",
      "osft-doc-1673/c231"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c369",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c369",
    "representativeText": "Without sustainable funding sources, open scholarly infrastructure services remain vulnerable to being acquired by players in the private sector, an increasingly common occurrence.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c369",
      "osft-doc-1673/c241",
      "osft-doc-1459/c402"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c399",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c399",
    "representativeText": "Constant and continuous documentation and sharing of research outputs helps prepare research for greater digestion and comprehension by the wider community, particularly non-specialist interested parties.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c399",
      "osft-doc-1459/c427",
      "osft-doc-1771/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c404",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c404",
    "representativeText": "Integrating a research openness metric into university ranking system algorithms would embed openness values into policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c404",
      "osft-doc-1459/c433",
      "osft-doc-1673/c262"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c418",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c418",
    "representativeText": "Metrics should be based on the best possible data in terms of accuracy and scope.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c418",
      "osft-doc-1459/c447",
      "osft-doc-1449/c377"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c429",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c429",
    "representativeText": "Experimentation should precede implementation of any metric, in order to better understand its scope, biases, and constraints.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c429",
      "osft-doc-1459/c460",
      "osft-doc-1673/c271"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c430",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c430",
    "representativeText": "Issues of transparency and reproducibility apply to scholarship itself.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c430",
      "osft-doc-1459/c461",
      "osft-doc-1673/c272"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c431",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c431",
    "representativeText": "Issues of transparency and reproducibility apply to the mechanisms through which research is measured.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c431",
      "osft-doc-1459/c462",
      "osft-doc-1673/c273"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c434",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c434",
    "representativeText": "New metrics will not solve the publish or perish problem, but will only transfer it.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c434",
      "osft-doc-1459/c466",
      "osft-doc-1673/c267"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c437",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c437",
    "representativeText": "Scholarship requires the involvement of a committed community of actors.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c437",
      "osft-doc-1459/c469",
      "osft-doc-1673/c275"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c456",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c456",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship activism as part of a broader Open movement is benefiting from cross-collaborations with advocates from across different sectors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c456",
      "osft-doc-1459/c495",
      "osft-doc-1673/c297"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c457",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c457",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is often seen as a gateway to Open Education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c457",
      "osft-doc-1459/c496",
      "osft-doc-1673/c298"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c458",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c458",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship has policies strengthened by experiences from the Open Source movement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c458",
      "osft-doc-1673/c299",
      "osft-doc-1459/c497"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c462",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c462",
    "representativeText": "Passionate champions become especially important as an asset to the movement when their experiences and knowledge can be shared and multiplied, through building of collaborations, networks and communities, and mentorship models.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c462",
      "osft-doc-1459/c500",
      "osft-doc-1673/c280"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c47",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should work and collaborate with researchers who practice various aspects of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c47",
      "osft-doc-1459/c45",
      "osft-doc-1673/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c473",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c473",
    "representativeText": "The push to develop policy models for Open Scholarship transpires from a combination of dynamic, broad and cohesive top-down and bottom-up approaches.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c473",
      "osft-doc-1459/c511",
      "osft-doc-1673/c290"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c474",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c474",
    "representativeText": "The imperative and agenda for Open Scholarship must remain recognised at the highest political levels.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c474",
      "osft-doc-1459/c512",
      "osft-doc-1673/c291"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c475",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c475",
    "representativeText": "Bodies such as governments and funders demand that researchers comply with rules about data sharing, open code, and the like.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c475",
      "osft-doc-1459/c538",
      "open-science-source-14-c1/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-14-c1",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c476",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c476",
    "representativeText": "Governments and funders do not always provide the resources or structures necessary for compliant behaviour.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c476",
      "osft-doc-1673/c374",
      "osft-doc-1459/c513"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c477",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c477",
    "representativeText": "Bottom-up policies weave together best practices from existing scientific research communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c477",
      "osft-doc-1673/c375",
      "osft-doc-1459/c514"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c479",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c479",
    "representativeText": "Evaluating the degree of alignment between top-down and bottom-up policies might help illustrate how both approaches can better accommodate and promote Open Scholarship together.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c479",
      "osft-doc-1673/c377",
      "osft-doc-1459/c516"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c484",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c484",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship has been recognised by key international organisations active in research and education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c484",
      "osft-doc-1459/c520",
      "osft-doc-1673/c294"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c486",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c486",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship tends to have a common language (English, usually) for ease of understanding.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c486",
      "osft-doc-1459/c522",
      "osft-doc-1673/c293"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c49",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should establish support structures that help guide other individuals along the path towards Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c49",
      "osft-doc-1459/c47",
      "osft-doc-1673/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c503",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c503",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship policies span countries, scientific disciplines, and components of the Open Scholarship ecosystem.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c503",
      "osft-doc-1459/c537",
      "osft-doc-1673/c368"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c505",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c505",
    "representativeText": "Open Science has been a high priority on the EU agenda for some time.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c505",
      "osft-doc-1459/c539",
      "osft-doc-1449/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c517",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c517",
    "representativeText": "EU Horizon 2020 is one of the most notable government initiatives involving Open Scholarship policies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c517",
      "osft-doc-1459/c543",
      "osft-doc-1673/c370"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c527",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c527",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship must be better promoted in non-English languages.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c527",
      "osft-doc-1459/c552",
      "osft-doc-1673/c159"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c528",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c528",
    "representativeText": "The hegemony of English often works to further empower Global North countries in conversations about Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c528",
      "osft-doc-1459/c553",
      "osft-doc-1673/c304"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c529",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c529",
    "representativeText": "The most influential scientists got their position by being successful in a 'closed' system.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c529",
      "osft-doc-1459/c554",
      "osft-doc-1673/c305"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c532",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c532",
    "representativeText": "'Open washing' refers to using Open Scholarship terms for products, services, and practices that are hardly open.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c532",
      "osft-doc-1459/c557",
      "osft-doc-1673/c306"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c535",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c535",
    "representativeText": "Misleading uses of Open Scholarship terminology include confusing Open Scholarship with Open Access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c535",
      "osft-doc-1459/c560",
      "osft-doc-1673/c311"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c543",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c543",
    "representativeText": "Legal and economic knowledge may be as important as technical knowledge in Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c543",
      "osft-doc-1673/c307",
      "osft-doc-1459/c568"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c550",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c550",
    "representativeText": "Due to the relative novelty of many Open Scholarship practices, institutes are reluctant to risk their reputation on a global playing field by adopting new operational processes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c550",
      "osft-doc-1459/c574",
      "osft-doc-1673/c313"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c567",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c567",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship proponents need to be patient and understand researchers' burdens.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c567",
      "osft-doc-1459/c591",
      "osft-doc-1673/c321"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c579",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c579",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship movement must make sure that other regions are not negatively impacted by decisions taken by other extrinsic groups.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c579",
      "osft-doc-1459/c605",
      "osft-doc-1673/c325"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c580",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c580",
    "representativeText": "Universities and research institutes from across the world are waking up to the promise of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c580",
      "osft-doc-1459/c606",
      "osft-doc-1673/c326"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c582",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c582",
    "representativeText": "Universities are in a strong position to help guide and develop policy frameworks, best practices, and education on the various aspects of Open Scholarship, including by providing administrative support.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c582",
      "osft-doc-1673/c327",
      "osft-doc-1459/c608"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c584",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c584",
    "representativeText": "Rewarding openness in hiring, promotion, and tenure is a key driver in the increased adoption of open practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c584",
      "osft-doc-1459/c610",
      "osft-doc-1673/c330"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c587",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c587",
    "representativeText": "A huge global network of experts already exists with professional capacity for systematic training and education in scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c587",
      "osft-doc-1459/c613",
      "osft-doc-1673/c333"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c588",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c588",
    "representativeText": "Funding of such networks of experts is critical for any sort of sustainability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c588",
      "osft-doc-1459/c614",
      "osft-doc-1673/c334"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c589",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c589",
    "representativeText": "Platforms, communities and technologies already exist today that can support the Open Scholarship movement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c589",
      "osft-doc-1459/c615",
      "osft-doc-1673/c335"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c591",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c591",
    "representativeText": "Harmonising the scholarly communication policy landscape must avoid license proliferation, with many one-off licences that may not be mutually compatible and require too much work to interpret.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c591",
      "osft-doc-1459/c617",
      "osft-doc-1673/c358"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c596",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c596",
    "representativeText": "Embargo periods to protect publisher revenues are lengthy, complex, and confusing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c596",
      "osft-doc-1459/c621",
      "osft-doc-1673/c341"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c605",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c605",
    "representativeText": "There is no widely-agreed upon large-scale solution for issues regarding Open Access for books.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c605",
      "osft-doc-1459/c630",
      "osft-doc-1673/c344"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c616",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c616",
    "representativeText": "Data that lack explicitly granted reuse rights inherit poor reuse rights from publications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c616",
      "osft-doc-1673/c349",
      "osft-doc-1459/c639"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c617",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c617",
    "representativeText": "A lack of suitable incentives creates fear rooted in traditionally-embedded mentality and practices, such as the fear that sharing data reduces an individual's competitiveness.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c617",
      "osft-doc-1673/c350",
      "osft-doc-1459/c640"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c621",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c621",
    "representativeText": "Elsevier and Springer Nature (via Digital Science) appear to be developing services spanning the entire research workflow, from discovery through to funding.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c621",
      "osft-doc-1459/c644",
      "osft-doc-1673/c354"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c626",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c626",
    "representativeText": "There is an increasing colonisation of the preprint landscape by commercial interests.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c626",
      "osft-doc-1459/c649",
      "osft-doc-1673/c356"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c628",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c628",
    "representativeText": "Researchers are generally resistant to change.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c628",
      "osft-doc-1459/c651",
      "osft-doc-1449/c466"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c630",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c630",
    "representativeText": "Giving researchers too much choice could be off-putting.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c630",
      "osft-doc-1459/c653",
      "osft-doc-1673/c364"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c632",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c632",
    "representativeText": "People tend to choose things that are most similar to what they already have, or things that are most similar to other choices they have.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c632",
      "osft-doc-1459/c655",
      "osft-doc-1673/c365"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c80",
    "representativeText": "Where subscription cancellations or terminations occur, adequate post-subscription access and support should be ensured using existing sustainable and legal mechanisms.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c80",
      "osft-doc-1673/c35",
      "osft-doc-1459/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c82",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should explore routes for reinvesting money saved for library budgets.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c82",
      "osft-doc-1673/c36",
      "osft-doc-1459/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c83",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should purchase back legacy documents and incorporate them into the scholarly body of work.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c83",
      "osft-doc-1673/c37",
      "osft-doc-1459/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c84",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c84",
    "representativeText": "The open sharing and archiving of legacy articles on which copyright has expired should be improved.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c84",
      "osft-doc-1459/c83",
      "osft-doc-1673/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c86",
    "representativeText": "Research funders can define the limits of what is an acceptable standard of publication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c86",
      "osft-doc-1459/c85",
      "osft-doc-1673/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c96",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c96",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes that currently lack rights retention policies for scholarly research should develop them.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c96",
      "osft-doc-1459/c97",
      "osft-doc-1673/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c97",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should adopt the CASRAI CRediT guidelines to help identify paper author contributions more clearly.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c97",
      "osft-doc-1673/c42",
      "osft-doc-1459/c98"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c224",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c224",
    "representativeText": "Sharing data is not just a question of publishing some figures or files.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c224",
      "open-science-source-12/c115",
      "osft-doc-0298/c181"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c234",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c234",
    "representativeText": "We should be sensitive to disciplinary differences in research practice, particularly during the transition period to full Open Science practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c234",
      "osft-doc-1327/c900",
      "osft-doc-1047/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c335",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c335",
    "representativeText": "This part of the transition to Open Science is arguably one of the biggest challenges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c335",
      "open-science-source-12/c59",
      "osft-doc-1327/c676"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c409",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c409",
    "representativeText": "Research practices must be based on reliability, honesty, respect and accountability for excellent science to be possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c409",
      "osft-doc-1327/c918"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c465",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c465",
    "representativeText": "Costs are always an issue and can be hard to determine.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c465",
      "osft-doc-1327/c186",
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c1",
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c162",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c162",
    "representativeText": "Research funders and libraries hold most of the purse strings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c162",
      "osft-doc-1373/c153",
      "osft-doc-1673/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c196",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c196",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should start implementing semantic technology across all scholarship outputs, including to enable unrestricted text and data mining.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c196",
      "osft-doc-1373/c183",
      "osft-doc-1673/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c244",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c244",
    "representativeText": "Previous works on Open Scholarship have been, and remain, crucial for building a central identity for the global Open Scholarship community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c244",
      "osft-doc-1373/c225",
      "osft-doc-1673/c126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c276",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c276",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship include sharing.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c276",
      "osft-doc-1673/c153",
      "osft-doc-0680/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0680",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c278",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c278",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship include inclusivity.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c278",
      "osft-doc-1673/c155",
      "osft-doc-1869/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c291",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c291",
    "representativeText": "Thousands of individual initiatives and organisations already exist to help provide and promote Open Education at different levels around the world.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c291",
      "osft-doc-1373/c263",
      "osft-doc-1673/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c314",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c314",
    "representativeText": "Ongoing tensions among stakeholders result in a lack of well-defined strategic priorities for Open Access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c314",
      "osft-doc-1373/c284",
      "osft-doc-1673/c197"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c325",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c325",
    "representativeText": "Traditional research workflows should be replaced entirely by Open Scholarship methodologies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c325",
      "osft-doc-1373/c295",
      "osft-doc-1673/c193"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c353",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c353",
    "representativeText": "Publishing norms should change so that all objects within a research output are concordant with the FAIR principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c353",
      "osft-doc-1373/c325",
      "osft-doc-1673/c220"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c39",
    "representativeText": "Making one's own work available open access can almost always be done at no cost.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c39",
      "osft-doc-1373/c41",
      "open-science-source-28/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-28",
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c14",
    "representativeText": "Governments around the world are embracing Open Science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c14",
      "osft-doc-1737/c12",
      "osft-doc-1771/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c15",
    "representativeText": "Canada has an opportunity to be a part of this movement to shape the global vision of Open Science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c15",
      "osft-doc-1737/c13",
      "osft-doc-1771/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c21",
    "representativeText": "Withholding scientific research outputs requires a valid reason consistent with a framework on which scientific information will be kept private or confidential.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c21",
      "osft-doc-1737/c19",
      "osft-doc-1771/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c33",
    "representativeText": "For legacy publications, a responsive action plan should be developed to share publications requested with a time-bound commitment for delivery.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c33",
      "osft-doc-1737/c37",
      "osft-doc-1771/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c34",
    "representativeText": "When a research project and resulting publication have received support from multiple funders, the federal government should uphold the most open of the Open Access policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c34",
      "osft-doc-1737/c38",
      "osft-doc-1771/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c37",
    "representativeText": "When commonly agreed data and metadata standards are not available, meaningful engagement and coordination with the extramural and international scientific communities and disciplinary societies may be required to achieve interoperability of scientific and research data and metadata.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c37",
      "osft-doc-1771/c42",
      "osft-doc-1737/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c38",
    "representativeText": "The Data Strategy Roadmap and the Open Science Action Plan should be aligned.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c38",
      "osft-doc-1737/c46",
      "osft-doc-1771/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c39",
    "representativeText": "Consideration should be given to scientific and research data when developing and implementing data strategies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c39",
      "osft-doc-1771/c44",
      "osft-doc-1737/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c40",
    "representativeText": "Coordination between Chief Scientific Data Officers, Chief Information Officers, Chief Data Officers, Open Science Champions and Open Government Champions is critical for effective implementation of Open Science action plans.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c40",
      "osft-doc-1737/c50",
      "osft-doc-1771/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c41",
    "representativeText": "An Open Science strategy for federally funded research conducted outside of federal government agencies and departments should be developed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c41",
      "osft-doc-1737/c53",
      "osft-doc-1771/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c48",
    "representativeText": "Open Science is enabled by people, technology and infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c48",
      "osft-doc-1737/c66",
      "osft-doc-1771/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c56",
    "representativeText": "As used in this roadmap, science includes mathematics.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c56",
      "osft-doc-0951/c41",
      "osft-doc-1771/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c70",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, observational data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c70",
      "osft-doc-1737/c83",
      "osft-doc-1771/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c71",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c71",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, monitoring data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c71",
      "osft-doc-1737/c84",
      "osft-doc-1771/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c72",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, operational data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c72",
      "osft-doc-1737/c85",
      "osft-doc-1771/c78"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c73",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, modelling and simulation data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c73",
      "osft-doc-1737/c86",
      "osft-doc-1771/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c74",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, risk-assessment data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c74",
      "osft-doc-1737/c87",
      "osft-doc-1771/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c75",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, survey and surveillance data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c75",
      "osft-doc-1737/c88",
      "osft-doc-1771/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c76",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, research and development data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c76",
      "osft-doc-1737/c89",
      "osft-doc-1771/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c77",
    "representativeText": "Scientific and research data include, but are not limited to, technology innovation data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c77",
      "osft-doc-1737/c90",
      "osft-doc-1771/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c225",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c225",
    "representativeText": "Restrictive licensing or complex material transfer agreements slow scientific progress due to complex legal jargon or stringent terms and conditions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c225",
      "osft-doc-1459/c365",
      "osft-doc-1612/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1612",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c237",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c237",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructure can be built with current off-the-shelf technologies at a much lower cost than traditional publishing methods.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c237",
      "osft-doc-1373/c363",
      "osft-doc-1459/c395"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c277",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c277",
    "representativeText": "Significant successes in Open Scholarship are often attributed to passionate, persevering champions, particularly in the policy and advocacy/adoption arenas.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c277",
      "osft-doc-1373/c459",
      "osft-doc-1459/c498"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c284",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c284",
    "representativeText": "The depth of critical analysis of Open Scholarship continues to develop as the movement grows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c284",
      "osft-doc-1373/c466",
      "osft-doc-1459/c504"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c79",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c79",
    "representativeText": "The majority of scholarly journals should transform from subscription to Open Access publishing in accordance with community-specific publication preferences.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c79",
      "osft-doc-1373/c134",
      "osft-doc-1459/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1686/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1686/c45",
    "representativeText": "These research data archiving and sharing approaches already existed before the coining of the term FAIR.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1686/c45",
      "osft-doc-1507/c44",
      "osft-doc-1449/c216"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1702/c104",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1702/c104",
    "representativeText": "Federal science publications have been validated by a peer-review process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1702/c104",
      "osft-doc-1737/c82",
      "osft-doc-1771/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c51",
    "representativeText": "Successful and harmonized implementation of the Open Science Action Plans should be supported by a new high-level Open Science Steering Committee co-chaired by the Chief Science Advisor and either or both the Chief Information Officer of Canada and the President of Shared Services Canada.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c51",
      "osft-doc-1771/c47",
      "osft-doc-0951/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c54",
    "representativeText": "The Chief Science Advisor could conduct the strategy-development exercise in partnership with the federal granting agencies, learned societies and provincial and territorial funders.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c54",
      "osft-doc-0951/c29",
      "osft-doc-1399/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1771/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1771/c61",
    "representativeText": "Science includes engineering.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1771/c61",
      "osft-doc-1646/c55",
      "osft-doc-0951/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c1",
    "representativeText": "Research is increasingly data- and computation-driven.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c46",
      "open-science-source-42/c276"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c8",
    "representativeText": "PDB structures are made freely available without restrictions on use.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c8",
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c11",
      "open-science-source-16-c2/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c2",
      "open-science-source-16-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c13",
    "representativeText": "The use of Indigenous data should result in equitable outcomes.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c13",
      "osft-doc-1027/c18",
      "open-science-source-30/c178"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c169",
    "representativeText": "Data ecosystems must be designed and function in ways that enable Indigenous Peoples to derive benefit from the data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c169",
      "osft-doc-1027/c38",
      "open-science-source-26/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c198",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c198",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research to test efficacy of interventions is needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c198",
      "osft-doc-0142/c71",
      "osft-doc-0150/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c7",
    "representativeText": "The research environment is complex.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c7",
      "osft-doc-0142/c733",
      "osft-doc-1449/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c168",
    "representativeText": "Methods relying on artificial intelligence and machine learning rely on having sufficient and unbiased data to supply as inputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c168",
      "open-science-source-42/c331"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0298"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c119",
    "representativeText": "Good data management and stewardship is a pre-condition supporting knowledge discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c119",
      "osft-doc-0971/c1",
      "osft-doc-0963/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-0971"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c336",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c336",
    "representativeText": "The creation of knowledge is made more efficient through collaboration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c336",
      "osft-doc-1459/c369",
      "osft-doc-1673/c229"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c93",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should be more transparent about the financial aspects of their publishing workflows.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c93",
      "open-science-source-43/c75",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c129",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c129",
    "representativeText": "re3data.org is an internationally recognized meta-repository for research data repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c129",
      "osft-doc-1686/c112",
      "osft-doc-1412/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1412",
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c33",
    "representativeText": "An open access policy will improve the rigor and reliability of taxpayer-funded research by providing more transparency and the ability for easier verification of results.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c33",
      "open-science-source-34/c17",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-20",
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0534/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0534/c28",
    "representativeText": "The Policy requires that final peer-reviewed manuscripts be submitted to PubMed Central to be made publicly available immediately upon publication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0534/c28",
      "open-science-source-28/c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9",
      "open-science-source-28",
      "osft-doc-0534"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 3
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c26",
    "representativeText": "Altmetrics and indicators around non-academic impact are less well-developed.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c26",
      "osft-doc-0142/c570",
      "osft-doc-0142/c712",
      "osft-doc-0142/c825",
      "osft-doc-0142/c597"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 5,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 5
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c207",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c207",
    "representativeText": "Improving reproducibility requires capacity building, not just infrastructures or policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c207",
      "osft-doc-0050/c192",
      "osft-doc-0050/c177",
      "osft-doc-0050/c98"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c6",
    "representativeText": "A large share of all research information is locked inside proprietary infrastructures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c6",
      "osft-doc-0730/c5",
      "osft-doc-0730/c31",
      "osft-doc-0730/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c2",
    "representativeText": "Articles reporting on federally funded research are not widely available to the public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c2",
      "open-science-source-36/c15",
      "open-science-source-36/c293",
      "open-science-source-36/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c35",
    "representativeText": "Presidents and provosts should designate and empower a senior administrator to lead their open scholarship effort.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c35",
      "osft-doc-1449/c79",
      "osft-doc-1449/c138",
      "osft-doc-1449/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c112",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c112",
    "representativeText": "AI enables more powerful science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c112",
      "open-science-source-42/c19",
      "open-science-source-42/c22",
      "open-science-source-42/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c139",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research must evaluate reproducibility interventions rigorously.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c139",
      "osft-doc-0150/c133",
      "osft-doc-0150/c216",
      "osft-doc-0150/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c16",
    "representativeText": "FORRT actively works towards principled teaching and mentoring.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c16",
      "osft-doc-1878/c19",
      "osft-doc-1878/c51",
      "osft-doc-1878/c316"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1353/c104",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1353/c104",
    "representativeText": "The Equator Network aggregates reporting guidelines to improve discoverability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1353/c104",
      "osft-doc-0084/c50",
      "osft-doc-0084/c48",
      "osft-doc-0084/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0084",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c193",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c193",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's self-assessment tool is applicable to both teaching and mentoring.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c193",
      "osft-doc-0441/c195",
      "osft-doc-0441/c199",
      "osft-doc-0441/c201"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c210",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c210",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's database of curated resources facilitates the process of educators searching for educational resources and pedagogic tools on open and reproducible research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c210",
      "osft-doc-0441/c214",
      "osft-doc-0441/c327",
      "osft-doc-0441/c226"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c56",
    "representativeText": "Policy-covered works must include the language from one of the two template options when deposited in agency-designated repositories or distributed by any other means, in order to meet the grantee's public access obligation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c56",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c101",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c84",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c23",
    "representativeText": "Assessment of individual research performance using solely quantitative indicators is problematic in principle.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c23",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1253",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1251",
      "osft-doc-0142/c614"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c158",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c158",
    "representativeText": "The adoption of HL7 FHIR may help in improving FAIRness of health datasets.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c158",
      "osft-doc-1686/c146",
      "osft-doc-1686/c159",
      "osft-doc-1686/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 4,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 4
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0268/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0268/c5",
    "representativeText": "Open science represents a culture change in the way stakeholders in the research, education and knowledge exchange communities create, store, share and deliver the outputs of their activity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0268/c5",
      "osft-doc-1449/c4",
      "osft-doc-1449/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0268",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c74",
    "representativeText": "Any transfer or licensing of copyrights to third parties should not restrict the public's right to immediate open access to a scientific publication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c74",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c66",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-15-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c52",
    "representativeText": "Persistent identifiers must be accompanied by, and resolvable to, open, high-quality metadata that supports machine-readability, provenance tracking, and automated linking across systems.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c52",
      "osft-doc-0150/c52",
      "osft-doc-0150/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c8",
    "representativeText": "Funders, publishers and institutions should require Globally Unique, Persistent and Resolvable Identifiers (GUPRIs) for research objects and entities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c8",
      "osft-doc-0150/c9",
      "osft-doc-0150/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c443",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c443",
    "representativeText": "Altmetrics capture new forms of information about the dissemination of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c443",
      "osft-doc-1373/c414",
      "osft-doc-1373/c413"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c664",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c664",
    "representativeText": "The existing scholarly system has perverse incentives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c664",
      "osft-doc-1373/c641",
      "osft-doc-1373/c155"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c176",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c176",
    "representativeText": "Science is a global public good.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c176",
      "open-science-source-10/c135",
      "open-science-source-10/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c291",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c291",
    "representativeText": "\"Open\" can be expressed in various ways.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c291",
      "osft-doc-1327/c916",
      "osft-doc-1327/c559"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c139",
    "representativeText": "Integrating tenets of open scholarship into teaching helps provide students with first-hand practical experience probing the production of knowledge and evaluating it more critically.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c139",
      "osft-doc-1878/c134",
      "osft-doc-1878/c311"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c219",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c219",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should continue to link Open Scholarship communities to foster increased inter-disciplinary engagement and collaboration.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c219",
      "osft-doc-1373/c206",
      "osft-doc-1373/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c518",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c518",
    "representativeText": "A wider systemic transformation of peer review and the research system in which peer review works is needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c518",
      "open-science-source-38/c166",
      "open-science-source-38/c168"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c151",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c151",
    "representativeText": "Using HL7 FHIR to implement the FAIR principles is relevant for researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c151",
      "osft-doc-1686/c20",
      "osft-doc-1686/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c110",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c110",
    "representativeText": "Integrating open and reproducible scholarship into teaching could maximize students' and early career scholars' likelihood of present and future engagement with resources, facilitating knowledge acquisition.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c110",
      "osft-doc-0441/c116",
      "osft-doc-0441/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c18",
    "representativeText": "Equitable access to scientific information must be fostered to respond to global emergencies and increase the resilience of societies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c18",
      "osft-doc-0975/c19",
      "osft-doc-0975/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c139",
    "representativeText": "The Web's potentials are not fully exploited yet for scholarly communications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c139",
      "open-science-source-06/c9",
      "open-science-source-06/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-06"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c26",
    "representativeText": "Without open research information, it is difficult, if not impossible, to scrutinize black-box indicators and analytics.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c26",
      "osft-doc-0730/c27",
      "osft-doc-0730/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c53",
    "representativeText": "Research information is increasingly made openly available.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c53",
      "osft-doc-0730/c55",
      "osft-doc-0730/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c11",
    "representativeText": "Research funding organisations should shift from short-term project grants to sustained structural investment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c11",
      "open-science-source-18/c742",
      "open-science-source-18/c577"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c154",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c154",
    "representativeText": "The information available on funding decisions and investments is patchy and inconsistent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c154",
      "osft-doc-0142/c47",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1334"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c100",
    "representativeText": "The RCSB PDB serves as the designated PDB Core Archive Keeper.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c100",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c6",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c101",
    "representativeText": "The RCSB PDB coordinates a two-phase weekly update procedure for both new and revised entries.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c101",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c23",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c3/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c3/c36",
    "representativeText": "Each structure deposited to the PDB is validated for scientific and technical accuracy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c36",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c116",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c167",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c167",
    "representativeText": "Notions of quality are often specific to different disciplines and contexts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c167",
      "osft-doc-0142/c32",
      "osft-doc-0142/c244"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c516",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c516",
    "representativeText": "Research funders, scholarly publishers and other stakeholders should keep up efforts of experimentation with novel approaches to peer review.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c516",
      "osft-doc-1327/c248",
      "osft-doc-1327/c821"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c28",
    "representativeText": "A government-wide open access policy will support informed, transparent, federal budget and policy decision-making.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c28",
      "open-science-source-34/c20",
      "open-science-source-34/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-20",
      "open-science-source-34"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c61",
    "representativeText": "Most university copyright or IP policies already contain language that will enable compliance with the licensing requirement by modifying the default allocation of rights.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c61",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c106",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c38",
    "representativeText": "Publishers are transitioning from subscriptions to alternative business models, including but not limited to article processing charges for authors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c38",
      "open-science-source-36/c3",
      "open-science-source-36/c109"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c41",
    "representativeText": "Earth Science Information Partners (ESIP) are working toward developing guidance on how to operationalize CARE and FAIR for repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c41",
      "osft-doc-1027/c49",
      "osft-doc-1027/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c61",
    "representativeText": "The Traditional Knowledge (TK) Labels are an extra-legal digital mechanism that re-positions Indigenous cultural authority and governance over Indigenous data and collections.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c61",
      "osft-doc-1027/c70",
      "osft-doc-1027/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c90",
    "representativeText": "Community data rights are just at the beginning of a similar journey to Indigenous data governance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c90",
      "osft-doc-1027/c99",
      "osft-doc-1027/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c96",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c96",
    "representativeText": "The OCAP principles were developed to recognize the collective rights of First Nations communities in Canada to information collected from their territories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c96",
      "osft-doc-1027/c101",
      "osft-doc-1027/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c208",
    "representativeText": "The National Open Science Festival brings together all stakeholders and initiatives interested in open science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c208",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c131",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c124"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c51",
    "representativeText": "There is a demand for training of researchers in digital/computational expertise and in software development and management.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c51",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c2",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-54-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c27",
    "representativeText": "Recipients of Open Science NL funding must follow NWO's grant rules with regard to intellectual property (IP) management.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c27",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c8",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c107",
    "representativeText": "Open infrastructure organizations must adopt governance models that put researchers over profits.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c107",
      "open-science-source-03/c101",
      "open-science-source-03/c145"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c290",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c290",
    "representativeText": "\"Open\" is a gradable adjective rather than an absolute one, meaning something can be more or less open according to a set of descriptive parameters.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c290",
      "osft-doc-1327/c558",
      "osft-doc-1327/c892"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c208",
    "representativeText": "AI for Science efforts need to become genuinely interdisciplinary in order to succeed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c208",
      "open-science-source-42/c310",
      "open-science-source-42/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c300",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c300",
    "representativeText": "AI models, particularly LLMs, are prone to hallucinate outputs, including scientific citations, that are false or misleading.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c300",
      "open-science-source-42/c239",
      "open-science-source-42/c240"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c31",
    "representativeText": "Scientists aim to tackle important problems facing society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c31",
      "open-science-source-45/c250",
      "open-science-source-45/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c181",
    "representativeText": "The large-scale data analysis and pattern recognition capabilities of AI present significant opportunities for advancing scientific research and discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c181",
      "open-science-source-45/c272",
      "open-science-source-45/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-55/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-55/c30",
    "representativeText": "Quality is hard to define, and even harder to measure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-55/c30",
      "osft-doc-0142/c238",
      "osft-doc-0142/c242"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c119",
    "representativeText": "Journals and publishers should strengthen their capacity to manage digital research objects by upskilling editorial and other relevant staff.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c119",
      "osft-doc-0150/c115",
      "osft-doc-0150/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c12",
    "representativeText": "Institutions, funders, and publishers should build sustainable support networks for reproducibility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c12",
      "osft-doc-0150/c13",
      "osft-doc-0150/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c136",
    "representativeText": "Most existing studies rely on proxy indicators aimed at enabling redoing, which offer only partial insight because they rarely assess the success of redoing as a direct outcome.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c136",
      "osft-doc-0150/c130",
      "osft-doc-0150/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c169",
    "representativeText": "The distinction between redoing and practices aimed at enabling redoing clarifies what is to be done and for what purpose, facilitating researchers or stakeholders in navigating this conceptually confused territory.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c169",
      "osft-doc-0150/c163",
      "osft-doc-0150/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c25",
    "representativeText": "Achieving reproducibility at scale requires more than individual effort.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c25",
      "osft-doc-0150/c25",
      "osft-doc-0150/c191"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c60",
    "representativeText": "Any metrics used to monitor reproducibility must be responsibly implemented.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c60",
      "osft-doc-0150/c60",
      "osft-doc-0150/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c95",
    "representativeText": "Improving reproducibility depends on researchers, supervisors, and editorial staff having the skills and support needed to implement good practices in their daily work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c95",
      "osft-doc-0150/c92",
      "osft-doc-0150/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1203",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1203",
    "representativeText": "Peer review itself may not always deliver an accurate outcome.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1203",
      "open-science-source-18/c436",
      "open-science-source-18/c433"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c105",
    "representativeText": "Strengthening reproducibility requires active engagement from research leaders, supervisors, and principal investigators.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c105",
      "osft-doc-0050/c108",
      "osft-doc-0050/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c116",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c116",
    "representativeText": "Journals and publishers should dedicate resources to apply reproducibility and data-sharing checks consistently and effectively.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c116",
      "osft-doc-0050/c120",
      "osft-doc-0050/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c128",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c128",
    "representativeText": "There remains a substantial lack of evidence on the outcomes of reproducibility interventions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c128",
      "osft-doc-0050/c134",
      "osft-doc-0050/c124"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c204",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c204",
    "representativeText": "The relevance and feasibility of reproducibility must not be assumed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c204",
      "osft-doc-0050/c189",
      "osft-doc-0050/c166"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c98",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c98",
    "representativeText": "Sustainable support networks and training ecosystems for reproducibility should be embedded within existing research and education structures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c98",
      "osft-doc-0050/c100",
      "osft-doc-0050/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c12",
    "representativeText": "FORRT is a community-driven infrastructure for educators that advances rigor through pedagogical reform.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c12",
      "osft-doc-1878/c12",
      "osft-doc-1878/c298"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c121",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c121",
    "representativeText": "Open teaching initiatives improve scientific consumption among the lay public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c121",
      "osft-doc-1878/c115",
      "osft-doc-1878/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c127",
    "representativeText": "The facts of science should be taught relative to the process by which those facts were acquired.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c127",
      "osft-doc-1878/c121",
      "osft-doc-1878/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c161",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c161",
    "representativeText": "Scholars' professional success is usually measured by publications and grant funding track records.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c161",
      "osft-doc-1878/c154",
      "osft-doc-1878/c159"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c169",
    "representativeText": "The current incentive structures of academia work against changing methods of training to teach students to use open scholarship practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c169",
      "osft-doc-1878/c165",
      "osft-doc-1878/c153"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c171",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c171",
    "representativeText": "The burden of implementing open scholarship practices in teaching can be reduced with new and existing initiatives such as open educational resources, massive open online courses, pedagogical communities, and databases of open access materials.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c171",
      "osft-doc-1878/c167",
      "osft-doc-1878/c208"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c216",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c216",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's database of curated resources organizes the resources available on open scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c216",
      "osft-doc-1878/c212",
      "osft-doc-1878/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c229",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c229",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's glossary is devised to be an access point for those wishing to learn about openness, integrity, accessibility and reproducibility in research and education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c229",
      "osft-doc-1878/c227",
      "osft-doc-1878/c230"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c263",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c263",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's reversals and replications initiative aims to collate replications and reversal effects in social science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c263",
      "osft-doc-1878/c259",
      "osft-doc-1878/c260"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c272",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c272",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's syllabus builds on FORRT's cluster framework.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c272",
      "osft-doc-1878/c267",
      "osft-doc-1878/c268"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c275",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c275",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's syllabus is comprised of a series of assignments for students.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c275",
      "osft-doc-1878/c270",
      "osft-doc-1878/c271"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c282",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c282",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's third prong aims to help modify the academic incentive structure about teaching and mentoring through recognition and commendations of excellent teaching and mentoring.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c282",
      "osft-doc-1878/c275",
      "osft-doc-1878/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c294",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c294",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's Educators' Corner encourages educators to exchange ideas, learn from each other, and stay up-to-date with best practices regarding open and reproducible teaching and mentoring.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c294",
      "osft-doc-1878/c286",
      "osft-doc-1878/c283"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c8",
    "representativeText": "Teaching students about open scholarship helps open scholarship become a public good.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c8",
      "osft-doc-1878/c7",
      "osft-doc-1878/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c88",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c88",
    "representativeText": "Early career researchers untrained in open scholarship practices may be unaware, unsupported, and less likely to implement open scholarship practices independently.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c88",
      "osft-doc-1878/c83",
      "osft-doc-1878/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c33",
    "representativeText": "Journal articles should be disseminated as widely as possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c33",
      "osft-doc-1124/c35",
      "osft-doc-1124/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c42",
    "representativeText": "Self-archiving and open-access journals are direct and effective means of achieving open access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c42",
      "osft-doc-1124/c43",
      "osft-doc-1124/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c45",
    "representativeText": "Openness of research information is vital for high-quality decision making in science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c45",
      "open-science-source-05/c42",
      "open-science-source-05/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c60",
    "representativeText": "Research information means information relating to the conduct and communication of research.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c60",
      "open-science-source-05/c58",
      "open-science-source-05/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0731/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0731/c2",
    "representativeText": "Findable data are described with rich metadata.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0731/c2",
      "osft-doc-1940/c10",
      "osft-doc-1940/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0731",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c101",
    "representativeText": "Trust is built on the pillar of capacity and resources (sustainability).",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c101",
      "osft-doc-1287/c103",
      "osft-doc-1287/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0963/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0963/c24",
    "representativeText": "Authors must deposit research data in a FAIR-aligned repository.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0963/c24",
      "osft-doc-1412/c188",
      "osft-doc-1412/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c111",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR criteria should apply to already existing and newly created Indigenous data in both Indigenous and non-Indigenous/hybrid datasets.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c111",
      "open-science-source-26/c104",
      "open-science-source-26/c103"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c116",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c116",
    "representativeText": "Global to local data and research communities should be aware of the need to apply the CARE Principles and the actions to take before engaging with Indigenous data anywhere along the data lifecycle.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c116",
      "open-science-source-26/c110",
      "open-science-source-26/c109"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c44",
    "representativeText": "There is a scarcity of data that align with Indigenous rights and interests and which Indigenous Peoples can control and access consistent with the CARE Principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c44",
      "open-science-source-26/c36",
      "open-science-source-26/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c74",
    "representativeText": "The TK Labels increase capacity for better understanding of equity and decision-making regarding re-use and circulation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c74",
      "open-science-source-26/c65",
      "open-science-source-26/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1023",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1023",
    "representativeText": "A variety of \"engagement resources\" are needed for bringing together the scholarly communication community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1023",
      "osft-doc-1869/c27",
      "osft-doc-1869/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c775",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c775",
    "representativeText": "The quality of peer review should be improved.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c775",
      "open-science-source-18/c283",
      "open-science-source-18/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c349",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c349",
    "representativeText": "Increased transparency of research processes can help to resolve ongoing reproducibility crises in medicine, psychology, economics, and sociology.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c349",
      "osft-doc-1459/c379",
      "osft-doc-1459/c378"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1398/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1398/c40",
    "representativeText": "Universities exist for the public good.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1398/c40",
      "osft-doc-0825/c39",
      "osft-doc-0825/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c147",
    "representativeText": "HRPOs can employ the RDA WG guidelines in their local contexts to address FAIRification of research data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c147",
      "osft-doc-1686/c141",
      "osft-doc-1686/c145"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c161",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c161",
    "representativeText": "Health research institutions offering certified FAIR health data sets must establish infrastructure similar to the FAIR4Health platform for the FAIRification of data sets and the publication of relevant FAIR metadata.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c161",
