{ "status": "passed", "validationScope": "Corpus identities, membership joins, and arithmetic. Semantic correctness and source availability are not validated.", "counts": { "waveDocuments": 153, "extractedClaims": 21422, "equivalenceStars": 2517, "claimsInStars": 6917, "equivalenceSpokes": 4400, "documentsInStars": 150, "topdownThemes": 71, "bottomupThemes": 67, "topdownAssignedStars": 1913, "topdownUnassignedStars": 604, "bottomupAssignedStars": 2509, "bottomupResidueStars": 8 }, "comparison": { "jointlyAssignedStars": 1909, "adjustedRandIndex": 0.18115135086345435, "normalizedMutualInformation": 0.517113225502037, "nmiNormalization": "arithmetic mean of partition entropies; natural logarithms", "interpretation": "Agreement of two organizations of shared input, not independent validation." }, "coverage": { "claimsOutsideStars": 14505, "documentsOutsideStars": [ "open-science-source-16-c6", "osft-doc-0460", "osft-doc-0832" ], "publicUrlDocumentCount": 67, "missingPublicUrlDocumentCount": 86 }, "themeCounts": [ { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T1-openness-serves-science", "display_name": "Openness serves better science", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 90, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 623, "star_count": 209, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T2-linked-machine-actionable-record", "display_name": "The scientific record should become linked and machine-actionable", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 60, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 225, "star_count": 78, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T3-immediate-access", "display_name": "Research should be available without delay", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 56, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 162, "star_count": 45, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T4-open-licensing-reuse", "display_name": "Research should be open to reuse", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 55, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 176, "star_count": 62, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T5-free-compliance-route", "display_name": "Sharing research should not depend on the author’s ability to pay", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 31, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 100, "star_count": 32, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T6-identifiers-open-metadata", "display_name": "Research should remain identifiable and connected across systems", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 45, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 156, "star_count": 63, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T7-assessment-reform", "display_name": "Research assessment should recognize the full contribution to science", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 54, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 496, "star_count": 150, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "T8-infrastructure-public-obligations", "display_name": "Shared infrastructure should remain accountable to the research community", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 46, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 482, "star_count": 135, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "D1-infrastructure-monopoly-vs-fragmentation", "display_name": "Shared infrastructure and distributed control", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 25, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 56, "star_count": 21, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "D2-publishing-money", "display_name": "Which publishing costs institutions should pay", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 43, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 206, "star_count": 73, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "D3-consent-and-access", "display_name": "Who may authorize access and reuse", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 43, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 259, "star_count": 97, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "D4-universal-vs-situated", "display_name": "Common standards and different research contexts", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 44, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 151, "star_count": 51, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "D5-commercial-participation", "display_name": "Commercial participation and community ownership", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 13, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 47, "star_count": 21, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "G1-endorsed-but-not-routine", "display_name": "Open practice is widely endorsed but has not become routine", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 21, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 78, "star_count": 29, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "M1-declarations-do-not-bind", "display_name": "Declarations and recommendations bind no one; prestige and enforceability run in opposite directions", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 0, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 0, "star_count": 0, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "M2-conditioned-resources-change-practice", "display_name": "Practice changes when a named party conditions a valued resource on audited compliance", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 30, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 54, "star_count": 21, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "M3-requirements-need-support-and-legitimacy", "display_name": "A requirement works and stays legitimate only when compliance is feasible, supported, and governed by those it binds", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 34, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 74, "star_count": 29, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "M4-gains-exposed-to-reversal", "display_name": "Open-science gains remain exposed to policy reversal and short-cycle funding", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 0, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 0, "star_count": 0, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "V1-ai-volume-outruns-verification", "display_name": "AI produces plausible output faster than verification can absorb it", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 14, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 45, "star_count": 16, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "V2-checkable-record-with-declared-checks", "display_name": "The record must make claims checkable: identifiers, typed links, rights, provenance, declared checks, portability", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 4, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 4, "star_count": 2, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "V3-certification-needs-independent-audit", "display_name": "A badge or self-declaration certifies nothing; certification must be independently audited and not paid for by the certified", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 3, "star_count": 1, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "V4-machines-check-humans-judge", "display_name": "Machines perform bounded, attributable checks; humans retain judgment", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 7, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 10, "star_count": 4, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "V5-machine-reuse-preserves-authority-reciprocity", "display_name": "Machine reuse of open resources must preserve source, community authority, and reciprocity", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 2, "star_count": 1, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C01-open-science-needs-infrastructure-making", "display_name": "Open science needs infrastructure making outputs findable and practically, not just nominally, open", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 56, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 122, "star_count": 38, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C02-open-science-reform-requires-broad", "display_name": "Open science reform requires broad collaboration among universities, funders, libraries, and publishers", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 28, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 52, "star_count": 19, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C03-open-science-is-a-broad", "display_name": "Open science is a broad cultural and structural transformation of research now underway but still incomplete.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 42, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 117, "star_count": 25, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C04-open-scholarship-should-give-everyone", "display_name": "Open scholarship should give everyone free, equal access to and participation in knowledge.