      "osft-doc-1686/c161",
      "osft-doc-1686/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c162",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c162",
    "representativeText": "Health research institutions offering certified FAIR health data sets must adopt the FAIR4FHIR IG once available.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c162",
      "osft-doc-1686/c162",
      "osft-doc-1686/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c86",
    "representativeText": "Repositories seeking RatSWD accreditation must provide access procedures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c86",
      "osft-doc-1686/c78",
      "osft-doc-1686/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c88",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c88",
    "representativeText": "Repositories seeking RatSWD accreditation must ensure long-term availability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c88",
      "osft-doc-1686/c79",
      "osft-doc-1686/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1686/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1686/c94",
    "representativeText": "FAIRsFAIR will augment existing certification mechanisms for digital data repositories, such as CoreTrustSeal.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1686/c94",
      "osft-doc-1507/c99",
      "osft-doc-1507/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c15",
    "representativeText": "FORRT fosters a wider ecosystem for resource-sharing and discussion.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c15",
      "osft-doc-0441/c14",
      "osft-doc-0441/c318"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c303",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c303",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to diversify those who learn from research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c303",
      "osft-doc-0441/c313",
      "osft-doc-0441/c337"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c319",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c319",
    "representativeText": "FORRT streamlines the education pipeline by providing a platform for the curated provision of educational, research and teaching materials as well as exemplary applied pedagogies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c319",
      "osft-doc-0441/c328",
      "osft-doc-0441/c280"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c75",
    "representativeText": "There appears to be much less systematic incorporation of open scholarship practices in the education pipeline than in individual researchers' own labs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c75",
      "osft-doc-0441/c78",
      "osft-doc-0441/c249"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1940/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1940/c1",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles emphasise machine-actionability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1940/c1",
      "osft-doc-0645/c2",
      "osft-doc-0645/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c188",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c188",
    "representativeText": "The technology used for scholarly communication should respond to the recognized requirements of scientists for improved dissemination, reproducibility and recognition.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c188",
      "open-science-source-03/c204",
      "open-science-source-03/c203"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-06"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c4/c112",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c4/c112",
    "representativeText": "The PDB archive and individual PDB structures impact the sciences broadly, going well beyond biomedicine.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c112",
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c23",
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0296/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0296/c2",
    "representativeText": "The outputs of scientific research are many and varied, including research articles reporting new knowledge, data, reagents, and software, intellectual property, and highly trained young scientists.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0296/c2",
      "osft-doc-0142/c653",
      "osft-doc-0142/c651"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c193",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c193",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's self-assessment tool enables educators to attain a nuanced perspective on the degree of open and reproducible research incorporated in their teaching and mentoring.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c193",
      "osft-doc-1878/c191",
      "osft-doc-1878/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c3",
    "representativeText": "Developing pedagogy to train students in open and reproducible scholarship has received much less attention.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c3",
      "osft-doc-1878/c2",
      "osft-doc-1878/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c324",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c324",
    "representativeText": "FORRT offers teachers a pedagogical entry point to better research practices for both younger and older generations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c324",
      "osft-doc-1878/c314",
      "osft-doc-1878/c302"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1353/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1353/c146",
    "representativeText": "Journals have provided gatekeeping via peer review to determine what is worth disseminating.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1353/c146",
      "open-science-source-18/c121",
      "open-science-source-18/c556"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c163",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c163",
    "representativeText": "Semantic web technologies should be used in order to spread already-existing and newly-developing research output.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c163",
      "osft-doc-1459/c171",
      "osft-doc-1459/c172"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c379",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c379",
    "representativeText": "Next-generation metrics should be underpinned by an open, transparent and linked data infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c379",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1324",
      "osft-doc-0142/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c326",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c326",
    "representativeText": "Public knowledge mitigates inequalities in the ability to access cutting-edge scientific outputs, including research results and teaching and mentoring materials.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c326",
      "osft-doc-0441/c335",
      "osft-doc-0441/c112"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c12",
    "representativeText": "Within the Open Science community there is no commonly agreed set of principles that describe the desired system of scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c12",
      "osft-doc-1327/c567",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1051"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c116",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c116",
    "representativeText": "The broader community of stakeholders is coalescing around a set of common, dovetailed visions spanning all facets of the scholarly data publishing ecosystem.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c116",
      "osft-doc-1327/c745",
      "osft-doc-1327/c742"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c150",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c150",
    "representativeText": "Funders should act as leaders and direction setters.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c150",
      "open-science-source-18/c583",
      "open-science-source-18/c608"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c10",
    "representativeText": "FORRT is a community-driven infrastructure for educators that advances research transparency through pedagogical reform.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c10",
      "osft-doc-1878/c10",
      "osft-doc-1878/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 3,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 3
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c57",
    "representativeText": "Research assessment should seek a variety of perspectives.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c57",
      "open-science-source-21/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c47",
    "representativeText": "The organisation should commit to a patent non-assertion policy or covenant.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c47",
      "osft-doc-1781/c178"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0860/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0860/c2",
    "representativeText": "Organisations and the infrastructure they run need to reflect the fact that research transcends disciplines, geography, institutions, and stakeholders.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0860/c2",
      "open-science-source-38/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c4/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c4/c27",
    "representativeText": "All agency publications should carry full reuse rights, such as those provided by a CC BY 4.0 International License or its functional equivalent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c27",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1253/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1253/c36",
    "representativeText": "Achieving an open scientific ecosystem requires more than open-access publishing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1253/c36",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1061"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-23/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-23/c61",
    "representativeText": "NIH should incentivize the open sharing of research outputs, including publications, data, and software code, in grant review criteria and career advancement evaluations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-23/c61",
      "osft-doc-1673/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-23",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c20",
    "representativeText": "NIST should require that all publications resulting from its funded research carry full reuse rights, such as those provided by a CC BY 4.0 International License or its functional equivalent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c20",
      "osft-doc-1373/c593"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c2",
    "representativeText": "There has been considerable progress towards the adoption of open science practices by researchers in many disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c2",
      "osft-doc-1449/c325"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c339",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c339",
    "representativeText": "Universities should endeavour to integrate Open Science dimensions in their HR and career frameworks as an explicit element in recruitment, performance evaluation and career advancement policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c339",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c243"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c14",
    "representativeText": "Data, code, and software needed to validate or replicate the conclusions of articles should be made immediately available.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c14",
      "open-science-source-19/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-20"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c36",
    "representativeText": "The current system of academic publishing focuses largely on research quantity and novelty rather than quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c36",
      "osft-doc-1878/c146"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0756/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0756/c4",
    "representativeText": "A board-governed organisation drawn from the stakeholder community builds more confidence that the organisation will take decisions that consider different interests.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0756/c4",
      "osft-doc-1287/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c439",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c439",
    "representativeText": "One-size-fits-all solutions do not work for open science policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c439",
      "osft-doc-1673/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c502",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c502",
    "representativeText": "Universities should develop individual HR criteria for recognising and rewarding Open Science in job descriptions, performance appraisals and promotion criteria, taking into account staff's multiple responsibilities including research output, process, impact, teaching, supervision, leadership, service, public engagement, and collaborative and team accomplishments.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c502",
      "osft-doc-1283/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c67",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c67",
    "representativeText": "Grant dependency for funding operations makes operations more easily distracted from building core infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c67",
      "osft-doc-1287/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0296/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0296/c29",
    "representativeText": "For the purposes of research assessment, institutions should consider the value and impact of all research outputs, including datasets and software, in addition to research publications.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0296/c29",
      "osft-doc-0108/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1150/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1150/c20",
    "representativeText": "Data must be made more openly available to users in a standardized way.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1150/c20",
      "open-science-source-03/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c818",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c818",
    "representativeText": "The broad framework for the future of open science should embrace the diversity in the open science space.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c818",
      "open-science-source-03/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1353/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1353/c135",
    "representativeText": "Few incentives for researchers to pursue open practices are a barrier to meeting the ideals of open access, open data and open workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1353/c135",
      "osft-doc-1327/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c352",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c352",
    "representativeText": "Open source and open scholarship accelerate research discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c352",
      "osft-doc-1869/c220"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c14",
    "representativeText": "Open science opens the process of scientific knowledge communication to societal actors beyond the traditional scientific community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c14",
      "osft-doc-1702/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open Science aims at promoting public access to scientific results.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c10",
      "osft-doc-0825/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c48",
    "representativeText": "Grant dependency for funding operations makes infrastructure organisations fragile.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c48",
      "osft-doc-1781/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1287",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0900/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0900/c25",
    "representativeText": "Scientific knowledge should be made available to the public who helped pay for it and who will benefit from its accessibility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0900/c25",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1005"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0900",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c1",
    "representativeText": "Federal agencies should update their public access policies, as soon as possible and no later than December 31, 2025, to make publications resulting from federally funded research publicly accessible without an embargo on their free and public release.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c1",
      "open-science-source-36/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c171",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c171",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c171",
      "osft-doc-1612/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1213/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1213/c24",
    "representativeText": "Open Access is about the opportunity to re-use information with as few restrictions as possible, subject to proper attribution.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1213/c24",
      "osft-doc-1449/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c146",
    "representativeText": "Promotion and tenure decisions should be broader.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c146",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c397",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c397",
    "representativeText": "Open science does not have a singular definition.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c397",
      "open-science-source-04/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c198",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c198",
    "representativeText": "Research assessment policies should be fairer and more rigorous.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c198",
      "osft-doc-1459/c212"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c282",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c282",
    "representativeText": "Stakeholder groups' goals often conflict or are in tension, depending on their intrinsic motivations, understanding, and goals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c282",
      "osft-doc-1327/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c16",
    "representativeText": "Open Science represents a complex and multi-dimensional process of transition, different for every university.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c16",
      "osft-doc-1869/c324"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c117",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c117",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship refers to the process of research as practiced in any scholarly research discipline.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c117",
      "osft-doc-1459/c235"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c351",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c351",
    "representativeText": "Incentives must change to facilitate cultural change.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c351",
      "osft-doc-1353/c199"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c72",
    "representativeText": "Academic research is changing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c72",
      "open-science-source-38/c263"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c223",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c223",
    "representativeText": "Open science requires investment in capacity building and human capital.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c223",
      "osft-doc-1283/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c124",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c124",
    "representativeText": "There is a need to develop criteria and tools to implement the CARE Principles with FAIR.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c124",
      "open-science-source-30/c116"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c44",
    "representativeText": "Organisations need financial resources beyond immediate operating costs to weather economic, social and technological volatility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c44",
      "osft-doc-1287/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c125",
    "representativeText": "Data producers and publishers should examine and implement the FAIR principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c125",
      "osft-doc-0730/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c76",
    "representativeText": "FAIR describes concise, domain-independent, high-level principles that can be applied to a wide range of scholarly outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c76",
      "osft-doc-0932/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0932"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1213/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1213/c6",
    "representativeText": "Open Access improves the pace of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1213/c6",
      "open-science-source-34/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c650",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c650",
    "representativeText": "Open science advocates for increased quality through practices like better transparency and replicability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c650",
      "osft-doc-1283/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-53/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-53/c15",
    "representativeText": "Open Access and Open Science have gained momentum in recent years.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-53/c15",
      "open-science-source-12/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-53"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c126",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c126",
    "representativeText": "Open science should ensure equity among researchers from developed and developing countries by enabling fair and reciprocal sharing of scientific inputs and outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c126",
      "osft-doc-1327/c342"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c197",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c197",
    "representativeText": "Open science infrastructure should be internationally interconnected.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c197",
      "osft-doc-1283/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c13",
    "representativeText": "The commitments should address future governance, with defined criteria for acceptable successor organisations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c13",
      "osft-doc-0860/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c150",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c150",
    "representativeText": "Common metadata and identifier standards should be adopted.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c150",
      "open-science-source-22/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-22"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c132",
    "representativeText": "Problems with peer review are becoming increasingly evident in its various domains.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c132",
      "osft-doc-1327/c820"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c56",
    "representativeText": "Researchers are choosing fast, open channels such as preprint servers to share the results of research as quickly as possible.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c56",
      "open-science-source-23/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-23"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c35",
    "representativeText": "The rising price of Article Processing Charges drives an overall increase in the cost of research communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c35",
      "open-science-source-36/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c6",
    "representativeText": "Software and code from SSA-funded research must carry an open license such as those approved by the Open Source Initiative.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c6",
      "osft-doc-1869/c251"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c102",
    "representativeText": "The articulation of the CARE Principles offers an opportunity to find synergies between the FAIR and CARE Principles with actions and responsibilities across the data lifecycle and ecosystem.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c102",
      "osft-doc-1027/c110"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c134",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c134",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous data must be both FAIR and CARE, from data creation to data reuse.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c134",
      "osft-doc-1027/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c22",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous Peoples' ethics should inform the use of data across time in order to minimize harm, maximize benefits, promote justice, and allow for future use.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c22",
      "open-science-source-30/c205"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c124",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c124",
    "representativeText": "Public and private funders must invest in standards-based infrastructure for data sharing and reuse.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c124",
      "osft-doc-0645/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0138/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0138/c1",
    "representativeText": "The existing reward system in academic research prioritizes publication over accuracy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0138/c1",
      "osft-doc-1353/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c30",
    "representativeText": "A mature research system needs a variable geometry of expert judgement, quantitative and qualitative indicators.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c30",
      "osft-doc-1449/c375"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0296/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0296/c5",
    "representativeText": "Scientific output must be evaluated wisely.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0296/c5",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1299"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c21",
    "representativeText": "Findability requires useful, complete descriptions of the contents, known as metadata.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c21",
      "osft-doc-0645/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c159",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c159",
    "representativeText": "The current publication culture entrenches the reluctance of current and future scholars to implement open scholarship practices, out of concern that doing so will hinder their and their students' productivity, employability, and career progression.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c159",
      "osft-doc-1878/c152"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c317",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c317",
    "representativeText": "Changes to the practices of individual researchers are needed to remain up-to-date with advancements in policies and infrastructures and to meet improved standards of open, transparent, and reproducible research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c317",
      "osft-doc-1459/c170"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c72",
    "representativeText": "Open and FAIR research information requires the use of standardized protocols and persistent identifiers to support high levels of Findability and Interoperability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c72",
      "open-science-source-05/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c19",
    "representativeText": "Trust must run strongly across the sustainability (funding) of an infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c19",
      "osft-doc-1287/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0846/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0846/c53",
    "representativeText": "A high priority should be generating a contingency fund that can support a complete, orderly wind down, in most cases within 12 months.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0846/c53",
      "osft-doc-1287/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c16",
    "representativeText": "Policies and action plans should be developed in consultation with the scientific community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c16",
      "osft-doc-1399/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c23",
    "representativeText": "Strategies for implementing FAIR principles for research data and metadata should be fully implemented by January 2025.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c23",
      "osft-doc-1399/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0975/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0975/c34",
    "representativeText": "Open science practices and infrastructures produce a substantial economic return on investment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0975/c34",
      "open-science-source-03/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c37",
    "representativeText": "Contextual information on disciplinary differences in research indicators should be provided to those undertaking assessment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c37",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1322"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c60",
    "representativeText": "Source data should be made available where possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c60",
      "open-science-source-50/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c557",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c557",
    "representativeText": "Connected issues in scholarly communication need to be addressed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c557",
      "open-science-source-04/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c731",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c731",
    "representativeText": "Different groups have different needs and challenges in the open science space.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c731",
      "osft-doc-1459/c527"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c485",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c485",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship has strong support from institutes around the world.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c485",
      "osft-doc-1459/c521"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c115",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c115",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should develop and advertise quantifiable incentives for sharing open data in hiring, promotion, and tenure decisions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c115",
      "open-science-source-12/c213"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c118",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c118",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship refers to the communication of research as practiced in any scholarly research discipline.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c118",
      "osft-doc-1459/c236"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c132",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship stakeholders share the belief that increased adoption of Open Scholarship practices is a 'good thing'.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c132",
      "osft-doc-1459/c254"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c248",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c248",
    "representativeText": "Member States should review research assessment and career evaluation systems in order to align them with the principles of open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c248",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c27",
    "representativeText": "Sharing research outputs in a timely manner and with licenses that encourage reuse promotes reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c27",
      "osft-doc-1449/c476"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c13",
    "representativeText": "Enhancing access to research outputs broadens the range of people who can benefit from DOT-funded research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c13",
      "osft-doc-0777/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-0777"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c54",
    "representativeText": "Requiring that this additional license be granted as a term and condition of funding ensures that NSF receives its additional license at the moment the publication is created, which is how the longstanding federal purpose license operates.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c54",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c6"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c298",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c298",
    "representativeText": "\"Open\" can connote a wide field of meanings, including but not limited to access, participation, and licensing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c298",
      "osft-doc-1327/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c427",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c427",
    "representativeText": "Scientists are becoming increasingly reliant on AI technologies in scientific research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c427",
      "open-science-source-45/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open science makes multilingual scientific knowledge openly available for everyone.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c9",
      "osft-doc-1673/c200"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0068/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0068/c39",
    "representativeText": "Member States should develop effective institutional and national open science policies and legal frameworks that are consistent with existing international and regional law and are in line with the definition, values and principles as well as actions outlined in the Recommendation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0068/c39",
      "open-science-source-03/c158"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c66",
    "representativeText": "Grant dependency for funding operations makes operations fragile.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c66",
      "open-science-source-38/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0151"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c60",
    "representativeText": "Transparency allows others to verify and validate the research process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c60",
      "osft-doc-1171/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1171"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c247",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c247",
    "representativeText": "Developing educational resources is essential to facilitate engagement with, and adherence to, research integrity, transparency, openness, accessibility, replicability and reproducibility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c247",
      "osft-doc-1878/c245"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0446/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0446/c1",
    "representativeText": "Academic researchers and librarians work in a constantly changing environment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0446/c1",
      "open-science-source-45/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0446"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c87",
    "representativeText": "(Meta)data should be registered or indexed in a searchable resource.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c87",
      "open-science-source-05/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c24",
    "representativeText": "Assessment of individual research performance using solely quantitative indicators is problematic in practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c24",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1241"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1124/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1124/c12",
    "representativeText": "Open access gives readers extraordinary power to find and make use of relevant literature.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1124/c12",
      "osft-doc-0504/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1213/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1213/c49",
    "representativeText": "All publications must be published under an open license.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1213/c49",
      "open-science-source-06/c226"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c26",
    "representativeText": "All stakeholders in research and its communication must take responsibility for supporting Open Science activities, including appropriate financial and administrative support to ensure long-term sustainability and minimize the bureaucratic burden on researchers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c26",
      "open-science-source-12/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c54",
    "representativeText": "Institutions need to have a career and reward structure for all researchers, and particularly for Early Career Researchers, that values and promotes a diverse range of outputs, activities and career directions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c54",
      "osft-doc-1869/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c374",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c374",
    "representativeText": "Foundation and policies are needed to make the vision of open science as a cure for science's problems more than just words.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c374",
      "open-science-source-12/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c415",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c415",
    "representativeText": "Open science has different uptake and adoption by different fields.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c415",
      "osft-doc-1459/c299"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c780",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c780",
    "representativeText": "Advancement opportunities should be offered to support open science culture.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c780",
      "osft-doc-1869/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c500",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c500",
    "representativeText": "Discussion is needed to seek development of alternative business models, such as the consortium approach of the Open Library of Humanities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c500",
      "osft-doc-1459/c534"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c100",
    "representativeText": "One-size-fits-all solutions are in most cases inappropriate and unlikely to be successful.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c100",
      "osft-doc-1327/c548"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c415",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c415",
    "representativeText": "Open Science encourages dissemination by diffusing knowledge at an earlier stage in the research process and opening up access to research data and research results.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c415",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c47",
    "representativeText": "Making the underlying research data and methodology available allows individual users to replicate the results of the original authors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c47",
      "osft-doc-1702/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c266",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c266",
    "representativeText": "Anyone should have the right to freely contribute to, and participate in, the Open Scholarship process.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c266",
      "osft-doc-1373/c245"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c667",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c667",
    "representativeText": "Academia needs to centre its scholarly practices on free access to research output.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c667",
      "osft-doc-1373/c648"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c10",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should share research data and materials in free, openly-licensed formats.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c10",
      "osft-doc-1459/c366"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c15",
    "representativeText": "Institutions should maintain the institutional infrastructure required for open research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c15",
      "osft-doc-1449/c494"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c223",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c223",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship lowers barriers to collaboration by building resources for broader communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c223",
      "osft-doc-1193/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1193",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship increases recognition for research through broad availability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c9",
      "open-science-source-29/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "open-science-source-29"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c142",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c142",
    "representativeText": "Principled education can leverage open scholarship ideals to teach all students, not only those pursuing a career in academia, about the procedures of science and its intricacies while offering hands-on experience with reproducibility, replication, pre-registration, and analytical flexibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c142",
      "osft-doc-1878/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c51",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's main goal is to build, together with educators, a pathway to the stepwise adoption of principled, open teaching and mentoring practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c51",
      "osft-doc-1878/c315"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1060",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1060",
    "representativeText": "Successful and sustainable scholarly communication solutions require broad collaboration.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1060",
      "open-science-source-22/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c335",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c335",
    "representativeText": "The open science community should embrace diversity.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c335",
      "open-science-source-03/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c120",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c120",
    "representativeText": "Those in charge of research assessment, including hiring, tenure, and grant-awarding committees, should adhere to the DORA principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c120",
      "osft-doc-1373/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c157",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c157",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should invite all relevant stakeholders, including universities, research institutions, learned societies, funders, libraries, and publishers, to collaborate on a transition to open research practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c157",
      "open-science-source-03/c247"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c351",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c351",
    "representativeText": "Open source and open scholarship accelerate innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c351",
      "open-science-source-21/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c291",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c291",
    "representativeText": "Traditional forms of peer review are under critical scrutiny.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c291",
      "open-science-source-18/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c290",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c290",
    "representativeText": "Open science approaches can enable wider public scrutiny of research products.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c290",
      "osft-doc-0002/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0002"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c53",
    "representativeText": "AI has much potential as a driving force in global research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c53",
      "open-science-source-42/c868"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c6",
    "representativeText": "Open science has the potential of making the scientific process more transparent, inclusive and democratic.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c6",
      "open-science-source-03/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c52",
    "representativeText": "Code and software associated with research data should be openly shared.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c52",
      "osft-doc-1449/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c138",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c138",
    "representativeText": "FAIR and CARE are complementary perspectives which enable maximum value through the appropriate and ethical reuse of Indigenous data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c138",
      "open-science-source-30/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1253/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1253/c13",
    "representativeText": "Open science practices benefit stakeholders in society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1253/c13",
      "osft-doc-1449/c468"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c161",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c161",
    "representativeText": "Research-performing institutions, particularly those in receipt of public funds, should implement policies and strategies for open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c161",
      "osft-doc-0068/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c19",
    "representativeText": "The sharing of scientific knowledge, data and information must be facilitated to respond to global emergencies and increase the resilience of societies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c19",
      "osft-doc-0975/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c191",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c191",
    "representativeText": "Digital infrastructures for open science should be based, as far as possible, on open source software stacks.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c191",
      "osft-doc-0860/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c213",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c213",
    "representativeText": "Funding programmes should be invested in to enable scientists to create and use open science platforms, particularly in low- and middle-income countries.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c213",
      "open-science-source-38/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c33",
    "representativeText": "Open science practices and infrastructures enable dynamic research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c33",
      "osft-doc-0975/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open science has transformative potential for reducing existing inequalities in science, technology and innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c9",
      "osft-doc-1612/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c151",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c151",
    "representativeText": "Knowledge tends to grow when it is shared.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c151",
      "open-science-source-27/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-27"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c154",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c154",
    "representativeText": "Scientific knowledge should be part of the knowledge commons.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c154",
      "open-science-source-06/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-06"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c90",
    "representativeText": "A key characteristic of infrastructures is that they are foundational.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c90",
      "osft-doc-0020/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0020"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c149",
    "representativeText": "Libraries, publishers and software developers should all collaborate to build new tools that optimally support scholarship in a distributed open environment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c149",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1002"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c67",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c67",
    "representativeText": "Notions such as journal impact factor are increasingly irrelevant in a world of disaggregated knowledge units of vastly varying granularity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c67",
      "open-science-source-33/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-33"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c91",
    "representativeText": "The formats and technologies of communication that underpin scholarly publishing must be changed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c91",
      "open-science-source-43/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c17",
    "representativeText": "The operating policies and procedures, detailed financials, sustainability models, fees, strategic and product roadmaps, organisational charts, and other appropriate operational information should be made openly available, within the constraints of privacy laws.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c17",
      "osft-doc-0860/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c22",
    "representativeText": "Organisations and services must be able to adapt and change, not merely survive.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c22",
      "osft-doc-0860/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c189",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c189",
    "representativeText": "Open, community governed scholarly communication infrastructures should incorporate long-term preservation to ensure resilience, sustainability, and global accessibility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c189",
      "open-science-source-03/c185"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c76",
    "representativeText": "Structural and cultural barriers to open science remain.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c76",
      "open-science-source-42/c489"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c7",
    "representativeText": "When Open Access publication fees are applied, the structure of such fees must be transparent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c7",
      "osft-doc-1213/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c73",
    "representativeText": "Publication venues must provide machine-readable information on the Open Access status and the license embedded in the article, in standard non-proprietary format.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c73",
      "osft-doc-1213/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c4/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c4/c3",
    "representativeText": "The PDB is managed by the Worldwide Protein Data Bank partnership (wwPDB).",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c345",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c345",
    "representativeText": "The problem of peer review capacity has been growing for some time.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c345",
      "open-science-source-17/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-17",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c34",
    "representativeText": "Corresponding data and software should be made available via a digital repository maintained or approved by a U.S. federal agency.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c34",
      "open-science-source-24-c10/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-24-c10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c78",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c78",
    "representativeText": "Open infrastructure can serve as a key enabler of open science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c78",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-22/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-22/c36",
    "representativeText": "Scientific progress is a global endeavor.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-22/c36",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c56",
    "representativeText": "DOT-funded research should adhere to the FAIR Data Principles to ensure full reuse.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c56",
      "osft-doc-0298/c182"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-0298"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c82",
    "representativeText": "DOT should adopt ORCIDs for researchers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c82",
      "osft-doc-1283/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c49",
    "representativeText": "The existing federal purpose license likely already provides agencies with sufficient authority to require that publicly accessible copies of scholarly publications are provided to the public with reuse rights.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c49",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c62",
    "representativeText": "University policy compliance with the licensing requirement is typically accomplished by the university owning all rights in works created under a grant.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c62",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c3/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c3/c64",
    "representativeText": "Universities must retain rights sufficient to hold the requisite rights to apply the CC BY 4.0 license or functional equivalent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c64",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c109"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c6/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c6/c59",
    "representativeText": "Institutional repositories run by libraries and other research institutions generally do not charge authors to deposit articles, manuscripts, or data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c59",
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-24-c7"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c16",
    "representativeText": "Full reuse enables others to build on research results.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c16",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-27/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-27/c13",
    "representativeText": "Diverse understandings of knowledge and knowledge-making should be able to co-exist in scientific production.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-27/c13",
      "osft-doc-0150/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-29/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-29/c11",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should apply appropriate licenses or waivers to their outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-29/c11",
      "osft-doc-1459/c168"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-29",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-29/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-29/c26",
    "representativeText": "Open research practices come at the cost of time and other resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-29/c26",
      "open-science-source-03/c249"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-29"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c181",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous Peoples' authority to control Indigenous data must be empowered.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c181",
      "open-science-source-26/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c194",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c194",
    "representativeText": "Those working with Indigenous data are responsible for ensuring that the creation, interpretation, and use of those data uphold, or are respectful of, the dignity of Indigenous nations and communities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c194",
      "open-science-source-26/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c78",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c78",
    "representativeText": "Benefits accrue when data ecosystems are designed and function to support creation and use of data that reflect community values.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c78",
      "osft-doc-1027/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c2",
    "representativeText": "Federal agencies should update their public access policies, as soon as possible and no later than December 31, 2025, to make the data supporting federally funded research publicly accessible without an embargo on their free and public release.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c2",
      "open-science-source-36/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c242",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c242",
    "representativeText": "Subscription journal licenses may limit the right to read a scholarly publication to subscribers only.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c242",
      "open-science-source-19/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c26",
    "representativeText": "Open access refers to a range of publishers' business models used to provide free access to scholarly publications, whether or not those publications were federally funded.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c26",
      "open-science-source-02/c243"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c209",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c209",
    "representativeText": "The National Open Science Festival facilitates knowledge and experience sharing by connecting people and organisations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c209",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c145",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c145",
    "representativeText": "Making research outputs as open and FAIR as possible could stimulate their reuse.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c145",
      "osft-doc-0484/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-0484"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c7",
    "representativeText": "The open science transition is important.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c7",
      "osft-doc-1449/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c67",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c67",
    "representativeText": "Generative AI tools can assist the advancement of scientific research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c67",
      "open-science-source-45/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-43/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-43/c93",
    "representativeText": "Peer review adds to researcher workload.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-43/c93",
      "open-science-source-18/c202"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-46/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-46/c105",
    "representativeText": "Funders must adapt.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-46/c105",
      "open-science-source-06/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-46"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-55/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-55/c39",
    "representativeText": "DORA puts forward a general recommendation not to use the JIF in evaluations, especially as a surrogate measure of the quality of individual research articles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-55/c39",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1053"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c141",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c141",
    "representativeText": "Funders should provide targeted, sustained support for meta-research on reproducibility interventions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c141",
      "osft-doc-0150/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c19",
    "representativeText": "Meta-researchers, supported by funders and publishers, should investigate the benefits of reproducibility interventions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c19",
      "osft-doc-0150/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c28",
    "representativeText": "Achieving reproducibility at scale requires strong coordination across the research ecosystem.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c28",
      "osft-doc-0150/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c75",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility metrics should complement, not replace, expert judgement.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c75",
      "osft-doc-0150/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c27",
    "representativeText": "Funding agencies should be explicit about the criteria used in evaluating the scientific productivity of grant applicants.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c27",
      "osft-doc-0296/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c7",
    "representativeText": "Mandating open access to publicly funded articles and data is the greatest accelerator of science solutions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c7",
      "osft-doc-0900/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1195",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1195",
    "representativeText": "The repertoire of metrics that can be attached to research outputs is increasing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1195",
      "osft-doc-1449/c334"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1230",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1230",
    "representativeText": "More work should be done to identify quantitative data or indicators that could be used as supporting evidence for specific types of research impact.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1230",
      "osft-doc-1327/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c29",
    "representativeText": "One size is unlikely to fit all in research assessment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c29",
      "open-science-source-18/c690"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c418",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c418",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly research is increasingly collaborative.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c418",
      "open-science-source-45/c173"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c90",
    "representativeText": "Indicators should be updated in response to their systemic and potential effects.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c90",
      "osft-doc-1459/c453"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c91",
    "representativeText": "Improving reproducibility depends on strong policies and infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c91",
      "osft-doc-0050/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c1",
    "representativeText": "Dramatic changes to the transparency, rigor, reproducibility and replicability of research practices have occurred in the last decade.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c1",
      "osft-doc-1878/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c222",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c222",
    "representativeText": "Resources in FORRT's database are categorized according to FORRT's framework of clusters pervading the literature on open and reproducible scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c222",
      "osft-doc-1878/c220"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c235",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c235",
    "representativeText": "Where there are several, potentially competing, definitions for a term, FORRT's glossary provides alternative definitions and related references.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c235",
      "osft-doc-1878/c233"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c287",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c287",
    "representativeText": "Scholars, instructors and educational institutions striving to develop or reform degree programs and courses can use FORRT's pedagogies as an initial template towards the creation of their own pedagogies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c287",
      "osft-doc-1878/c280"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c308",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c308",
    "representativeText": "FORRT works to create widespread individual and institutional buy-in by providing infrastructure, community, and resources that lower the cost for individuals and institutions to pivot away from legacy approaches to research training towards more rigorous, cutting-edge practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c308",
      "osft-doc-1878/c317"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c51",
    "representativeText": "Other organizations need to lend their effort and resources to this open access initiative.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c51",
      "osft-doc-1124/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c6",
    "representativeText": "Removing access barriers to the peer-reviewed journal literature will share the learning of the rich with the poor and the poor with the rich.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c6",
      "osft-doc-1124/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c70",
    "representativeText": "Open research information should follow the FAIR principles for Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reusability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c70",
      "open-science-source-05/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0900/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0900/c24",
    "representativeText": "The price of publication should directly correlate with the quality of services offered.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0900/c24",
      "osft-doc-0114/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0963/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0963/c27",
    "representativeText": "Authors must cite and link to the data in the article, following the Joint Declaration of Data Citation Principles and ESIP Guidelines, using the unique, resolvable, and persistent identifiers provided by the repository in which the data are archived.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0963/c27",
      "open-science-source-06/c216"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0963"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1031/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1031/c24",
    "representativeText": "Open and Collaborative Science cultivates social innovation in society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1031/c24",
      "osft-doc-1398/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1031",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c2",
    "representativeText": "Usage of quantitative indicators on research is becoming more frequent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c2",
      "osft-doc-0142/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1124/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1124/c3",
    "representativeText": "The public good made possible by the old tradition and new technology includes the world-wide electronic distribution of the peer-reviewed journal literature.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1124/c3",
      "osft-doc-0504/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1253/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1253/c20",
    "representativeText": "Open access means providing access to the research itself.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1253/c20",
      "osft-doc-1213/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1213",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c617",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c617",
    "representativeText": "Effective open science tools such as high-quality open journals and open datasets can improve the visibility of science by making research more accessible and improving engagement with outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c617",
      "osft-doc-0138/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c794",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c794",
    "representativeText": "A common ground approach is needed to develop workable, global open science solutions like the ones UNESCO is hoping to develop.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c794",
      "open-science-source-03/c212"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c822",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c822",
    "representativeText": "The value of peer review should be preserved.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c822",
      "osft-doc-0142/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c117",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c117",
    "representativeText": "Unrestricted text and data mining over scholarship outputs should be enabled.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c117",
      "osft-doc-1459/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c239",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c239",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly communication processes need to increasingly embrace the power of Web-native technologies in order to make use of the semantic Web.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c239",
      "osft-doc-1459/c260"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c244",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c244",
    "representativeText": "The benefits of research should be integrated into the functioning of wider society.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c244",
      "osft-doc-1459/c265"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c258",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c258",
    "representativeText": "Tensions exist between the best way to adopt Open Scholarship practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c258",
      "osft-doc-1673/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c298",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c298",
    "representativeText": "Funding agencies should adopt complete Open Access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c298",
      "osft-doc-1459/c328"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c334",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c334",
    "representativeText": "Well-curated and annotated materials should be shared within communities without restrictive licensing or complex material transfer agreements, which slow scientific progress due to complex legal jargon or stringent terms and conditions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c334",
      "osft-doc-1673/c224"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c385",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c385",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship infrastructures should achieve a streamlined process of large-scale, data-intensive research, operated collaboratively through high-performance computer clusters that transcend all geographical, technical, and disciplinary boundaries.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c385",
      "osft-doc-1459/c412"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c405",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c405",
    "representativeText": "Integrating a research openness metric into university ranking system algorithms would align measures with core open values.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c405",
      "osft-doc-1459/c434"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c424",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c424",
    "representativeText": "The Journal Impact Factor should not be used in any form.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c424",
      "osft-doc-1459/c456"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c43",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should refuse to sign copyright transfer agreements unless they are allowed to retain copyright of their work under a Creative Commons license of their own choosing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c43",
      "osft-doc-1459/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c537",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c537",
    "representativeText": "The Open movement is beset by communication and engagement challenges, including from powerful players with opposing or divergent interests.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c537",
      "osft-doc-1459/c562"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c559",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c559",
    "representativeText": "Initiatives such as SCOSS, which is dedicated to supporting a sustainable and open scholarly infrastructure, should be supported.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c559",
      "osft-doc-1459/c406"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c597",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c597",
    "representativeText": "Embargo compliance reconciliation systems are time-consuming and expensive.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c597",
      "osft-doc-1459/c622"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c623",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c623",
    "representativeText": "Publisher bundling of research workflow services would lead to new inefficiencies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c623",
      "osft-doc-1459/c646"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c625",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c625",
    "representativeText": "Publisher bundling of research workflow services would lead to the same price bloat associated with 'big deal' licensing contracts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c625",
      "osft-doc-1459/c648"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c627",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c627",
    "representativeText": "Commercial colonisation of the preprint landscape leads to wider commercial control, irrespective of the final venue of publication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c627",
      "osft-doc-1459/c650"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c631",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c631",
    "representativeText": "Giving researchers too much choice could lead to no change from traditional habits.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c631",
      "osft-doc-1459/c654"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c635",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c635",
    "representativeText": "Engagement in practices of open science and scholarship can be considered as happening in a spectrum of practices that each person has to negotiate.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c635",
      "osft-doc-1459/c658"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1398/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1398/c25",
    "representativeText": "Open science offers accessible evidence, fostering confidence and building hope regarding society's transformative options such as vaccines, sustainable practices, and renewable energy technologies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1398/c25",
      "osft-doc-0825/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c348",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c348",
    "representativeText": "Universities should offer appropriate support, professional development and training opportunities for Open Science, aligned with employees' different needs depending on discipline, career progression, seniority and goals.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c348",
      "osft-doc-1283/c116"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c361",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c361",
    "representativeText": "The JIF is often used as a surrogate for the quality of individual articles in a journal.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c361",
      "open-science-source-55/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c50",
    "representativeText": "The transparency of making research data and methodology available is good for research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c50",
      "osft-doc-1327/c651"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c60",
    "representativeText": "Multiple groups within the university must contribute towards the implementation of Open Science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c60",
      "open-science-source-25/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c124",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c124",
    "representativeText": "National level actors must mandate ORCID for researchers across all research outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c124",
      "osft-doc-1673/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c195",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c195",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should develop an equivalent to the CASRAI CRediT guidelines to identify the contributions of authors of non-paper products, such as data and software, as clearly as possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c195",
      "osft-doc-1373/c182"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c245",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c245",
    "representativeText": "Previous works on Open Scholarship have been, and remain, crucial for communicating the case for Open Scholarship to wider society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c245",
      "osft-doc-1673/c125"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c392",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c392",
    "representativeText": "Disruption beyond the current structure and close association of research practices with finalised research-paper-based products is unlikely to catalyse change.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c392",
      "osft-doc-1373/c361"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c436",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c436",
    "representativeText": "Traditional metrics for measuring scientific impact are too heavily focused on journal publications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c436",
      "osft-doc-0142/c644"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c457",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c457",
    "representativeText": "The principles and practices outlined in the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment and the Leiden Manifesto should be adopted.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c457",
      "osft-doc-1373/c425"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c487",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c487",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship community must collaborate with other related or overlapping communities, including Open Science Hardware and Open Source Software, on common areas of interest.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c487",
      "osft-doc-1373/c449"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c566",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c566",
    "representativeText": "Commonly used Open Scholarship terms should be defined with precision.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c566",
      "osft-doc-1373/c541"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1612/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1612/c77",
    "representativeText": "New harms must not be created in the sharing and use of data from Indigenous communities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1612/c77",
      "osft-doc-1027/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1027",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c154",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c154",
    "representativeText": "The core principles of Open Scholarship include equity.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c154",
      "osft-doc-1459/c277"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1702/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1702/c54",
    "representativeText": "Open data can support an increased pace of innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1702/c54",
      "osft-doc-0748/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0748",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1702/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1702/c91",
    "representativeText": "FAIR data principles comprise Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Reusable.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1702/c91",
      "osft-doc-1449/c222"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c169",
    "representativeText": "Funders should reward incremental steps by providing incentives for different aspects of open scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c169",
      "osft-doc-1327/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c63",
    "representativeText": "Open source technologies, tools and platforms are an effective way of accelerating open scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c63",
      "osft-doc-1702/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c138",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c138",
    "representativeText": "Principled education can offer hands-on experience addressing concepts of reproducibility, replication, pre-registration, and analytical flexibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c138",
      "osft-doc-0441/c321"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c147",
    "representativeText": "The current publication culture places a premium on novelty over confirming published findings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c147",
      "open-science-source-18/c330"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c301",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c301",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to improve how research is conducted.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c301",
      "osft-doc-0441/c311"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c308",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c308",
    "representativeText": "FORRT provides a supportive community and collection of open resources and initiatives to facilitate positive incremental developments in research practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c308",
      "osft-doc-0441/c225"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c34",
    "representativeText": "Open Science has direct implications for the credibility of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c34",
      "osft-doc-0441/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c55",
    "representativeText": "Encouraging the progressive opening of teaching and mentoring resources facilitates access, discovery, and learning.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c55",
      "osft-doc-0441/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c28",
    "representativeText": "Open infrastructure must be favored.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c28",
      "open-science-source-38/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c35",
    "representativeText": "Greater access to scientific process and outputs can improve the effectiveness and productivity of scientific systems by reducing duplication costs in collecting, creating, transferring and reusing data and scientific material and by allowing more research from the same data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c35",
      "osft-doc-0975/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c169",
    "representativeText": "Raw and derived data need to be preserved as part of the research object and shared publicly.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c169",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-23/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-23/c59",
    "representativeText": "NIH should require immediate sharing of research findings through repositories.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-23/c59",
      "open-science-source-41/c414"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-41"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c10",
    "representativeText": "Data should be assigned globally unique and persistent identifiers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c10",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c7"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c43",
    "representativeText": "The re-analysis of findings allows other experts to root out false results, increasing public trust in science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c43",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-28/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-28/c9",
    "representativeText": "Underlying data supporting the Funded Manuscripts must be made accessible immediately and as open as possible upon availability of the Funded Manuscripts, subject to any applicable ethical, legal, or regulatory requirements or restrictions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-28/c9",
      "open-science-source-34/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-28",
      "open-science-source-34"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c881",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c881",
    "representativeText": "Open science principles and practices offer a clear pathway to improve public scrutiny.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c881",
      "osft-doc-1171/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1171"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c24",
    "representativeText": "AI is reshaping the research landscape, with growing adoption and optimism about its potential.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c24",
      "open-science-source-42/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c58",
    "representativeText": "With the rise of AI, research is at a tipping point.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c58",
      "open-science-source-42/c262"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c51",
    "representativeText": "Funders and publishers of all types, as well as research institutions, should require, and implement where relevant, the use of Globally Unique, Persistent and Resolvable Identifiers (GUPRIs) across the research lifecycle.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c51",
      "osft-doc-1283/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c125",
    "representativeText": "The evidence base for which reproducibility interventions work, under what conditions, and with what trade-offs, remains limited.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c125",
      "osft-doc-0050/c144"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c27",
    "representativeText": "Openness is a means to optimizing conditions for dissent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c27",
      "osft-doc-1878/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c329",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c329",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to generate positive downstream consequences for the scientific community and society in the form of more reproducible, more robust work conducted by today's students and by researcher-teachers who use FORRT.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c329",
      "osft-doc-1878/c320"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c41",
    "representativeText": "Other fields have discovered similarly worryingly low rates of replicability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c41",
      "osft-doc-1878/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c84",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c84",
    "representativeText": "Training students to engage in open practices helps increase adoption rates and ensure open scholarship practices are widely adopted in the future.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c84",
      "osft-doc-1878/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c26",
    "representativeText": "Open science serves as a shield for quality science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c26",
      "osft-doc-1398/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0846/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0846/c37",
    "representativeText": "Software should be directly recognized and cited.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0846/c37",
      "osft-doc-1459/c356"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1007",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1007",
    "representativeText": "The global scholarly communication community needs new infrastructure items—products, services, tools, websites, and other resources—that will help encourage, achieve, sustain and monitor reforms in scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1007",
      "open-science-source-06/c193"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c160",
    "representativeText": "All research processes and outputs, including historical ones, should be openly licensed and available for re-use in appropriate venues.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c160",
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c250",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c250",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship are often missing from many traditional forms of scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c250",
      "osft-doc-1459/c279"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c341",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c341",
    "representativeText": "Optimisation of the knowledge creation process can be achieved through integrating external knowledge sources and collective intelligence.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c341",
      "osft-doc-1459/c374"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c342",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c342",
    "representativeText": "Optimisation of the knowledge creation process can be achieved through facilitating collaboration through online tools and platforms.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c342",
      "osft-doc-1459/c375"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1398/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1398/c41",
    "representativeText": "Universities' purpose transcends the boundaries of academia.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1398/c41",
      "osft-doc-1767/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1398",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1398/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1398/c42",
    "representativeText": "Universities play a vital role in actively contributing to the betterment of society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1398/c42",
      "osft-doc-0825/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c315",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c315",
    "representativeText": "Universities should integrate Open Science concepts, thinking, and its practical applications in educational and skills development programmes, analysing and mapping their needs for Open Science skills training.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c315",
      "osft-doc-1327/c873"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c138",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c138",
    "representativeText": "re3data offers a database of research repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c138",
      "osft-doc-1686/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c210",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c210",
    "representativeText": "Low-barrier training and communities should be developed for students, staff, and faculty to engage in open scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c210",
      "osft-doc-1449/c320"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1449",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c228",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c228",
    "representativeText": "Individual and institutional barriers hold back wide adoption of open, reproducible research practices and workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c228",
      "osft-doc-1353/c133"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c65",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c65",
    "representativeText": "Scholars and students would benefit from integrating open scholarship into their teaching and mentoring practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c65",
      "osft-doc-0441/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c152",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c152",
    "representativeText": "No barriers should be established to restrict the use and reuse of research results.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c152",
      "osft-doc-1373/c650"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c6/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c6/c47",
    "representativeText": "Equity should be ensured in benefitting from the results of federally funded research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c47",
      "open-science-source-44/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "open-science-source-44"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c179",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c179",
    "representativeText": "Any value created from Indigenous data should contribute to Indigenous aspirations for wellbeing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c179",
      "osft-doc-1027/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c1",
    "representativeText": "AI is becoming an established tool used by researchers across scientific fields.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c1",
      "open-science-source-41/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c160",
    "representativeText": "The current academic incentive structure discourages scholars from devoting time and energy to incorporating open scholarship practices into training.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c160",
      "osft-doc-1878/c161"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c326",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c326",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's approach to providing relevant pedagogical learning materials, tools and applied pedagogies lowers the opportunity costs for teachers to pivot towards an education centered around openness, reproducibility, and rigor.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c326",
      "osft-doc-1878/c224"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0900/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0900/c23",
    "representativeText": "Financial models for publication should be transparent.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0900/c23",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0971/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0971/c2",
    "representativeText": "Good research data management is not a goal in itself but is the key conduit leading to subsequent data and knowledge integration and reuse.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0971/c2",
      "osft-doc-0645/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0971"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1253/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1253/c15",
    "representativeText": "Open science comprises collaboration and sharing of information, including open educational resources, presentations, research data, computer code, peer review materials, and other aspects of the research and publication lifecycle.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1253/c15",
      "osft-doc-0411/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c470",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c470",
    "representativeText": "The growth and adoption of preprints provides a method of getting research out sooner and more transparently.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c470",
      "osft-doc-1353/c151"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c357",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c357",
    "representativeText": "Software and code should be formally recognised as a research output, along with research articles, data, and metadata.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c357",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1702/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1702/c53",
    "representativeText": "Open data can support an increased pace of discovery.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1702/c53",
      "open-science-source-12/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c69",
    "representativeText": "In the context of the Roadmap, science is understood to include both fundamental and applied natural, physical, biomedical and social science, as well as engineering and mathematics.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c69",
      "osft-doc-0105/c150"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c206",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c206",
    "representativeText": "The National Open Science Festival is an important vehicle for Open Science NL to engage with the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c206",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c48",
    "representativeText": "Additional emphasis on teaching and mentoring of reproducible and open research practices helps ensure that students are experienced and trained to engage in and evaluate these practices, not simply exposed to best practices, when they complete their studies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c48",
      "osft-doc-1878/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c325",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c325",
    "representativeText": "The multidisciplinary FORRT community and the resources it provides support the transition into and continued development of open and reproducible teaching and mentoring practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c325",
      "osft-doc-0680/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-0680"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c11",
    "representativeText": "FORRT is a community-driven infrastructure for educators that advances reproducibility through pedagogical reform.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c11",
      "osft-doc-1878/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c10",
    "representativeText": "New pieces of research infrastructure have proliferated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c10",
      "osft-doc-1781/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c12",
    "representativeText": "New journal business models have proliferated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c12",
      "osft-doc-1253/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c14",
    "representativeText": "New OA options for authors have proliferated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c14",
      "open-science-source-36/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c149",
    "representativeText": "Investments and creative exploration should occur to identify other alternatives to APCs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c149",
      "osft-doc-0504/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-0504"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c160",
    "representativeText": "Outsiders to a given APC-based journal cannot tell how far the APC exceeds the journal's expenses.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c160",
      "open-science-source-36/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c195",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c195",
    "representativeText": "Shifting resources from APC-based OA to green and diamond OA will enfranchise more voices in global research without reducing the quality or openness of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c195",
      "open-science-source-38/c130"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c23",
    "representativeText": "Embargoes on repository OA cause harms.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c23",
      "osft-doc-1673/c336"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c306",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c306",
    "representativeText": "Read-and-publish agreements reduce incentives for authors or institutions to favor journals with lower or no APCs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c306",
      "open-science-source-36/c340"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c308",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c308",
    "representativeText": "A journal APC can be high because it's tied to high expenses, for example at highly selective journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c308",
      "open-science-source-36/c326"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c321",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c321",
    "representativeText": "APCs should not be paid at hybrid journals.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c321",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-15-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c323",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c323",
    "representativeText": "Hybrid journals charge higher average APCs than full OA journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c323",
      "open-science-source-36/c328"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c325",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c325",
    "representativeText": "Hybrid journals often double-dip, charging twice for their OA articles, once through subscriptions and once through APCs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c325",
      "open-science-source-36/c142"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c344",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c344",
    "representativeText": "Diamond OA journals offer no-fee publishing to all authors, not just those affiliated with institutions taking part in a read-and-publish agreement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c344",
      "open-science-source-23/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-23"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c39",
    "representativeText": "Open access is not an end in itself, but a means to further ends.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c39",
      "open-science-source-04/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-04"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c4",
    "representativeText": "The number of new OA journals has grown.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c4",
      "open-science-source-06/c239"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-06"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c41",
    "representativeText": "Open access is a means to the quality of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c41",
      "osft-doc-1213/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c59",
    "representativeText": "OA research is at risk of enclosure when hosted on closed, proprietary, or commercial infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c59",
      "osft-doc-1287/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-02/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-02/c9",
    "representativeText": "New research assessment practices have proliferated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-02/c9",
      "osft-doc-0142/c198"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open science has transformative potential for accelerating progress towards the implementation of the 2030 Agenda and the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c10",
      "osft-doc-0975/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c100",
    "representativeText": "Community-building efforts are crucial for the long-term sustainability of open science infrastructures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c100",
      "open-science-source-38/c295"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c107",
    "representativeText": "Web-based platforms and social media, as well as open source hardware and software, especially low-cost sensors and mobile apps, are important agents of interaction for citizen science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c107",
      "osft-doc-1449/c428"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c11",
    "representativeText": "Gender equality and Africa should be mainstreamed in open science policies and practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c11",
      "osft-doc-0975/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c121",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c121",
    "representativeText": "Open science should support high-quality research by bringing together multiple sources of knowledge, making research methods and outputs widely available for rigorous review and scrutiny, and ensuring transparent evaluation processes.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c121",
      "osft-doc-1283/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c129",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c129",
    "representativeText": "The practice of science should be sustainable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c129",
      "osft-doc-0002/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c130",
    "representativeText": "The practice of science should be equitable, including in opportunities for scientific education and capacity development.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c130",
      "osft-doc-0002/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0002"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c139",
    "representativeText": "Collaboration between disciplines should be promoted.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c139",
      "open-science-source-42/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c151",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c151",
    "representativeText": "Member States should encourage bibliodiversity through the diversity of formats and means of publications, including those produced by the humanities and social sciences, and diversity of business models, by supporting not-for-profit, academic and scientific community-driven publishing models as a common good.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c151",
      "open-science-source-10/c217"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c154",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c154",
    "representativeText": "Member States should enhance open science communication to support the dissemination of scientific knowledge to scholars in other research fields, decision makers and the public at large.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c154",
      "osft-doc-1283/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c16",
    "representativeText": "Open scientific practices improve the reliability of the evidence needed for robust decision-making and policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c16",
      "osft-doc-0975/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c160",
    "representativeText": "Member States should mainstream gender equality aspects into open science policies, strategies and practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c160",
      "osft-doc-0068/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c162",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c162",
    "representativeText": "Research-performing institutions, universities, scientific unions and associations, and learned societies should adopt statements of principle in line with the Recommendation to encourage open science practice, in coordination with national science academies, associations of early-career researchers, and the International Science Council.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c162",
      "osft-doc-0068/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c163",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c163",
    "representativeText": "Member States should enhance the inclusion of citizen and participatory science as integral parts of open science policies and practices at the national, institutional and funder levels.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c163",
      "osft-doc-0068/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c164",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c164",
    "representativeText": "Member States should design models that allow co-production of knowledge with multiple actors.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c164",
      "osft-doc-0068/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c165",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c165",
    "representativeText": "Member States should establish guidelines to ensure the recognition of non-scientific collaborations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c165",
      "osft-doc-0068/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c167",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c167",
    "representativeText": "Member States should foster equitable public-private partnerships for open science and engage the private sector in open science, provided that there is appropriate certification and regulation to prevent vendor lock-in, predatory behaviour, and unfair or inequitable extraction of profit from publicly funded scientific activities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c167",
      "osft-doc-0068/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c169",
    "representativeText": "Member States should design, implement and monitor funding and investment policies and strategies for science based on the core values and principles of open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c169",
      "osft-doc-0068/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c170",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c170",
    "representativeText": "The costs associated with operationalization of open science relate to the support of open science research, publishing, data and coding practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c170",
      "osft-doc-0068/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c172",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c172",
    "representativeText": "The costs associated with operationalization of open science relate to capacity building of all actors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c172",
      "osft-doc-0068/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c173",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c173",
    "representativeText": "The costs associated with operationalization of open science relate to innovative, highly collaborative and participatory approaches to the scientific enterprise.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c173",
      "osft-doc-0068/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c2",
    "representativeText": "Science, technology and innovation provide solutions that improve human well-being in responding to global challenges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c2",
      "osft-doc-0975/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c209",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c209",
    "representativeText": "Convergence between the various semantic artefacts, particularly vocabularies, taxonomies, ontologies and metadata schema, is essential for the interoperability and reuse of data for interdisciplinary research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c209",
      "osft-doc-0142/c323"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c22",
    "representativeText": "Existing international legal frameworks on intellectual property rights, including the rights of scientists to their scientific productions, are important.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c22",
      "osft-doc-0975/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c229",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c229",
    "representativeText": "A core set of data science and data stewardship skills, skills related to intellectual property law, and skills needed to ensure open access and engagement with society should be incorporated into higher education research skills curricula.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c229",
      "osft-doc-1449/c498"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c232",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c232",
    "representativeText": "Enabling open science requires advanced and professional data stewards who manage and curate data according to agreed principles, notably FAIR and CARE principles, within trusted institutions or services.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c232",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c24",
    "representativeText": "Open science builds upon existing intellectual property systems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c24",
      "osft-doc-0975/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c245",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c245",
    "representativeText": "Attention should be given to preventing and mitigating the unintended negative consequences of open science practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c245",
      "osft-doc-1327/c793"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c25",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters an open approach that encourages the use of open licensing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c25",
      "osft-doc-0975/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c26",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters an open approach that adds materials to the public domain.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c26",
      "osft-doc-0975/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c260",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c260",
    "representativeText": "Assessment of researchers against open science criteria should be fit for different stages of careers, with particular attention to researchers at the beginning of their careers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c260",
      "open-science-source-10/c177"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c29",
    "representativeText": "A growing number of scientific outputs is already in the public domain or licensed under open license schemes that allow free access, re-use and distribution of work under specific conditions, provided that the creator is appropriately credited.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c29",
      "osft-doc-0975/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c3",
    "representativeText": "Science, technology and innovation provide solutions that advance environmental sustainability and respect for the planet's biological and cultural diversity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c3",
      "osft-doc-0975/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c30",
    "representativeText": "Open science originated several decades ago as a movement to transform scientific practice to adapt to the changes, challenges, opportunities and risks of the digital era and to increase the societal impact of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c30",
      "osft-doc-0975/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c314",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c314",
    "representativeText": "The monitoring of open science should, whenever possible, be supported by open non-proprietary and transparent infrastructures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c314",
      "open-science-source-21/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-21"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c34",
    "representativeText": "Open science practices and infrastructures enable economic partnerships.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c34",
      "osft-doc-0975/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c37",
    "representativeText": "Collective science processes carried out by research communities using shared knowledge infrastructure to advance shared research agendas dealing with complex problems are of growing importance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c37",
      "osft-doc-0975/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c4",
    "representativeText": "Science, technology and innovation provide solutions that foster sustainable social and economic development.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c4",
      "osft-doc-0975/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c42",
    "representativeText": "Open science's collaborative and inclusive characteristics guide scientific work towards solving problems of social importance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c42",
      "open-science-source-27/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "open-science-source-27"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c45",
    "representativeText": "Open science respects the diversity of cultures and knowledge systems around the world as foundations for sustainable development.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c45",
      "osft-doc-0975/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c46",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters open dialogue with indigenous peoples and local communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c46",
      "osft-doc-0975/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c47",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters respect for diverse knowledge holders for contemporary problem solving and emergent strategies towards transformative change.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c47",
      "osft-doc-0975/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c5",
    "representativeText": "Science, technology and innovation provide solutions that promote democracy and peace.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c5",
      "osft-doc-0975/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c57",
    "representativeText": "Open science builds on the pillar of open scientific knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c57",
      "osft-doc-0068/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c58",
    "representativeText": "Open science builds on the pillar of open science infrastructures.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c58",
      "osft-doc-0068/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c59",
    "representativeText": "Open science builds on the pillar of science communication.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c59",
      "osft-doc-0068/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c6",
    "representativeText": "The expansion of information and communication technologies and global interconnectedness provides opportunities and potential to accelerate human progress.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c6",
      "osft-doc-0975/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c61",
    "representativeText": "Open science builds on the pillar of open dialogue with other knowledge systems.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c61",
      "osft-doc-0068/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c7",
    "representativeText": "The expansion of information and communication technologies and global interconnectedness provides opportunities and potential to foster knowledge societies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c7",
      "osft-doc-0975/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-03/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-03/c83",
    "representativeText": "Open hardware generally includes the design specifications of a physical object licensed such that the object can be studied, modified, created and distributed by anyone, providing as many people as possible with the ability to construct, remix and share their knowledge of hardware design and function.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-03/c83",
      "osft-doc-0633/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0633"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c125",
    "representativeText": "Adequate incentives should be provided to reward endeavours to publish better, rather than more.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c125",
      "open-science-source-43/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c128",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c128",
    "representativeText": "Scholarship needs original research that contributes novel results to the body of knowledge in order to progress.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c128",
      "open-science-source-12/c139"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-12"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c129",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c129",
    "representativeText": "A system of scholarly communication should identify research gaps.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c129",
      "osft-doc-1327/c845"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c153",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c153",
    "representativeText": "Scientific knowledge should be a public good.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c153",
      "open-science-source-11/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-11"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c26",
    "representativeText": "Research output is often communicated in a highly abstract domain-specific language, preventing knowledge dissemination to other research fields and to other members of society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c26",
      "open-science-source-41/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-41"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c28",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly communication system is exceedingly expensive.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c28",
      "osft-doc-1327/c172"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c31",
    "representativeText": "Research output has grown exponentially over the last few centuries.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c31",
      "open-science-source-18/c679"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c33",
    "representativeText": "The exponential growth of research output has led to information overload.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c33",
      "open-science-source-45/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-04/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-04/c89",
    "representativeText": "In practice, one cannot reproduce every research result to verify its credibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-04/c89",
      "open-science-source-17/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-17"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c10",
    "representativeText": "The research community monitors and incentivizes open science using closed data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c10",
      "osft-doc-0730/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c100",
    "representativeText": "A commitment to adhere to the Principles of Open Scholarly Infrastructure, with regular updates on performance and improvements, provides a means by which a scholarly infrastructure can provide assurances to the community that it qualifies for the level of trust accorded to an open scholarly infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c100",
      "osft-doc-0730/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c11",
    "representativeText": "The research community routinely makes decisions based on information that is biased against less privileged languages, geographical regions, and research agendas.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c11",
      "osft-doc-0730/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c15",
    "representativeText": "Research information should be as open as possible and as closed as necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c15",
      "osft-doc-0730/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c19",
    "representativeText": "Sharing experiences and coordinating action are important to promote a system-wide transition from closed to open research information.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c19",
      "osft-doc-0730/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c2",
    "representativeText": "Research information often plays a vital role in the distribution of resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c2",
      "osft-doc-0730/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c20",
    "representativeText": "Decision making in science is too often based on closed research information.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c20",
      "osft-doc-0730/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c25",
    "representativeText": "Decisions about the careers of researchers, about the future of research organizations, and ultimately about the way science serves the whole of humanity depend on black-box indicators and analytics.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c25",
      "osft-doc-0730/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c3",
    "representativeText": "Research information often plays a vital role in the evaluation of researchers and institutions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c3",
      "osft-doc-0730/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c32",
    "representativeText": "The Web of Science and Scopus databases provide metadata for scientific publications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c32",
      "osft-doc-0730/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c33",
    "representativeText": "The Web of Science and Scopus databases impose severe restrictions on the use of their metadata.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c33",
      "osft-doc-0730/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c34",
    "representativeText": "The Web of Science and Scopus databases make their metadata available only to organizations that pay hefty subscription fees.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c34",
      "osft-doc-0730/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c35",
    "representativeText": "Indicators and analytics based on databases such as Web of Science and Scopus lack transparency and reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c35",
      "osft-doc-0730/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c37",
    "representativeText": "Addressing the problems of closed research information must be a top priority.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c37",
      "osft-doc-0730/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c38",
    "representativeText": "Decisions should be informed by open research information.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c38",
      "osft-doc-0730/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c4",
    "representativeText": "Research performing and research funding organizations use research information to set strategic priorities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c4",
      "osft-doc-0730/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c40",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructures for open research information should be governed by relevant stakeholders in the academic community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c40",
      "osft-doc-0730/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c41",
    "representativeText": "Openness of research information ensures that all stakeholders have full access to information that is of relevance to them.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c41",
      "osft-doc-0730/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c43",
    "representativeText": "Openness of research information enables information from different sources to be linked and integrated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c43",
      "osft-doc-0730/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c46",
    "representativeText": "When researchers or research organizations perform additional data curation, the enriched information resulting from this can again be shared openly, enabling everyone to benefit from it.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c46",
      "osft-doc-0730/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c48",
    "representativeText": "The importance of openness of research information is widely recognized, including by the research assessment reform movement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c48",
      "osft-doc-0730/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c49",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles have played a crucial role in advancing the availability of open metadata for research data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c49",
      "osft-doc-0730/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c5",
    "representativeText": "Research information is indispensable for researchers and societal stakeholders to find and assess relevant research outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c5",
      "osft-doc-0730/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c50",
    "representativeText": "A growing number of infrastructures for open research information have adopted the Principles of Open Scholarly Infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c50",
      "osft-doc-0730/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c54",
    "representativeText": "A number of open research information infrastructures offer alternatives to closed databases.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c54",
      "osft-doc-0730/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c56",
    "representativeText": "More concerted action is needed to reach the tipping point in the transition from closed to open research information.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c56",
      "osft-doc-0730/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c60",
    "representativeText": "Research information includes metadata on research software, research data, samples, and instruments.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c60",
      "osft-doc-0730/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c61",
    "representativeText": "Research information includes information on funding and grants.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c61",
      "osft-doc-0730/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c62",
    "representativeText": "Research information includes information on organizations and research contributors.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c62",
      "osft-doc-0730/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c63",
    "representativeText": "Research information is located in systems such as bibliographic databases, software archives, data repositories, and current research information systems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c63",
      "osft-doc-0730/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c64",
    "representativeText": "Open research information refers to research information that is free to access.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c64",
      "osft-doc-0730/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c65",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c65",
    "representativeText": "Open research information refers to research information that is free of restrictions on reuse.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c65",
      "osft-doc-0730/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c66",
    "representativeText": "Openness of research information is a spectrum, not an absolute.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c66",
      "osft-doc-0730/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c69",
    "representativeText": "If the highest levels of Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reusability are realized, research information is both open and FAIR.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c69",
      "osft-doc-0730/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c72",
    "representativeText": "Achieving open and FAIR research information requires the application of a Creative Commons CC0 waiver or public domain dedication as appropriate to support Interoperability and Reusability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c72",
      "osft-doc-0730/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c73",
    "representativeText": "Achieving open and FAIR research information requires transparency of processing and provenance to support Interoperability and Reusability.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c73",
      "osft-doc-0730/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c75",
    "representativeText": "Research information that cannot be ethically shared, including information that has privacy implications, should not be made open.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c75",
      "osft-doc-0730/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c76",
    "representativeText": "Aggregated forms of privacy-implicating research information may be made open in some cases.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c76",
      "osft-doc-0730/c78"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c77",
    "representativeText": "Whether to make aggregated forms of privacy-implicating research information open should be assessed on a case-by-case basis in the context of relevant regulations and legal requirements.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c77",
      "osft-doc-0730/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c78",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c78",
    "representativeText": "Publishing refers to the act of making the outputs of research generally available for consumption, use, and critique.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c78",
      "osft-doc-0730/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c79",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c79",
    "representativeText": "Publishing includes the formal publication of textual outputs such as journal articles or scholarly books.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c79",
      "osft-doc-0730/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c8",
    "representativeText": "The research community has become strongly reliant on closed infrastructures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c8",
      "osft-doc-0730/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c80",
    "representativeText": "Publishing includes the posting of reports and other non-peer-reviewed outputs.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c80",
      "osft-doc-0730/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c82",
    "representativeText": "Publishing may also include the release of creative works, including sculpture, visual art, film or video, or other artifacts, where they are intended to represent or communicate the results of a research process.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c82",
      "osft-doc-0730/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c83",
    "representativeText": "Publishing includes cases where the audience is limited, for instance where access is limited to subscribers.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c83",
      "osft-doc-0730/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c84",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c84",
    "representativeText": "Publishing does not include private and confidential reports or other documents that are not intended for general circulation.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c84",
      "osft-doc-0730/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c85",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c85",
    "representativeText": "Publishing is separate from archival.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c85",
      "osft-doc-0730/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c87",
    "representativeText": "Some, but not all, publishing platforms also support archival through the publishing process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c87",
      "osft-doc-0730/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c88",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c88",
    "representativeText": "Scholarly infrastructures refers to infrastructures through which research information is shared.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c88",
      "osft-doc-0730/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c89",
    "representativeText": "A precise definition of infrastructures is challenging.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c89",
      "osft-doc-0730/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c9",
    "representativeText": "The research community has ended up assessing researchers and institutions based on non-transparent evidence.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c9",
      "osft-doc-0730/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c91",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructures are used by a diversity of actors for differing purposes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c91",
      "osft-doc-0730/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c92",
    "representativeText": "Other systems depend on infrastructures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c92",
      "osft-doc-0730/c93"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c95",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructures are scholarly infrastructures that provide trustworthy assurances of openness.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c95",
      "osft-doc-0730/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c96",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c96",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructures are scholarly infrastructures that provide trustworthy assurances of community accountability.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c96",
      "osft-doc-0730/c97"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c97",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructures are scholarly infrastructures that provide trustworthy assurances of stability.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c97",
      "osft-doc-0730/c98"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c98",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c98",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructures are scholarly infrastructures that provide trustworthy assurances of transparency.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c98",
      "osft-doc-0730/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c99",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c99",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructures are scholarly infrastructures that provide trustworthy assurances of reliability.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c99",
      "osft-doc-0730/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c156",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c156",
    "representativeText": "Other methods of evaluation, including article-level usage metrics, blog comments, discussion on mail lists, press quotes, and other forms of media, are becoming increasingly important reflections of scholarly and public impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c156",
      "osft-doc-0142/c636"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c175",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c175",
    "representativeText": "Research objects should support automatic extraction of information at varying granularities and its integration with third-party information.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c175",
      "osft-doc-0645/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c184",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c184",
    "representativeText": "Where possible, existing tools should be adapted and integrated within the new open infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c184",
      "open-science-source-22/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-22"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c190",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c190",
    "representativeText": "The changes needed in scholarly communication need to be quantified.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c190",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1014"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c208",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly community should be concerned with the creation of research objects as part of its daily research routines.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c208",
      "osft-doc-1459/c481"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c250",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c250",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly communications market is not a monolithic one.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c250",
      "osft-doc-1327/c539"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c254",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c254",
    "representativeText": "Free services pose sustainability risks.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c254",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1077"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c51",
    "representativeText": "For scientific domains, new forms of publication must facilitate reproducibility of results.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c51",
      "open-science-source-04/c78"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "open-science-source-06"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c57",
    "representativeText": "The peer-reviewed journal article uniquely provides a dated version of record of the authors' views at the time of publication, and as such becomes an immutable part of the scientific record.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c57",
      "osft-doc-0084/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-0084"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c69",
    "representativeText": "The business models currently driving scholarly publishing, which rest mainly on libraries buying access rights to digital journals from publishers, are no longer adequate to support the rich, variegated, integrated and disparate knowledge offerings that new technologies enable and that new scholarship requires.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c69",
      "open-science-source-10/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "open-science-source-10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-06/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-06/c94",
    "representativeText": "New media, new communicative possibilities, and the need to communicate and comprehend increasing amounts of numerical and multimedia data make traditional scholarly publication forms inadequate.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-06/c94",
      "osft-doc-1449/c203"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-06",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c11",
    "representativeText": "Supporting its community can include an infrastructure organisation advocating for policy changes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c11",
      "osft-doc-0860/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c14",
    "representativeText": "The commitments should include continued alignment with POSI and any legal or structural constraints.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c14",
      "osft-doc-0860/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c15",
    "representativeText": "Organisations and services should regularly review their relevance, effectiveness, and the level of community support to determine whether their continued operation is necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c15",
      "osft-doc-0860/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c16",
    "representativeText": "If no longer needed, organisations and services should take responsible steps to transition or wind down operations in consultation with the community and in alignment with their living will.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c16",
      "osft-doc-0860/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c26",
    "representativeText": "The actual level of reserves should be determined and periodically reviewed by the governing body, ensuring that resources are available to support Living Will implementation, including an orderly wind-down, transition to a successor, or response to major unforeseen events.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c26",
      "osft-doc-0860/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c27",
    "representativeText": "A financial reserve policy may include how funds will be held.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c27",
      "osft-doc-0860/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c28",
    "representativeText": "A financial reserve policy may include under what circumstances funds will be used.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c28",
      "osft-doc-0860/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c29",
    "representativeText": "A financial reserve policy may include how much would be necessary for an adequate wind-down or transfer of assets, given the complexity of the organisation's infrastructure.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c29",
      "osft-doc-0860/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c31",
    "representativeText": "Data related to the running of the scholarly infrastructure should be community property.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c31",
      "osft-doc-0860/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c42",
    "representativeText": "Organisations should have a clear policy outlining how private or sensitive data will be handled, particularly in the event of a transfer to another organisation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c42",
      "osft-doc-0860/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c43",
    "representativeText": "Content, data, and software must be practically obtainable, not merely nominally open.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c43",
      "osft-doc-0860/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c44",
    "representativeText": "Content, data, and software should be made easily available with clear public documentation about where they are and how to access them.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c44",
      "osft-doc-0860/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c46",
    "representativeText": "Content, data, and software must be deposited with at least one trusted third-party digital archive, in line with the Living Will.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c46",
      "osft-doc-0860/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c51",
    "representativeText": "Where relevant, organisations should document dependencies on standards.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c51",