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 42, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 97, "star_count": 31, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C05-institutions-states-and-researchers-should", "display_name": "Institutions, states, and researchers should build training, communities, and coordination to grow open scholarship.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 18, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 68, "star_count": 25, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C06-scholarly-communication-s-journals-infrastructure", "display_name": "Scholarly communication's journals, infrastructure, preprints, and research output have all rapidly proliferated.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 23, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 42, "star_count": 17, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C07-peer-review-remains-central-to", "display_name": "Peer review remains central to research assessment but should become more transparent, open, and less burdensome.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 25, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 81, "star_count": 30, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C08-stakeholders-disciplines-and-contexts-interpret", "display_name": "Stakeholders, disciplines, and contexts interpret and value openness, quality, and rigor differently.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 21, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 72, "star_count": 24, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C09-open-infrastructure-platforms-tools-technologies", "display_name": "Open infrastructure (platforms, tools, technologies) enables and underpins open science practices.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 29, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 57, "star_count": 22, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C10-institutions-and-communities-should-train", "display_name": "Institutions and communities should train students and researchers in open, reproducible scholarship practices.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 16, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 157, "star_count": 64, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C11-individuals-and-institutions-should-adopt", "display_name": "Individuals and institutions should adopt open source tools and practices throughout the research workflow.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 17, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 55, "star_count": 21, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C12-implementing-open-science-practices-imposes", "display_name": "Implementing open science practices imposes significant, often hard-to-determine costs", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 21, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 34, "star_count": 13, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C13-the-scholarly-publishing-system-s", "display_name": "The scholarly publishing system's licensing, embargo, and funder-publisher conflicts block access to research", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 11, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 27, "star_count": 11, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C14-research-is-beset-by-fragmentation", "display_name": "Research is beset by fragmentation, low reproducibility, and questionable practices", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 15, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 25, "star_count": 11, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C15-open-science-and-citizen-science", "display_name": "Open science and citizen science need sustained funding, skills, and career support.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 12, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 18, "star_count": 8, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C16-persistent-evidence-guidance-infrastructure-and", "display_name": "Persistent evidence, guidance, infrastructure, and awareness gaps impede open science practices.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 9, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 83, "star_count": 39, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C17-advancing-open-science-is-a", "display_name": "Advancing open science is a collective, community-driven effort needing broad participation.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 22, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 55, "star_count": 22, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C18-open-scholarship-has-grown-into", "display_name": "Open scholarship has grown into a broad, global network of initiatives, institutions, and standards", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 17, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 49, "star_count": 20, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C19-metrics-and-indicators-for-research", "display_name": "Metrics and indicators for research evaluation must be transparently designed and responsibly governed.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 12, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 44, "star_count": 16, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C20-research-outputs-and-publishing-take", "display_name": "Research outputs and publishing take many forms beyond the traditional journal article", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 18, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 77, "star_count": 24, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C21-science-its-methods-and-its", "display_name": "Science, its methods, and its enabling technologies must advance more urgently.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 11, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 15, "star_count": 7, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C22-peer-review-is-biased-opaque", "display_name": "Peer review is biased, opaque, inconsistent, and strained by rising capacity demands.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 11, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 35, "star_count": 13, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C23-coordinated-policy-and-shared-principles", "display_name": "Coordinated policy and shared principles across stakeholders are needed to drive real change", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 18, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 28, "star_count": 10, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C24-key-concepts-like-quality-ethics", "display_name": "Key concepts like quality, ethics, impact, and infrastructure resist easy definition or solutions", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 9, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 13, "star_count": 5, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C25-scientific-recognition-and-funding-depend", "display_name": "Scientific recognition and funding depend on status and prestige, not research quality, entrenching inequality.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 12, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 23, "star_count": 9, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C26-federal-departments-and-agencies-should", "display_name": "Federal departments and agencies should adopt time-bound open science action plans with defined milestones.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 5, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 23, "star_count": 9, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C27-the-journal-impact-factor-has", "display_name": "The Journal Impact Factor has statistical properties that undermine its use as a quality measure.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 8, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 14, "star_count": 5, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C28-collaboration-across-disciplines-sectors-and", "display_name": "Collaboration across disciplines, sectors, and communities should be actively fostered and recognized", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 13, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 35, "star_count": 14, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C29-key-parts-of-the-research", "display_name": "Key parts of the research system stay closed or opaque despite open science ideals.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 9, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 13, "star_count": 5, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C30-replication-is-a-valuable-growing", "display_name": "Replication is a valuable, growing activity that funders should actively support.