      "osft-doc-0860/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-09/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-09/c9",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure organisations should not lobby for regulatory change to cement their own positions or narrow self-interest.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-09/c9",
      "osft-doc-0860/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c103",
    "representativeText": "Universities and research performing organisations should formally recognise editorial and peer-review contributions in hiring and promotion decisions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c103",
      "open-science-source-17/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-17"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c108",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c108",
    "representativeText": "The development and deployment of Artificial Intelligence in scholarly communication requires strong safeguards to protect the integrity and openness of the scholarly record.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c108",
      "open-science-source-43/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c149",
    "representativeText": "Lead Stakeholders should establish or strengthen national and regional coordination mechanisms with clear mandates, inclusive stakeholder participation, and sustainable resourcing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c149",
      "osft-doc-1283/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c167",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c167",
    "representativeText": "Research evaluation systems that privilege journal-based prestige metrics distort research priorities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c167",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-15-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c168",
    "representativeText": "Research evaluation systems that privilege journal-based prestige metrics disadvantage equitable and community governed publishing models.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c168",
      "osft-doc-1327/c688"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c17",
    "representativeText": "Diamond Open Access promotes inclusion.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c17",
      "open-science-source-11/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-11"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c185",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c185",
    "representativeText": "Public-interest infrastructure should be decentralised.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c185",
      "open-science-source-02/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "open-science-source-10"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c187",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c187",
    "representativeText": "Community-led infrastructure providers should strengthen open, community governed scholarly communication infrastructures by investing in interoperable, open-source publishing platforms that integrate repositories and preprint systems as core components.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c187",
      "open-science-source-43/c73"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c196",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c196",
    "representativeText": "Global standards, interoperability frameworks, and emerging technologies, including AI applications, should be designed as enabling, community governed systems that lower barriers to participation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c196",
      "osft-doc-1327/c310"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c3",
    "representativeText": "Diamond Open Access is a community governed model.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c3",
      "open-science-source-11/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-11"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c50",
    "representativeText": "Governments should build a shared evidence base to inform policy and demonstrate the societal value of open knowledge.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c50",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c59",
    "representativeText": "Diamond Open Access is sustained not only by platforms and repositories, but by people.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c59",
      "open-science-source-11/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-11"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-10/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-10/c61",
    "representativeText": "The contributions of editorial teams, reviewers, technical staff, metadata specialists, repository managers, and community co-ordinators deserve structured recognition and support.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-10/c61",
      "osft-doc-1869/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-11/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-11/c5",
    "representativeText": "Diamond Open Access is community-owned.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-11/c5",
      "open-science-source-10/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-11"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c12",
    "representativeText": "Open data is essential to accelerating discovery.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c12",
      "osft-doc-1195/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1195"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c14",
    "representativeText": "Open data has become more widespread over the past decade.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c14",
      "osft-doc-1412/c165"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c16",
    "representativeText": "Research is often fragmented, with data in one place, methods in another, and code somewhere else.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c16",
      "osft-doc-0138/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-0138"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c17",
    "representativeText": "Attitudes towards data sharing are improving.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c17",
      "osft-doc-1412/c208"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c217",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c217",
    "representativeText": "Policy must be paired with the day-to-day support and infrastructure that make sharing practical and reusable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c217",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c153"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-54-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c39",
    "representativeText": "Significant challenges to sharing open data remain.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c39",
      "osft-doc-1412/c207"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c72",
    "representativeText": "Regional approaches that account for local research cultures and infrastructures could work better than one-size-fits-all data mandate strategies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c72",
      "open-science-source-38/c110"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-12/c99",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-12/c99",
    "representativeText": "Evidence of the value of open data can drive cultural change by helping embed open science into research assessment and reward systems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-12/c99",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-12",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-13/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-13/c4",
    "representativeText": "In some parts of the world, impact factors are still the dominant way in which researchers are evaluated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-13/c4",
      "osft-doc-1449/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-13",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-14-c1/c312",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-14-c1/c312",
    "representativeText": "Community resource projects are specifically devised and implemented to create a set of data, reagents, or other material whose primary utility will be as a resource for the broad scientific community.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-14-c1/c312",
      "open-science-source-14-c2/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-14-c1",
      "open-science-source-14-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-14-c2/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-14-c2/c4",
    "representativeText": "Rapid release of sequence data should continue.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-14-c2/c4",
      "open-science-source-14-c3/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-14-c2",
      "open-science-source-14-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c15",
    "representativeText": "Research data and other research outputs should be made as open as possible and as closed as necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c15",
      "open-science-source-21/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-21"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c4",
    "representativeText": "Where applicable, Open Access publication fees should be covered by the Funders or research institutions, not by individual researchers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c4",
      "open-science-source-36/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c50",
    "representativeText": "Prices for publishing services should be fair and reasonable and reflect the publishing costs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c50",
      "open-science-source-43/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c58",
    "representativeText": "For cOAlition S funded research covered by Plan S requirements, all peer-reviewed scholarly articles must be published in venues that fulfil the requirements set out for publication venues.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c58",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-15-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c61",
    "representativeText": "Details of the review system must be openly available on the respective journal and platform websites.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c61",
      "osft-doc-1213/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c65",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c65",
    "representativeText": "The journal/platform must accept the retention of copyright by the authors or their institutions, at no extra cost.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c65",
      "osft-doc-1213/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c1/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c1/c77",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should directly deposit publications, in a machine-readable community standard format with complete metadata, into author-designated or centralised Open Access repositories that fulfil the Plan S criteria.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c77",
      "osft-doc-1213/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c110",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c110",
    "representativeText": "Stakeholders are increasingly advocating for openness throughout the entire research process, including access to preprints, protocols, research data, research software, code, and peer review reports.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c110",
      "osft-doc-1449/c215"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c145",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c145",
    "representativeText": "Truly open resources support creatively reshaping and enriching data because they can be used without restrictions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c145",
      "osft-doc-1373/c328"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c16",
    "representativeText": "Funders need to shift their spending towards more responsible practices and open infrastructures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c16",
      "open-science-source-18/c749"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c50",
    "representativeText": "The rights retention strategy has gained particular traction, with numerous institutions adopting and expanding upon it through their own Rights Retention Policies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c50",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-15-c2/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-15-c2/c56",
    "representativeText": "cOAlition S organisations may advance preprint posting through supportive policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c56",
      "open-science-source-18/c754"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-18"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c10",
    "representativeText": "Publication of new macromolecular structures in most scientific journals is contingent on mandatory deposition to the PDB of the 3D atomic coordinates comprising the structural model plus experimental data and associated metadata.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c10",
      "open-science-source-41/c176"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-41"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c106",
    "representativeText": "PDB data are made available from all wwPDB partner sites via FTP.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c106",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c125",
    "representativeText": "Launch of the OneDep system has enabled, for the first time, large-scale remediation to improve data consistency across all entries in the PDB Core Archive.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c125",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c130",
    "representativeText": "The enduring value of the PDB Core Archive to its User community depends critically on data accuracy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c130",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c146"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c143",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c143",
    "representativeText": "The wwPDB validation report is updated annually to incorporate software updates, new validation processes, and updated archive-wide validation statistics from PDB entries deposited in the previous year.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c143",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c159",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c159",
    "representativeText": "The PDBx/mmCIF data dictionary must be frequently extended to support expanded collection of metadata for rapidly evolving experimental methods such as SFX/XFEL and 3DEM.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c159",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c165",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c165",
    "representativeText": "The PDBx/mmCIF data dictionary contains data items that provide links between individual 3D structures and related data stored by other specialist data resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c165",
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c2",
    "representativeText": "The PDB Core Archive houses 3D atomic coordinates of structural models of proteins, DNA/RNA, and their complexes with metals and small molecules.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c2",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c40",
    "representativeText": "Data on the type of structure determination experiment performed are archived.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c40",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c54",
    "representativeText": "Deposition of experimental data/metadata together with atomic coordinate data is required for all incoming PDB structures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c54",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c61",
    "representativeText": "Experimental data/metadata accompanying MX, NMR and 3DEM structures are processed using the universal OneDep system for deposition/validation/biocuration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c61",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c63",
    "representativeText": "Significant advances in structure determination techniques over the last decade have resulted in an increase in the size and complexity of macromolecular structures studied by structural biologists.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c63",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c153"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c1/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c1/c97",
    "representativeText": "An increasing number of scientific journals require wwPDB validation reports to be included at the time of manuscript submission.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c97",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c3/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c3/c18",
    "representativeText": "The PDB archive manages 'Big Data' as a global public good.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c18",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c3/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c3/c24",
    "representativeText": "PDB data impacts patent applications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c24",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c134"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c3/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c3/c27",
    "representativeText": "PDB-101 materials illustrate how PDB data help explain fundamental biology, biomedicine, energy sciences, and biotechnology.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c27",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c3/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c3/c3",
    "representativeText": "The Protein Data Bank was established as the first open access digital data resource in all of biology and medicine.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c3/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c3/c34",
    "representativeText": "Each structure deposited to the PDB is standardized using controlled vocabularies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3/c34",
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c3",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c4/c144",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c4/c144",
    "representativeText": "The PDB is a primary data archive central to biomedicine worldwide, on par with the International Nucleotide Sequence Database Collaboration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c144",
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-16-c4/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-16-c4/c57",
    "representativeText": "An official wwPDB Validation Report is produced for every new PDB structure when the Data Depositor finalizes the entry for public release.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-16-c4/c57",
      "open-science-source-16-c1/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-16-c1",
      "open-science-source-16-c4"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-17/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-17/c102",
    "representativeText": "Predatory journals are the ratings-inflation equilibrium of scientific publishing's issuer-pays structure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-17/c102",
      "open-science-source-36/c183"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-17",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-17/c143",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-17/c143",
    "representativeText": "eLife's publish-review-curate model publishes editorial assessments alongside papers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-17/c143",
      "open-science-source-33/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-17",
      "open-science-source-33"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c105",
    "representativeText": "Uncertainties around the future of peer review have begun to build up, associated with the rise of artificial intelligence.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c105",
      "open-science-source-46/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-46"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c144",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c144",
    "representativeText": "Peer review is organised in the domain of assessment of research units.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c144",
      "osft-doc-0142/c750"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c17",
    "representativeText": "Peer review burden should be minimised where possible.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c17",
      "open-science-source-36/c209"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c220",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c220",
    "representativeText": "Peer review follows a series of fairly well-known steps common to the different domains.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c220",
      "open-science-source-36/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c334",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c334",
    "representativeText": "It is unclear how peer review can work effectively in evaluating a broad notion of research quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c334",
      "osft-doc-0142/c813"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c34",
    "representativeText": "The challenges facing peer review may, as a result, undermine trust in science more generally.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c34",
      "open-science-source-43/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c347",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c347",
    "representativeText": "Application influx to research funding is increasing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c347",
      "open-science-source-46/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-46"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c352",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c352",
    "representativeText": "The opportunities offered by AI will likely lead to further growth in application volumes for research funding.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c352",
      "open-science-source-46/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-46"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c355",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c355",
    "representativeText": "Response rates to peer review requests are becoming a growing problem.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c355",
      "open-science-source-47/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-47"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c420",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c420",
    "representativeText": "Anonymous reviewers may misuse their power by blocking work that they consider to be in competition with their own.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c420",
      "osft-doc-0142/c770"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c437",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c437",
    "representativeText": "Peer review is unreliable in terms of interrater consistency, meaning that different reviewers tend to produce different judgements on proposals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c437",
      "osft-doc-0142/c764"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c452",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c452",
    "representativeText": "What is perceived as arbitrary in peer review may sometimes be a reflection of legitimate differences in perspective between reviewers, for example resulting from their different disciplinary backgrounds.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c452",
      "osft-doc-0142/c647"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c467",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c467",
    "representativeText": "Peer review does a poor job in spotting scientific fraud, for example manufactured and manipulated data or papers produced by paper mills or AI tools.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c467",
      "osft-doc-0142/c772"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c47",
    "representativeText": "Research funders rely heavily on peer review to decide which project proposals to fund.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c47",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c486",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c486",
    "representativeText": "There is a pressing need for further evidence on AI use in research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c486",
      "open-science-source-42/c894"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c515",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c515",
    "representativeText": "Research funders, scholarly publishers and other stakeholders should keep investing in the implementation of peer review innovations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c515",
      "osft-doc-1327/c204"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c519",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c519",
    "representativeText": "There is a strong expectation of 21st-century science to contribute to addressing major societal challenges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c519",
      "open-science-source-45/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c632",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c632",
    "representativeText": "In the proposed model, funding becomes a function of collective success, measured in whichever way is most appropriate in context, rather than of individual 'superstar' academics' grant-winning abilities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c632",
      "osft-doc-1869/c163"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c682",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c682",
    "representativeText": "As the peer review capacity problem intensifies, there is a growing risk that many outputs published in scientific journals and other publication channels may provide unreliable information.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c682",
      "open-science-source-41/c298"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-41"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c700",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c700",
    "representativeText": "Instead of relying on a uniform model of peer review, publication infrastructures need to facilitate diverse ways in which researchers can engage with each other's research outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c700",
      "osft-doc-1327/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c761",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c761",
    "representativeText": "The transition to a more strategic approach to funding allocation at the level of research institutions rather than individual researchers or research teams requires institutions to enhance their strategic profile.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c761",
      "osft-doc-0142/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-18/c788",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-18/c788",
    "representativeText": "The proposed layered approaches to quality assurance will increase trust in science more generally.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-18/c788",
      "open-science-source-43/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c17",
    "representativeText": "The data needed to verify or reproduce the results of published articles is often unavailable.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c17",
      "osft-doc-1353/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c19",
    "representativeText": "Trust in scientific research is of particular importance at the present time.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c19",
      "open-science-source-42/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c31",
    "representativeText": "Data should be made available under an open license or as part of the worldwide public domain, specifically a CC0 license.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c31",
      "osft-doc-0756/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "osft-doc-0756"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c33",
    "representativeText": "NIH's PubMed Central is a robust, cost-effective option for making federally funded research articles publicly available.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c33",
      "open-science-source-23/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-23"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c42",
    "representativeText": "Library subscription revenue plays a significant role in supporting the overall operations of many scholarly societies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c42",
      "open-science-source-36/c166"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c47",
    "representativeText": "Governments around the world are making open the default for their publicly funded research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c47",
      "osft-doc-1459/c572"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-19/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-19/c62",
    "representativeText": "A repository-based policy can be realized in a cost-effective manner.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-19/c62",
      "open-science-source-20/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-19",
      "open-science-source-20"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c6",
    "representativeText": "The cost of subscribing to resources continues to outpace library budgets.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c6",
      "osft-doc-1327/c829"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-20",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-20/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-20/c9",
    "representativeText": "Authors can flourish when their research data and works are made freely available for others.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-20/c9",
      "osft-doc-1449/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-20",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c110",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c110",
    "representativeText": "Funder acknowledgments can be inconsistent, with funder names incomplete or missing, or specific grant numbers lacking.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c110",
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-54-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c47",
    "representativeText": "The perspectives and autonomy of underrepresented groups who may be providing data must be taken into account.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c47",
      "osft-doc-1612/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c48",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance emphasize Collective Benefit, Authority to Control, Responsibility, and Ethics in sharing Indigenous data and knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c48",
      "open-science-source-30/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c95",
    "representativeText": "Federal agencies have an opportunity to align with academic institutions, private funders, and other stakeholders to be one of the mutually reinforcing vectors pointing toward openness.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c95",
      "osft-doc-0633/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0633"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-22/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-22/c11",
    "representativeText": "Preprints support rigor by allowing broad engagement in public commenting and peer review.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-22/c11",
      "osft-doc-1353/c157"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-22/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-22/c17",
    "representativeText": "Preprints are free to post.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-22/c17",
      "open-science-source-28/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "open-science-source-28"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-22/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-22/c31",
    "representativeText": "NIH may make preprints more discoverable by extending the NLM preprint pilot to all preprints, not just those that are NIH-funded.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-22/c31",
      "open-science-source-23/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "open-science-source-23"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-22/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-22/c32",
    "representativeText": "An increasing number of preprints are being reviewed outside of journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-22/c32",
      "open-science-source-23/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-22",
      "open-science-source-23"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-23/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-23/c37",
    "representativeText": "Requiring deposit of Author Accepted Manuscripts allows maximum grant funds to support research activities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-23/c37",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-23",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c11",
    "representativeText": "Enhancing access to research outputs increases public awareness of the Department's work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c11",
      "open-science-source-36/c173"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c21",
    "representativeText": "The reuse rights granted by an open license remove restrictions on adaptations, better enabling the use of computer screen readers and other assistive technologies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c21",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c30",
    "representativeText": "Repositories are a critical component of national research infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c30",
      "osft-doc-1213/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c47",
    "representativeText": "Federal agencies and departments should deliberately build capacity for robust equity assessment for policymaking and program implementation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c47",
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c6"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c73",
    "representativeText": "Sharing code and software associated with research data openly provides users with the necessary tools to analyze the data, increasing its value to the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c73",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c83",
    "representativeText": "Digital object identifiers and ORCIDs are each nonproprietary community standards for their identifier type.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c83",
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c1/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c1/c86",
    "representativeText": "PIDs have growing centrality in research infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1/c86",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c1",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c102",
    "representativeText": "Agencies should instruct agency-designated repositories to check submissions for compliance with the agency template.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c102",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c103",
    "representativeText": "When policy-covered submissions do not contain the language specified in the template, repositories should add the language before the works are made public.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c103",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c104",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c104",
    "representativeText": "Agencies may instruct repositories to add template language Option 1 or Option 2, at their discretion.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c104",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c105",
    "representativeText": "Most university IP policies allocate copyright ownership in works of scholarship to individual creators, not the university.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c105",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c31",
    "representativeText": "Data underlying publications should be shared no later than the time of publication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c31",
      "osft-doc-1449/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c57",
    "representativeText": "The Open Source Initiative maintains a number of approved licenses that meet the terms of allowing free access, modification, and reuse.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c57",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c59",
    "representativeText": "Metadata standards in data management plans are important to facilitate alignment with the FAIR Data Principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c59",
      "osft-doc-0298/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "osft-doc-0298"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c82",
    "representativeText": "The scope of the additional license directly correlates to the agency's public access obligation under the 2022 OSTP Memorandum.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c82",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c83",
    "representativeText": "Information about the additional license must be communicated to the public with any copy of the scholarly publication made publicly accessible to comply with the agency's public access policy.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c83",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c85",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c85",
    "representativeText": "The template's contents may include information about the copyright license.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c85",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c86",
    "representativeText": "The template's contents may include the funding agreement number.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c86",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c87",
    "representativeText": "The template's contents may include the author's ORCID ID.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c87",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c2/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c2/c89",
    "representativeText": "The template may alternatively be attached by the repository manager or a publisher when the publisher agrees to deposit public access copies in an agency-designated repository.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2/c89",
      "open-science-source-24-c3/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c2",
      "open-science-source-24-c3"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c4/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c4/c45",
    "representativeText": "NASA should identify and adopt non-proprietary community standards, such as ROR IDs and ORCIDs, when considering the use of PIDs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c45",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c4/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c4/c5",
    "representativeText": "NASA's plan should be updated to further clarify the compliance paths available to researchers and how they interact.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c5",
      "open-science-source-36/c313"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c34",
    "representativeText": "Libraries play an important role in educating faculty and students about campus data resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c34",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c35",
    "representativeText": "Complying with the data requirement presents challenges, particularly around costs and the implementation of new campus workflows and policies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c35",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c5/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c5/c37",
    "representativeText": "NIH's GREI initiative aims to establish shared infrastructure and practices among generalist repositories in NIH's data ecosystem.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c37",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c6/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c6/c16",
    "representativeText": "Publications and underlying data should be made available in machine-readable formats.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6/c16",
      "osft-doc-1327/c119"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c6",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c11",
    "representativeText": "The NASA TOPS initiative has developed an Open Science 101 Curriculum that anyone can use to improve their understanding of open science workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c11",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c12",
    "representativeText": "The NASA TOPS initiative has developed an Open Science 101 Curriculum that anyone can use to gain the skills needed to share their research effectively.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c12",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c13",
    "representativeText": "The Open Science 101 Curriculum draws from existing best practices from academia, industry, and other stakeholder communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c13",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c14",
    "representativeText": "The Open Science 101 Curriculum is a valuable resource for intramural and extramural researchers and federal government staff working on research sharing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c14",
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c8"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c20",
    "representativeText": "Costs related to data sharing and management are also a challenge facing institutions and authors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c20",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c7/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c7/c21",
    "representativeText": "The costs associated with data vary significantly based on type and discipline.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7/c21",
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c7",
      "open-science-source-54-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c15",
    "representativeText": "The desirable characteristics for publication repositories should be consulted by the agency as it determines what repositories researchers can use for compliance.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c15",
      "open-science-source-34/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-34"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c51",
    "representativeText": "Full public reuse of a publication allows others to perform text and data mining.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c51",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c8/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c8/c52",
    "representativeText": "Full public reuse of a publication allows others to deploy AI and other computational technology on it.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8/c52",
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c8",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-24-c9/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-24-c9/c25",
    "representativeText": "NIJ should require that grantees provide an additional license to NIJ that specifically provides the right to grant the public reuse rights to agency publications covered by the public access policy.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-24-c9/c25",
      "open-science-source-24-c4/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c4",
      "open-science-source-24-c9"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c1",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship is the idea that, to advance knowledge, research results of all kinds should be openly shared as early as is practical.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c1",
      "osft-doc-1459/c332"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c14",
    "representativeText": "Foundations increasingly require grantees to share research data and other research products.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c14",
      "osft-doc-1353/c178"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c39",
    "representativeText": "Universities must evaluate how to support alternative publishing business models in a manner that promotes openness, equity, trust, and sustainability in scholarly research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c39",
      "osft-doc-1449/c199"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-25/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-25/c43",
    "representativeText": "Universities need strategies for financing storage, curation and access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-25/c43",
      "osft-doc-1449/c240"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c10",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles comprise Responsibility.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c10",
      "osft-doc-1027/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c100",
    "representativeText": "The claiming of rights to own, control, access, and possess information about their peoples is fundamentally tied to the preservation and development of First Nations culture.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c100",
      "osft-doc-1027/c109"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c105",
    "representativeText": "The use of Indigenous data in hybrid datasets requires machine-readable provenance for Indigenous data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c105",
      "osft-doc-1027/c112"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c106",
    "representativeText": "The use of Indigenous data in hybrid datasets requires signaling the decision-making point that needs to be approached to allow or refuse consent to use the data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c106",
      "osft-doc-1027/c113"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c107",
    "representativeText": "For Indigenous collections, Indigenous researchers and communities may try out the FAIR Data Maturity Model criteria.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c107",
      "osft-doc-1027/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c108",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c108",
    "representativeText": "In hybrid datasets there is a need to engage with Indigenous researchers and communities to co-produce policies and practices that rectify the unFAIRness of existing data and ensure the FAIRness of newly created or deposited data aligns with the CARE Principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c108",
      "osft-doc-1027/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c11",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles comprise Ethics.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c11",
      "osft-doc-1027/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c111",
    "representativeText": "Full adoption of the CARE Principles may be impeded while implementation criteria are created.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c111",
      "osft-doc-1027/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c112",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c112",
    "representativeText": "Practicing CARE in data collection requires defining cultural metadata and recording provenance.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c112",
      "osft-doc-1027/c119"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c113",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c113",
    "representativeText": "Engaging CARE in data stewardship necessitates using appropriate governance models.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c113",
      "osft-doc-1027/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c115",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c115",
    "representativeText": "It is less clear how to implement CARE in the data community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c115",
      "osft-doc-1027/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c119",
    "representativeText": "Exclusion of Indigenous data essentially erases Indigenous Peoples and interests from data-related futures due to the perceived additional work caused by uncertainty.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c119",
      "osft-doc-1027/c125"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c122",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c122",
    "representativeText": "The solution should be simple and deliverable even in an automated machine-readable environment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c122",
      "osft-doc-1027/c126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c125",
    "representativeText": "Similar work could be done for CARE to achieve consensus and agreement on practical implementation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c125",
      "osft-doc-1027/c128"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c126",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c126",
    "representativeText": "The working method and experience of the FAIR Data Maturity Model Working Group could support GIDA and the International Indigenous Data Sovereignty Interest Group in developing the CARE criteria with broad community input.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c126",
      "osft-doc-1027/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c128",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c128",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles are the first attempt to outline collective rights as part of openness.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c128",
      "osft-doc-1027/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c129",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c129",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles should not yet be co-opted into other spaces.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c129",
      "osft-doc-1027/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c130",
    "representativeText": "The full criteria for implementation of the CARE Principles have not yet been determined and used.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c130",
      "osft-doc-1027/c133"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c131",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c131",
    "representativeText": "Space must be left for the design and maturity of the CARE Principles to occur within the Indigenous environments from which they originate.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c131",
      "osft-doc-1027/c134"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c133",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c133",
    "representativeText": "This could be aligned to FAIR if the decision point described in the first point can be identified and approached in an automated, machine-actionable way.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c133",
      "osft-doc-1027/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c136",
    "representativeText": "Assessing the FAIR-ness of a data set is typically a technical exercise that can be done independently by the researcher to prepare the final data set for reuse.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c136",
      "osft-doc-1027/c139"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c137",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c137",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles require engagement with people to address the cultural, ethical, legal, and social dimensions associated with the intended uses of the dataset.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c137",
      "osft-doc-1027/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c138",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c138",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous communities expect CARE-full data practices to be enacted at each step of the data lifecycle.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c138",
      "osft-doc-1027/c141"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c139",
    "representativeText": "A broader temporal dimension must be reflected in the application of the CARE Principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c139",
      "osft-doc-1027/c142"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c140",
    "representativeText": "At present there is no process to assess whether a research project meets the CARE Principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c140",
      "osft-doc-1027/c143"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c141",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c141",
    "representativeText": "Creating an assessment of whether a research project meets the CARE Principles represents the next stage towards an equitable cyberinfrastructure that supports the FAIR and CARE-full use of Indigenous data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c141",
      "osft-doc-1027/c144"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c24",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles promote equitable participation and outcomes from data access, use, reuse, and attribution in contemporary data landscapes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c24",
      "osft-doc-1027/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c29",
    "representativeText": "Implementation of the CARE Principles as a required dimension of open and FAIR data must ensure that data use is purposeful.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c29",
      "osft-doc-1027/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c3",
    "representativeText": "Operationalizing the FAIR Principles for scientific data with the CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance enhances machine actionability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c3",
      "osft-doc-1027/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c31",
    "representativeText": "Diversity in FAIR assessment methods is a benefit to communities trying to implement the FAIR criteria.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c31",
      "osft-doc-1027/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c32",
    "representativeText": "Diversity in FAIR assessment methods is a challenge due to the inability to easily compare outcomes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c32",
      "osft-doc-1027/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c33",
    "representativeText": "Similar methods could be used to develop a framework for the CARE Principles in an equivalent 18-month timeframe using the RDA community and platform as host.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c33",
      "osft-doc-1027/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c34",
    "representativeText": "The development of a maturity model framework for CARE could be accelerated to completion in as little as 4 years from the inception of the CARE Principles if all efficiencies were in place.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c34",
      "osft-doc-1027/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c35",
    "representativeText": "There is a paradox of scarcity and abundance for Indigenous data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c35",
      "osft-doc-1027/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c38",
    "representativeText": "Data can be subject to both the CARE and FAIR Principles and produce different outcomes depending on how implementation criteria have been operationalized within cyber infrastructures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c38",
      "osft-doc-1027/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c40",
    "representativeText": "A range of datasets are working towards being FAIR, though many have not taken active steps toward adopting mechanisms that support CARE.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c40",
      "osft-doc-1027/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c42",
    "representativeText": "Earth and space science research data is highly relevant to Indigenous communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c42",
      "osft-doc-1027/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c44",
    "representativeText": "Data that are well documented through compliance with FAIR criteria are easier to manage when implementing the CARE Principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c44",
      "osft-doc-1027/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c45",
    "representativeText": "Tribal databases and Indigenous Content Management Systems hold tribal data using protocols consistent with tribal values and worldviews, thus employing CARE.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c45",
      "osft-doc-1027/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c46",
    "representativeText": "These collections are generally not consistent with FAIR principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c46",
      "osft-doc-1027/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c47",
    "representativeText": "These collections require enriched metadata and protocols to be consistent with FAIR principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c47",
      "osft-doc-1027/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c53",
    "representativeText": "These factors continue to affect how ethical and socially responsible data use can occur within the sciences, particularly as machine learning approaches accelerate data re-use.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c53",
      "osft-doc-1027/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c55",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous communities face a number of challenges in facilitating the culturally appropriate reuse of scientific data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c55",
      "osft-doc-1027/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c56",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles should not be thought of as only applying to Indigenous Knowledge or Traditional Knowledge but also to scientific data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c56",
      "osft-doc-1027/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c59",
    "representativeText": "In many cases scientific datasets also contain Indigenous Knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c59",
      "osft-doc-1027/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c60",
    "representativeText": "Users and producers of such data, both in the past and currently, often do not realize the need to acknowledge Indigenous provenance or make space for cultural metadata when creating this data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c60",
      "osft-doc-1027/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c62",
    "representativeText": "The TK Labels are digital tags that restore relationships between Indigenous and non-Indigenous rights holders by correcting and providing more information about cultural material collected.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c62",
      "osft-doc-1027/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c63",
    "representativeText": "The TK Labels improve the quality of provenance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c63",
      "osft-doc-1027/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c64",
    "representativeText": "The TK Labels encourage communities to enrich records with their own traditional knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c64",
      "osft-doc-1027/c73"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c69",
    "representativeText": "The TK Labels are an example of a tool that supports implementation of both the FAIR and CARE Principles by enabling local authority and reflecting community protocols.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c69",
      "osft-doc-1027/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c70",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles and tools like the TK Labels have important implications for international policy frameworks such as the Convention on Biological Diversity and the Nagoya Protocol.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c70",
      "osft-doc-1027/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c71",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c71",
    "representativeText": "The Nagoya Protocol supports fair and equitable benefit sharing for genetic resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c71",
      "osft-doc-1027/c78"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c72",
    "representativeText": "The Nagoya Protocol currently excludes digital sequence information, in part due to the practicalities of tracking provenance and secondary use of datasets.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c72",
      "osft-doc-1027/c79"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c73",
    "representativeText": "Open genomic data supports innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c73",
      "osft-doc-1027/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c74",
    "representativeText": "Open genomic data enables the appropriation of value.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c74",
      "osft-doc-1027/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c75",
    "representativeText": "Open genomic data increases inequities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c75",
      "osft-doc-1027/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c76",
    "representativeText": "Implementation of CARE and application of TK Labels to genomic databases or metadata databases will illustrate the value that this work can contribute toward delivering on the promise of fair and equitable benefit sharing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c76",
      "osft-doc-1027/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c77",
    "representativeText": "There has been broadening interest in applying the CARE Principles outside the realm of Indigenous Peoples.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c77",
      "osft-doc-1027/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c79",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c79",
    "representativeText": "RDA provides a platform for research communities, including small, technical, or sporadic ones.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c79",
      "osft-doc-1027/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c8",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles comprise Collective benefit.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c8",
      "osft-doc-1027/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c80",
    "representativeText": "Researchers can participate in discussions at a global level from their local research environment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c80",
      "osft-doc-1027/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c82",
    "representativeText": "The International Indigenous Data Sovereignty Interest Group created the CARE Principles and now seeks to identify policy and practice to implement the principles across data ecosystems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c82",
      "open-science-source-30/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c83",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles are a new, game-changing perspective that stimulates researchers across domains and regions to articulate community data rights.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c83",
      "osft-doc-1027/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c86",
    "representativeText": "Openness is a legal term connected to the rights of the data concerned.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c86",
      "osft-doc-1027/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c87",
    "representativeText": "Some data rights, such as ownership, are well known and regulated, while others are less regulated and more controversial.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c87",
      "osft-doc-1027/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c88",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c88",
    "representativeText": "The role of personal data rights is clear and legislated in most countries, but due to cultural and legislative differences across regions and countries there are no consistent rights.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c88",
      "osft-doc-1027/c97"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c89",
    "representativeText": "Both open and non-open datasets can be FAIR.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c89",
      "osft-doc-1027/c98"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c9",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles comprise Authority to control.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c9",
      "osft-doc-1027/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c92",
    "representativeText": "The OCAP principles comprise ownership.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c92",
      "osft-doc-1027/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c93",
    "representativeText": "The OCAP principles comprise control.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c93",
      "osft-doc-1027/c103"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c94",
    "representativeText": "The OCAP principles comprise access.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c94",
      "osft-doc-1027/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c95",
    "representativeText": "The OCAP principles comprise possession.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c95",
      "osft-doc-1027/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c97",
    "representativeText": "OCAP enabled First Nations to assert control over data collection processes in their communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c97",
      "osft-doc-1027/c106"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-26/c99",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-26/c99",
    "representativeText": "The claiming of rights to own, control, access, and possess information about their peoples is fundamentally tied to First Nations self-determination.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-26/c99",
      "osft-doc-1027/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-28/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-28/c1",
    "representativeText": "A preprint is a version of a manuscript hosted on a public server prior to formal peer review.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-28/c1",
      "open-science-source-36/c373"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-28",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-28/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-28/c20",
    "representativeText": "The Data Availability Statement should instead include the applicable details where the underlying data can be found.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-28/c20",
      "osft-doc-0963/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-28",
      "osft-doc-0963"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-28/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-28/c25",
    "representativeText": "Grantees should not use their foundation grant budget to pay publishing fees.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-28/c25",
      "open-science-source-29/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-28",
      "open-science-source-29"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c107",
    "representativeText": "The CARE Principles would add an important layer of relational and temporal governance for Indigenous collections within an open access logic.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c107",
      "open-science-source-38/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c137",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c137",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Principles are a precursor to good data management and stewardship practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c137",
      "osft-doc-0645/c124"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c140",
    "representativeText": "Existing principles within the open data movement, such as FAIR, primarily focus on characteristics of data that facilitate increased data sharing among entities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c140",
      "open-science-source-26/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "open-science-source-30"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c172",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c172",
    "representativeText": "Data enable better engagement between citizens, institutions, and governments to improve decision-making.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c172",
      "osft-doc-0748/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-0748"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c41",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous Peoples' data include data generated by Indigenous Peoples, as well as by governments and other institutions, on and about Indigenous Peoples and territories.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c41",
      "osft-doc-1027/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c44",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous Peoples' data comprise information about Indigenous persons such as administrative, census, health, social, commercial, and corporate information.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c44",
      "osft-doc-1027/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-30/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-30/c45",
    "representativeText": "Indigenous Peoples' data comprise information and knowledge about Indigenous Peoples as collectives, including traditional and cultural information, oral histories, ancestral and clan knowledge, cultural sites, stories, and belongings.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-30/c45",
      "osft-doc-1027/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-30",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-31/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-31/c54",
    "representativeText": "A more just open scholarly communications system must aspire toward epistemic justice, particularly for those suffering under unjust sociopolitical and economic structures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-31/c54",
      "osft-doc-1593/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-31",
      "osft-doc-1593"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-33/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-33/c18",
    "representativeText": "Funders and institutions are increasingly moving away from using single metrics to assess research(ers).",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-33/c18",
      "osft-doc-1449/c337"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-33",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c48",
    "representativeText": "Federal agencies should allow researchers to include reasonable publication costs and costs associated with submission, curation, management of data, and special handling instructions as allowable expenses in all research budgets.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c48",
      "open-science-source-36/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-34/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-34/c7",
    "representativeText": "The primary limitation of the 2013 Memorandum is the optional 12-month embargo from public access of any publication resulting from federally funded research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-34/c7",
      "open-science-source-36/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-34",
      "open-science-source-36"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c114",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c114",
    "representativeText": "OSTP's 2022 guidance no longer allows an embargo period.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c114",
      "osft-doc-0534/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0534"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c123",
    "representativeText": "Publishers will not offer researchers an option for their publications to be deposited in repositories at the time of publication unless the researcher pays a publication charge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c123",
      "osft-doc-0534/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-0534"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c146",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly publishing industry is difficult to predict.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c146",
      "osft-doc-1327/c901"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c164",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c164",
    "representativeText": "Research institutions that publish greater than average volumes of research will have to bear much of the cost of publication under pay-to-publish models.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c164",
      "osft-doc-1449/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c175",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c175",
    "representativeText": "Public access leads to faster corrections and retractions because it allows more researchers to view and identify research integrity issues.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c175",
      "osft-doc-1449/c403"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c181",
    "representativeText": "Research quality varies from journal to journal for a range of reasons regardless of public access or open access status.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c181",
      "osft-doc-1327/c930"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c186",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c186",
    "representativeText": "Paper mills fabricate scholarly publications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c186",
      "open-science-source-43/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c188",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c188",
    "representativeText": "Paper mills bribe journal editors to accept manuscripts for publication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c188",
      "open-science-source-43/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c190",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c190",
    "representativeText": "Some researchers find paper mills attractive because they face pressure to publish a high quantity of scholarly publications to advance in their careers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c190",
      "open-science-source-43/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c197",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c197",
    "representativeText": "Some publishers may charge to make a scholarly publication open access and mislead researchers into believing that the publishers conduct high-quality peer review without doing so.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c197",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-36/c292",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-36/c292",
    "representativeText": "Further analysis, such as on whether spending on publication charges is expected to increase, decrease, or stay the same, should be provided by OSTP to better inform agencies as they begin to implement their public access policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-36/c292",
      "osft-doc-1327/c708"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-36",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c10",
    "representativeText": "Recipients of Open Science NL funding must comply with the NWO Open Access Policy.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c10",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c106",
    "representativeText": "Open science infrastructure fosters transparency within and outside of the scientific community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c106",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c120",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c120",
    "representativeText": "The terms reproducible and replicable can be interpreted differently between disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c120",
      "osft-doc-0150/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c135",
    "representativeText": "Funding is mainly allocated to the creation of new tools.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c135",
      "open-science-source-38/c313"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c136",
    "representativeText": "A replication study is a study that tries to repeat an earlier study, using similar methods to collect, process and analyse new data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c136",
      "open-science-source-39/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-39"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c159",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c159",
    "representativeText": "An inclusive evidence base for open science is essential for validating the progress, impact and effectiveness of open science practices and initiatives.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c159",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c189",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c189",
    "representativeText": "Monitoring and evaluation promote transparency in the implementation of open science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c189",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c153"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c191",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c191",
    "representativeText": "Open science monitoring initiatives are being undertaken in many countries, including Ireland and France, and at the European level by the EOSC Association.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c191",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c157"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c192",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c192",
    "representativeText": "Communities, in the context of this Work Programme, are groups of people who share particular attitudes and common interests, meaning an interest in open science.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c192",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-54-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c205",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c205",
    "representativeText": "The National Open Science Festival gives stakeholders interested in open science the opportunity to learn about open science practices and policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c205",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c125"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c207",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c207",
    "representativeText": "The National Open Science Festival is an important vehicle for Open Science NL to acquire useful input for the development of funding incentives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c207",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c4",
    "representativeText": "In this work programme, the term \"knowledge institutions\" also includes universities of applied sciences.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c4",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c48",
    "representativeText": "Best practices in software development, management, licensing and curation must be followed to develop open, FAIR and sustainable software.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c48",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c141"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-54-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c7",
    "representativeText": "Recipients of Open Science NL funding must comply with the NWO research data management protocol.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c7",
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "open-science-source-37-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c1/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c1/c83",
    "representativeText": "There has been a renewed interest in institutional publishing through open access university presses and library publishing services.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c83",
      "osft-doc-1449/c181"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c109",
    "representativeText": "When society is actively involved in research and innovation, the outcomes become more relevant.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c109",
      "osft-doc-0975/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c154",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c154",
    "representativeText": "Monitoring open science is crucial for measuring progress and impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c154",
      "osft-doc-1459/c454"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c17",
    "representativeText": "Monitoring and evaluation enable progress tracking in open science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c17",
      "open-science-source-41/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "open-science-source-41"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c34",
    "representativeText": "Data access conditions and procedures are not standardised.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c34",
      "osft-doc-1412/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c44",
    "representativeText": "Uptake of a data access standard is not guaranteed by the availability of a trustworthy technical solution.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c44",
      "osft-doc-1195/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1195"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-37-c2/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-37-c2/c95",
    "representativeText": "Additional capacity building for citizen science is needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2/c95",
      "osft-doc-1283/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c2",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c191",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c191",
    "representativeText": "Institutions may invest in promoting the adoption and use of ORCID identifiers, which facilitate machine- and human-readable attribution.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c191",
      "osft-doc-1449/c198"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c207",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c207",
    "representativeText": "There is a need for ways to study, understand, and decisively act across stakeholder roles and geolocations in order to bolster and strengthen critical open infrastructure resources.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c207",
      "osft-doc-0633/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0633"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c22",
    "representativeText": "Direct financial contributions, including grants, are the primary source of support for many open infrastructures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c22",
      "open-science-source-51/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-51"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c249",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c249",
    "representativeText": "Understanding infrastructure relationships may help open infrastructures find ways to team up to gain adoption and scale and to reinforce, rather than compete with, each other's assets, skills, and operational environments.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c249",
      "open-science-source-10/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-10",
      "open-science-source-38"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c43",
    "representativeText": "Other organizations should support and adopt the principles of the Barcelona Declaration on Open Research Information.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c43",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1375"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c434",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c434",
    "representativeText": "POSI's 16 principles cover financial sustainability of open scholarly infrastructure.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c434",
      "osft-doc-1781/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c5",
    "representativeText": "Disruption in the availability of open infrastructures in the research ecosystem can jeopardize swaths of human knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c5",
      "osft-doc-0836/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-0836"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c72",
    "representativeText": "Many academic institutions are taking a wait-and-see approach to investments in boosting public access policy compliance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c72",
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "open-science-source-54-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-38/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-38/c80",
    "representativeText": "Traditional evaluation metrics can conflict with open science practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-38/c80",
      "osft-doc-1449/c467"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-38",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-39/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-39/c42",
    "representativeText": "Several major publishers have updated their journal policies' language to align with the TOP framework.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-39/c42",
      "osft-doc-1353/c204"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-39",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c102",
    "representativeText": "Current LLM-based AI scientific assistants make a relatively small contribution to a relatively narrow range of tasks, such as supporting literature reviews.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c102",
      "open-science-source-42/c242"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c222",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c222",
    "representativeText": "To encourage scientists to use a new model or dataset, developers need to make it as easy as possible for scientists to use and integrate into their workflows.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c222",
      "open-science-source-42/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c235",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c235",
    "representativeText": "When starting discussions on a partnership, parties should align early on the overall goal.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c235",
      "osft-doc-1449/c426"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c332",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c332",
    "representativeText": "There can be a trade-off between accuracy and interpretability in AI systems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c332",
      "open-science-source-42/c469"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c363",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c363",
    "representativeText": "Direct environmental effects of AI include emissions from powering the data centres and devices that AI models are trained and run on.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c363",
      "open-science-source-42/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c423",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c423",
    "representativeText": "The type and depth of training needed will depend on an individual's discipline and profile.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c423",
      "osft-doc-1869/c259"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c50",
    "representativeText": "AI opportunities to transform how scientists digest and communicate knowledge are not without risk.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c50",
      "open-science-source-42/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c58",
    "representativeText": "AI models, once validated, can serve as new sources of synthetic scientific data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c58",
      "open-science-source-42/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c83",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c83",
    "representativeText": "AI could more accurately model complex systems by ingesting more data about them and learning more powerful patterns and regularities within this data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c83",
      "open-science-source-42/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c123",
    "representativeText": "Research funders, research institutions and industry actors should incentivise international collaboration by investing in open science infrastructures, tools, and practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c123",
      "open-science-source-45/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c2",
    "representativeText": "AI is enhancing the efficiency of scientists.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c2",
      "open-science-source-45/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c246",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c246",
    "representativeText": "Developing computational analysis software code has become an important aspect of the modern scientific endeavour.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c246",
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-54-c2"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c284",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c284",
    "representativeText": "Open science includes transparent peer review as part of the entire research and publication process it seeks to open.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c284",
      "osft-doc-0411/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0411"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c4",
    "representativeText": "AI is enhancing the creativity of scientists.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c4",
      "open-science-source-45/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c433",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c433",
    "representativeText": "Scientists lacking the required technical expertise for building, testing and finding errors in a model is a core issue in the adoption of AI in scientific research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c433",
      "open-science-source-45/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c491",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c491",
    "representativeText": "One of the primary incentives for disseminating research findings should be to advance the research enterprise.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c491",
      "osft-doc-1327/c515"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c526",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c526",
    "representativeText": "Interdisciplinary collaboration faces various barriers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c526",
      "osft-doc-0142/c729"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c638",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c638",
    "representativeText": "Standardisation of data management and sharing is required for AE systems to access a broad range of data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c638",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1329"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c696",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c696",
    "representativeText": "Without oversight, there is a risk that industry entities will prioritise commercial interests over broader scientific advancement, controlling critical infrastructure, databases, and algorithms to maintain their market dominance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c696",
      "open-science-source-43/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c98",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c98",
    "representativeText": "Research institutions and training centres should establish AI literacy curriculums across scientific fields to build researchers' capacity to understand the opportunities, limitations, and adequacy of AI-based tools within their fields and research contexts.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c98",
      "open-science-source-45/c268"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "open-science-source-45"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-43/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-43/c1",
    "representativeText": "Science relies on integrity and trustworthiness.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-43/c1",
      "osft-doc-1449/c408"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-43/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-43/c44",
    "representativeText": "Authors should retain the copyright.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-43/c44",
      "open-science-source-15-c1/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c1",
      "open-science-source-43"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-43/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-43/c90",
    "representativeText": "Rankings of academic achievement with metrics such as citation counts, journal impact factor (JIF) and publication number must be used responsibly.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-43/c90",
      "open-science-source-55/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-43",
      "open-science-source-55"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c106",
    "representativeText": "Pressure to publish has increased.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c106",
      "osft-doc-1327/c981"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c117",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c117",
    "representativeText": "The pressure to publish is not a new phenomenon.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c117",
      "osft-doc-1327/c980"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c162",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c162",
    "representativeText": "Collaboration across countries, disciplines and institutions is highly valued for helping researchers tackle challenges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c162",
      "osft-doc-1327/c609"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c199",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c199",
    "representativeText": "Career advancement, funding and institutional support remain significant motivators for researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c199",
      "osft-doc-1869/c93"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c221",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c221",
    "representativeText": "Researchers increasingly recognize societal and engagement indicators as meaningful measures of impact.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c221",
      "osft-doc-0142/c236"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c228",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c228",
    "representativeText": "Support from institutions is crucial for researchers to do outreach effectively.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c228",
      "osft-doc-1869/c198"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c253",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c253",
    "representativeText": "Researchers are increasingly willing to step outside the lab to communicate their findings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c253",
      "osft-doc-0446/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0446"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c281",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c281",
    "representativeText": "Researchers need skills to do outreach.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c281",
      "osft-doc-0105/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-0105"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-45/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-45/c50",
    "representativeText": "Universities, funders, and information and analytic providers must encourage outreach and engagement by rewarding public communication efforts and enabling researchers to share their work with policymakers, educators and the public.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-45/c50",
      "osft-doc-1869/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-45",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-48/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-48/c4",
    "representativeText": "Skepticism about the trustworthiness of content is not a new situation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-48/c4",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1066"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-48",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c29",
    "representativeText": "Transparency is important to scientific inquiry.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c29",
      "osft-doc-0633/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-0633"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c50",
    "representativeText": "Authors can ensure machine-actionable reusability of their data by following the FAIR guidelines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c50",
      "osft-doc-0645/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c52",
    "representativeText": "Data and code imperfectly shared are typically better than data and code perfectly kept to oneself.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c52",
      "osft-doc-1412/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-1412"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c72",
    "representativeText": "The standard required by the peer-review method is open to interpretation by the specific journal.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c72",
      "osft-doc-1327/c932"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-50/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-50/c92",
    "representativeText": "Reproduction attempts can be incorrect because of unclear reporting or a lack of code.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-50/c92",
      "osft-doc-0084/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-50",
      "osft-doc-0084"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-53/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-53/c21",
    "representativeText": "SCOSS provides a framework to help SCOSS-endorsed community-led, non-commercial open infrastructure become sustainable for the long term.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-53/c21",
      "osft-doc-1459/c583"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-53",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c1/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c1/c30",
    "representativeText": "Libraries appear to be the institutional unit most likely to take proactive steps to support public access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c1/c30",
      "osft-doc-1869/c308"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c1",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c2/c134",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c2/c134",
    "representativeText": "A healthy diversity of ideological positions is needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c134",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1001"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c2/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c2/c147",
    "representativeText": "Findability of research software should be increased through appropriate metadata.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c147",
      "osft-doc-0932/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-0932"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c2/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c2/c40",
    "representativeText": "The focus of these communities includes sharing of best practice in particular areas, such as software citation or development of RSE career paths.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c40",
      "osft-doc-1869/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c2/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c2/c68",
    "representativeText": "Policy development is a key part of cultural change.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2/c68",
      "osft-doc-1449/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c2",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-54-c3/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-54-c3/c11",
    "representativeText": "Open source software has significance in academic research, teaching, and operations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-54-c3/c11",
      "osft-doc-1869/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-54-c3",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-55/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-55/c16",
    "representativeText": "Concerns about the JIF and journals' perceived prestige may limit the adoption of open access publishing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-55/c16",
      "osft-doc-1673/c340"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-55/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-55/c35",
    "representativeText": "Several proposals and initiatives have challenged the use of the JIF in academic evaluations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-55/c35",
      "osft-doc-0142/c1312"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-55/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-55/c36",
    "representativeText": "Several proposals and initiatives have promoted the responsible use of metrics to improve academic evaluations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-55/c36",
      "osft-doc-0142/c822"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-55",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0002/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0002/c1",
    "representativeText": "The UNESCO Recommendation on Open Science is the first international standard setting instrument on open science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0002/c1",
      "osft-doc-1253/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0020/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0020/c34",
    "representativeText": "If possible, the organisation and staff should have direct incentives to deliver on the mission.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0020/c34",
      "osft-doc-0756/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0020",
      "osft-doc-0756"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c101",
    "representativeText": "Integrating coaching, peer-support mechanisms, and train-the-trainer models equips researchers at all career stages with practical, context-specific guidance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c101",
      "osft-doc-0150/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c102",
    "representativeText": "Integrating coaching, peer-support mechanisms, and train-the-trainer models helps normalise reproducible methods early in researchers' careers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c102",
      "osft-doc-0150/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c103",
    "representativeText": "Stakeholders should invest in, and provide sustainable career pathways for, specialist roles that support research teams with specific competences.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c103",
      "osft-doc-0150/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c106",
    "representativeText": "Coordinated training ecosystems strengthen institutional capacity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c106",
      "osft-doc-0150/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c107",
    "representativeText": "Coordinated training ecosystems ensure that reproducibility becomes a routine and sustainable part of research practice.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c107",
      "osft-doc-0150/c97"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c109",
    "representativeText": "Research leaders, supervisors, and principal investigators shape local research culture.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c109",
      "osft-doc-0150/c106"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c110",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c110",
    "representativeText": "Research leaders, supervisors, and principal investigators set expectations for rigour, transparency, and documentation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c110",
      "osft-doc-0150/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c111",
    "representativeText": "Developing targeted training and incentive structures for research leaders can enhance their awareness of reproducibility challenges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c111",
      "osft-doc-0150/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c112",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c112",
    "representativeText": "Developing targeted training and incentive structures for research leaders can equip them with practical strategies for supporting good practice within their teams.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c112",
      "osft-doc-0150/c109"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c113",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c113",
    "representativeText": "Developing targeted training and incentive structures for research leaders can reinforce their accountability as role models for responsible research behaviour.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c113",
      "osft-doc-0150/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c114",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c114",
    "representativeText": "Embedding training on reproducibility within institutional frameworks ensures that responsibility for reproducibility extends beyond early-career researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c114",
      "osft-doc-0150/c112"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c116",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c116",
    "representativeText": "Training programmes on reproducibility should be paired with awareness raising on why reproducibility practices matter when training is obligatory.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c116",
      "osft-doc-0150/c113"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c118",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c118",
    "representativeText": "Publishers are facing growing challenges in ensuring research quality and provenance.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c118",
      "osft-doc-0150/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c123",
    "representativeText": "Editorial and other relevant teams need budget, training, and technical support to assess compliance with data availability requirements, metadata standards, persistent identifier use, and repository best practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c123",
      "osft-doc-0150/c118"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c125",
    "representativeText": "Journals should collaborate with internal and external service providers to integrate automated and AI-enabled tools, such as automated data-availability checkers, code-execution verifiers, and metadata validators, directly into manuscript workflows.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c125",
      "osft-doc-0150/c119"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c126",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c126",
    "representativeText": "The reliability of automated and AI-enabled manuscript-screening tools is itself an active area of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c126",
      "osft-doc-0150/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c127",
    "representativeText": "The viability of automated and AI-enabled manuscript-screening tools should be regularly assessed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c127",
      "osft-doc-0150/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c130",
    "representativeText": "Effective policy for improving reproducibility must be grounded in robust empirical evidence.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c130",
      "osft-doc-0150/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c131",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c131",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research must clarify how reproducibility manifests across diverse research communities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c131",
      "osft-doc-0150/c134"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c132",
    "representativeText": "A rapidly expanding meta-research community has begun to fill the evidence gaps regarding reproducibility interventions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c132",
      "osft-doc-0150/c126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c133",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c133",
    "representativeText": "Funders, publishers, and institutions must provide stronger support to the meta-research community so it can generate actionable insights.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c133",
      "osft-doc-0150/c127"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c135",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of evidence on how reproducibility interventions intersect, interact, or amplify each other.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c135",
      "osft-doc-0150/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c137",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c137",
    "representativeText": "Evidence on the effectiveness of reproducibility training programmes is particularly limited, especially regarding which formats benefit which audiences and how long such effects persist.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c137",
      "osft-doc-0150/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c140",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research must identify the conditions that enable reproducibility interventions to succeed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c140",
      "osft-doc-0150/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c143",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c143",
    "representativeText": "Publishers and funders should publicly share the results of their internal investigations of reproducibility interventions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c143",
      "osft-doc-0150/c138"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c146",
    "representativeText": "Future research should include systematic cost-benefit analyses that assess impacts on research workflow, equity, and researcher wellbeing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c146",
      "osft-doc-0150/c141"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c147",
    "representativeText": "It is important to examine the potential negative consequences of reproducibility interventions, such as risks of sharing low-quality or biased data, standardisation constraining methodological innovation, and new administrative burdens disproportionately affecting certain disciplines or career stages.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c147",
      "osft-doc-0150/c143"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c149",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research can help funders, publishers, and institutions implement workflows that are proportionate, targeted, and sensitive to disciplinary and contextual variation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c149",
      "osft-doc-0150/c145"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c15",
    "representativeText": "Institutions should provide training to research leaders to foster reproducibility practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c15",
      "osft-doc-0150/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c150",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c150",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research on reproducibility frequently depends on access to funder and publisher data such as grant information, peer-review records, editorial decision timelines, and other publisher or funder workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c150",
      "osft-doc-0150/c146"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c152",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c152",
    "representativeText": "Meta-research on reproducibility is currently hindered by fragmented processes, inconsistent data-sharing arrangements, privacy considerations, and unclear pathways or standards for establishing collaborations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c152",
      "osft-doc-0150/c142"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c153",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c153",
    "representativeText": "Funders and publishers can make a real difference by streamlining their internal workflows to support meta-research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c153",
      "osft-doc-0150/c148"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c156",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c156",
    "representativeText": "Funders and publishers can make a real difference by establishing secure mechanisms for researcher access to sensitive operational data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c156",
      "osft-doc-0150/c150"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c157",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c157",
    "representativeText": "By making funding and publishing processes more transparent and consistent, organisations can enable rigorous empirical investigation into how funding and publishing practices influence reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c157",
      "osft-doc-0150/c151"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c159",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c159",
    "representativeText": "Epistemic diversity is defined as the condition or fact of being different or varied, which affects the development and/or understanding of knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c159",
      "osft-doc-0150/c153"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c160",
    "representativeText": "The Knowledge Production Modes (KPM) framework interprets reproducibility as a function of both epistemic relevance and practical feasibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c160",
      "osft-doc-0150/c156"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c165",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c165",
    "representativeText": "Treating reproducibility as universal risks epistemic injustice by marginalising valid forms of inquiry that do not conform to norms imported from experimental, positivist, or quantitative traditions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c165",
      "osft-doc-0150/c158"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c167",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c167",
    "representativeText": "Redoing is defined as attempting to repeat part or all of a study.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c167",
      "osft-doc-0150/c161"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c168",
    "representativeText": "Practices aimed at enabling redoing are defined as providing transparency so others can understand or reuse the work.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c168",
      "osft-doc-0150/c162"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c171",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c171",
    "representativeText": "The effectiveness of mandates depends on various factors, such as how strongly they are enforced or norms regarding use of standards within research fields.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c171",
      "osft-doc-0150/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c173",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c173",
    "representativeText": "Machine Learning-driven research has novel challenges for relevance and feasibility such as nondeterminism, data leakage, and environmental variability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c173",
      "osft-doc-0150/c169"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c175",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c175",
    "representativeText": "Well-adapted, epistemically aligned interpretations of reproducibility and replicability can be meaningful in qualitative research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c175",
      "osft-doc-0150/c171"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c179",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c179",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future research culture for reproducibility prioritises quality over quantity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c179",
      "osft-doc-0150/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c18",
    "representativeText": "Meta-researchers, supported by funders and publishers, should investigate the costs of reproducibility interventions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c18",
      "osft-doc-0150/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c180",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c180",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future research culture for reproducibility centres reproducibility in research practice and in training.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c180",
      "osft-doc-0150/c195"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c181",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future of reproducibility has standardised reproducibility requirements that account for methodological and epistemic diversity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c181",
      "osft-doc-0150/c196"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c182",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c182",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future of reproducibility has standardised and shareable methods, tools and workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c182",
      "osft-doc-0150/c197"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c183",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c183",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future of reproducibility incentivises reproducible, open and collaborative practices by providing recognition, funding, and visibility for them, including alternative research outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c183",
      "osft-doc-0150/c198"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c184",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c184",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future of reproducibility has infrastructure designed for ease of use with clear guidance, policies and training.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c184",
      "osft-doc-0150/c199"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c185",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c185",
    "representativeText": "The envisioned future infrastructure for reproducibility hosts FAIR and open tools and workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c185",
      "osft-doc-0150/c200"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c186",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c186",
    "representativeText": "In the envisioned future of reproducibility, sufficient resources are available to develop and maintain reproducibility infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c186",
      "osft-doc-0150/c201"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c187",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c187",
    "representativeText": "Improving reproducibility is a question of the alignment of epistemic, cultural, technical, and institutional factors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c187",
      "osft-doc-0150/c202"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c193",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c193",
    "representativeText": "Research communities are best placed to lead development of reproducibility standards suited to their own epistemic contexts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c193",
      "osft-doc-0150/c209"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c194",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c194",
    "representativeText": "Early-stage planning to embed reproducibility into research design is advisable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c194",
      "osft-doc-0150/c210"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c195",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c195",
    "representativeText": "Early-stage planning to embed reproducibility into research design can heavily reduce downstream work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c195",
      "osft-doc-0150/c211"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c197",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c197",
    "representativeText": "Mandates and structured checks may be necessary at reporting stage.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c197",
      "osft-doc-0150/c214"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c200",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c200",
    "representativeText": "Greater understanding is needed on the gains and savings associated with different approaches to reproducibility.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c200",
      "osft-doc-0150/c218"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c21",
    "representativeText": "Robust, sustainable infrastructure is an essential foundation for reproducible research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c21",
      "osft-doc-0150/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c23",
    "representativeText": "Standards for identifying, describing, interlinking and sharing digital objects are essential.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c23",
      "osft-doc-0150/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c24",
    "representativeText": "Standards for identifying, describing, interlinking and sharing digital objects are often domain specific.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c24",
      "osft-doc-0150/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c26",
    "representativeText": "Achieving reproducibility at scale requires shared standards.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c26",
      "osft-doc-0150/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c29",
    "representativeText": "Investing in open, trustworthy infrastructures and fostering an active community committed to transparency and collaboration enables stakeholders to create an environment in which research outputs are consistently findable, accessible, reusable, interoperable, and verifiable.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c29",
      "osft-doc-0150/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c32",
    "representativeText": "Many critical components of the research ecosystem operate on fragile or short-term funding models.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c32",
      "osft-doc-0150/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c42",
    "representativeText": "Many existing frameworks focus on how researchers should produce reusable data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c42",
      "osft-doc-0150/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c43",
    "representativeText": "Comparable guidance for those who re-use data remains less developed than guidance for producing reusable data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c43",
      "osft-doc-0150/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c44",
    "representativeText": "Guidance for those who re-use data is often fragmented across disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c44",
      "osft-doc-0150/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c46",
    "representativeText": "Overarching principles such as ethical use, attribution, careful assessment of uncertainty, and concerns around data security and governance may apply more broadly across domains.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c46",
      "osft-doc-0150/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c5",
    "representativeText": "Practices that enable redoing, such as transparent workflows and FAIR outputs, create conditions for scrutiny, whether or not reproduction is actually undertaken.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c5",
      "osft-doc-0150/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c53",
    "representativeText": "Mandating GUPRIs and open metadata strengthens research integrity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c53",
      "osft-doc-0150/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c54",
    "representativeText": "Mandating GUPRIs and open metadata reduces ambiguity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c54",
      "osft-doc-0150/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c55",
    "representativeText": "Mandating GUPRIs and open metadata supports FAIR data principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c55",
      "osft-doc-0150/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c56",
    "representativeText": "Mandating GUPRIs and open metadata enables consistent attribution and accountability across diverse research domains.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c56",
      "osft-doc-0150/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c6",
    "representativeText": "Practices that enable redoing, such as transparent workflows and FAIR outputs, create conditions for reuse, whether or not reproduction is actually undertaken.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c6",
      "osft-doc-0150/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c70",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility metrics can support automated oversight, for example by tracking availability of open outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c70",
      "osft-doc-0150/c68"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c71",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c71",
    "representativeText": "Poorly designed reproducibility indicators risk oversimplifying complex research practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c71",
      "osft-doc-0150/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c72",
    "representativeText": "Poorly designed reproducibility indicators risk encouraging box ticking.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c72",
      "osft-doc-0150/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c73",
    "representativeText": "Poorly designed reproducibility indicators risk disadvantaging fields with different norms.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c73",
      "osft-doc-0150/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c74",
    "representativeText": "Poorly designed reproducibility indicators risk becoming targets in their own right.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c74",
      "osft-doc-0150/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c76",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility metrics should be transparent about their limitations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c76",
      "osft-doc-0150/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c80",
    "representativeText": "Replication work remains undervalued in many fields.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c80",
      "osft-doc-0150/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c82",
    "representativeText": "Replication is a core scientific activity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c82",
      "osft-doc-0150/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c84",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c84",
    "representativeText": "Replication can guide improvements in methods, reporting, and research design across disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c84",
      "osft-doc-0150/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c86",
    "representativeText": "Grant proposals could begin by replicating the key prior studies that the work builds upon.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c86",
      "osft-doc-0150/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c9",
    "representativeText": "Funders, publishers and institutions should require open metadata for research objects and entities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c9",
      "osft-doc-0150/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c90",
    "representativeText": "Dedicated or top-up funding for replication studies may stimulate early uptake.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c90",
      "osft-doc-0150/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c91",
    "representativeText": "Dedicated or top-up funding for replication studies may build community capacity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c91",
      "osft-doc-0150/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c93",
    "representativeText": "Sustained investment in replication funding will support mainstreaming replication over time, so that it becomes a routine and expected part of funded research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c93",
      "osft-doc-0150/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0068/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0068/c50",
    "representativeText": "Member States should ensure that the market for services relating to science and open science functions in the global and public interest.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0068/c50",
      "open-science-source-03/c168"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0068"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0084/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0084/c17",
    "representativeText": "A research article is the end product of one research process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0084/c17",
      "osft-doc-1213/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0084",
      "osft-doc-1213"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0084/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0084/c4",
    "representativeText": "Sharing of data, protocols, materials, software, and other tools should be adopted to increase the proportion of true research findings.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0084/c4",
      "osft-doc-1193/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0084",
      "osft-doc-1193"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0084/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0084/c59",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should adhere to the relevant reporting guideline(s).",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0084/c59",
      "osft-doc-1283/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0084",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0084/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0084/c7",
    "representativeText": "Standardization of definitions and analyses should be pursued to increase the proportion of true research findings.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0084/c7",
      "osft-doc-0142/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0084",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0105/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0105/c106",
    "representativeText": "All, and only, individuals who have participated in the research must be appropriately recognized and acknowledged.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0105/c106",
      "osft-doc-1283/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-1283"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0105/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0105/c87",
    "representativeText": "Research and scientific findings must be appropriately considered in evidence-informed decision-making.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0105/c87",
      "osft-doc-1795/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0105",
      "osft-doc-1795"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c14",
    "representativeText": "The properties of the Journal Impact Factor are field-specific: it is a composite of multiple, highly diverse article types, including primary research papers and reviews.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c14",
      "osft-doc-0296/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c16",
    "representativeText": "Data used to calculate the Journal Impact Factors are neither transparent nor openly available to the public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c16",
      "osft-doc-0296/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c17",
    "representativeText": "Outputs other than research articles will grow in importance in assessing research effectiveness in the future.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c17",
      "osft-doc-0296/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c18",
    "representativeText": "The peer-reviewed research paper will remain a central research output that informs research assessment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c18",
      "osft-doc-0296/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c22",
    "representativeText": "The opportunities provided by online publication, such as relaxing unnecessary limits on the number of words, figures, and references in articles and exploring new indicators of significance and impact, must be capitalized on.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c22",
      "osft-doc-0296/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c24",
    "representativeText": "Such steps are beginning to increase the momentum toward more sophisticated and meaningful approaches to research evaluation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c24",
      "osft-doc-0296/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c25",
    "representativeText": "More sophisticated and meaningful approaches to research evaluation can now be built upon and adopted by all of the key constituencies involved.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c25",
      "osft-doc-0296/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c28",
    "representativeText": "Funding agencies should clearly highlight, especially for early-stage investigators, that the scientific content of a paper is much more important than publication metrics or the identity of the journal in which it was published.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c28",
      "osft-doc-0296/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c32",
    "representativeText": "Institutions should clearly highlight, especially for early-stage investigators, that the scientific content of a paper is much more important than publication metrics or the identity of the journal in which it was published.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c32",
      "osft-doc-0296/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c39",
    "representativeText": "Whether a journal is open-access or subscription-based, publishers should remove all reuse limitations on reference lists in research articles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c39",
      "osft-doc-0296/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c40",
    "representativeText": "Whether a journal is open-access or subscription-based, publishers should make reference lists in research articles available under the Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c40",
      "osft-doc-0296/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c41",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should remove or reduce the constraints on the number of references in research articles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c41",
      "osft-doc-0296/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c42",
    "representativeText": "Where appropriate, publishers should mandate the citation of primary literature in favor of reviews in order to give credit to the group or groups who first reported a finding.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c42",
      "osft-doc-0296/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c45",
    "representativeText": "Where possible, organizations that supply metrics should provide computational access to data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c45",
      "osft-doc-0296/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c46",
    "representativeText": "Organizations that supply metrics should make clear that inappropriate manipulation of metrics will not be tolerated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c46",
      "osft-doc-0296/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c47",
    "representativeText": "Organizations that supply metrics should be explicit about what constitutes inappropriate manipulation of metrics and what measures will be taken to combat it.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c47",
      "osft-doc-0296/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c50",
    "representativeText": "Wherever appropriate, researchers should cite primary literature in which observations are first reported rather than reviews, in order to give credit where credit is due.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c50",
      "osft-doc-0296/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c51",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should use a range of article metrics and indicators in personal or supporting statements as evidence of the impact of individual published articles and other research outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c51",
      "osft-doc-0296/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c52",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should challenge research assessment practices that rely inappropriately on Journal Impact Factors.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c52",
      "osft-doc-0296/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c53",
    "representativeText": "Researchers should promote and teach best practice that focuses on the value and influence of specific research outputs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c53",
      "osft-doc-0296/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0108/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0108/c9",
    "representativeText": "Scientific output must be measured accurately.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0108/c9",
      "osft-doc-0296/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0108",
      "osft-doc-0296"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c11",
    "representativeText": "The shift toward net-zero clean economies depends on open access to scientific knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c11",
      "osft-doc-0900/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c12",
    "representativeText": "The shift toward net-zero clean economies depends on political willingness to take evidence-based action.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c12",
      "osft-doc-0900/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c2",
    "representativeText": "The climate emergency poses an existential threat.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c2",
      "osft-doc-0900/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c20",
    "representativeText": "All published research articles should transition from subscription to fully open-access models before the end of the decade.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c20",
      "osft-doc-0900/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c3",
    "representativeText": "Immediate and far-reaching action is needed in response to the climate emergency.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c3",
      "osft-doc-0900/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c4",
    "representativeText": "The planet is edging closer to several irreversible tipping points.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c4",
      "osft-doc-0900/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c6",
    "representativeText": "A wide spectrum of science solutions is needed urgently.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c6",
      "osft-doc-0900/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c8",
    "representativeText": "The current system restricts access to most scientific research for many scientists and virtually all practitioners, innovators, and entrepreneurs in the world.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c8",
      "osft-doc-0900/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0114/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0114/c9",
    "representativeText": "Restrictions on access to major breakthroughs in sustainability and climate sciences are even more severe.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0114/c9",
      "osft-doc-0900/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c101",
    "representativeText": "Clear communication of the rationale for selecting particular indicators, and how they will be used as a management tool, is paramount.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c101",
      "osft-doc-1047/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1021",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1021",
    "representativeText": "Journal impact factors can have clogging effects on scholarly communication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1021",
      "osft-doc-1327/c823"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1052",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1052",
    "representativeText": "Research policymakers, the wider academic community, institutions, funders and government must promote decent and fair standards of behaviour in the use of metrics.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1052",
      "osft-doc-1449/c357"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c119",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should be mindful of the limitations of particular indicators in the way they present their own CVs and evaluate the work of colleagues.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c119",
      "osft-doc-1047/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1213",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1213",
    "representativeText": "Alternative metrics can be susceptible to biases, gaming and difficulties of interpretation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1213",
      "osft-doc-1449/c327"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1267",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1267",
    "representativeText": "Guidelines on the use of quantitative evidence of impact should provide suggested data to evidence specific types of impact.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1267",
      "osft-doc-1047/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1293",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1293",
    "representativeText": "Excellence in research is multidimensional.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1293",
      "open-science-source-18/c335"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-18",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1305",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1305",
    "representativeText": "Scientometric data are fairly well developed.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1305",
      "osft-doc-1047/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c1328",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c1328",
    "representativeText": "The different systems operated by HEIs, funders and publishers need to interoperate.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c1328",
      "osft-doc-0050/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c151",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c151",
    "representativeText": "Publishers should mandate ORCID iDs and ISNIs and funder grant references for article submission.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c151",
      "osft-doc-1253/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1253"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c17",
    "representativeText": "Wider use of quantitative indicators could support the transition to a more open, accountable and outward-facing research system.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c17",
      "osft-doc-1327/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c184",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c184",
    "representativeText": "There is a need for greater research and innovation in the science of science policy to develop and apply insights from computing, statistics, social science and economics to better understand the relationship between research, its qualities and wider impacts.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c184",
      "osft-doc-0050/c199"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0142"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c204",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c204",
    "representativeText": "Bibliometrics focuses on the quantitative analysis of scientific and scholarly publications, including patents.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c204",
      "osft-doc-1047/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c211",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c211",
    "representativeText": "Bibliometrics often do not distinguish between negative or positive citation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c211",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1096"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c212",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c212",
    "representativeText": "Highly cited literature might attract attention due to controversy or even error.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c212",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1097"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c214",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c214",
    "representativeText": "Altmetrics are non-traditional metrics that cover not just citation counts but also downloads, social media shares and other measures of impact of research outputs.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c214",
      "osft-doc-1047/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c218",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c218",
    "representativeText": "Altmetrics indicators are derived from social websites, such as Twitter, Academia.edu, Mendeley, and ResearchGate, with data that can be gathered automatically by computer programs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c218",
      "osft-doc-1047/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c24",
    "representativeText": "Peer review should remain the primary basis for assessing research papers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c24",
      "osft-doc-1047/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c607",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c607",
    "representativeText": "Additional impact indicators must be interpreted in context.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c607",
      "osft-doc-1449/c391"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c650",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c650",
    "representativeText": "Metrics should not become the 'tail that wags the dog' of research practice in all disciplines.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c650",
      "osft-doc-1767/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c679",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c679",