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 8, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 37, "star_count": 15, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C31-networked-technologies-and-collaboration-make", "display_name": "Networked technologies and collaboration make knowledge creation more efficient and societies more connected.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 8, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 21, "star_count": 9, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C32-funders-should-replace-short-term", "display_name": "Funders should replace short-term project grants with sustained, strategic structural funding", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 6, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 11, "star_count": 4, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C33-crossing-planetary-boundaries-will-trigger", "display_name": "Crossing planetary boundaries will trigger cascading, catastrophic crises demanding urgent action.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 4, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 24, "star_count": 12, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C34-science-should-be-defined-broadly", "display_name": "Science should be defined broadly to cover natural, biomedical, social, engineering and math fields", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 8, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 27, "star_count": 9, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C35-reproducibility-and-research-indicators-risk", "display_name": "Reproducibility and research indicators risk gaming, oversimplification, and other unintended harms.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 7, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 14, "star_count": 6, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C37-open-scholarship-policy-is-diverse", "display_name": "Open scholarship policy is diverse, multi-level, and shaped by both top-down and bottom-up initiatives.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 9, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 32, "star_count": 13, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C38-agencies-existing-federal-purpose-license", "display_name": "Agencies' existing federal purpose license already authorizes public access, and it must be disclosed", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 7, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 22, "star_count": 6, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C39-competing-teaching-research-and-administrative", "display_name": "Competing teaching, research, and administrative demands leave researchers too time-constrained to adopt new practices.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 6, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 13, "star_count": 5, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C40-the-pdb-is-a-centrally", "display_name": "The PDB is a centrally governed, continuously maintained global archive of macromolecular structure data.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 4, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 32, "star_count": 14, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C41-academic-and-scientific-structures-perpetuate", "display_name": "Academic and scientific structures perpetuate systemic inequality disadvantaging marginalized and underrepresented groups.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 7, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 25, "star_count": 10, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C42-reproducibility-s-relevance-as-a", "display_name": "Reproducibility's relevance as a quality standard depends on research context, not universal", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 5, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 19, "star_count": 8, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C43-national-level-bodies-should-actively", "display_name": "National-level bodies should actively fund, build, and showcase open scholarship infrastructure and practices.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 6, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 23, "star_count": 8, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C44-teaching-should-integrate-open-and", "display_name": "Teaching should integrate open and reproducible scholarship into how science is taught and mentored", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 4, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 86, "star_count": 41, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C45-open-scholarship-terminology-is-complex", "display_name": "Open Scholarship terminology is complex and prone to confusion or misuse", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 7, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 30, "star_count": 10, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C46-forrt-s-community-built-database", "display_name": "FORRT's community-built database curates, organizes, and summarizes open-scholarship resources.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 65, "star_count": 31, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C47-repositories-should-attach-a-standardized", "display_name": "Repositories should attach a standardized notice template with license, ORCID, and funding data.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 16, "star_count": 7, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C48-ecrin-certifies-clinical-trial-centers", "display_name": "ECRIN certifies clinical trial centers' data management processes for GCP compliance.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 8, "star_count": 4, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "topdown-all", "theme_id": "C49-nestor-s-certification-criteria-span", "display_name": "Nestor's certification criteria span legal, organizational, financial, and FAIR-aligned technical concerns", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 8, "star_count": 4, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-001", "display_name": "Research data, code, and publications should be openly shared and freely accessible to all.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 86, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 267, "star_count": 71, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-002", "display_name": "Open science depends on interoperable, sustainable, FAIR-compliant infrastructure like repositories and open-source software", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 74, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 236, "star_count": 77, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-003", "display_name": "Open science and open access practices generate broad benefits for research and society", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 69, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 317, "star_count": 99, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-004", "display_name": "Multiple research actors should collaborate, adapt practices, and reap open science's societal benefits", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 58, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 163, "star_count": 65, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-005", "display_name": "Research outputs should carry open licenses, persistent identifiers, and proper attribution", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 54, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 126, "star_count": 43, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-006", "display_name": "Institutions, funders, and researchers must reform incentives, training, and infrastructure to embed open science.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 52, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 276, "star_count": 85, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-007", "display_name": "Open science's scope covers many kinds of data, outputs, publications, and information, still evolving.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 51, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 247, "star_count": 88, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-008", "display_name": "Research data should follow FAIR principles, complemented by CARE principles for Indigenous data governance", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 48, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 247, "star_count": 97, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-009", "display_name": "Strengthening research reproducibility requires funders, publishers, and meta-researchers to build shared norms, infrastructure, and incentives", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 48, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 233, "star_count": 94, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-010", "display_name": "Governments, institutions, and stakeholders should take wide-ranging action to build, fund, and mandate open science.