    "representativeText": "There is significant disciplinary diversity in the use and acceptance of indicators for the assessment of research outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c679",
      "osft-doc-1047/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1047"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c694",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c694",
    "representativeText": "Colleagues from the arts and humanities are not alone in their distrust of certain research assessment indicators.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c694",
      "osft-doc-1449/c397"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c890",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c890",
    "representativeText": "The increasing adoption of metrics and the growing role of commercial or proprietary systems have brought the issue of open scholarly infrastructures and standards to the fore.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c890",
      "osft-doc-1781/c183"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0142/c912",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0142/c912",
    "representativeText": "Over-emphasis on a small set of ranking indicators risks encouraging perverse behaviour within and across institutions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0142/c912",
      "osft-doc-1767/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0142",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c187",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c187",
    "representativeText": "Meaningful change in data sharing practices requires stronger mandates and enforcement rather than gentle prompts.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c187",
      "osft-doc-0633/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0150",
      "osft-doc-0633"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c20",
    "representativeText": "Funders and publishers should enable meta-research regarding funding and publishing workflows through streamlined processes for collaboration and data-access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c20",
      "osft-doc-0050/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c3",
    "representativeText": "The relevance and feasibility of reproducibility differ substantially between different modes of producing knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c3",
      "osft-doc-0050/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c41",
    "representativeText": "Standards and guidelines for data re-use should help secondary users understand how to assess fitness-for-purpose.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c41",
      "osft-doc-0050/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c12",
    "representativeText": "POSI has been built upon and discussed by others in the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c12",
      "osft-doc-1781/c175"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-1781"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0151/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0151/c45",
    "representativeText": "An infrastructure organisation's role is to provide a base for others to work on.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0151/c45",
      "osft-doc-0756/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0151",
      "osft-doc-0756"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0152/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0152/c8",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship refers to an attempt to realign modern research practices with the collective ideal of scholarly research.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0152/c8",
      "osft-doc-1373/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0152",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0268/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0268/c15",
    "representativeText": "The UNESCO Recommendation on Open Science provides a single framework for the 193 UNESCO member states to use as a road map.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0268/c15",
      "osft-doc-1593/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0268",
      "osft-doc-1593"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c108",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c108",
    "representativeText": "Critical metadata linking datasets to publications, and thus to funding sources, are often missing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c108",
      "open-science-source-21/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-0298"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c11",
    "representativeText": "An increasing number of publishers and funders require data management plans upon publication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c11",
      "osft-doc-0645/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-0645"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c13",
    "representativeText": "An increasing number of publishers and funders require open access to data upon publication.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c13",
      "osft-doc-1449/c219"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0298/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0298/c135",
    "representativeText": "Discovering datasets is the first step in reusing public data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0298/c135",
      "osft-doc-1940/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0298",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c15",
    "representativeText": "Open data and content can be freely used, modified, and shared by anyone for any purpose.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c15",
      "osft-doc-1702/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c19",
    "representativeText": "Open Science encompasses open workflows.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c19",
      "osft-doc-1612/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c43",
    "representativeText": "Increased transparency in research leads to greater efficiency, rigour, accountability, sustainability for future generations, and reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c43",
      "osft-doc-0633/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-0633"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0411/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0411/c5",
    "representativeText": "Open Science is about increased accountability for research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0411/c5",
      "osft-doc-1612/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0411",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c101",
    "representativeText": "Current academic structures around science communication, prestige-based funding, and teaching and mentoring practices often serve as a bottleneck that considerably hinders the chances of minorities in academia.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c101",
      "osft-doc-1878/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c104",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c104",
    "representativeText": "The key factors predicting recognition of one's scientific work are seniority, location, and institutional reputation rather than research quality.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c104",
      "osft-doc-1878/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c105",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c105",
    "representativeText": "Recognition trickles down to funding, visibility, and citations of one's scientific work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c105",
      "osft-doc-1878/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c106",
    "representativeText": "This trickle-down of recognition contributes to increasing inequality regarding which scientific ideas and perspectives get more diffused and become more impactful to future scientific investigations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c106",
      "osft-doc-1878/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c107",
    "representativeText": "Junior researchers who co-author with prominent scientists have an ongoing competitive advantage, including continued collaboration with top-cited scientists and a higher likelihood of becoming one themselves.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c107",
      "osft-doc-1878/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c109",
    "representativeText": "Inequality in academia influences who has access to higher education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c109",
      "osft-doc-1878/c103"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c110",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c110",
    "representativeText": "Inequality in academia influences who gets to be a prominent scholar.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c110",
      "osft-doc-1878/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c111",
    "representativeText": "Inequality in academia influences which populations get studied.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c111",
      "osft-doc-1878/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c117",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c117",
    "representativeText": "Open teaching initiatives allow a wider variety of societal actors, including researchers, citizen scientists, policy makers, businesses, and third sector organizations, to collaborate and contribute their expertise towards a common goal in science production.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c117",
      "osft-doc-1878/c111"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c118",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c118",
    "representativeText": "Open teaching initiatives promote greater diversity of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c118",
      "osft-doc-1878/c112"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c119",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c119",
    "representativeText": "Open teaching initiatives promote greater democratization of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c119",
      "osft-doc-1878/c113"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c120",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c120",
    "representativeText": "Open teaching initiatives improve scientific literacy among the lay public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c120",
      "osft-doc-1878/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c123",
    "representativeText": "Integrating open teaching initiatives into science produces greater alignment between the scientific process and its outcomes and principled values.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c123",
      "osft-doc-1878/c117"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c124",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c124",
    "representativeText": "Integrating open teaching initiatives into science produces greater alignment between the scientific process and its outcomes and the needs and expectations of society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c124",
      "osft-doc-1878/c118"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c125",
    "representativeText": "Principled teaching and mentoring is teaching and mentoring that integrates both subject matter and open and reproducible scholarship tenets.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c125",
      "osft-doc-1878/c119"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c126",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c126",
    "representativeText": "Teaching and mentoring have the potential to powerfully motivate positive change.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c126",
      "osft-doc-1878/c120"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c13",
    "representativeText": "FORRT is a community-driven infrastructure for educators that advances ethics through pedagogical reform.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c13",
      "osft-doc-1878/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c130",
    "representativeText": "Students must be familiar with the notion that scientific claims should be taken in light of epistemic uncertainty.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c130",
      "osft-doc-1878/c126"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c132",
    "representativeText": "Epistemic uncertainty is the intrinsic incertitude about the validity of claims.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c132",
      "osft-doc-1878/c127"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c133",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c133",
    "representativeText": "Academics are typically familiarized with, and utilize, heuristics in line with epistemic uncertainty, especially when judging the output of each other's work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c133",
      "osft-doc-1878/c128"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c134",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c134",
    "representativeText": "Epistemic uncertainty is one key aspect motivating the peer-review system.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c134",
      "osft-doc-1878/c129"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c135",
    "representativeText": "Science education would benefit from systematically integrating field content with epistemic uncertainty.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c135",
      "osft-doc-1878/c130"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c136",
    "representativeText": "Teaching students without acknowledging epistemic uncertainty gives them a false sense of certainty about the facts of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c136",
      "osft-doc-1878/c131"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c138",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c138",
    "representativeText": "The belief that statistical analyses give a 'seal of objectivity' to research conclusions may be ill-advised.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c138",
      "osft-doc-1878/c133"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c140",
    "representativeText": "CREP offers students training opportunities to conduct large-scale collaborative replication projects.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c140",
      "osft-doc-1878/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c141",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c141",
    "representativeText": "CREP offers training and support for teachers wishing to guide their students through large-scale collaborative replication research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c141",
      "osft-doc-1878/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c147",
    "representativeText": "Principled education finds normative support in several social sciences' codes of conduct.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c147",
      "osft-doc-1878/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c149",
    "representativeText": "Educators should focus on continuous self-improvement and education as a means to teach effectively.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c149",
      "osft-doc-1878/c142"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c150",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c150",
    "representativeText": "The scientific enterprise is a continuous learning process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c150",
      "osft-doc-1878/c143"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c151",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c151",
    "representativeText": "Portraying the scientific enterprise as a continuous learning process in science education contributes to a more realistic portrayal of the subject matter.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c151",
      "osft-doc-1878/c144"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c152",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c152",
    "representativeText": "Portraying the scientific enterprise as a continuous learning process in science education promotes the curiosity and interest of students about the academic profession.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c152",
      "osft-doc-1878/c145"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c155",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c155",
    "representativeText": "The current publication culture encourages aggressive competition over collaborative teamwork.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c155",
      "osft-doc-1878/c148"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c157",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c157",
    "representativeText": "The current publication culture is antithetical to scientific ideals of cumulative and team science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c157",
      "osft-doc-1878/c150"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c158",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c158",
    "representativeText": "The current publication culture informs how students are taught and mentored.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c158",
      "osft-doc-1878/c151"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c163",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c163",
    "representativeText": "Teaching can become deprioritized due to the competing demands of career progression and mobility in the job marketplace, which rely largely on research and grant-writing productivity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c163",
      "osft-doc-1878/c158"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c166",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c166",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarship enriches the learning experience of students.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c166",
      "osft-doc-1878/c162"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c17",
    "representativeText": "Principled teaching and mentoring is an underappreciated dimension of the scientific endeavour.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c17",
      "osft-doc-1878/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c170",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c170",
    "representativeText": "Integrating new research practices into teaching and mentoring may appear to be a substantial task for most researchers and educators, given the time constraints they face.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c170",
      "osft-doc-1878/c166"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c173",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c173",
    "representativeText": "Community is a substantial contributor to the success of open education initiatives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c173",
      "osft-doc-1878/c169"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c177",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c177",
    "representativeText": "Accessibility should be considered a normative practice in science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c177",
      "osft-doc-1878/c173"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c181",
    "representativeText": "Educators must be familiar with the relevant literature to teach open and reproducible scholarship effectively.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c181",
      "osft-doc-1878/c180"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c185",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c185",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises reproducibility and replicability knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c185",
      "osft-doc-1878/c183"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c186",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c186",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises conceptual and statistical knowledge.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c186",
      "osft-doc-1878/c184"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c187",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c187",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises reproducible analyses.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c187",
      "osft-doc-1878/c185"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c188",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c188",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises preregistration.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c188",
      "osft-doc-1878/c186"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c189",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c189",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises FAIR data and materials.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c189",
      "osft-doc-1878/c187"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c19",
    "representativeText": "Science progresses most when conditions for reasoned dissent are enhanced.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c19",
      "osft-doc-1878/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c190",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c190",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises replication research.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c190",
      "osft-doc-1878/c188"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c191",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c191",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's cluster framework comprises academic life and culture.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c191",
      "osft-doc-1878/c189"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c192",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c192",
    "representativeText": "Each FORRT cluster is broken down into sub-categories to provide educators with useful information on the extent of open scholarship and how topics are connected to one another.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c192",
      "osft-doc-1878/c190"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c196",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c196",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's self-assessment tool delineates a clear path forward, per knowledge area.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c196",
      "osft-doc-1878/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c197",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c197",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's self-assessment tool differentiates between information and application.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c197",
      "osft-doc-1878/c195"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c198",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c198",
    "representativeText": "There are no prerequisites to use FORRT's self-assessment tool.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c198",
      "osft-doc-1878/c196"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c200",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c200",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's self-assessment protocol facilitates the translation of educational ideals into a tangible and coherent framework.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c200",
      "osft-doc-1878/c198"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c202",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c202",
    "representativeText": "Data generated by FORRT's self-assessment tool may be useful for the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c202",
      "osft-doc-1878/c200"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c203",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c203",
    "representativeText": "Collecting anonymized information from educators makes it possible to assess and track how much open and reproducible content is being integrated into courses across institutions and countries.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c203",
      "osft-doc-1878/c201"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c204",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c204",
    "representativeText": "Data from FORRT's self-assessment tool may help highlight the challenges faced by educators of different backgrounds and diverse disciplines.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c204",
      "osft-doc-1878/c202"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c206",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c206",
    "representativeText": "Data from FORRT's self-assessment tool may help substantiate the advocacy of scientific organizations and agencies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c206",
      "osft-doc-1878/c204"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c207",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c207",
    "representativeText": "Data from FORRT's self-assessment tool provides the community with an overview of current practices in open and reproducible education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c207",
      "osft-doc-1878/c205"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c208",
    "representativeText": "This overview may elucidate the factors behind the emergence, development, and sustainability of scientific integrity, principled teaching, and open education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c208",
      "osft-doc-1878/c206"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c210",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c210",
    "representativeText": "Cumulative development in teaching is indispensable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c210",
      "osft-doc-1878/c207"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c215",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c215",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's database of curated resources increases the findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reusability (FAIR) of such resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c215",
      "osft-doc-1878/c211"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c219",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c219",
    "representativeText": "The community is critical to helping keep FORRT's database of curated resources up to date.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c219",
      "osft-doc-1878/c216"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c220",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c220",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's database of curated resources is designed by the community, for the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c220",
      "osft-doc-1878/c217"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c221",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c221",
    "representativeText": "Contributors should label resources according to their type, educational level, language, conditions of use, subject area, and primary user, and add useful tags.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c221",
      "osft-doc-1878/c218"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c223",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c223",
    "representativeText": "Anyone can contribute to FORRT's database of curated resources by submitting new resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c223",
      "osft-doc-1878/c221"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c224",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c224",
    "representativeText": "Small-time commitments made by the community can yield meaningful improvements in organizing current resources on open-scholarship education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c224",
      "osft-doc-1878/c222"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c227",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c227",
    "representativeText": "Members of the community can search FORRT's database of curated resources by cluster or by using specific search terms.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c227",
      "osft-doc-1878/c225"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c228",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c228",
    "representativeText": "Scholars and educators are constantly updating their knowledge and vocabulary as the landscape of open scholarship evolves.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c228",
      "osft-doc-1878/c226"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c23",
    "representativeText": "Openness helps researchers advance academic research by considering the boundary conditions under which findings hold.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c23",
      "osft-doc-1878/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c234",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c234",
    "representativeText": "Each term in FORRT's glossary is presented together with a brief definition, using non-technical language and appropriate references.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c234",
      "osft-doc-1878/c232"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c236",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c236",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's glossary is a crowdsourced project, cutting across experts and students, where definitions of terms are provided and agreed upon via consensus-based methodology by the users of that terminology.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c236",
      "osft-doc-1878/c234"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c237",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c237",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's glossary prioritises terms relating to social justice for inclusion.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c237",
      "osft-doc-1878/c235"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c238",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c238",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's summaries contain the article's abstract.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c238",
      "osft-doc-1878/c236"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c239",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c239",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's summaries contain the article's main takeaways.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c239",
      "osft-doc-1878/c237"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c24",
    "representativeText": "Openness helps researchers test competing hypotheses about the underlying processes of findings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c24",
      "osft-doc-1878/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c240",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c240",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's summaries contain direct quotes when relevant.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c240",
      "osft-doc-1878/c238"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c241",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c241",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's summaries contain suggestions of articles on similar topics.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c241",
      "osft-doc-1878/c239"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c244",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c244",
    "representativeText": "Each of FORRT's summaries is drafted by a member of FORRT's community and then revised by two other independent FORRT members.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c244",
      "osft-doc-1878/c242"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c246",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c246",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's summaries are continuously extended.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c246",
      "osft-doc-1878/c244"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c248",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c248",
    "representativeText": "There is growing awareness of the benefits of training in open scholarship methods within research practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c248",
      "osft-doc-1878/c246"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c250",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c250",
    "representativeText": "Many pedagogical resources are regularly developed for facilitating open scholarship engagement but are not often openly and actively shared with the wider community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c250",
      "osft-doc-1878/c249"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c251",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c251",
    "representativeText": "The dearth of available ready-to-use educational resources may be a reason pedagogical resources are not often openly shared with the wider community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c251",
      "osft-doc-1878/c250"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c256",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c256",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's lesson plans are neither static nor rigid.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c256",
      "osft-doc-1878/c252"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c257",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c257",
    "representativeText": "Replications of previous scientific work are at the core of the Open Scholarship movement.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c257",
      "osft-doc-1878/c253"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c258",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c258",
    "representativeText": "Successful and failed replications are important in informing teaching.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c258",
      "osft-doc-1878/c254"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c259",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c259",
    "representativeText": "Successful and failed replications are important in informing new research projects.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c259",
      "osft-doc-1878/c255"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c260",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c260",
    "representativeText": "Replication efforts are becoming more widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c260",
      "osft-doc-1878/c256"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c261",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c261",
    "representativeText": "It is challenging for scholars and educators to keep up to date with which effects in their field replicate and which do not.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c261",
      "osft-doc-1878/c257"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c262",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c262",
    "representativeText": "A reversal effect is when an effect has its original direction flipped in a replication.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c262",
      "osft-doc-1878/c258"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c265",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c265",
    "representativeText": "A scientific claim qualifies for inclusion in FORRT's reversals and replications collection if it has failed to replicate.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c265",
      "osft-doc-1878/c261"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c266",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c266",
    "representativeText": "A scientific claim qualifies for inclusion in FORRT's reversals and replications collection if it was studied in a meta-analysis and effect sizes were notably smaller than the original ones.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c266",
      "osft-doc-1878/c262"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c267",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c267",
    "representativeText": "A scientific claim qualifies for inclusion in FORRT's reversals and replications collection if the presence of publication bias regarding the claim has been detected.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c267",
      "osft-doc-1878/c263"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c268",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c268",
    "representativeText": "A scientific claim qualifies for inclusion in FORRT's reversals and replications collection if clear errors in the analysis related to the original effect have been pointed out.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c268",
      "osft-doc-1878/c264"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c269",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c269",
    "representativeText": "A scientific claim qualifies for inclusion in FORRT's reversals and replications collection if the claim was formally retracted.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c269",
      "osft-doc-1878/c265"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c270",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c270",
    "representativeText": "A scientific claim qualifies for inclusion in FORRT's reversals and replications collection if there is evidence of fraud related to the original effect.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c270",
      "osft-doc-1878/c266"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c274",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c274",
    "representativeText": "For each week of FORRT's syllabus, there are suggestions of core and additional readings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c274",
      "osft-doc-1878/c269"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c277",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c277",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's syllabus is not intended to be a one-size-fits-all approach.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c277",
      "osft-doc-1878/c272"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c278",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c278",
    "representativeText": "Educators can use FORRT's syllabus in its current format.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c278",
      "osft-doc-1878/c273"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c279",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c279",
    "representativeText": "Educators may adapt FORRT's syllabus to meet their current courses and needs.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c279",
      "osft-doc-1878/c274"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c28",
    "representativeText": "Openness is a social justice imperative.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c28",
      "osft-doc-1878/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c288",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c288",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's pedagogies aim to highlight the instructor and their educational method.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c288",
      "osft-doc-1878/c281"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c290",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c290",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's pedagogies initiative may contribute in the long term to fostering social justice through the opening and democratization of educational resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c290",
      "osft-doc-1878/c282"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c292",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c292",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's Educators' Corner aims to recognize the efforts of educators in developing classes, materials, tools and initiatives regarding principled education and social justice in academia.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c292",
      "osft-doc-1878/c284"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c293",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c293",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's Educators' Corner can increase the visibility of educators' efforts towards principled education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c293",
      "osft-doc-1878/c285"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c296",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c296",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's open office hours are free to access and hosted online by members of the FORRT community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c296",
      "osft-doc-1878/c289"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c297",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c297",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to facilitate and encourage the transition to open and reproducible research practices by students in the early stages of their academic life.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c297",
      "osft-doc-1878/c290"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c298",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c298",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's Remote Mentorship Program matches interested students from underprivileged and underrepresented backgrounds, non-WEIRD students, and students without access to local open-scholarship-friendly institutions or personnel to willing mentor scholars for cross-border or online mentoring of theses.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c298",
      "osft-doc-1878/c291"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c304",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c304",
    "representativeText": "Underprivileged and underrepresented minorities who are early-career researchers often suffer significant barriers to their professional development.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c304",
      "osft-doc-1878/c294"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c305",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c305",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to promote the thriving of underprivileged and underrepresented students, trainees, and early-career scholars by serving as a link between willing mentors and mentees.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c305",
      "osft-doc-1878/c295"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c306",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c306",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's support initiative for underprivileged and underrepresented early-career scholars works in the same way as FORRT's remote mentorship program, except that mentorship is more broadly construed to help with academic tasks beyond academic theses.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c306",
      "osft-doc-1878/c296"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c307",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c307",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's goal is to align the ideals of wider discourses around credibility and open science with the practices of the day-to-day work of scholars and educators.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c307",
      "osft-doc-1878/c297"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c309",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c309",
    "representativeText": "FORRT fills a niche in the emerging ecology of open scholarship initiatives with its specific targeting.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c309",
      "osft-doc-1878/c299"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c310",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c310",
    "representativeText": "The TOP Guidelines, DORA, and the Hong Kong Principles are aimed at the outputs of the academic system at different levels, from individual researchers to institutions like journals, funding bodies, and universities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c310",
      "osft-doc-1878/c300"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c314",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c314",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's focus on teaching and education corresponds to a ground-level approach to open scholarship reform, whereas most existing initiatives aim at structural or systemic aspects of academic work.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c314",
      "osft-doc-1878/c304"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c315",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c315",
    "representativeText": "The TOP Guidelines, DORA, the Hong Kong Principles and other such initiatives incentivize open and reproducible research practices by providing standards for evaluating and rewarding research outcomes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c315",
      "osft-doc-1878/c305"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c316",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c316",
    "representativeText": "Journals, funders, and academic institutions put in place policies and infrastructures to improve research practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c316",
      "osft-doc-1878/c306"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c319",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c319",
    "representativeText": "Principled research training exposes students to a more honest educational process, especially with respect to the ethical and epistemic commitments that are at the heart of the scientific enterprise.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c319",
      "osft-doc-1878/c309"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c320",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c320",
    "representativeText": "A principled approach to open and reproducible methods of education generates an atmosphere of constructive curiosity and problem-solving in the classroom.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c320",
      "osft-doc-1878/c310"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c322",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c322",
    "representativeText": "First-hand practical experience in probing the production of knowledge turns students into more competent consumers and creators of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c322",
      "osft-doc-1878/c312"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c323",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c323",
    "representativeText": "Bringing academic activity into greater reach for students fosters a more confident consideration of research-based options within and outside of academia in students' career planning.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c323",
      "osft-doc-1878/c313"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c33",
    "representativeText": "Open science can save lives, for example by promoting awareness among citizens or building trust and support in public policies during a pandemic.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c33",
      "osft-doc-1878/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c330",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c330",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to improve the conditions for the production of knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c330",
      "osft-doc-1878/c321"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c331",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c331",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to increase science's value as a public good that is accessible to all members of society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c331",
      "osft-doc-1878/c322"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c334",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c334",
    "representativeText": "Advocacy for the use of science as a public good builds up societal capacity to prevent harmful effects that may come from mis- and disinformation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c334",
      "osft-doc-1878/c325"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c338",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c338",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's community and infrastructure create opportunities for scholars to shape the minds and future of coming generations of scientists and consumers of science that were not available before.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c338",
      "osft-doc-1878/c329"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c339",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c339",
    "representativeText": "Scholars have a responsibility to influence their students in a meaningful way.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c339",
      "osft-doc-1878/c331"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c34",
    "representativeText": "Research transparency has attracted renewed attention in the last decade.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c34",
      "osft-doc-1878/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c340",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c340",
    "representativeText": "Scholars can broaden the horizons of their students' imagination.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c340",
      "osft-doc-1878/c332"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c341",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c341",
    "representativeText": "Scholars can teach their students how to do research independently.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c341",
      "osft-doc-1878/c333"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c342",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c342",
    "representativeText": "Scholars can help their students discover connections between phenomena that seem unrelated at first.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c342",
      "osft-doc-1878/c334"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c343",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c343",
    "representativeText": "Scholars can develop in their students the confidence to challenge outdated dogma.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c343",
      "osft-doc-1878/c335"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c347",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c347",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship includes all scholarly activities beyond research, such as teaching.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c347",
      "osft-doc-1878/c338"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c348",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c348",
    "representativeText": "The notion of principled teaching applies to the production of knowledge in general, not just to quantitative sciences.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c348",
      "osft-doc-1878/c339"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c35",
    "representativeText": "There is growing awareness of the misalignment of incentives in the current system of academic publishing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c35",
      "osft-doc-1878/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c37",
    "representativeText": "Questionable research practices are considerably prevalent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c37",
      "osft-doc-0680/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-0680"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c38",
    "representativeText": "Questionable research practices have adverse consequences.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c38",
      "osft-doc-0680/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-0680"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c42",
    "representativeText": "Discussions about a crisis have turned into a movement with many transparency-themed initiatives being formed in recent years.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c42",
      "osft-doc-1878/c43"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c46",
    "representativeText": "Many of the potential benefits of teaching and training in open scholarship remain undiscovered.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c46",
      "osft-doc-1878/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c47",
    "representativeText": "Where institutions have attempted to include open scholarship into their educational offerings, they have often done so through the lens of research integrity, addressing this primarily within their research community rather than for their students.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c47",
      "osft-doc-1878/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c52",
    "representativeText": "FORRT aims to generate and sustain a conversation about the ethics and social impact of a higher-education pedagogy that emphasizes themes of scholarly openness, epistemic uncertainty, and research credibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c52",
      "osft-doc-1878/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c53",
    "representativeText": "FORRT responds to calls for a wider interpretation of open scholarship as inclusive scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c53",
      "osft-doc-1878/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c56",
    "representativeText": "Teachers and their students commonly experience barriers when incorporating open scholarship in teaching and learning.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c56",
      "osft-doc-1878/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c57",
    "representativeText": "In higher education, the role of educating students and kindling their passion for knowledge typically falls on academic faculty or staff.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c57",
      "osft-doc-1878/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c59",
    "representativeText": "The view that scholars are better equipped to impart knowledge to students that they have gained through their research is a key part of the academic ethos.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c59",
      "osft-doc-1878/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c60",
    "representativeText": "Researchers on the cutting edge of their discipline have the expertise to provide students with a sense of authenticity and excitement through active involvement and contributions to the field's advancements.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c60",
      "osft-doc-1878/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c61",
    "representativeText": "Educator-researchers are more effective at instilling an actively critical approach to understanding complex research findings than a passive acceptance of facts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c61",
      "osft-doc-1878/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c62",
    "representativeText": "Academics must know a given set of scientific facts to be inspiring educators.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c62",
      "osft-doc-1878/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c63",
    "representativeText": "Academics must be familiar with the procedures by which scholarly knowledge is generated to be inspiring educators.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c63",
      "osft-doc-1878/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c66",
    "representativeText": "A collection of scientific evidence, or its unreflective and decontextualized communication, does not yield scientific literacy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c66",
      "osft-doc-1878/c64"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c68",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c68",
    "representativeText": "Educational programs should be built around the development of abilities that give rise to responsible conduct.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c68",
      "osft-doc-1878/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c69",
    "representativeText": "Education in the responsible conduct of research should be provided within the context of the overall education program.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c69",
      "osft-doc-1878/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c7",
    "representativeText": "Engaging students with open scholarship allows them to better understand findings in light of epistemic uncertainty.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c7",
      "osft-doc-1878/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c71",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c71",
    "representativeText": "Training in open and reproducible research practices yields similar benefits to education in the responsible conduct of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c71",
      "osft-doc-1878/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c72",
    "representativeText": "Scholarship is a system of methods of inquiry and knowledge production.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c72",
      "osft-doc-1878/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c74",
    "representativeText": "Many of the changes encouraged to foster adoption of open scholarship in the last decade have been grassroots campaigns sparked and sustained by individual early adopters, rather than top-down initiatives at the institutional level.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c74",
      "osft-doc-1878/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c76",
    "representativeText": "The asymmetries in adoption of open scholarship practices are reinforced by privilege.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c76",
      "osft-doc-1878/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c79",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c79",
    "representativeText": "It is still common that students finish their studies without learning about open scholarship during their studies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c79",
      "osft-doc-1878/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c81",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c81",
    "representativeText": "It is difficult to find evidence of social science programs requiring any training in open scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c81",
      "osft-doc-1878/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c9",
    "representativeText": "Teaching students about open scholarship reduces knowledge inequities in academia and beyond.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c9",
      "osft-doc-1878/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c91",
    "representativeText": "The majority of higher education students will not pursue an academic career.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c91",
      "osft-doc-1878/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c92",
    "representativeText": "Higher education presents a valuable opportunity to teach prospective consumers of research how scientific research is conducted in an open and transparent manner.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c92",
      "osft-doc-1878/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c93",
    "representativeText": "Higher education presents a valuable opportunity to teach prospective consumers of research how to evaluate research critically.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c93",
      "osft-doc-1878/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c95",
    "representativeText": "Students' impressions of how they envision, evaluate, and trust science strongly influence how they will interact with science in their future.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c95",
      "osft-doc-1878/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c97",
    "representativeText": "The current model of scientific production and educational practices contributes to and reproduces global inequalities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c97",
      "osft-doc-1878/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0441/c99",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0441/c99",
    "representativeText": "Science has inherited many of society's systematic barriers hindering the success of traditionally marginalized groups based on gender, race, ethnicity, origin, or social class.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0441/c99",
      "osft-doc-1878/c93"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c10",
    "representativeText": "Open access is economically feasible.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c10",
      "osft-doc-1124/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c14",
    "representativeText": "The more who join the effort to advance open access, the sooner the benefits of open access will be enjoyed by all.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c14",
      "osft-doc-1124/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c16",
    "representativeText": "The literature that should be freely accessible online primarily encompasses scholars' peer-reviewed journal articles.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c16",
      "osft-doc-1124/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c17",
    "representativeText": "The literature that should be freely accessible online also includes unreviewed preprints that scholars might wish to put online for comment or to alert colleagues to important research findings.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c17",
      "osft-doc-1124/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c19",
    "representativeText": "The only constraint on reproduction and distribution, and the only role for copyright in the domain of open access, should be to give authors control over the integrity of their work.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c19",
      "osft-doc-1124/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c24",
    "representativeText": "There is a strong incentive for professional associations, universities, libraries, foundations, and others to embrace open access as a means of advancing their missions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c24",
      "osft-doc-1124/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c26",
    "representativeText": "Open access is an attainable goal, not merely preferable or utopian.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c26",
      "osft-doc-1124/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c27",
    "representativeText": "Scholars need the tools and assistance to deposit their refereed journal articles in open electronic archives.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c27",
      "osft-doc-1124/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c29",
    "representativeText": "When archives conform to standards created by the Open Archives Initiative, search engines and other tools can treat the separate archives as one.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c29",
      "osft-doc-1124/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c30",
    "representativeText": "Users need not know which archives exist or where they are located in order to find and make use of their contents.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c30",
      "osft-doc-1124/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c31",
    "representativeText": "Scholars need the means to launch a new generation of journals committed to open access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c31",
      "osft-doc-1124/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c32",
    "representativeText": "Scholars need the means to help existing journals that elect to make the transition to open access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c32",
      "osft-doc-1124/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c36",
    "representativeText": "Price is a barrier to access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c36",
      "osft-doc-1124/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c43",
    "representativeText": "Self-archiving and open-access journals are within the reach of scholars themselves, immediately, without needing to wait on changes brought about by markets or legislation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c43",
      "osft-doc-1124/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c45",
    "representativeText": "Flexibility, experimentation, and adaptation to local circumstances are the best ways to assure that progress toward open access in diverse settings will be rapid, secure, and long-lived.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c45",
      "osft-doc-1124/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c5",
    "representativeText": "Removing access barriers to the peer-reviewed journal literature will enrich education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c5",
      "osft-doc-1124/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c50",
    "representativeText": "The Open Society Institute's commitment and resources are substantial.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c50",
      "osft-doc-1124/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c8",
    "representativeText": "Removing access barriers to the peer-reviewed journal literature will lay the foundation for uniting humanity in a common intellectual conversation and quest for knowledge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c8",
      "osft-doc-1124/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0504/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0504/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open access has so far been limited to small portions of the journal literature.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0504/c9",
      "osft-doc-1124/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0504",
      "osft-doc-1124"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0633/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0633/c53",
    "representativeText": "Software and data are becoming increasingly critical pillars for scientific progress.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0633/c53",
      "osft-doc-1869/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0633/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0633/c60",
    "representativeText": "Strengthening the security of open science software and data lays a strong foundation for future innovations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0633/c60",
      "osft-doc-1193/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-1193"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c106",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c106",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Guiding Principles precede implementation choices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c106",
      "osft-doc-0971/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-0971"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c22",
    "representativeText": "Improving knowledge discovery by assisting both humans and their computational agents in the discovery, access, integration, and analysis of task-appropriate scientific data and other scholarly digital objects is one of the grand challenges of data-intensive science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c22",
      "osft-doc-1197/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c3",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Principles support data reuse by individuals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c3",
      "osft-doc-1940/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c30",
    "representativeText": "There is an emergence of numerous general-purpose data repositories at scales ranging from institutional to open globally-scoped repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c30",
      "osft-doc-1449/c218"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c34",
    "representativeText": "The resulting data ecosystem appears to be moving away from centralization.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c34",
      "osft-doc-1195/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1195"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c88",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c88",
    "representativeText": "(Meta)data should be retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communications protocol.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c88",
      "osft-doc-1197/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c89",
    "representativeText": "The communications protocol used to retrieve (meta)data should be open, free, and universally implementable.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c89",
      "osft-doc-1197/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c91",
    "representativeText": "Metadata should be accessible even when the data are no longer available.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c91",
      "osft-doc-1197/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c93",
    "representativeText": "(Meta)data should use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c93",
      "osft-doc-1197/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0645/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0645/c94",
    "representativeText": "(Meta)data should include qualified references to other (meta)data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0645/c94",
      "osft-doc-1197/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c22",
    "representativeText": "Errors, gaps, and biases in closed research information are difficult to expose.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c22",
      "open-science-source-05/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c25",
    "representativeText": "Indicators and analytics derived from closed research information lack reproducibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c25",
      "open-science-source-05/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0730/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0730/c50",
    "representativeText": "In a research assessment context, openness of research information guarantees that both those performing an assessment and those being assessed have access to all evidence considered in the assessment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0730/c50",
      "open-science-source-05/c47"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0731/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0731/c1",
    "representativeText": "Findable (meta)data are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0731/c1",
      "osft-doc-1940/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0731",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0731/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0731/c5",
    "representativeText": "Accessible (meta)data are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communications protocol.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0731/c5",
      "osft-doc-1940/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0731",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0731/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0731/c6",
    "representativeText": "The communications protocol used to access data is open, free, and universally implementable.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0731/c6",
      "osft-doc-1940/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0731",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0731/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0731/c7",
    "representativeText": "The communications protocol used to access data allows for an authentication and authorization procedure, where necessary.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0731/c7",
      "osft-doc-1940/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0731",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0731/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0731/c8",
    "representativeText": "Metadata remain accessible even when the data they describe are no longer available.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0731/c8",
      "osft-doc-1940/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0731",
      "osft-doc-1940"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0777/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0777/c27",
    "representativeText": "Promotion of openness is a community-led effort.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0777/c27",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c197"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-37-c1",
      "osft-doc-0777"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0785/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0785/c5",
    "representativeText": "Member States should prioritize fostering a culture of open science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0785/c5",
      "osft-doc-0002/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0785"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0785/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0785/c7",
    "representativeText": "Member States should prioritize promoting innovative approaches to open science at different stages of the scientific process.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0785/c7",
      "osft-doc-0002/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0002",
      "osft-doc-0785"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c1",
    "representativeText": "The power of research must be unleashed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c1",
      "osft-doc-1398/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c10",
    "representativeText": "Armed conflict becomes far more probable as new planetary operating conditions emerge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c10",
      "osft-doc-1398/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c11",
    "representativeText": "New pandemics become far more probable as new planetary operating conditions emerge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c11",
      "osft-doc-1398/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c12",
    "representativeText": "The fundamental mechanisms behind climate change are understood.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c12",
      "osft-doc-1398/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c13",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c13",
    "representativeText": "Most nations are not ready to abandon fossil fuels.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c13",
      "osft-doc-1398/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c14",
    "representativeText": "The investment required for restructuring and rebuilding cities, mines, farms, industries, and transport systems to create a zero-carbon emission world is prohibitive for many nations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c14",
      "osft-doc-1398/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c15",
    "representativeText": "Progress toward a zero-carbon world can be accelerated if universities, funding agencies, and governments work together to put forward policy and legislation providing unrestricted access to publicly funded scientific research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c15",
      "osft-doc-1398/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c17",
    "representativeText": "Knowledge locked behind paywalls slows down societal progress.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c17",
      "osft-doc-1398/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c18",
    "representativeText": "Knowledge locked behind paywalls holds back industries and entrepreneurs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c18",
      "osft-doc-1398/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c19",
    "representativeText": "Knowledge locked behind paywalls delays access of knowledge to practitioners.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c19",
      "osft-doc-1398/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c2",
    "representativeText": "The public's trust in science must be reassured.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c2",
      "osft-doc-1398/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c20",
    "representativeText": "Knowledge locked behind paywalls diminishes the public's trust in science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c20",
      "osft-doc-1398/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c23",
    "representativeText": "Open Science empowers the public to participate in choosing among the transformative options that scientific advancements offer society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c23",
      "osft-doc-1398/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c31",
    "representativeText": "Exposing the scientific method to society has become more important than ever before.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c31",
      "osft-doc-1398/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c34",
    "representativeText": "The innovation cycle must be expedited.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c34",
      "osft-doc-1398/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c35",
    "representativeText": "The deployment of technologies must be accelerated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c35",
      "osft-doc-1398/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c36",
    "representativeText": "The public's trust in science must be maintained.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c36",
      "osft-doc-1398/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c4",
    "representativeText": "Destabilizing the global ecosystem is an even greater threat than COVID-19 to human health and well-being.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c4",
      "osft-doc-1398/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c42",
    "representativeText": "Universities and research organizations have the power to foster innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c42",
      "osft-doc-1398/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c43",
    "representativeText": "Universities and research organizations have the power to tackle the pressing challenges that affect communities worldwide.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c43",
      "osft-doc-1398/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c46",
    "representativeText": "The shift to open science reduces publishing costs by introducing transparency.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c46",
      "osft-doc-1398/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c48",
    "representativeText": "Free market competition for the highest quality publishing services will lower costs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c48",
      "osft-doc-1398/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c5",
    "representativeText": "Human activity has pushed Earth's natural equilibrium beyond the tipping point for six of the nine planetary boundaries.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c5",
      "osft-doc-1398/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c50",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should transition all academic journals to fully open-access models by 2030.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c50",
      "osft-doc-1398/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c51",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should preserve and champion registration as a core value of scientific publishing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c51",
      "osft-doc-1398/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c52",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should preserve and champion validation as a core value of scientific publishing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c52",
      "osft-doc-1398/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c53",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should preserve and champion certification as a core value of scientific publishing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c53",
      "osft-doc-1398/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c57",
    "representativeText": "Transparent pricing linked to quality is a foundational principle that is prevalent in other industries but glaringly absent in academic publishing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c57",
      "osft-doc-1398/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c59",
    "representativeText": "Academic publishers should promote transparent publishing practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c59",
      "osft-doc-1398/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c6",
    "representativeText": "New planetary operating conditions will directly impact every life as local ecosystems collapse.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c6",
      "osft-doc-1398/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c60",
    "representativeText": "The opacity and economic flaws of traditional subscription models enable and embolden malpractice in academic publishing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c60",
      "osft-doc-1398/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c61",
    "representativeText": "A competitive environment, paired with transparent pricing tied to service quality, can effectively root out malpractice-related side effects in academic publishing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c61",
      "osft-doc-1398/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c64",
    "representativeText": "In a future without boundaries to scientific knowledge, society is empowered to make informed decisions.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c64",
      "osft-doc-1398/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c7",
    "representativeText": "New planetary operating conditions will catastrophically impact life on the social level as food systems and global supply chains break down.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c7",
      "osft-doc-1398/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c8",
    "representativeText": "Mass migration becomes far more probable as new planetary operating conditions emerge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c8",
      "osft-doc-1398/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0825/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0825/c9",
    "representativeText": "Geopolitical insecurity becomes far more probable as new planetary operating conditions emerge.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0825/c9",
      "osft-doc-1398/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c102",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c102",
    "representativeText": "Trust is built on the pillar of believable insurance mechanisms for when something goes wrong.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c102",
      "osft-doc-1287/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c103",
    "representativeText": "Once the community can determine when a service should transition to community governance, the community must take responsibility for making that decision.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c103",
      "osft-doc-1287/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c11",
    "representativeText": "A lack of community engagement leads to a lack of community control.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c11",
      "osft-doc-1287/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c12",
    "representativeText": "A lack of community engagement leads to the locking up of community resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c12",
      "osft-doc-1287/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c17",
    "representativeText": "Successful infrastructure is trusted and relied on by the broad community it serves.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c17",
      "osft-doc-1287/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c2",
    "representativeText": "Data about the research process deserves the same level of respect and care as data supporting research claims.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c2",
      "osft-doc-1287/c2"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c22",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure organisations must not confuse serving themselves with serving their stakeholders.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c22",
      "osft-doc-1287/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c3",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly community does not own or control most of the information generated about the research process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c3",
      "osft-doc-1287/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c4",
    "representativeText": "The metadata generated in scholarly online discussions is increasingly held by private enterprises.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c4",
      "osft-doc-1287/c4"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c40",
    "representativeText": "Infrastructure organisations and their staff should have direct incentives to wind down.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c40",
      "osft-doc-0756/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0756",
      "osft-doc-0836"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c42",
    "representativeText": "Trust comprises intentions.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c42",
      "osft-doc-1287/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c44",
    "representativeText": "Trust comprises checks and balances.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c44",
      "osft-doc-1287/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c46",
    "representativeText": "Time-limited funds should be used only for time-limited activities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c46",
      "osft-doc-1287/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c6",
    "representativeText": "Private enterprises holding this metadata have no obligation to continue providing services at their current rates, particularly when that rate is zero.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c6",
      "osft-doc-1287/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c7",
    "representativeText": "Private enterprise has the strength of innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c7",
      "osft-doc-1287/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c70",
    "representativeText": "Acts that reduce the feasibility of forking are strong signals that concerns should be raised.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c70",
      "osft-doc-1287/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c8",
    "representativeText": "Private enterprise has the strength of customer focus.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c8",
      "osft-doc-1287/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c80",
    "representativeText": "The most obvious business model for an infrastructure organisation is currently a board-governed, not-for-profit membership organisation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c80",
      "osft-doc-1287/c82"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c82",
    "representativeText": "The process by which a governing group is established and refreshed needs careful consideration and community engagement.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c82",
      "osft-doc-1287/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c84",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c84",
    "representativeText": "The need for forkability implies centralization of control.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c84",
      "osft-doc-1287/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c86",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c86",
    "representativeText": "Federation tends to beget centralisation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c86",
      "osft-doc-1287/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c9",
    "representativeText": "There is a lot of exciting innovation in the scholarly infrastructure space, much of it coming from private, for-profit interests or public-private partnerships.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c9",
      "osft-doc-1287/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c90",
    "representativeText": "Google Scholar is a widely used infrastructure service.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c90",
      "osft-doc-1287/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c91",
    "representativeText": "Google Scholar has no responsibility to the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c91",
      "osft-doc-1287/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c92",
    "representativeText": "Google Scholar's revenue model and sustainability are opaque.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c92",
      "osft-doc-1287/c93"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c93",
    "representativeText": "Centralization can be hugely advantageous.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c93",
      "osft-doc-1287/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c95",
    "representativeText": "If trust is tackled directly rather than using federation to avoid the question of who can be trusted, infrastructure organisations should not need to federate for merely political reasons.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c95",
      "osft-doc-1287/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c96",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c96",
    "representativeText": "ORCID probably comes closest among existing infrastructure organisations to satisfying these principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c96",
      "osft-doc-1287/c98"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c97",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c97",
    "representativeText": "The ORCID principles represented the first attempt to address the issue of community trust.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c97",
      "osft-doc-1287/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c98",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c98",
    "representativeText": "Technical approaches such as federation have often been used in the past to combat the fear that a system can be co-opted or controlled by unaccountable parties.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c98",
      "osft-doc-1287/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0836/c99",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0836/c99",
    "representativeText": "The community must consider how to create accountable and trustworthy organisations.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0836/c99",
      "osft-doc-1287/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0846/c3",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0846/c3",
    "representativeText": "Research software is essential to all types of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0846/c3",
      "osft-doc-0932/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0846",
      "osft-doc-0932"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0860/c18",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0860/c18",
    "representativeText": "Information should be available for investigation and reuse by the community.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0860/c18",
      "open-science-source-09/c18"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-09",
      "osft-doc-0860"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0900/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0900/c10",
    "representativeText": "Access to knowledge is needed to address many other global challenges.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0900/c10",
      "osft-doc-0114/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0114",
      "osft-doc-0900"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0932/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0932/c7",
    "representativeText": "Improving the practice of scholarship is a common goal of the open science, open source, and FAIR communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0932/c7",
      "osft-doc-1327/c1071"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0932",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c1",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science's guidelines and recommendations apply to research by federally employed researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c1",
      "osft-doc-1399/c5"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c17",
    "representativeText": "Federal departments and agencies should have open science action plans in place by October 2020.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c17",
      "osft-doc-1399/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c2",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c2",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science's guidelines and recommendations apply to research contracted by federal departments and agencies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c2",
      "osft-doc-1399/c6"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c26",
    "representativeText": "The Chief Science Advisor should work with the federal science community to develop a framework for identifying research that should not be made openly available due to ethical, privacy, or security concerns.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c26",
      "osft-doc-1399/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c27",
    "representativeText": "Strategies developed in response to the 2018 Data Strategy Roadmap, the Open Science Action Plan, and open government directives should be well aligned, under the guidance of a Chief Scientific Data Officer.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c27",
      "osft-doc-1399/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c32",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science is well aligned with INKE's mandate of researching and supporting open social scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c32",
      "osft-doc-1399/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c33",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science is aligned with many of INKE's partners' and members' open access mandates.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c33",
      "osft-doc-1399/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c34",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science has implications for open scholarship on a global scale.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c34",
      "osft-doc-1399/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c35",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap for Open Science applies to scientific publications only.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c35",
      "osft-doc-1399/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c6",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c6",
    "representativeText": "Open Science's scientific inputs, outputs and processes include peer-reviewed articles.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c6",
      "osft-doc-1399/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0951/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0951/c8",
    "representativeText": "Open Science's scientific inputs, outputs and processes include public-facing communications.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0951/c8",
      "osft-doc-1399/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0963/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0963/c42",
    "representativeText": "CoreTrustSeal certification indicates that a repository meets the majority of the Enabling FAIR Data project's repository criteria and more.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0963/c42",
      "osft-doc-1507/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1507"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0963/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0963/c45",
    "representativeText": "Significant change is difficult to achieve within and across domains unless many stakeholders adopt similar policies and practices in a coordinated way.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0963/c45",
      "osft-doc-1327/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0963",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0975/c29",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0975/c29",
    "representativeText": "Open science fosters an open approach that makes use, as appropriate, of flexibilities that exist in intellectual property systems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0975/c29",
      "open-science-source-03/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0975/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0975/c30",
    "representativeText": "Open science practices fostering openness, transparency and inclusiveness already exist worldwide.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0975/c30",
      "open-science-source-03/c28"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-03",
      "osft-doc-0975"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1027/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1027/c92",
    "representativeText": "FAIR and Open are two interdependent issues that are related but not synonymous.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1027/c92",
      "open-science-source-26/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-26",
      "osft-doc-1027"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1031/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1031/c22",
    "representativeText": "Open and Collaborative Science fosters equitable collaboration between scientists and social actors.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1031/c22",
      "open-science-source-27/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-27",
      "osft-doc-1031"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1047/c4",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1047/c4",
    "representativeText": "The University must provide clear guidance on the use of quantitative indicators in research evaluation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1047/c4",
      "osft-doc-1449/c401"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1047",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1124/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1124/c20",
    "representativeText": "There are many degrees and kinds of wider and easier access to scholarly literature.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1124/c20",
      "osft-doc-1327/c313"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1124",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1171/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1171/c12",
    "representativeText": "Researchers hold themselves accountable by making their work openly available, supporting reproducibility, identifying errors, and enabling others to build on their findings.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1171/c12",
      "osft-doc-1449/c402"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1171",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1193/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1193/c72",
    "representativeText": "These challenges are of shared interest among open scholarship adopters.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1193/c72",
      "osft-doc-1327/c743"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1193",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1193/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1193/c76",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship OSE improves workflow efficiency.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1193/c76",
      "osft-doc-1373/c522"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1193",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1197/c19",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1197/c19",
    "representativeText": "To be reusable, (meta)data must be released with a clear and accessible data usage license.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1197/c19",
      "osft-doc-0645/c96"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0645",
      "osft-doc-1197"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1253/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1253/c58",
    "representativeText": "Global standards-setting frameworks like the UNESCO Recommendation demonstrate the vast network of scholarly communications stakeholders engaged in these efforts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1253/c58",
      "osft-doc-1327/c885"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c109",
    "representativeText": "All researchers must receive regular training and accreditation on research integrity pertaining to Open Science, including the ethical, legal and social implications of their research practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c109",
      "osft-doc-1767/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c124",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c124",
    "representativeText": "Appropriate funding and incentives need to be put in place to support Citizen Science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c124",
      "osft-doc-1449/c453"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1283/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1283/c74",
    "representativeText": "The development of policies to guarantee compliance with the EU Open Access mandate must happen in ways that are sensitive to disciplinary differences, the financial investment required and fast-changing publishing systems.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1283/c74",
      "osft-doc-1327/c736"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1283",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c16",
    "representativeText": "Successful infrastructure is stable.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c16",
      "osft-doc-0836/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1287/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1287/c63",
    "representativeText": "Even with the best possible governance structures, critical infrastructure can still drift away from the needs of the community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1287/c63",
      "osft-doc-0836/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0836",
      "osft-doc-1287"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1114",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1114",
    "representativeText": "Post-publication peer review allows articles to be quickly shared and then refined via broad feedback in real time online.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1114",
      "osft-doc-1353/c162"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1127",
    "representativeText": "Creating more open requires ensuring the scientific integrity of articles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1127",
      "osft-doc-1449/c412"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c1155",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c1155",
    "representativeText": "Uneven progress toward open is having unintended consequences.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c1155",
      "osft-doc-1869/c325"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c208",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c208",
    "representativeText": "The community must support new and entrepreneurial approaches to open.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c208",
      "osft-doc-1253/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1253",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c23",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c23",
    "representativeText": "Efforts to achieve open science should apply to all kinds of research, not solely science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c23",
      "osft-doc-1373/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c238",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c238",
    "representativeText": "Public engagement should be promoted as an area of interest/benefit convergence between HSS and science.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c238",
      "osft-doc-1767/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1767"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c296",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c296",
    "representativeText": "Libraries should support, engage, and/or collaborate on actions that continue to build out the framework for more open.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c296",
      "open-science-source-51/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-51",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c302",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c302",
    "representativeText": "There is broad support amongst libraries everywhere for open, despite wide differences in resources and definitions, aimed at providing stewardship in discovery, preserving and disseminating the scholarly record, ensuring efficient and effective use of budgets, and advocating for equitable access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c302",
      "osft-doc-1869/c307"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c562",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c562",
    "representativeText": "The easy solution isn't necessarily going to be the correct solution.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c562",
      "osft-doc-1353/c217"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1353"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c574",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c574",
    "representativeText": "New, more exciting, more rewarding ways to develop open science must be found urgently.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c574",
      "osft-doc-1449/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c659",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c659",
    "representativeText": "The evolution of the open science incentive system requires more open outreach and education.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c659",
      "osft-doc-1373/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c683",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c683",
    "representativeText": "Researchers want their work to receive credit.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c683",
      "osft-doc-1869/c94"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c687",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c687",
    "representativeText": "Alternative journal-quality metrics, such as the TOP factor, have been suggested but have yet to gain wide adoption.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c687",
      "osft-doc-1449/c457"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1353/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1353/c11",
    "representativeText": "Broad adoption of the proposed measures by researchers, institutions, funders and journals requires iterative evaluation and improvement.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1353/c11",
      "osft-doc-1612/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1353",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c100",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes that currently lack an Open Access repository should either launch and maintain one or find an existing resource to use, and adopt an Open Access policy.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c100",
      "open-science-source-02/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-02",
      "osft-doc-1373"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c128",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c128",
    "representativeText": "The UK Scholarly Communications License enables authors to retain more of their rights.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c128",
      "osft-doc-1449/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c130",
    "representativeText": "Engaging with the UK Scholarly Communications License would reduce the cost spent on hybrid APCs and BPCs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c130",
      "osft-doc-1459/c136"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c131",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c131",
    "representativeText": "Engaging with the UK Scholarly Communications License would help researchers in the UK comply with the UKRI Open Access policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c131",
      "osft-doc-1459/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c136",
    "representativeText": "National bodies should sign on to the Global Sustainability Coalition for Open Science Services.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c136",
      "osft-doc-1459/c142"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c137",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c137",
    "representativeText": "National bodies should investigate coalitions with the Open Research Funders Group.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c137",
      "osft-doc-1459/c143"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c14",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c14",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship has an inherent influence on society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c14",
      "osft-doc-1569/c14"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c140",
    "representativeText": "Plan S aims for full and immediate Open Access to publications from publicly funded research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c140",
      "osft-doc-1459/c148"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c145",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c145",
    "representativeText": "Research funders should develop calls to support evidence- and theory-based interventions to promote Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c145",
      "osft-doc-1459/c154"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c146",
    "representativeText": "Determinant studies that use behavior change theory to map the determinants of engaging in different Open Scholarship practices should be funded.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c146",
      "osft-doc-1459/c155"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c147",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c147",
    "representativeText": "Studies that use stakeholder theory to explore ways to achieve more Open Scholarship policies at research and education institutions should be funded.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c147",
      "osft-doc-1459/c156"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c15",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c15",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship has an inherent influence on global economics.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c15",
      "osft-doc-1569/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c151",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c151",
    "representativeText": "The formalisation of Open Science Training Courses should be encouraged in graduate school training programs and further.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c151",
      "osft-doc-1459/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c159",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c159",
    "representativeText": "In areas where instruction of new researchers is lacking, strategic community networks should be built to increase the strength of advocacy efforts.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c159",
      "osft-doc-1459/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c167",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c167",
    "representativeText": "Group members should be trained in a wide variety of relevant skills, including public engagement, policy development, data analysis, Web development, citizen science, and scholarly communications.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c167",
      "osft-doc-1459/c177"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c169",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c169",
    "representativeText": "Local Open Scholarship communities, including newer researchers and students, should continue to be built and empowered.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c169",
      "osft-doc-1459/c179"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c17",
    "representativeText": "Different academic fields must discuss what is culturally appropriate for themselves.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c17",
      "osft-doc-1459/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c174",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c174",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should help authors backfill open repositories with full text for the remaining works not otherwise covered.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c174",
      "osft-doc-1459/c185"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c177",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c177",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should continue working with other research institutes to share resources, infrastructure, and services in a more sustainable manner.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c177",
      "osft-doc-1459/c190"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c178",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c178",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should engage with research funders to have explicit and enforced mandates regarding Open Scholarship, without impinging upon academic freedoms.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c178",
      "osft-doc-1459/c191"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c180",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c180",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should openly share institute-level data and metrics on research activities, records and behaviour.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c180",
      "osft-doc-1459/c193"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c181",
    "representativeText": "Research assessment policies should be evidence-informed, rigorous, and adhered to at all levels.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c181",
      "osft-doc-1459/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c186",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c186",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should refuse to renew subscriptions to hybrid journals that have not attained a higher proportion of Open Access over subscription articles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c186",
      "osft-doc-1459/c199"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c192",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c192",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should begin implementation of national or international scholarly infrastructures, with cross-stakeholder agreed open standards, roadmaps, and governance structures.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c192",
      "osft-doc-1459/c205"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c194",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c194",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should publicise the outcomes of any research or investigations into the status of national-level scholarly publishing markets.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c194",
      "osft-doc-1459/c207"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c197",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c197",
    "representativeText": "National (or higher) level bodies should formulate recommended career metrics that value candidates' efforts towards open learning and teaching or open education.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c197",
      "osft-doc-1459/c211"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c20",
    "representativeText": "New realities identified by supportive learning communities can be incorporated into decision making processes.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c20",
      "osft-doc-1459/c19"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c209",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c209",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should formalize training in Open Scholarship workflows.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c209",
      "osft-doc-1459/c222"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c21",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c21",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should search for existing data they can reuse instead of creating their own data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c21",
      "osft-doc-1459/c20"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c212",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c212",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should incentivize junior scholars to practice openness in their scholarly lifecycle, including research and education.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c212",
      "osft-doc-1459/c225"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c22",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may use and support open search engines instead of proprietary services.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c22",
      "osft-doc-1459/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c224",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c224",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is analogous to a boundary object, in that it is flexibly adaptive, interpreted differently across communities but with enough immutable content to maintain its integrity.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c224",
      "osft-doc-1459/c242"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c24",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should use RSS readers to aggregate news and research updates from a number of sources.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c24",
      "osft-doc-1459/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c240",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c240",
    "representativeText": "The semantic Web promises to enhance networking, collaboration, and transparency in research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c240",
      "osft-doc-1459/c261"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c241",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c241",
    "representativeText": "There has been an undeniable explosion in the rate of innovation in scholarly communication in the last 10 years.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c241",
      "osft-doc-1459/c262"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c243",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c243",
    "representativeText": "Educational resources and research outputs should be free from unnecessary constraints on widespread re-use.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c243",
      "osft-doc-1459/c264"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c247",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c247",
    "representativeText": "The creation and management of boundary objects is a key process in developing and maintaining coherence across intersecting communities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c247",
      "osft-doc-1459/c268"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c254",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c254",
    "representativeText": "Awareness of Open Scholarship to engage with the practices (Users) is a major precondition to Open Scholarship adoption.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c254",
      "osft-doc-1673/c160"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c255",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c255",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship tools that guide adoption of practices (Process) are a major precondition to Open Scholarship adoption.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c255",
      "osft-doc-1673/c161"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c256",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c256",
    "representativeText": "Community and systemic support to create a sustainable Open Scholarship environment (Context) is a major precondition to Open Scholarship adoption.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c256",
      "osft-doc-1673/c162"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c265",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c265",
    "representativeText": "Many popular indexing services, such as Scopus and Web of Science, are explicitly biased against journals from developing countries or those that do not have English as the primary language.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c265",
      "osft-doc-1459/c293"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c266",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c266",
    "representativeText": "The narrative of Open Scholarship must integrate the diverse world-views, experiences, and challenges of Latin America, Asia, Africa and the Middle East.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c266",
      "osft-doc-1459/c294"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c267",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c267",
    "representativeText": "The term Open Science, because it contains the word 'Science', can have an adverse effect of excluding researchers from the arts, humanities, engineering, mathematics, and other fields that might not be considered to be science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c267",
      "osft-doc-1459/c295"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c268",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c268",
    "representativeText": "This exclusionary problem of the term Open Science seems mainly confined to native-English speaking researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c268",
      "osft-doc-1673/c170"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c269",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c269",
    "representativeText": "In many other languages, the word used for science is more general than in English.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c269",
      "osft-doc-1459/c297"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c27",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should establish and foster practices of re-use and remix.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c27",
      "osft-doc-1459/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c271",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c271",
    "representativeText": "Many open scientific practices are geared towards more empirical and quantitative research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c271",
      "osft-doc-1673/c172"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c276",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c276",
    "representativeText": "There are considerable barriers to preprints of industry work, including the possibility of material that has not yet been peer-reviewed being seen as promotional.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c276",
      "osft-doc-1673/c178"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c278",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c278",
    "representativeText": "The pharmaceutical industry is becoming aware of the potential for many aspects of open scholarship to improve the transparency, accessibility and speed of reporting its research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c278",
      "osft-doc-1459/c307"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c279",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c279",
    "representativeText": "In the highly regulated, compliance-focused pharmaceutical industry, which presents a substantial source of revenue to publishers, there are additional barriers to change beyond those discussed in the academic community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c279",
      "osft-doc-1459/c308"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c28",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may pre-register studies to openly document research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c28",
      "osft-doc-1459/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c287",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c287",
    "representativeText": "Conflict resolution in scholarly communication can come in a range of flavours, based around key issues such as academic freedom, governance structures, and financing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c287",
      "osft-doc-1459/c317"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c289",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c289",
    "representativeText": "The lack of well-defined objectives for Open Scholarship makes defining a pathway with clear cut stepping stones difficult.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c289",
      "osft-doc-1459/c319"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c30",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may use lab notebooks to openly document research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c30",
      "osft-doc-1459/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c301",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c301",
    "representativeText": "All the strategic sub-domain actions for Open Scholarship are, at least to some degree, important.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c301",
      "osft-doc-1673/c198"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c309",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c309",
    "representativeText": "It is unlikely that more than 10 million scholars would agree with rules created for them by a small number of people or groups with financial interest.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c309",
      "osft-doc-1673/c205"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c31",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should answer relevant questions and join discussions on public websites.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c31",
      "osft-doc-1459/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c316",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c316",
    "representativeText": "A number of recent initiatives exist that work towards the development of copyright frameworks that help the Open Scholarship cause.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c316",
      "osft-doc-1459/c344"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c320",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c320",
    "representativeText": "Open licences, licensing, and rights waivers for copyright should be understandable by both humans and machines.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c320",
      "osft-doc-1673/c211"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c321",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c321",
    "representativeText": "Open licensing has typically been administered through some combination of Creative Commons and Open Source licensing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c321",
      "osft-doc-1673/c212"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c322",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c322",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship should move away from patenting.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c322",
      "osft-doc-1673/c217"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c327",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c327",
    "representativeText": "Data repositories and data journals should be used more widely for sharing research outputs, without restrictions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c327",
      "osft-doc-1459/c358"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c339",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c339",
    "representativeText": "Optimisation of the knowledge creation process can be achieved through modularising the process of knowledge creation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c339",
      "osft-doc-1459/c372"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c34",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should become familiar with openly collaborative writing tools.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c34",
      "osft-doc-1459/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c344",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c344",
    "representativeText": "The process behind research should be as transparent as possible, and as closed as necessary.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c344",
      "osft-doc-1459/c377"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c35",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may use executable writing formats.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c35",
      "osft-doc-1459/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c351",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c351",
    "representativeText": "A range of Web 2.0 tools now exist to make automatic generation of research paper results as simple as possible.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c351",
      "osft-doc-1459/c381"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c353",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c353",
    "representativeText": "Sustainability of research is achieved through increased access to expertise, collaboration, knowledge aggregation, and enhanced productivity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c353",
      "osft-doc-1459/c383"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c355",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c355",
    "representativeText": "Benefaction, by starting from and expanding someone's workflow, codebase, or tools, avoids unnecessary duplication of technical tasks.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c355",
      "osft-doc-1459/c386"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c356",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c356",
    "representativeText": "Web 2.0 technologies for communication and collaboration help to facilitate increasing demands for higher productivity and research complexity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c356",
      "osft-doc-1459/c387"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c357",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c357",
    "representativeText": "Much of researchers' contribution to scholarly research in an open, collaborative, and collective manner is dependent on their willingness to do so.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c357",
      "osft-doc-1459/c388"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c358",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c358",
    "representativeText": "Researchers' motivation to contribute openly is largely down to whether they perceive the process as advantageous to them, for example getting a return on investment in social capital or prestige.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c358",
      "osft-doc-1459/c389"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c359",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c359",
    "representativeText": "Many tools to facilitate and accelerate scientific discovery, and enhance the research process, already exist in some form.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c359",
      "osft-doc-1459/c390"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c364",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c364",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly technical infrastructure can be built at a much lower cost than traditional publishing methods.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c364",
      "osft-doc-1459/c396"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c366",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c366",
    "representativeText": "Open scholarly infrastructure has a clear role in defining particular research practices and workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c366",
      "osft-doc-1459/c398"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c386",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c386",
    "representativeText": "The potential social aspects of infrastructure services give additional scope for a range of purposes, including networking, marketing and promotion, non-academic information exchange, and discussion forums.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c386",
      "osft-doc-1459/c413"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c39",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should share presentations, posters, and recordings online.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c39",
      "osft-doc-1459/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c390",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c390",
    "representativeText": "Web 2.0 technologies are fully capable of helping to make scholarship more readily understandable through non-specialist summaries, blogging, and other less formal communicative methods.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c390",
      "osft-doc-1459/c417"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c392",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c392",
    "representativeText": "The wider public can have influence on the intrinsic research process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c392",
      "osft-doc-1459/c420"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c395",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c395",
    "representativeText": "Dispersed, external individuals from beyond traditional non-digital spheres should be included in an active role in research.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c395",
      "osft-doc-1459/c423"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c397",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c397",
    "representativeText": "Community science opens up opportunities for crowd-funding of research projects.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c397",
      "osft-doc-1459/c425"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c400",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c400",
    "representativeText": "Public spaces and infrastructure such as public libraries, museums, art galleries, and schools should be leveraged.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c400",
      "osft-doc-1459/c428"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c406",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c406",
    "representativeText": "Doing away with any form of measurement is often considered to be bad for the progress of scientific research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c406",
      "osft-doc-1459/c435"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c410",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c410",
    "representativeText": "The Journal Impact Factor confines assessment to journal-based research outputs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c410",
      "osft-doc-1459/c440"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c415",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c415",
    "representativeText": "Altmetrics capture new forms of information about the process of collaboration.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c415",
      "osft-doc-1459/c444"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c416",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c416",
    "representativeText": "Altmetrics help to expand the traditional view of publication being the end of a narrow research pipeline.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c416",
      "osft-doc-1459/c445"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c417",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c417",
    "representativeText": "The principles of responsible metrics use are closely aligned with the goals of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c417",
      "osft-doc-1459/c446"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c42",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may publish only in APC-free Open Access journals or those operated by non-profits or learned societies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c42",
      "osft-doc-1459/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c428",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c428",
    "representativeText": "The potential utility of a wide range of research evaluation sources, including pre-registrations, registered reports, sources regarding software, materials, and data, and public outreach efforts and citizen science, may be investigated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c428",
      "osft-doc-1459/c459"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c435",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c435",
    "representativeText": "There is a strong role for qualitative evaluation procedures in the future of research assessment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c435",
      "osft-doc-1459/c467"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c439",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c439",
    "representativeText": "Diversity, in this context, generally means encouraging tolerance and inclusion of people from a range of different backgrounds.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c439",
      "osft-doc-1459/c472"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c44",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may use an author addendum to legally retain the rights to their work during publication.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c44",
      "osft-doc-1459/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c441",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c441",
    "representativeText": "The wider Open Scholarship community must build awareness that community diversity and inclusivity are fundamental principles.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c441",
      "osft-doc-1459/c479"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c442",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c442",
    "representativeText": "The wider Open Scholarship community must develop tools and techniques to fix existing diversity and inclusivity issues.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c442",
      "osft-doc-1459/c480"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c445",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c445",
    "representativeText": "Community cohesion and messaging must be extended to all other related communities.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c445",
      "osft-doc-1459/c482"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c447",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c447",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship community must create educational curricula for practitioners.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c447",
      "osft-doc-1459/c484"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c450",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c450",
    "representativeText": "Community science includes tackling community-driven megaprojects.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c450",
      "osft-doc-1459/c488"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c451",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c451",
    "representativeText": "Community science produces spill-over effects to and from education.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c451",
      "osft-doc-1459/c489"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c452",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c452",
    "representativeText": "Community science strengthens the ability to participate intellectually, donate computing power, biological samples or other resources, including money, towards research projects.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c452",
      "osft-doc-1459/c490"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c454",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c454",
    "representativeText": "The 'Open' movement goes beyond just scholarship, and is related to wider fields such as Open Culture, Open Government, Open Source, and Open Society.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c454",
      "osft-doc-1459/c493"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c464",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c464",
    "representativeText": "The impact of evidence supporting Open Scholarship can be seen at multiple levels, from the practices of individuals up to national-level policies around Open Access and Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c464",
      "osft-doc-1459/c502"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c469",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c469",
    "representativeText": "Open Access models generally transcend geographical, institutional, or sectoral variations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c469",
      "osft-doc-1459/c507"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c471",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c471",
    "representativeText": "The growth and adoption of preprints has led to a rapidly evolving landscape around preprints, with technological innovation and community practices constantly adapting.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c471",
      "osft-doc-1459/c509"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c472",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c472",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship charters and declarations offer internally consistent sets of goals and actions that are the result of a lot of thinking and discussing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c472",
      "osft-doc-1459/c510"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c478",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c478",
    "representativeText": "Bottom-up policies are more often voluntary than mandatory, compared to top-down approaches.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c478",
      "osft-doc-1673/c376"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c482",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c482",
    "representativeText": "SciELO has proven unequivocally successful across Latin America, Portugal, and South Africa.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c482",
      "osft-doc-1459/c518"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c483",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c483",
    "representativeText": "Africa Journals Online (AJOL) has become very popular in Africa.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c483",
      "osft-doc-1459/c519"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c487",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c487",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship movement's published articles and resources are typically free.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c487",
      "osft-doc-1459/c523"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c491",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c491",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship movement's tendency to embrace technology helps it disseminate its ideas more broadly and quickly than traditional publication methods.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c491",
      "osft-doc-1459/c524"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c492",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c492",
    "representativeText": "Practices such as platform-independent text formatting, well-formed document structures, and alt-texts help make information machine-readable.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c492",
      "osft-doc-1459/c525"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c495",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c495",
    "representativeText": "There is currently little consensus over whether the future of Open Scholarship should be owned purely by non-profit entities or whether there is space for private or corporate interests.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c495",
      "osft-doc-1459/c528"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c496",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c496",
    "representativeText": "The future of Open Scholarship is likely to be a mixed model combining all actor types.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c496",
      "osft-doc-1459/c529"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c498",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c498",
    "representativeText": "Discussion is needed to overcome the misconception that Open Scholarship is anti-commercial and to demonstrate its return on investment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c498",
      "osft-doc-1459/c532"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c499",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c499",
    "representativeText": "Discussion is needed to resolve frictions between a Scholarly Commons model for research and its operation within a capitalistic framework.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c499",
      "osft-doc-1459/c533"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c506",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c506",
    "representativeText": "The EU's Open Science focus has primarily been on economic growth, development, and innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c506",
      "osft-doc-1459/c540"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c507",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c507",
    "representativeText": "The core academic and social aspects of Open Scholarship appear to have been somewhat under-discussed in the EU.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c507",
      "osft-doc-1459/c541"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c508",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c508",
    "representativeText": "Other nations have been generally slow in adopting national Open Science policies or strategies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c508",
      "osft-doc-1459/c542"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c518",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c518",
    "representativeText": "The Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) component of the Work Programme 'Science with and for Society' makes open education, research, and access explicit targets of EU policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c518",
      "osft-doc-1459/c544"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c519",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c519",
    "representativeText": "There is a general lack of synthesized and consistent strategy on the political motivations for Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c519",
      "osft-doc-1459/c545"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c52",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c52",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should leave constructive comments and annotations on preprints and code using open tools.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c52",
      "osft-doc-1459/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c520",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c520",
    "representativeText": "Deeper coordination is needed to strategically identify which aspects of Open Scholarship match with each intended political outcome.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c520",
      "osft-doc-1459/c546"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c525",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c525",
    "representativeText": "Whether researchers adopt open scholarship practices for pragmatic reasons without using the label or self-identifying as open scholars requires further empirical investigation.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c525",
      "osft-doc-1459/c550"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c526",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c526",
    "representativeText": "The heterogeneous geographical reach and awareness of Open Scholarship practices needs to be investigated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c526",
      "osft-doc-1459/c551"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c53",
    "representativeText": "Individuals should react positively to requests for open peer review and requests from non-profits and learned societies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c53",