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 48, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 236, "star_count": 91, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-011", "display_name": "Open science practices, infrastructure, and teaching improve research quality and benefit society", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 47, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 254, "star_count": 91, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-012", "display_name": "Openness means research data, tools, and outputs are free of restrictions on use and reuse.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 43, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 90, "star_count": 39, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-013", "display_name": "Research assessment must value diverse, quality outputs while peer review needs reform amid overload", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 42, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 278, "star_count": 82, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-014", "display_name": "Science is a collaborative, global, multidisciplinary endeavor addressing societal challenges", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 41, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 152, "star_count": 58, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-015", "display_name": "Scholarly literature can and should be made freely, immediately accessible at little or no cost", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 43, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 135, "star_count": 40, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-016", "display_name": "Research objects, metadata, and institutional processes should be open, transparent, and machine-actionable", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 43, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 87, "star_count": 36, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-017", "display_name": "Scholarly communication and open science are rapidly evolving, driven by new digital technologies and growing metrics", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 41, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 147, "star_count": 59, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-018", "display_name": "Open science faces persistent barriers, unresolved disagreements, and evidence gaps on many fronts.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 41, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 145, "star_count": 54, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-019", "display_name": "Scholarly publishing should be reformed toward transparency, fairness, and openness", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 36, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 121, "star_count": 48, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-020", "display_name": "Research outputs need standardized, machine-readable metadata and documentation to enable findability and responsible reuse", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 33, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 69, "star_count": 26, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-021", "display_name": "The current scholarly system's incentives, culture, and infrastructure impede open science.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 35, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 114, "star_count": 41, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-022", "display_name": "Open scholarship should embrace diversity, collaborate broadly, and keep governance open to all stakeholders", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 34, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 104, "star_count": 30, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-023", "display_name": "Research outputs must be deposited in trustworthy, certified repositories ensuring long-term preservation.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 35, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 73, "star_count": 29, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-024", "display_name": "Institutions, funders and metric-suppliers should adopt structured, transparent policies enforcing open science practices", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 32, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 108, "star_count": 41, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-025", "display_name": "Article processing charges impose inequitable financial barriers on under-resourced, early-career, and LMIC authors", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 32, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 109, "star_count": 33, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-026", "display_name": "Many distinct barriers — awareness, incentives, training, infrastructure, metadata — impede open science adoption", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 30, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 125, "star_count": 51, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-027", "display_name": "Mechanisms for assessing research quality — peer review, metrics, reproducibility indicators, AI — carry inherent biases and risks", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 27, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 109, "star_count": 44, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-028", "display_name": "Open Scholarship is a broad, principle-driven movement encompassing diverse practices, disciplines, and communities worldwide", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 28, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 263, "star_count": 91, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-029", "display_name": "Open science needs vary by discipline and stakeholder group, so no single approach fits all", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 27, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 99, "star_count": 34, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-030", "display_name": "Open scholarly infrastructure, policy, and diamond open access are expanding through trustworthy, community-driven mechanisms", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 26, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 78, "star_count": 35, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-031", "display_name": "Research information should be open by default, closed only when privacy, ethics, or law require it", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 24, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 49, "star_count": 18, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-032", "display_name": "Open-science organisations must adapt, be accountable, and empower community and Indigenous self-determination", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 23, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 47, "star_count": 20, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-033", "display_name": "High costs and restrictive licensing create barriers to scholarly communication and access", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 22, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 43, "star_count": 18, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-034", "display_name": "Infrastructure organisations should diversify revenue and hold financial reserves for sustainability and orderly wind-down.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 22, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 124, "star_count": 28, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-035", "display_name": "Libraries and universities should actively track and support an open, equitable, public-good scholarly ecosystem", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 22, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 63, "star_count": 26, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-036", "display_name": "Open data sharing faces unresolved technical, rights, and governance barriers, plus risks of capture.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 21, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 35, "star_count": 17, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-037", "display_name": "Training and mentoring in open, reproducible research practices should be embedded throughout education and careers", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 20, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 176, "star_count": 75, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-038", "display_name": "Open infrastructure is fragile without diverse funding and forkable, community-controlled governance.