      "osft-doc-1459/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c530",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c530",
    "representativeText": "This closed-system bias is powerful in defining the research practices of early career researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c530",
      "osft-doc-1459/c555"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c531",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c531",
    "representativeText": "Misleading uses of Open Scholarship terminologies dilute the intended messages.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c531",
      "osft-doc-1459/c556"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c533",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c533",
    "representativeText": "Free is not open.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c533",
      "osft-doc-1459/c558"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c534",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c534",
    "representativeText": "Simply providing research tools is not open.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c534",
      "osft-doc-1459/c559"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c536",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c536",
    "representativeText": "There is a danger that companies with a history of anti-openness could move into and co-opt the Open Scholarship movement if it is not appropriately defined and adhered to.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c536",
      "osft-doc-1459/c561"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 1,
      "hedged": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c538",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c538",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship community should adopt the stance of 'radical kindness' when engaging with powerful players with opposing or divergent interests, treating them with absolute, unwavering civility even when such courtesies are not repaid.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c538",
      "osft-doc-1459/c563"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c54",
    "representativeText": "Individuals may refuse to perform peer review and editorial work for free for commercial publishers.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c54",
      "osft-doc-1459/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c545",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c545",
    "representativeText": "Underestimating the power of copyright laws and their intersection with various aspects of Open Scholarship may have been one of the key reasons the Open movement has not met some of its principal objectives.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c545",
      "osft-doc-1459/c570"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c55",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c55",
    "representativeText": "Reviewers should request that all relevant materials be made open and properly cited in their reviewing.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c55",
      "osft-doc-1459/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c555",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c555",
    "representativeText": "The Open Scholarship movement often seems to be fairly combative about minute issues without realizing the amount of agreement on the main issues.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c555",
      "osft-doc-1459/c579"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c556",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c556",
    "representativeText": "Focusing on core principles and/or values and identifying them as a shared commonality sets fertile ground for further, productive discussion.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c556",
      "osft-doc-1459/c580"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c558",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c558",
    "representativeText": "A greater understanding of financial workflows in scholarly communication is required.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c558",
      "osft-doc-1459/c582"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c560",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c560",
    "representativeText": "Initiatives such as The 2.5% Commitment could be important in the future for Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c560",
      "osft-doc-1459/c584"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c561",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c561",
    "representativeText": "There is a clear scope for diverting funds away from present flows such as subscriptions into more sustainable Open Scholarship ventures.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c561",
      "osft-doc-1459/c585"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c562",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c562",
    "representativeText": "The Open Library of the Humanities' consortium model distributes the financial burden of individual libraries among a larger group of consortium members.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c562",
      "osft-doc-1459/c586"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c569",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c569",
    "representativeText": "Researchers do not necessarily need to be open activists.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c569",
      "osft-doc-1459/c593"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c571",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c571",
    "representativeText": "Enthusiasm for openness carries the danger of not being receptive to critique.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c571",
      "osft-doc-1459/c596"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c572",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c572",
    "representativeText": "Enthusiasm for openness carries the danger of not acknowledging that there are situations where standard open practices can have dangers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c572",
      "osft-doc-1459/c597"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c574",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c574",
    "representativeText": "Open data could be captured by governments for surveillance or by companies for corporate interests.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c574",
      "osft-doc-1459/c599"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c575",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c575",
    "representativeText": "The limitations of openness also relate to the dangers of platform-based economies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c575",
      "osft-doc-1459/c600"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c576",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c576",
    "representativeText": "The limitations of openness also relate to unequal relations in research co-operations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c576",
      "osft-doc-1459/c601"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c577",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c577",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship includes an inherent bias towards English-speaking communities, which discriminates against those who do not speak English as their first language.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c577",
      "osft-doc-1459/c602"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c581",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c581",
    "representativeText": "Discussions about Open Scholarship are happening at different levels.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c581",
      "osft-doc-1459/c607"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c59",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should address publication bias as a best practice for Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c59",
      "osft-doc-1459/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c590",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c590",
    "representativeText": "There is a great opportunity now available to harmonise the scholarly communication policy landscape to simplify compliance for researchers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c590",
      "osft-doc-1459/c616"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c595",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c595",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of research into personal determinants and environmental conditions of (not) publishing Open Access.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c595",
      "osft-doc-1459/c620"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c598",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c598",
    "representativeText": "There are conflicts between funder and publisher policies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c598",
      "osft-doc-1459/c623"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c599",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c599",
    "representativeText": "Copyright continues to be transferred from researchers to publishers.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c599",
      "osft-doc-1459/c624"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c60",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should address questionable research practices with bias-reducing workflows as a best practice for Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c60",
      "osft-doc-1459/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c600",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c600",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of distributed article-processing charge funding.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c600",
      "osft-doc-1459/c625"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c601",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c601",
    "representativeText": "High and unsustainable APCs and BPCs are widely applied.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c601",
      "osft-doc-1459/c626"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c603",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c603",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of knowledge in negotiating the difficulties of Open Access adoption.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c603",
      "osft-doc-1459/c628"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c604",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c604",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of awareness that most journals indexed in the DOAJ do not charge article processing charges.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c604",
      "osft-doc-1459/c629"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c606",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c606",
    "representativeText": "There are continuing perceptions of a lack of prestige for many OA journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c606",
      "osft-doc-1459/c631"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c607",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c607",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of appropriate offsetting deals around OA deals and hybrid journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c607",
      "osft-doc-1459/c632"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c609",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c609",
    "representativeText": "The lack of high-profile role models strengthens cultural inertia through a lack of awareness.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c609",
      "osft-doc-1459/c633"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c610",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c610",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of research into personal determinants and environmental conditions of (not) sharing data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c610",
      "osft-doc-1459/c634"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c611",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c611",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of skills and awareness of best practices in data sharing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c611",
      "osft-doc-1459/c635"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c613",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c613",
    "representativeText": "There are licensing issues in data sharing and a lack of awareness surrounding them.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c613",
      "osft-doc-1673/c347"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c614",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c614",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of infrastructure to support good RDM throughout the research lifecycle.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c614",
      "osft-doc-1459/c638"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c63",
    "representativeText": "Groups and labs may have profiles on public open science discussion platforms where needed.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c63",
      "osft-doc-1459/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "may": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c636",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c636",
    "representativeText": "Future communication efforts must focus on open practices as not being completely new, but simply more efficient and more rewarding versions of current practices.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c636",
      "osft-doc-1459/c659"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c75",
    "representativeText": "Communication departments and research assessment officials should be engaged and informed about open science and scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c75",
      "osft-doc-1459/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c76",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c76",
    "representativeText": "University Ranking Providers should include an openness element in their indicators.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c76",
      "osft-doc-1673/c22"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c79",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c79",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should map and coordinate when current subscription and big deal licenses will run out and let them expire.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c79",
      "osft-doc-1459/c78"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c81",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c81",
    "representativeText": "There should be sufficient co-ordination between libraries and relevant others beforehand, so that libraries can continue to provide outstanding services without interruption.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c81",
      "osft-doc-1459/c80"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c85",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c85",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should help inform researchers about the Author Alliance termination of transfer tool to help them retain their rights as authors.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c85",
      "osft-doc-1459/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c87",
    "representativeText": "Research funders have the power to mandate publication in journals with a cap on APCs and BPCs.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c87",
      "osft-doc-1459/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c88",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c88",
    "representativeText": "Research funders have the power to mandate publication in OA-only venues with specific licenses.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c88",
      "osft-doc-1459/c87"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c89",
    "representativeText": "Research funders have the power to mandate publication in journals with short or zero-length embargoes on self-archiving.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c89",
      "osft-doc-1459/c88"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c90",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should refuse to engage with publishers that double dip on payments.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c90",
      "osft-doc-1459/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c91",
    "representativeText": "Transparency and data should be demanded from publishers in cases where double dipping is suspected.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c91",
      "osft-doc-1459/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c92",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should refuse to engage with publishers in which there is no transparency around pricing for either subscriptions or Open Access, including publishers who insist on using non-disclosure agreements as part of licensing contract terms.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c92",
      "osft-doc-1459/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1398/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1398/c46",
    "representativeText": "Universities must reallocate their financial resources away from restricted access publishing models toward covering only publishing services that offer full and immediate open access.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1398/c46",
      "osft-doc-0825/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0825",
      "osft-doc-1398"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1399/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1399/c34",
    "representativeText": "The Roadmap's strong support of full and immediate open access suggests a shift in national policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1399/c34",
      "osft-doc-0951/c42"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0951",
      "osft-doc-1399"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1412/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1412/c160",
    "representativeText": "Both authors (or sets of authors) receiving credit for their work through normal mechanisms of citation recognition is important.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1412/c160",
      "osft-doc-1449/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1412",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1412/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1412/c64",
    "representativeText": "Data sharing practices tend to be a private activity.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1412/c64",
      "osft-doc-1702/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1412",
      "osft-doc-1702"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1449/c230",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1449/c230",
    "representativeText": "Research performing institutions must foster the adoption of the FAIR principles among their researchers when sharing data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1449/c230",
      "open-science-source-25/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-25",
      "osft-doc-1449"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c101",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c101",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes that currently lack an Open Access policy should adopt one.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c101",
      "osft-doc-1673/c46"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c103",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c103",
    "representativeText": "Research libraries should collect information about how the sector as a whole interacts with the research literature.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c103",
      "osft-doc-1673/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c127",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should create scholarly standards to implement an alternative non-profit and community-owned scholarly publishing platform or environment.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c127",
      "osft-doc-1373/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c131",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c131",
    "representativeText": "The scholarly publishing market might require a detailed government-level investigation in order to stabilise it.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c131",
      "osft-doc-1673/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c144",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c144",
    "representativeText": "Consortia such as the German Projekt DEAL could provide examples of how to take the first step towards this at a national level.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c144",
      "osft-doc-1673/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c145",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c145",
    "representativeText": "Gaining support from SPARC for such developments would be useful.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c145",
      "osft-doc-1673/c53"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c201",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c201",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should fund further research into determinants identified as relevant to engaging in Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c201",
      "osft-doc-1373/c188"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c202",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c202",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should fund development of interventions to target individuals and institutions to adopt Open Scholarship practices and policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c202",
      "osft-doc-1373/c189"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c203",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c203",
    "representativeText": "National level actors should engage library consortia with national negotiation consortia and any relevant higher education unions to strengthen researcher coalitions.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c203",
      "osft-doc-1373/c190"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c237",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c237",
    "representativeText": "The term \"Open Scholarship\" refers to the re-use of research as practised in any scholarly research discipline.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c237",
      "osft-doc-1673/c119"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c240",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c240",
    "representativeText": "There have been dozens of declarations, charters, and statements about the priorities of the various aspects of Open Scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c240",
      "osft-doc-1673/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c271",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c271",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship include participation.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c271",
      "osft-doc-1673/c148"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c272",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c272",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship include equality.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c272",
      "osft-doc-1673/c149"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c274",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c274",
    "representativeText": "The core principles or values of Open Scholarship include cognitive justice.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c274",
      "osft-doc-1673/c151"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c304",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c304",
    "representativeText": "There are few preprints from the pharmaceutical industry.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c304",
      "osft-doc-1673/c176"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c305",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c305",
    "representativeText": "There are no preprints from the pharmaceutical industry covering primary clinical data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c305",
      "osft-doc-1673/c177"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c363",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c363",
    "representativeText": "Research material sharing is critical for reducing redundancy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c363",
      "osft-doc-1673/c222"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c368",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c368",
    "representativeText": "Streamlined MTAs and OSTAs allow efficient, open and collaborative scientific practices.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c368",
      "osft-doc-1673/c227"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c44",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c44",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should advocate for open education with corresponding practices to help spread open approaches among peers and the next generation of scientists.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c44",
      "osft-doc-1373/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "may": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c46",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c46",
    "representativeText": "Individual researchers should encourage wider adoption of an open mindset that emphasises the importance of the research process over the outcome.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c46",
      "osft-doc-1373/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c491",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c491",
    "representativeText": "The global scholarly community is vast, covering every continent.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c491",
      "osft-doc-1373/c453"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c5",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c5",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is an attempt to realign modern research practices with the collective (commons) ideal.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c5",
      "osft-doc-1569/c3"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c636",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c636",
    "representativeText": "There is a lack of agreement on how Research Data Management activities should be funded, which is a barrier to data sharing.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c636",
      "osft-doc-1673/c346"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c66",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c66",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should locate Open Scholarship hotspots and link them together to help community cohesion and expansion.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c66",
      "osft-doc-1673/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c669",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c669",
    "representativeText": "Academia needs to centre its scholarly practices on the possibility to freely re-use research output in all its forms.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c669",
      "open-science-source-04/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-04",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 1,
      "should": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c67",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c67",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should establish a local Open Scholarship hotspot if one does not yet exist.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c67",
      "osft-doc-1673/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c70",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should establish rights experts to help with copyright issues and effective use of Creative Commons licenses.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c70",
      "osft-doc-1673/c17"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1459/c72",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1459/c72",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should initiate debates on meaningful standards and practices at a disciplinary level for publishing data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1459/c72",
      "osft-doc-1673/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c100",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c100",
    "representativeText": "CoreTrustSeal's established procedures and standards emerged from research data community work to identify key practices for data repositories that support long-term access to reusable data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c100",
      "osft-doc-1686/c95"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c107",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c107",
    "representativeText": "The three-point-FAIRification-Framework aims to maximize interoperability.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c107",
      "osft-doc-1686/c97"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c109",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c109",
    "representativeText": "Metadata for Machines (M4M) Workshops constitute a community of practice that considers its domain-relevant metadata requirements and other policy considerations.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c109",
      "osft-doc-1686/c99"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c11",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c11",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles have been established as best practice in the refinement of health datasets for open science, research, and innovation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c11",
      "osft-doc-1686/c11"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c111",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c111",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR Implementation Profile (FIP) comprises re-usable metadata schemata produced in the M4M workshop.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c111",
      "osft-doc-1686/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c112",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c112",
    "representativeText": "FAIR Data Points (FDP) or FAIR Digital Objects (FDO) are configured based on the FAIR implementation guide.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c112",
      "osft-doc-1686/c101"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c113",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c113",
    "representativeText": "FAIR Data Points (FDP) or FAIR Digital Objects (FDO) contribute to a global Internet of FAIR data and services.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c113",
      "osft-doc-1686/c102"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c114",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c114",
    "representativeText": "GO FAIR has developed a policy for certification of FAIR resources.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c114",
      "osft-doc-1686/c103"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c115",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c115",
    "representativeText": "GO FAIR's certification approach aims to address people, organizations, and data sets in a holistic way.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c115",
      "osft-doc-1686/c104"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c12",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c12",
    "representativeText": "The introduction of the FAIR principles by Wilkinson et al. is considered the tipping point for open health science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c12",
      "osft-doc-1686/c12"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 1,
      "asserts": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c122",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c122",
    "representativeText": "ECRIN targets clinical trial centers rather than arbitrary research repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c122",
      "osft-doc-1686/c105"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c123",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c123",
    "representativeText": "Clinical trial centers are specialized organizations that not only maintain data but also participate in the data collection process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c123",
      "osft-doc-1686/c106"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c124",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c124",
    "representativeText": "ECRIN's relation to FAIR is weak because no technical formats or standards are described or assumed.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c124",
      "osft-doc-1686/c107"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c125",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c125",
    "representativeText": "ECRIN assumes organizational processes and quality assurance procedures for clinical research data that also apply to other types of health data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c125",
      "osft-doc-1686/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c126",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c126",
    "representativeText": "The ECRIN Datacenter Certification Program enables non-commercial clinical trial sites to have their processes for creating and maintaining GCP-compliant trial databases monitored and evaluated.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c126",
      "osft-doc-1686/c109"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c127",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c127",
    "representativeText": "Research data repositories listed in re3data must be run by a legal entity.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c127",
      "osft-doc-1686/c110"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c128",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c128",
    "representativeText": "Research data repositories listed in re3data must focus on research data.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c128",
      "osft-doc-1686/c111"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c130",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c130",
    "representativeText": "The main goal of the re3data COREF project is to further professionalize re3data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c130",
      "osft-doc-1686/c113"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c131",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c131",
    "representativeText": "The main goal of the re3data COREF project is to provide reliable and customizable descriptions of research data repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c131",
      "osft-doc-1686/c114"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c132",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c132",
    "representativeText": "re3data is used by researchers and services worldwide for finding datasets.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c132",
      "osft-doc-1686/c115"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c133",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c133",
    "representativeText": "re3data's relation to FAIR data certification, though not explicit, shows extremely close proximity in content, underlined by its use of machine-readable, community-consented vocabularies and a REST API.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c133",
      "osft-doc-1686/c118"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c134",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c134",
    "representativeText": "re3data provides no certificate but a number of badges that characterize important features and add a citeable identifier (DOI).",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c134",
      "osft-doc-1686/c119"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c135",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c135",
    "representativeText": "There are several other initiatives that contribute to the FAIR data policy landscape.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c135",
      "osft-doc-1686/c121"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c136",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c136",
    "representativeText": "The metadata about a data set used to answer a research question should be public.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c136",
      "osft-doc-1686/c123"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c137",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c137",
    "representativeText": "The RDA Metadata Standards Catalog WG does not offer a repository for metadata records.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c137",
      "osft-doc-1686/c128"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c139",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c139",
    "representativeText": "re3data does not offer a repository to upload metadata records.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c139",
      "osft-doc-1686/c130"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c140",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c140",
    "representativeText": "There is an unresolved issue regarding what metadata should be published about a data set that cannot be accessed or downloaded but may be used for research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c140",
      "osft-doc-1686/c132"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c143",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c143",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles have paved the way to creating a level playing field for data reuse.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c143",
      "osft-doc-1686/c135"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c144",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c144",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR principles pose challenges in some areas of research where reuse may not be an automatic right due to issues of confidentiality, privacy, commercial interests and sensitivities in general.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c144",
      "osft-doc-1686/c137"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c145",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c145",
    "representativeText": "There are global disparities in the uptake of the FAIR principles in health research and within health research performing organisations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c145",
      "osft-doc-1686/c139"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c146",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c146",
    "representativeText": "The adoption of FAIR practices in health research organizations needs to be accelerated.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c146",
      "osft-doc-1686/c140"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c157",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c157",
    "representativeText": "The FHIR implementation of the FAIR principles needs to tackle challenges such as metadata/data mapping and the use of Globally Unique, Persistent and Resolvable Identifiers (GUPRIs).",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c157",
      "osft-doc-1686/c158"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c16",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c16",
    "representativeText": "There are limited tools to help accelerate the FAIRification process.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c16",
      "osft-doc-1686/c15"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c164",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c164",
    "representativeText": "Health research institutions offering certified FAIR health data sets must cooperate with other FAIR initiatives.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c164",
      "osft-doc-1686/c7"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c165",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c165",
    "representativeText": "Health research institutions offering certified FAIR health data sets must train the administrative and research personnel on how to deliver FAIR.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c165",
      "osft-doc-1686/c8"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c166",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c166",
    "representativeText": "Health research institutions offering certified FAIR health data sets must certify the processes adopted according to the ISO9000 family of quality standards.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c166",
      "osft-doc-1686/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c168",
    "representativeText": "Implementing a FAIR strategy in health research, including training and skills development, is important for facilitating researchers' compliance with FAIR principles.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c168",
      "osft-doc-1686/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c17",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c17",
    "representativeText": "The Research Data Alliance is a global research community organization.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c17",
      "osft-doc-1686/c16"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c20",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c20",
    "representativeText": "FAIRness can be assessed using the HL7 FHIR standard.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c20",
      "osft-doc-1686/c21"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c22",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures for FAIR health data sets are essential for health researchers that use them.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c22",
      "osft-doc-1686/c23"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c24",
    "representativeText": "Certification frequently comes to be synonymous with trust.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c24",
      "osft-doc-1686/c24"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c25",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c25",
    "representativeText": "Acquiring a certificate is generally not a small expense.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c25",
      "osft-doc-1686/c25"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c26",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c26",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures can increase the quality of research data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c26",
      "osft-doc-1686/c26"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c27",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c27",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures can increase the attractiveness of data for subsequent use by third parties.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c27",
      "osft-doc-1686/c27"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c30",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures can fulfil requirements imposed by funders or scientific journals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c30",
      "osft-doc-1686/c29"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c31",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c31",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures can improve internal workflows.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c31",
      "osft-doc-1686/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c32",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c32",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures can increase acceptance of the additional workload caused by FAIR among staff members.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c32",
      "osft-doc-1686/c31"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c33",
    "representativeText": "Certification procedures allow use of the auditor's expertise in the case of formal certifications.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c33",
      "osft-doc-1686/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c34",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c34",
    "representativeText": "Establishing certification processes streamlines the participation of the organization in the digital economy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c34",
      "osft-doc-1686/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c35",
    "representativeText": "Certifications in the field of FAIR data are currently not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c35",
      "osft-doc-1686/c34"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c36",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c36",
    "representativeText": "Lack of clarity about which certifications exist, how they differ, and how to find the appropriate certification may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c36",
      "osft-doc-1686/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c38",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c38",
    "representativeText": "Lack of clarity about the personnel and other financial costs required may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c38",
      "osft-doc-1686/c37"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c40",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c40",
    "representativeText": "Uncertainty about the success of the certification process in principle may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c40",
      "osft-doc-1686/c39"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c41",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c41",
    "representativeText": "Giving access to sensitive internal data and IP by third parties may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c41",
      "osft-doc-1686/c40"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c42",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c42",
    "representativeText": "Existing local certifications that already cover certain parts of the envisaged certification may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c42",
      "osft-doc-1686/c41"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c43",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c43",
    "representativeText": "A number of approaches in the domain of research data archiving and sharing do not always explicitly cover the term FAIR but do so intentionally.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c43",
      "osft-doc-1686/c44"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c47",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c47",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR data principles apply to (meta-)data in the sense of indirectly accessible data from repositories or via application programming interfaces, where the target resources are software systems or infrastructures.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c47",
      "osft-doc-1686/c48"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c48",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR data principles apply to (meta-)data in the sense of data models, schemas, and standards, focusing on the suitability of the existing modelling constructs of the standard to achieve FAIRness rather than on specific instance data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c48",
      "osft-doc-1686/c49"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c49",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c49",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR data principles apply to executable algorithms or tools that assist users or machines in generating FAIR (meta-)data or provide an assessment of the current level of FAIRness achieved.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c49",
      "osft-doc-1686/c50"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c50",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR data principles apply to proof of competence, enabling scientists or data curators to support aspects of FAIR during the lifecycle of digital resources, for example by demonstrating specific knowledge or skills through training.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c50",
      "osft-doc-1686/c51"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c51",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c51",
    "representativeText": "Certification means assurance given by an independent certification body that a product, service or system meets the requirements of a standard.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c51",
      "osft-doc-1686/c52"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c54",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c54",
    "representativeText": "CoreTrustSeal is a basic certification (level 1) standard for trusted digital repositories with regard to long-term preservation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c54",
      "osft-doc-1686/c54"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c56",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c56",
    "representativeText": "CoreTrustSeal's catalogue of guidelines focuses on Organizational Infrastructure and Digital Object Management.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c56",
      "osft-doc-1686/c55"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c57",
    "representativeText": "CoreTrustSeal is suitable for repositories that are committed to the curation and long-term preservation of the usability of the repository, considering the requirements and knowledge base of a designated community.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c57",
      "osft-doc-1686/c56"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c58",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c58",
    "representativeText": "Among currently certified repositories, hardly any focus on biomedical data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c58",
      "osft-doc-1686/c57"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c59",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c59",
    "representativeText": "Nestor is primarily a German initiative based on DIN 31644:2012-04, \"Information and documentation - Criteria for trustworthy digital archives.\"",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c59",
      "osft-doc-1686/c58"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c60",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c60",
    "representativeText": "Nestor includes organizational concerns such as human resources, qualification, processes, and responsibilities.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c60",
      "osft-doc-1686/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c61",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c61",
    "representativeText": "Nestor includes legal concerns such as legal regulations and contractual coverage.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c61",
      "osft-doc-1686/c60"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c62",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c62",
    "representativeText": "Nestor includes financial concerns such as ensuring sustainability.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c62",
      "osft-doc-1686/c61"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c63",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c63",
    "representativeText": "Nestor covers similar aspects—PIDs, data discovery, access, licenses, provenance and reuse—from all four axes of FAIR.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c63",
      "osft-doc-1686/c62"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c64",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c64",
    "representativeText": "Nestor certification is an extended certification (level 2) standard for trusted digital repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c64",
      "osft-doc-1686/c63"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c69",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c69",
    "representativeText": "ISO 16363 is based upon the Trusted Digital Repositories and Audit Checklist (TRAC) standard.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c69",
      "osft-doc-1686/c65"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c70",
    "representativeText": "ISO 16919 relies heavily on ISO/IEC 17021, a standard for auditing and certification of general types of management systems.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c70",
      "osft-doc-1686/c66"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c73",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c73",
    "representativeText": "ISO 16363 comprises the main part of infrastructure and risk management.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c73",
      "osft-doc-1686/c69"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c74",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c74",
    "representativeText": "ISO 16363's commitment to FAIR aspects is comparable to nestor's, because ISO 16363 does not add specific constraints on digital assets.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c74",
      "osft-doc-1686/c70"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c75",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c75",
    "representativeText": "ISO 16363 is a formal certification (level 3) standard for trusted digital repositories.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c75",
      "osft-doc-1686/c71"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c77",
    "representativeText": "ISO 16363 certification may only be conducted by organizations or persons certified according to ISO 16919.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c77",
      "osft-doc-1686/c72"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c78",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c78",
    "representativeText": "RatSWD is an independent advisory board of the German Federal Government.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c78",
      "osft-doc-1686/c73"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c79",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c79",
    "representativeText": "RatSWD's main tasks include the strategic development of the research data infrastructure.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c79",
      "osft-doc-1686/c74"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c80",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c80",
    "representativeText": "RatSWD's main tasks include representing the interests of data producers and data users.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c80",
      "osft-doc-1686/c75"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c81",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c81",
    "representativeText": "RatSWD accreditation is the most popular certification in Germany.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c81",
      "osft-doc-1686/c76"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c82",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c82",
    "representativeText": "Data sharing and reuse are the primary drivers for the existence of RatSWD accreditation.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c82",
      "osft-doc-1686/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c87",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c87",
    "representativeText": "Repositories seeking RatSWD accreditation must provide documentation of datasets.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c87",
      "osft-doc-1686/c81"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c89",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c89",
    "representativeText": "Repositories seeking RatSWD accreditation must be fully operational.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c89",
      "osft-doc-1686/c83"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c90",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c90",
    "representativeText": "Repositories seeking RatSWD accreditation must provide proof of a minimum of three external data users.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c90",
      "osft-doc-1686/c84"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c91",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c91",
    "representativeText": "RatSWD's additional certification criteria relate to operational aspects, including proof of an operational concept, response times to data requests, proof of staff and infrastructure, and a data quality assurance concept.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c91",
      "osft-doc-1686/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c92",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c92",
    "representativeText": "FAIRsFAIR has developed a framework for measuring FAIRness based on the work of the RDA FAIR Data Maturity Model Working Group.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c92",
      "osft-doc-1686/c86"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c93",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c93",
    "representativeText": "A research data object may comprise data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c93",
      "osft-doc-1686/c89"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c94",
    "representativeText": "A research data object may comprise metadata.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c94",
      "osft-doc-1686/c90"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c95",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c95",
    "representativeText": "A research data object may comprise documentation, such as policies and procedures.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c95",
      "osft-doc-1686/c91"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c96",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c96",
    "representativeText": "The components of a research data object influence the implementation of the FAIR assessment.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c96",
      "osft-doc-1686/c92"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1569/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1569/c7",
    "representativeText": "Open Scholarship is sometimes also referred to as 'Open Science'.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1569/c7",
      "osft-doc-1459/c9"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1569"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1612/c22",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1612/c22",
    "representativeText": "OS practices can perpetuate inequities in scholarship.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1612/c22",
      "osft-doc-1031/c13"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1031",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1612/c7",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1612/c7",
    "representativeText": "OS practices include the sharing of data.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1612/c7",
      "osft-doc-0138/c10"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0138",
      "osft-doc-1612"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c1",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c1",
    "representativeText": "Canadian science should be open to all.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c1",
      "osft-doc-1737/c1"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1646/c30",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1646/c30",
    "representativeText": "Federal departments and agencies should make federal science articles openly accessible by January 2022, while respecting privacy, security, ethical considerations and appropriate intellectual property protection.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1646/c30",
      "osft-doc-1771/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1646",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c152",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c152",
    "representativeText": "The core principles of Open Scholarship include collaboration.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c152",
      "osft-doc-1459/c275"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c24",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c24",
    "representativeText": "Research groups should improve engagement between faculty advisory boards, researchers, students, and librarians.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c24",
      "osft-doc-1459/c73"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c359",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c359",
    "representativeText": "Open source addressed license proliferation through OSI-approved licenses.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c359",
      "osft-doc-1373/c592"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1673/c45",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1673/c45",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes that lack an Open Access repository should launch and maintain one or use an existing resource.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1673/c45",
      "osft-doc-1459/c100"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1459",
      "osft-doc-1673"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1686/c163",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1686/c163",
    "representativeText": "The FAIR data ecosystem is immature to have a clear view of the FAIR data certification prospects ahead.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1686/c163",
      "osft-doc-1507/c167"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1702/c8",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1702/c8",
    "representativeText": "Open science is practiced in full respect of privacy, security, ethical considerations and appropriate intellectual property protection.",
    "kind": "definitional",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1702/c8",
      "osft-doc-1737/c67"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1702",
      "osft-doc-1737"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c28",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c28",
    "representativeText": "Departments and agencies should develop action plans for Open Science by June 2021.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c28",
      "osft-doc-1771/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c33",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c33",
    "representativeText": "Open Science action plans should include a performance measurement element.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c33",
      "osft-doc-1771/c35"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1737/c48",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1737/c48",
    "representativeText": "Deputy heads should designate a Chief Scientific Data Officer by January 2021.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1737/c48",
      "osft-doc-1771/c45"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1737",
      "osft-doc-1771"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c149",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c149",
    "representativeText": "Researchers' careers can benefit strongly from being involved with open infrastructure, tooling, and community activities.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c149",
      "osft-doc-1878/c163"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1869",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c53",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c53",
    "representativeText": "Research funders should support open and reproducible research by making reproducibility part of their merit review criteria.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c53",
      "open-science-source-21/c97"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c116",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c116",
    "representativeText": "Open teaching initiatives improve scientific participation among the lay public.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c116",
      "osft-doc-0441/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c160",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c160",
    "representativeText": "Even academics with a teaching-focused role face considerable administrative burden in incorporating open scholarship into pre-existing modules or the pedagogical culture of their institute.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c160",
      "osft-doc-0441/c164"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c168",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c168",
    "representativeText": "There is a plethora of general and subject-specific infrastructures to achieve open education through new pedagogies.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c168",
      "osft-doc-0441/c172"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c181",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c181",
    "representativeText": "Educators must be aware of ongoing debates in the field of open and reproducible scholarship.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c181",
      "osft-doc-0441/c182"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c192",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c192",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's self-assessment tool can gauge low and high levels of adoption of principled education, and is thereby able to incorporate newcomers and experts.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c192",
      "osft-doc-0441/c194"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c213",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c213",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's database enriches resources with educational metadata.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c213",
      "osft-doc-0441/c217"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c287",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c287",
    "representativeText": "FORRT's open office hours aim to democratize access to open scholarship discussions to anyone in the world wishing to learn, adopt, and disseminate open and reproducible tenets.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c287",
      "osft-doc-0441/c295"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1878/c35",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1878/c35",
    "representativeText": "Open Science has direct implications for the public value of science.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1878/c35",
      "osft-doc-0441/c32"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0441",
      "osft-doc-1878"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-05/c57",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-05/c57",
    "representativeText": "Organizations that carry out, fund, and evaluate research should support the transition to open research information.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-05/c57",
      "osft-doc-0730/c59"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-05",
      "osft-doc-0730"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-21/c9",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-21/c9",
    "representativeText": "Open science enables more innovative collaborations.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-21/c9",
      "open-science-source-37-c1/c122"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-21",
      "open-science-source-37-c1"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-28/c10",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-28/c10",
    "representativeText": "All Funded Manuscripts must be accompanied by an Underlying Data Availability Statement that describes where any primary data can be found.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-28/c10",
      "open-science-source-15-c2/c125"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-15-c2",
      "open-science-source-28"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-41/c287",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-41/c287",
    "representativeText": "AI can enable new types of scientific creativity that may be unlikely to otherwise occur.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-41/c287",
      "open-science-source-42/c585"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-41",
      "open-science-source-42"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-42/c50",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-42/c50",
    "representativeText": "Researchers face barriers related to the sensitivity of available data.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-42/c50",
      "osft-doc-1327/c33"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-42",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "open-science-source-43/c70",
    "representativeClaimKey": "open-science-source-43/c70",
    "representativeText": "There should be a transition from subscriptions and transformative agreements to innovative digital open access models (free submission, free reading).",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "open-science-source-43/c70",
      "osft-doc-1327/c85"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-43",
      "osft-doc-1327"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c158",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c158",
    "representativeText": "By making funding and publishing processes more transparent and consistent, organisations can help generate evidence needed to inform effective policy-making.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c158",
      "osft-doc-0150/c152"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c161",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c161",
    "representativeText": "Relevance (of reproducibility as a quality indicator) depends on research goals.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c161",
      "osft-doc-0150/c157"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c164",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c164",
    "representativeText": "Especially in qualitative, exploratory, or interpretivist traditions, reproducibility may be less relevant as an indicator of quality than concepts like credibility, reflexivity, or plausibility.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c164",
      "osft-doc-0150/c154"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0050/c174",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0050/c174",
    "representativeText": "Conventional quantitative definitions of reproducibility and replicability are often considered inappropriate for qualitative research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0050/c174",
      "osft-doc-0150/c170"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0150/c77",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0150/c77",
    "representativeText": "Reproducibility metrics should be co-developed with and sensitive to the research communities they affect.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0150/c77",
      "osft-doc-0050/c77"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0050",
      "osft-doc-0150"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-0633/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-0633/c37",
    "representativeText": "Cross-cutting transparency helps lay a stronger foundation for evidence-based policy.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-0633/c37",
      "osft-doc-0748/c108"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-0633",
      "osft-doc-0748"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1327/c727",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1327/c727",
    "representativeText": "The international community should work on all pieces of the open scholarship puzzle.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1327/c727",
      "osft-doc-1869/c303"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1327",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 1,
      "must": 1
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c179",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c179",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should continue to only engage with publishers and other vendors that have progressively open services, tools, and policies in place.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c179",
      "osft-doc-1459/c192"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c497",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c497",
    "representativeText": "Further discussion is needed to overcome the widespread inertia surrounding current Open Scholarship business models.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c497",
      "osft-doc-1459/c531"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "must": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1373/c94",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1373/c94",
    "representativeText": "Research institutes should refuse to engage with publishers who have restrictive preprint, Open Access, or copyright policies.",
    "kind": "normative",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1373/c94",
      "osft-doc-1459/c93"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1373",
      "osft-doc-1459"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "should": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c37",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c37",
    "representativeText": "Uncertainty about the added value of a certification may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c37",
      "osft-doc-1686/c36"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1507/c39",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1507/c39",
    "representativeText": "Difficulty in quantifying the added value and communicating the value to management or third parties may be a reason certifications in the field of FAIR data are not widespread.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1507/c39",
      "osft-doc-1686/c38"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "osft-doc-1507",
      "osft-doc-1686"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "hedged": 2
    }
  },
  {
    "id": "osft-doc-1869/c236",
    "representativeClaimKey": "osft-doc-1869/c236",
    "representativeText": "Open data and software open up new, collaborative avenues of research.",
    "kind": "empirical",
    "memberClaimKeys": [
      "osft-doc-1869/c236",
      "open-science-source-24-c5/c30"
    ],
    "documentIds": [
      "open-science-source-24-c5",
      "osft-doc-1869"
    ],
    "declaredCounts": {
      "claims": 2,
      "documents": 2
    },
    "modalities": {
      "asserts": 2
    }
  }
]