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 20, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 123, "star_count": 33, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-039", "display_name": "Certification, trust-building, access protocols, and AI safeguards ensure research infrastructure reliability.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 20, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 64, "star_count": 26, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-040", "display_name": "Named organizations, registries, and alliances build infrastructure for finding and sharing research data.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 20, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 61, "star_count": 28, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-041", "display_name": "Closed, commercialized, or misleadingly 'open' scholarly practices harm science, and current funding models are unsustainable", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 20, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 64, "star_count": 22, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-042", "display_name": "Infrastructure organisations should plan for succession, wind-down, and support of the staff who sustain them", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 18, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 56, "star_count": 19, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-043", "display_name": "Funding agencies should require grantees to grant a license ensuring public reuse of publications.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 19, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 62, "star_count": 16, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-044", "display_name": "Journal Impact Factor and journal-based metrics are invalid proxies for quality and should not be used in evaluation", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 19, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 60, "star_count": 15, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-045", "display_name": "Open-science tools, principles, and publishing practices have specific unaddressed transparency and equity gaps", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 18, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 35, "star_count": 17, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-046", "display_name": "Subscription and hybrid journals should be forced to transition fully to open access.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 16, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 45, "star_count": 18, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-047", "display_name": "AI is rapidly transforming scientific research, bringing both new capabilities and new risks.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 14, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 72, "star_count": 30, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-048", "display_name": "Institutions and funders should refuse to pay or engage publishers over unfair fee practices", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 16, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 23, "star_count": 9, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-049", "display_name": "Structural inequality and privilege bias academic participation, and quantitative metrics poorly assess research.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 15, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 51, "star_count": 23, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-050", "display_name": "Funders hold power over research practice and should redirect investment toward openness and sustainability", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 15, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 37, "star_count": 16, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-051", "display_name": "Authors should retain copyright control over their work rather than transfer it to publishers", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 13, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 22, "star_count": 9, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-052", "display_name": "Indigenous Peoples must have authority to govern, control, and benefit from data about them", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 9, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 70, "star_count": 27, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-053", "display_name": "Fraud, gaming, and questionable practices pervade academic publishing and peer review.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 12, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 23, "star_count": 11, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-054", "display_name": "Scientific recognition and career success depend on metrics and prestige, not research quality.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 12, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 25, "star_count": 10, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-055", "display_name": "Metadata infrastructure lacks repositories, persistence guarantees, and accountable stewardship", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 10, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 14, "star_count": 6, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-056", "display_name": "Concrete criteria mark replication failures, while reproducibility itself is defined and valued contextually", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 11, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 38, "star_count": 16, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-057", "display_name": "The Journal Impact Factor is a widely used but flawed proxy for research quality", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 11, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 17, "star_count": 6, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-058", "display_name": "Collaborative tools, practices, and processes make knowledge creation more efficient and open.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 10, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 43, "star_count": 19, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-059", "display_name": "Extreme or oversimplified approaches — total freedom, rigid uniformity, or quick fixes — fail policy design.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 8, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 15, "star_count": 7, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-060", "display_name": "Infrastructure organisations should not act in self-interest but serve stakeholders and communities via decentralised, community-driven governance.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 10, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 15, "star_count": 5, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-061", "display_name": "Passionate individual champions, more than institutions, drive open scholarship's biggest successes", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 9, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 21, "star_count": 8, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-062", "display_name": "Crossing planetary boundaries is driving catastrophic, cascading crises that demand urgent action.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 7, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 25, "star_count": 12, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-063", "display_name": "The PDB is a single, standardized, validated global archive for macromolecular structure data.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 5, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 50, "star_count": 22, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-065", "display_name": "CARE and OCAP define Indigenous data governance and must mature on Indigenous terms", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 5, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 33, "star_count": 15, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-066", "display_name": "CoreTrustSeal, Nestor, and ISO 16363 form a tiered certification system for trusted digital repositories.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 5, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 31, "star_count": 15, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-067", "display_name": "FORRT provides a suite of curated tools supporting open and reproducible research education.", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 3, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 102, "star_count": 46, "full_proposition_support_validated": false }, { "route": "bottomup-v2", "theme_id": "bu-068", "display_name": "Active researcher-scholars, teaching science as an ongoing uncertain process, are the most effective educators", "relation": "detected_membership", "document_count": 2, "wave_document_count": 153, "star_document_count": 150, "claim_count": 59, "star_count": 29, "full_proposition_support_validated": false } ] }